10 Movie Idiots Who Made Simple Solutions Look IMPOSSIBLE

Some of our most beloved films fall victim to overlooking the obvious in favour for the dramatic...

Saw Cary Elwes
Lionsgate

Watching and enjoying films always comes with a certain degree of the suspension of disbelief. On an obvious level, there's fantasical elements like alien invasions, high-profile conspiracy, or basic magical formulae. But to look at things in a more subtle light, real life is unlikely to bring about such specific events will occur in such a specific order that fantastical outcomes prevail. That applies to your Wonka's golden tickets, your Bruce Almighty "chosen by God for the meme," or the intricate planning that brought about the Murder on the Orient Express.

As an audience, we can get on board with all of these phenomena quite easily, as long as everything is logical. Sadly, sometimes a film takes a step outside its self-contained boundaries that we start to have issues. As soon as you have to ask, "Wait, why did that happen?" or, "Shouldn't they have just done xyz?" you're in trouble. And if a plot couldn't progress without a specific McGuffin, chances are there'll be some quizzical looks on the faces of viewers.

Maybe it's time we had a look at some movie moments that had us scratching our heads at plot curiousities or, worse still, table-flipping at the downright idiocy of those on screen characters.

10. Gravity - You Can't Name Your Film After A Law Of Physics Only To Defy It

Gravity George Clooney
Warner Bros.

Sci-fi films usually are the best films for smudging reality a little bit. Would Tony Stark really be able to synthesise a new element in his basement with some PVC pipes, as he does in Iron Man 2? Nope. Can the Men in Black really wipe your memory with a little blinky light? Probably not. But as long as it all fits into the internal logic of the movie, the filmmakers really do have quite a bit of free reign.

Sci-fi films grounded in some sort of realism, though - they can be a bit tricky. Take the 2013 space thriller Gravity for instance. Hyperrealistic graphics and real world settings (or maybe real space setting to be more accurate) made Sandra Bullock and George Clooney's space-walk-gone-wrong all the more captivating. Space is super dangerous, and Gravity encapsulated the horrors of very possible events should those flimsy space stations encounter a problem. But there's something else that those astronauts don't want you to know, and it's that space can be kind of mundane.

Sure, seeing the rotation of the Earth might be cool, but have you ever looked into how pooping works up there? Without gravity, it's... messy. And I'm sure floating around weightlessly gets old once you've strapped yourself into bed a couple of times.

To counteract the ultimate banality of daily life in space, Gravity had to spice things up with the aforementioned horrific space-debris related accident that sees our two main characters Dr Stone and Lieutenant Kawolski almost jettisoned into space. During a space walk where the two are working on the Hubble Telescope, debris crashes into them and destroys their shuttle. Now, they have to make it across a considerable amount of space to a space station (first the ISS, then the Chinese Tiangong station) in order to have any chance at survival.

In the middle of this treacherous expedition, calamity ensues and Stone and Kawolski end up tumbling through the vacuum. Stone gets caught on some cables coming from a defunct parachute, and manages to grab Kawolski as he nearly flies straight past. But the ropes won't hold them both! And so, we say goodbye to George Clooney as he valiantly sacrifices himself so that Sandra Bullock might have a chance at making it back to Earth.

Is this scene dramatic? Yes. Is it a heartbreaking display of selflessness? Absolutely. Could Kawolski have been very easily saved, if either had even a rudimentary understanding of the laws of motion? Unfortunately, this is the case. With no gravity, comes no momentum. Gently pulling on the rope would have been enough to nudge Clooney back in the right direction, instead of letting him continue to drift away into the abyss. It's such a fundamental misunderstanding of physics that it's even annoyed Neil deGrasse Tyson.

I'm not saying we need to have all out 100% accurate portrayals of space exploration - no one needs to see their pooping situation on the big screen. But maybe a little more consultation with some clever science people might mean fewer misconceptions about space. Like, you know, that there are people whizzing about the stratosphere and running out of oxygen.


9. The Open House - That Is Not How Phones Work

the open house
Netflix

The Open House is another one of those Netflix original horror films that, while they have the potential to be great in principle, are ultimately executed poorly. Troubled youth Logan Wallace, still traumatised from witnessing the accident that killed his father, is given the opportunity to house-sit for his aunt with his mother Naomi at her open house –i.e. an unoccupied house she’s selling. It’s a remote, decent sized house in the middle of the mountains, so his mother thinks it’s a great chance for a break to try and mend their rocky relationship.

