10 Movie Mysteries That Will Likely Never Be Solved

Yes Joker, we would love to know how you got these scars!

In Bruges Colin Farrell
Universal

With any story you get invested in, you would usually expect something watertight, with as few threads left dangling by the end as possible. Essentially, you want any questions answered before you leave the cinema. This isn't always the case, however.

Sometimes, by the time the credits begin to roll on a movie, there are still mysteries left to ponder. These may revolve around plot holes, but may also just be a product of certain parts of the story not being explained in great detail. Or even at all.

There could be any number of reasons for this. Who doesn't love a cliffhanger that leaves the audience begging for an answer they know they just won't get? Sometimes it's meant to leave a plot thread open for a future story that for whatever reason may not happen, and sometimes it's there to let the audience decide.

Ambiguity is a powerful tool in cinema, and whether done well or not so much, a question to ponder can drive audiences crazy. This is true in particular for these 10 mysteries, as the odds of ever getting closure are about as slim as can be.

10. Who Was Sophie's Real Father? - Mamma Mia!

Mamma Mia Here We Go Again Pierce Brosnan Stellan Skarsgard Colin Firth
Universal

Who doesn't love ABBA? In 2008, an impressive cast came together to bring the Mamma Mia! musical to the big screen, and while the movie didn't exactly set the world alight, it did revolve around a genuinely compelling mystery that is still unsolved to this day.

Amanda Seyfried's Sophie was getting married and wanted to invite her father to the wedding. The issue? She didn't know who her father was. After going through her mother's diaries, she narrowed it down to three candidates who were all invited to the big day under the guise that they were Sophie's father themselves.

Through the twists and turns of the movie, interspersed with spontaneous singing and dancing, there was no definitive answer as to who Sophie's biological father was. All three men, Harry, Bill, and Sam decided they were happy being one-third of a father to Sophie, which is lovely and heartwarming, but it does leave audiences with a big question.

Amanda Seyfried herself has previously said she hoped that Bill was Sophie's father, however, even the sequel didn't confirm what everyone wanted to know. The identity of her father wasn't really the point of the movie, but still, it would have been nice to know.


9. What Exactly Is The Veil? - Harry Potter & The Order Of The Phoenix

Harry Potter Order Of The Phoenix Sirius Black Death
Warner Bros.

The wizarding world is something so vast and full of lore that there are bound to be inconsistencies and plot holes.

One thing that has never been the focus of such an explanation, however, is the Veil. This magical artifact was kept within the Department of Mysteries and was seemingly a gateway of sorts between life and death. However, there has never been a true and comprehensive explanation as to what it actually is.

As Sirius Black was killed by Bellatrix, he fell through the Veil and almost faded away. If he was intended to be killed he could've just been killed, so there was clearly some thought to the Veil, and likely a reason that it has been kept quiet all these years.

This has been a mystery that has been discussed by fans of the books and movies alike for years at this point, and if there was going to be an answer put forth, it likely would have been by now. Instead, Harry Potter fans will have to make do with the scraps of information they can gather from the books, but without being able to make a clear picture.


8. Why Did The Birds Stop? - The Birds

The Birds
Universal Pictures

Alfred Hitchcock was nothing short of a master of his craft, and after the huge success of Psycho turned his attention to The Birds. The story makes villains out of ordinary birds who suddenly begin to viciously attack the humans around them.

Though not necessarily clear from the movie itself, Hitchcock did give reason for the birds' attacks. They resented the humans for taking nature for granted. What a powerful and terrifying message to send, but as creepy as the entire movie is, there is no part of it as unnerving as the ending.

Forget seeing characters pecked to within an inch of their lives, the scariest part of the movie is actually when the birds stopped. The Brenner family packed up the car to headed to San Francisco, but as they drove away the birds simply calmly watched them drive away. The chaos stopped as suddenly as it started, but for no discernable reason.

This ending is left open to interpretation, and is far more disturbing than any conclusive ending could have ever been.


7. Did Ray Die? - In Bruges

In Bruges Colin Farrell
Universal

In Bruges is about as dark as a dark comedy can get. The story revolves around two hitmen who are sent to the titular Belgian city to hide out after a job goes wrong and one of them mistakenly shoots and kills a small child.

Throughout their time in Bruges, Colin Farrell's Ray struggles to come to terms with what happened, and contemplates suicide. He goes so far as to put a gun to his head, only for Brendan Gleeson's Ken to save his life.

You'd be forgiven for thinking that laughs in a movie like this would be few and far between, but Martin McDonagh manages to inject a surprising amount of humour. It even ends on something of a sarcastic note. After Ray has been shot multiple times in the final shootout, he is lifted into an ambulance, musing that if hell was anything like Bruges, he really hoped he didn't die.

Of course, this is a huge turnaround for the man who attempted suicide just hours before, but the movie ends before giving a definitive answer. All the audience is given is that at least he no longer wants to die, though whether he is able to enjoy that feeling for a couple of minutes or 50 more years remains a mystery.


6. What Did Bob Say To Charlotte? - Lost In Translation

Lost In Translation
Focus Features

There are many cliffhangers that leave the events of the entire movie that came before it in balance. Is it a happy or a sad ending? Did a certain character live or die? Then there is the ending of Lost in Translation, which concludes with a cliffhanger but on a smaller, more intimate note.

At the end of the movie, Bill Murray's Bob sees Scarlett Johansson's Charlotte, pulls his cab over, and goes over to embrace her. It's a quiet, personal moment that sees them kiss for the first time. Bob then whispers something in Charlotte's ear before she smiles, they say goodbye, and go their separate ways.

