10 Movie Remakes That Are Actually Worth Watching

They really don't remake them like they used to.

La Totale True Lies
AMLF/Universal Pictures

Hollywood’s cheerful recycling of previous hits shows no signs of stopping anytime soon, and as long as movies like Jon Favreau’s The Jungle Book can make nearly a billion dollars worldwide, then remakes will continue to seem like a sound financial proposition.

All it takes is one massive success to wash away the remakes that either split the critics (The Legend Of Tarzan) or performed below expectations and torpedoed plans for a sequel (Ghostbusters).

Favreau’s film will probably go some way to helping Hollywood forget about the film commentators labelled the summer’s biggest turkey, even though it had been in multiplexes for only three days: Ben-Hur.

Even before its release, Timur Bekmambetov’s take on the classic was branded a DOA dud, a flop in waiting, a wreck the participants would be lucky to walk away from. Clearly setting itself up to fail, the movie was actually a remake of a remake, and not just any remake – the 1959 version won a then unprecedented 11 Oscars.

The movie’s awards haul wasn’t equaled until 1997, and as much as James Cameron would like you to believe that his movie was unique, Titanic was basically a souped-up, spectacular remake of the 1953 film of the same name. When filmmakers get it right, remakes can be intoxicating, and here are 10 films that prove it.

10. Evil Dead

evil dead remake
TriStar Pictures

The Original: Declared the “number one Video Nasty” by Mary Whitehouse, banned in the UK and put on trial for obscenity, Sam Raimi’s feature debut needs no introduction.

The Remake: Everything a modern horror movie ought to be, Fede Alvarez’s remake ditches Bruce Campbell’s character and foregoes shameless fan service in favor of doing things on its own terms. It’s still remarkably true to the spirit of Raimi’s film, though, and its remit appears to have been to recreate “the ultimate experience in gruelling horror” for a new generation.

This turns out to be a really cool idea (who doesn’t want to see a zombie armed with a nail gun?) and it’s a step up from the usual attitude of “let’s give them what they want and get the hell out of here.” Though made with its tongue partly in its cheek, Alvarez’s film eschews comic book violence and redefines onscreen brutality. When his characters fall, smash their heads or are struck by nails, they hurt.


9. Knock Knock

knock knock keanu reeves
Lionsgate

The Original: Starring Sondra Locke and Colleen Camp, 1977’s Death Game is your typical home invasion thriller where two young girls seduce and torture a businessman while his wife and daughter are on a trip. Both actors felt the movie was a missed opportunity and touted the idea of a remake, hence their executive producer credits on Knock Knock.

The Remake: Better shot, paced and directed than Death Game, Knock Knock was helmed by Eli Roth, who gets his first A-list leading man with Keanu Reeves. Cast against type as the helpless, hapless businessman, Keanu spends a portion of the film either tied up or otherwise immobilized, but a word of warning to anyone expecting him to break free and deliver some John Wick-style revenge: this is not that kind of movie.

The combination of Eli Roth and a dull 70s thriller most viewers will have never heard of probably sounds like a turn off, but this is Roth’s most atypical film to date as well as one of his most tightly controlled. It’s essentially the Roth film for people who hated Hostel and The Green Inferno, lighter on the gore and nudity (and stupidity) than you’d expect from this director.


8. Wild Card

Wild Card Jason Statham
Lionsgate

The Original: Based on a novel by William Goldman, Heat stars Burt Reynolds (then entering his post-Cannonball Run career slump) as an ex-mercenary who hires himself out as a bodyguard/chaperone in Las Vegas. Complications ensue when he encounters the son of a mobster and a businessman who wants to learn how to defend himself.

The Remake: Reunited with director Simon West (The Mechanic, Expendables 2), Jason Statham gets a change of pace with Wild Card, playing a character rather than a growling thug who throws people through walls. This is a low key drama that’s closer to Hummingbird than Crank, but The Stath is so good in a rare (for him) non-growling role that you wish he’d do straight drama more often.

Better paced and more entertaining than the original (a troubled production where Reynolds fell out with the director), Wild Card won’t rock your world but it’s still a solid movie. Throw in a decent supporting cast that includes Stanley Tucci and Sophia Vergara, and you’ve got a movie that’s well worth a look.