But this is a home invasion thriller, so things are set to go wrong fast. An unknown, and ultimately completely anonymous killer rocks up to mess about with the duo for a few days, toying with them, psychologically and physically torturing them, and eventually murdering them both. It’s bleak as hell, and the isolated and seemingly random nature of these kills is the spookiest part of this film. But of course, there are a few points where it’s obvious that there’s more they could be doing which could have potentially avoided their untimely deaths.

For starters, if weird stuff starts happening like the house getting broken into, only to find the dining table fully set for dinner, it’s time to leave. At this point, they still have a functioning car and all that jazz, so this house is not yet the inescapable prison it will soon become. As for the idea that they can’t afford a hotel and therefore must stay in the house – they’re house sitting for a relative. Surely you could make the drive and ask to sleep on their couch? I’m sure “creepy stuff in an isolated mansion” is a good enough reason for anyone to see that this was the only sensible solution.

But most infuriatingly, when the proverbial starts hitting the fan, our not-really-a-hero grabs his phone, only to find the faceless murderer has removed the SIM card. Drat! If only it were possible to still phone emergency services even without an activated SIM card installed!

Oh wait, it is?

You mean this kid could have slammed 911 immediately and given the operator all the requisite details, maybe saving himself and his mother? Part of me hopes this is a moment of character idiocy, because the alternative is that this film’s makers have no idea how mobile phones work.


8. The Silence - Use Woodchipper! It's Super Effective

The Silence Stanley Tucci Kiernan Shipka
Netflix

If you haven’t seen the Netflix original The Silence, I don’t blame you. It looks for all the world like a bad knock-off of the 2018 critically acclaimed horror A Quiet Place. Blind monsters that use sound to hunt? A family able to survive thanks to their knowledge of sign language to communicate with their hard-of-hearing child? It’s all there.

Yet, despite being released via the streaming platform only last year, this one had been chilling on a shelf since 2017 waiting for someone to have the time and money to put it out. That’s right, it predates A Quiet Place by a full year. There’s little argument about who did it better though. (Hint: it’s the award winning blockbuster, and not the straight-to-stream low budget mess that was probably only released because it also featured Kiernan Shipka of The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina fame.)

Considering its production budget, I doubt anyone would really expect much from the film – but no one would be able to properly prepare for the nonsensical reasoning of these main. It starts with drilling into unknown caves which releases a bunch of weird bat-like ancient creatures who quickly spread and wreak havoc across the North American continent. Evolving in the dark means that they’re blind, and can only detect prey with sounds. Obviously, everything quickly descends into silence as the human race attempts to survive this plague of primitive bats.

Now, if these creatures were the ultra-smart, deadly creatures of A Quiet Place dominating an already collapsed society, I’d understand the threat a little bit more. But in The Silence, we see the start of the invasion. Everyone still has internet access. News sites and social media continue to get updated, but you’re telling me they couldn’t mobilise a slightly more efficient defence? Apparently not, because soon most people are rotting corpses on the street, filled with eggs ready to repopulate the earth with bat things. And when I say these things are not the ultra-smart creatures of A Quiet Place, I mean they really not smart. One scene shows them flying single file into a wood chipper because they are literally attracted to any sound at all.

So let’s break it down: stupid bat things, easy access to Twitter, and I assume a fair number of wood chippers across the United States. Nobody thought to tweet out that turning on a wood chipper takes out a fair few of the weird bat things attacking everyone? Even a blender would probably blitz a couple.

I don’t want to blame any one person in this film for being the biggest idiot, because literally anyone in America could have done better with the tools they had. Instead, The Silence tries to put out some anti-technology message because those darn kids just won’t stop with their iPads and their memes, and in doing so makes the biggest, most idiotic plot hole of them all.


7. A Quiet Place - You're Just Gonna Leave Those There?

A Quiet Place
Paramount

You know what, while we’re at it, let’s have a moment for The Quiet Place as well. It seems like in any situation with sonically-dependent monsters taking over the earth, a whole lot of common sense goes out of the window.

A Quiet Place has a lot more budget to its name, and better writing than The Silence could have even hoped to achieve. These sound-hating aliens have a better raison-d’etre too, since their limited backstory does reveal alien invasion plans which involve destroying anything that makes sound to create a habitable environment for their very sensitive ears. They’re better hunters than their Silence counterparts, and way, way smarter – so I don’t think the woodchipper remedy would suffice here.