There have been plenty of theories on what the final line of the movie is, with people even going so far as to play detective and manipulate the sound, but even then results are far from conclusive. Director Sofia Coppola has previously said that the whisper was never intended to be anything, instead just an acknowledgment between the two that their week together meant something.

Ultimately it doesn't matter what was said, and it's something that Coppola will always keep between the two characters.


5. Was Marla Singer Real? - Fight Club

Fight Club Marla
20th Century Fox

Not only can Fight Club boast one of the most iconic lines of cinematic dialogue, as well as Brad Pitt in one of his best-ever roles, David Fincher's film astounded audiences with the twist towards the end.

The fact that Tyler Durden and the Narrator are the same person makes perfect sense when looking back on the film, but it opens the door for another possibility that isn't as set in stone. If Tyler Durden is a figment of Edward Norton's imagination, then what of Marla Singer?

If you take to the internet with such a question, you will be bombarded with a 50/50 split of opinions both for and against her being real. There is no true evidence to confirm that she is, like Durden, an extension of the Narrator's psyche, but similarly, there is nothing concrete to prove 100% that she is real.

There are plenty of theories about Marla and what part of the Narrator's mind and personality she could be the personification of, particularly in comparison to Tyler Durden, but without any confirmation from the movie or anywhere since, these debates will likely rage on for many years to come.


4. Who Murdered Angela Hayes? - Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri Trailer
Fox Searchlight

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri is a powerful movie that addresses a lot of heavy issues. Loss, grief, sexual and domestic abuse, alcoholism, cancer, racism, and suicide are all touched upon as part of a narrative propelled by a mother wanting justice for the murder of her daughter.

Seven months after the fact, the police have still made no arrests for the brutal and heinous crime committed against Angela, which leads to her mother, Mildred renting out the titular billboards demanding answers and accountability. However, though this does motivate Chief Willoughby to give the files another look, by the time the film ends there are still no answers.

There is a morsel of hope offered to Frances McDormand's character, as Dixon overhears someone bragging about something similar to what happened to Angela, just like Willoughby hoped, but he was ultimately innocent of any wrongdoing when it came to this particular crime.

This movie is not a detective movie, it is not a whodunnit, and there is no clever scene at the end wrapping everything up in a neat little bow. There is no evidence left for audiences to figure it out for themselves, because the exact details of the crime aren't the point of the story, and they never will be.


3. How Did The Joker Really Get His Scars? - The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight
Warner Bros.

There are truly some iconic moments within Heath Ledger's exemplary performance as the Joker in The Dark Knight. This is arguably the greatest iteration of any character in the comic book movie world, and though the actor didn't put a single foot wrong, some moments were more memorable than others.

Right up there with the likes of "Why so serious?" as a quote from the Clown Prince of Crime was the question he asked about his face. "You wanna know how I got these scars?"

He asked the question to three separate characters and gave two completely contradictory answers. He tells Gambol a chilling story about his drunk father taking a blade to the inside of his mouth, while Rachel Dawes gets an equally unsettling story in which he did it to himself as something of a show of support for his wife. The third time is when he asks Batman, but he never gets the chance to answer.

Even if he had given Bats a story, it likely would have been again completely different. At this point, the Joker doesn't care about how he got the scars. Hell, he may not even remember himself. This just drives home the chaos and unpredictability of the character.


2. Did Tom Answer The Phone? - Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels

Lock Stock And Two Smoking Barrels
PolyGram Filmed Entertainment

There have been some simply iconic cliffhanger movie endings over the years, though some of the most famous have been given definitive closure over the years. Even the Italian Job has been spoken about by Michael Caine, however, the ending to Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, very much in the same vein as that of The Italian Job, has remained ambiguous for over two decades.

The story follows four friends, way out of their depths in the leagues of the London gangster scene, staring down the barrel of half a million quid's worth of debt, and the threat of losing their fingers and more.

By way of a very convoluted story, the friends actually end up completely in the clear of any of the crimes committed, but for the guns that Tom has kept in his car. As he is told to go and throw them in the river, Eddy, Soap, and Bacon discover that they are actually worth £250,000 each.

In the same way, The Italian Job ends with the van full of gold and men teetering over a cliff, Tom's phone rings while in his mouth as he is dangling over a bridge ready to drop the small fortune in guns into the river. We will never know for certain whether or not he answered the phone in time, or if he dropped the guns first.


1. What Was In The Briefcase? - Pulp Fiction

pulp fiction trunk
Miramax Films

After an explosive cinematic debut, Quentin Tarantino followed up Reservoir Dogs with arguably his strongest and most iconic movie to date. Pulp Fiction, even almost three decades later, is widely regarded as one of the director's finest-ever outings.

The one central character that connected the different threads throughout the movie was Marsellus Wallace, who sent Jules and Vincent to retrieve his briefcase from Big Brain Brett and co. This was obviously something incredibly important, but the movie resists the temptation of actually revealing what was inside.

The closest audiences got to said reveal was when Vincent looked inside. His face lit up in something of an homage to Kiss Me Deadly, but still, no peek for the camera. To say that this was such an important plot point for the movie, you'd be forgiven for expecting to find out exactly why Wallace was so keen to retrieve the briefcase, but absolutely no closure was given.

Even now, 30 years later, there is still a debate going on as to what was contained inside the case. Was it cash? Was it Marsellus Wallace's soul? At this point, it's fair to say that we will likely never know.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You Really Know Pulp Fiction?

Pulp Fiction Jules Vincent Trunk
Miramax

1. According To Jules, Who Gave Mia Wallace A Foot Massage?

Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.