Our protagonists, the Abbott family, are definitely pretty smart, then. They’d have to be to have survived this long in the silent hellscape that earth has become. Once again, they’re greatly helped by their knowledge of ASL they already used to communicate with their daughter Regan (this time the deaf character is actually played by deaf actress Millicent Simmonds, so good work on the inclusivity there!) They’ve set up a lot of gadgets to help them in their survival against the alien creatures, and father Lee even has some technological know-how with his attempts to make a hearing aid himself for his daughter. So they’re some smart cookies, I guess?

Sadly not. The opening of A Quiet Place truly shocked audiences with the immediate offing of Beau, the youngest son. He finds a space ship toy, which his terrified father quickly confiscates – removing the batteries and placing both on a shelf and warning him that it’s too loud to keep. His sister sneaks him the little rocket ship so he can play with it to his hearts content. Only, he also picks up the batteries, and once he’s figured out how to replace them, it immediately sets off lights and beeps. Ultimately, he gets got by the super speedy aliens. Heartbreaking.

Yes, they were smart enough to recognise the potential threat of a noisy toy, and it’s true that they weren’t really to know Beau would sneak him the toy like a well-meaning big sister who just wants her little brother to have some fun in this incredibly bleak time.

But wouldn’t it make a bit more sense to just… take the batteries out and let him keep the toy? No batteries means no beeps, and no beeps means no alerting the big scary monsters. Then you could let your little son have a nice new toy to play with, which would be a pretty nice distraction from the ongoing terror. And even if you did ultimately leave the toy behind instead of giving it to your son, those batteries are a wasted opportunity. He’s clearly the tech guy, so wouldn’t he be on the lookout for any power supplies?

If there’s one thing Outlast has taught me, it’s to always collect the batteries.


6. The Lord Of The Rings - If Only There Were Giant Eagles In Middle Earth

Lord Of The Rings fellowship
New Line Cinema

I’m not sure at one point exactly during the release of Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy this theory became so popular. It wouldn’t surprise me if this even went back to the time of the source books’ publication, because once you think about this too much, it almost undermines three books’ worth of plot.

LOTR sees one Frodo Baggins journey from his hobbit hole in Bag End, all the way to the dark land of Mordor to destroy a ring capable of bringing back a dark lord who could vanquish the entirety of Middle Earth. So like, a lot is riding on this little guy.

But it’s well established that Gandalf the Grey has a hotwire to the Great Eagles, a race of, well, giant eagles who have often helped him out in particularly troubling times. Stuck in a tree with the heir to dwarf kingdom of Erebor? Call the eagles. Boss goes mad and sticks you on the top of the tower? Ask a moth to get the eagles. The eagles even ultimately help recover Frodo and Sam from the nomnatively determined Mount Doom.

So why didn’t Gandalf maybe try asking the eagles if they could airdrop the ring into the lava? There’s a lot of discussion about their unwillingness to involve themselves too much in matters like these, but did Gandalf not think to just ask them? They could have at least given them a lift part of the way, and maybe we could have avoided a lot of the mess caused by needing to wait a year before Frodo was able to make it on foot. After all, it’s him taking so long that allows Sauron to steadily grow in strength – they really could have nipped it in the bud much sooner.


5. Jupiter Ascending - Wife And Child > Telescope

Jupiter Ascending Channing Tatum Mila Kunis
Warner Bros.

The Wachowskis have been royalty in the sci-fi film industry ever since they created one of the most infamous franchises, The Matrix. But in 2015, they released a film that nearly became their downfall. That film was Jupiter Ascending.

Jupiter Ascending concerns one illegal Russian immigrant, Jupiter Jones, who has spent her life cleaning toilets for a living only to discover she is the reincarnation of a space monarch. She befriends wolf-human hybrid Cane, who is basically Channing Tatum with a dodgy goatee and pointy ears, and embarks on a quest to claim her inheritance from this dead space queen. Opposition comes from the dead space queen’s children, all of whom want Jupiter’s sizeable inheritance for themselves. What exactly she is inheriting, you might wonder. Well, it’s Earth. Yeah, the whole planet. Because what you don’t realise is that these space dynasties “seed” planets with human populations, then “harvest” the population once the planet has reached capacity to blend humans down into… life juice? It’s like a really good moisturiser that keeps everyone basically immortal (except if you’re murdered – hint hint.)

So Jupiter goes off-planet to meet all her previous self’s children and admin the hell out of all of them to claim Earth as her own. (Seriously, there is a whole admin sequence at what is essentially the space DMV. Incredible.) Eddie Redmayne gives the performance of his life, reveals he murdered his mother, and then gets blown up in a life-juice factory on the planet Jupiter. Jupiter inherits the Earth, and returns to life as an illegal immigrant cleaning toilets.0.

Also Sean Bean is there and is part bee.

It was a critical disaster, even though it managed somewhat of a cult following. While I’d consider myself part of that following, I’m not blind to the questionable scriptwriting. One thing that cannot be faulted 99% of the time is the Wachowskis’ world-building abilities and interesting characterisation. Once you get your head around the system of space capitalism, it’s a surprisingly nice two hour jaunt around the solar system. Plus, it’s a very aesthetically pleasing film – one guy straight up built a gothic cathedral on his spaceship, which is taste in design I cannot fault.

Yet there is one character in this entire film for whose actions I cannot forgive. At the beginning of the movie, Jupiter Jones’ father lives in Russia with his pregnant wife, and likes to look at the stars with a very fancy telescope. One night, burglars break into their home to steal valuables. They try to take his telescope, he tries to stop them, and gets shot dead right in front of his pregnant wife. For some reason, this evidently very smart man decides that a telescope is worth risking his life over – nay, his entire family! This smidge of plot is unlikely to really change the wider events of the film, since Jupiter is already going to be the reincarnation of a Space Queen. But really, was your telescope worth it in the end? Doubt it.

There’s an important lesson here: if you’re being mugged, your belongings are not worth risking your life over.


4. Avengers: Infinity War - Tranquiliser Knees

Avengers Infinity War Star Lord Thanos
Marvel Studios

We knew from the start that Avengers: Infinity War wasn’t going to end well. Why else would there be the then-untitled Infinity Wat Part Two? Watching Infinity War for the first time was definitely an emotional rollercoaster, then. You couldn’t help but hope that maybe, just maybe, it would all work out.

That feeling was never greater than when Iron Man, Mantis, and Spider-Man come together to try and force the gauntlet off Thanos’ hand. You’ve got webs, rocket gloves, and most importantly Mantis’ calming influence to try and wiggle the glove from the Titan. We even see it begin to loosen and slip, and we nearly have success over the genocidal maniac!

Or we would have, if it weren’t for one Peter Quill. Instead of being any actual use in this scenario, Star Lord decides now is the time to have a gloat about how they’d over powered him, and thinks his best contribution to the situation is to start quizzing Thanos on the whereabouts of his daughter, Gamora. She’s dead, Quill gets upset, and single handedly chucks their only opportunity to stop Thanos from clicking his fingers out of the window.

Do I have an exact remedy for this isolated sect of the Avengers? No. But I find it hard to believe that not one of them could have dealt a quick bonk on the head to Peter Q to shut him up. Iron Man has all those gadgets in his suit and a predisposition to hate people talking at inopportune times, and even he apparently can’t ask F.R.I.D.A.Y to deploy the “STFU” protocol? If I were Tony Stark, my first act following the Big Click would have been to install tranquiliser darts in my knees.


3. Tangled - You've Already Kidnapped Her, Lying To Her Isn't The Worst Thing You've Done

Rapunzel Birthday Tangled
Tumblr

It’s not always the side we’re rooting for who makes some questionable decisions. Disney’s 2010 Rapunzel-inspired flick features heroes who do pretty much everything right – or at least, they do what they believe to be right. No, Rapunzel and Flynn Ride are not with whom I have a bone to pick.

Mother Gothel, for all her clever, witchy ways, makes a huge blunder almost immediately, and it’s one that almost single-handedly kicks into motion the events of the film.

She kidnaps the King and Queen’s daughter, right? She does this because the child has been bestowed with the gifts of a magic flower Gothel had kept secluded to keep secret the reason for her immortality. The girl goes up to be Rapunzel, her adopted daughter who she keeps locked in a tower “for her own safety”, but who Is bemused by the lantern show she sees in the distance on her birthday each year. It’s this curiosity regarding the lights in the sky which compels her, at the earliest opportunity, to escape the tower and go adventuring. Of course, the lanterns are released by the King and Queen, in memory of their long-lost daughter.

So why didn’t Gothel just give her a different ‘birthday’? Rapunzel was presumably still a baby when the lantern ritual started, and so unlikely to recognise that the date of her birthday had been changed. It’s impossible to say if this would have stunted her curious nature, or prevented her eventual escape, but it still just seems super stupid to me for Gothel to have allowed Rapunzel to make this link between lights and the sky and her birthday. She’s already lied to Rapunzel about her origins for her entire life, so I doubt this would be something that’d really weigh in on her conscience.


2. The Cabin In The Woods - Just Kill The Dude

Ancient Ones Cabin In The Woods
Mutant Enemy Productions

The Cabin in the Woods is a horror film for horror film loves. It plays with the ideas of archetypal characters and formulaic horror plots to imagine a world where these films have a much more serious role to play: they’re essential to the preservation of the entire planet. Instead of a cinema theatre full of scare-loving teens, the audience of this horror film is ultimately the “Ancient Ones,” old gods whose thirst must be satiated in a very extravagant blood ritual.

It turns out that all our favourite horror themes – the jock, the stoner, the blonde, the virgin – are all characters in this ritual who must be sacrificed to appease these creatures. But you can’t just give them a quick bonk on the head and be done with it; instead, the ritual must include torturing and terrifying the victims with some kind of classic horror baddie. Werewolves, zombies, chainsaw serial killers, you name it – they’re all options for this sadistic ceremony. Pretty much any horror convention you can think of is bundled up into The Cabin in the Woods as a necessary part of the procedure, all being features designed to appease these deities. Not completing the ritual will result in planet-wide destruction.

So, after an ignored warning to stay away from the cabin, some hanky panky, and terrorising from a zombie family, two of the teen group selected as the sacrifices remain: the “jester” a.k.a. the stoner kid, and the virgin – whose death turns out to be optional, thanks to some last minute exposition from a cameo by Signourney Weaver. Ripley makes it crystal clear that they have eight minutes to kill the stoner guy, or else the Ancient Ones will not be happy and will, you know, destroy everything they know and love. They squabble, kill Weaver’s character with some help from a wolf man and a zombie girl, and miss the literal deadline. The movie ends with a massive hand reaching out from the Earth’s core and starting its destruction. Way to go, guys.

Now, I am under no illusions than murdering someone is in any way a good thing. Whatever the circumstances, it isn’t nice, and it would definitely take a psychological toll on a person. But one guy’s life in exchange for the entire planet? Hell, if I was that guy, I wouldn’t be thrilled about it but I’d understand. Just make it as quick and as painless as possible, please.


1. Saw - Guess We Saw That One Coming

Saw Movie
Twisted Pictures

Saw is now one of the biggest horror franchises in the world, depicting absolute nightmare scenarios of kidnap, torture, and self-mutilation. Very icky. But the morbid curiosity its audience to see the Jigsaw Killer enact his own twisted justice on those he perceives to be in want of punishment has proved to be a successful formula.

It’s easy to forget how low budget or low concept Jigsaw’s original traps were. Since the first instalment, we’ve seen keys surgically implanted in eyes, motorcycle blenders, and shotgun collars. Yet Saw’s bathroom trap was super basic. Just a couple of guys chained to the wall in a dingy bathroom somewhere. There’s only a bathtub, some hacksaws and guns, and an already dead body. Their instructions are simple: Dr Lawrence must kill his companion Adam or else his wife and daughter will be killed, and Adam must escape – I assume without being murdered in the process.

Unfortunately, with such limited tools at their disposal, the opportunity for idiocy somehow increases. The denouement of the movie features an absolute mess of problem-solving from Cary Elwes’ Dr Lawrence Gordon. After he discovers a one-way mobile phone in the bathroom, it’s obvious that this, the only potential contact they have with the outside world, is absolutely invaluable. I don’t blame Gordon for being so desperate to answer it when it starts ringing – especially since it turns out to be phone call from his distressed daughter.

Yeeting the phone across the room when he hears the alarming commotion of gunshots and screaming, however, is not the one. Maybe the stress of the situation gets to him, or maybe he’s delirious from the kidnapping, but the doctor’s immediate reaction to his mobile falling out of reach is to – you guessed it – hack off his own foot to escape the chains and reach the phone. VERY icky.

One question remains: why didn’t he just… use… the saw… to reach the phone? At the very least, we’ve all done the lasso trick to reach a charging phone from bed without wanting to physically get up – so I’m pretty sure he could’ve worked something similar out with that shirt he so heroically ripped off to serve as a tourniquet for his self-amputation. Super gross, super horrific, and ultimately, super stupid. He probably would have ended up having to saw off the appendage eventually, or else be killed in some other horrific fashion. At least this way, he does actually make it out alive, albeit one foot down.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Doing my best until I reach Miranda Priestly levels of journalistic success.