7. Come Out And Play

Come Out And Play
Videocine

The Original: Three years after The Exorcist and eight years before the film adaptation of Children Of The Corn, Spanish director Narciso Ibanez Serrador brought evil children to the screen in Who Can Kill A Child, in which two English tourists arrive on an island where the children have killed all the adults. Atmospheric and disturbing, this is 70s Eurohorror at its finest.

The Remake: Come Out And Play follows the original fairly closely, so viewers expecting instant gratification and jump scares should look elsewhere. Mexican director Makinov (who also wrote, produced, edited and shot the movie) prefers atmosphere and slow burn suspense to all violence and gore, and his film has a closed-in, stripped-down feel that’s appropriate for the admittedly slender narrative.

The picture’s claustrophobic feel helps build a sense of mounting dread that pays off (and then some) in the third act, but to reveal any more would be unthinkable. If you’re looking for a small scale picture that knows how to generate thrills with scant resources, you’re better off watching Come Out And Play than the concurrent Paranormal Activity 4.


6. True Lies

True Lies
Universal Pictures

The Original: Directed by Claude Zidi, who later made Asterix And Obelix Vs Caesar, La Totale is a 1991 French comedy about a supposedly boring civil servant who turns out to be a secret agent. When he suspects his wife of having an affair, he spies on her using all the sophisticated surveillance gear at his disposal with “hilarious” consequences.

The Remake: What’s surprising about True Lies is how much of the original James Cameron retained, even recreating several shots from the action sequences. This is of course a bigger, slicker movie, and it goes without saying that at no point in Zidi's movie does anyone commandeer an F-16 fighter jet at a moment’s notice.

In fact, Cameron’s large-scale action sequences actually improve the original narrative, which became a bit of a damp squib in its third act as the villains were revealed to be a bunch of incompetent klutzes. Cameron isn’t having any of that and throws in everything but the proverbial sink for the sake of an entertaining show, including an amusingly OTT finale where Arnie fights off the villain while piloting said F-16.


5. 3:10 To Yuma

3:10 To Yuma Russell Crowe
Lionsgate

The Original: Based on a short story by Elmore Leonard, 3:10 To Yuma is one of the best Westerns of the 1950s. A small time farmer (Van Heflin) winds up being tasked with ensuring that Glenn Ford’s captured outlaw leader is put on the eponymous train, unaware Ford’s gang are prepared to stop him.

The Remake: Bigger, bolder and with a different ending, this new version packs in four towering performances from Christian Bale as the farmer, Russell Crowe as the scripture-quoting villain, Peter Fonda as a bounty hunter and Ben Foster as one of Crowe’s henchmen.

This is a good old-fashioned Western, one of the best of 2000s, full of a-man’s-gotta-do-what-a-man’s-gotta-do heroism, but it takes the time to develop its characters so that they never come across as stick figures. The director is James Mangold (Copland, The Wolverine), who’s an old hand at action, so even when the going gets rough you can always tell what’s happening.

When The Magnificent Seven opens, it’ll be interesting to stack Mangold’s picture alongside Antoine Fuqua’s reboot and see which comes off as the better movie.


4. Charlie And The Chocolate Factory

Charlie And The Chocolate Factory Willy Wonka Johnny Depp
Warner Bros.

The Original: Disowned by Roald Dahl, who’d wanted Spike Milligan for the title role, Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory is your average children’s musical set in a psychedelic wonderland where green-haired, orange-skinned Oompa Loompas assist an eccentric recluse in creating lickable wallpaper, fizzy lifting drinks and everlasting gobstoppers.

The Remake: Now titled after Dahl’s book, Charlie And The Chocolate Factory is mostly about Charlie (Freddie Highmore), a shining innocent surrounded by dark, bizarre characters. Part Michael Jackson, part George McFly, and very different from Gene Wilder’s take on the character, you’re never sure if Johnny Depp’s Wonka is going to turn out to be a benefactor or the Child Catcher from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.

In a subplot absent from the original film, Christopher Lee appears as Depp’s father, adding more depth to the narrative and fleshing out Wonka as something more than just an eccentric recluse. Tim Burton styles the movie so you won’t be able to take your eyes off the screen, whether you’re just passing through the fudge processing centre or watching a kid expand into an oversized blueberry.


3. House On Haunted Hill

House On A Haunted Hill Remake
Warner Bros.

The Original: Vincent Price plays Frederick Loren, a millionaire who offers six people $10,000 each to spend the night in a haunted house. Courtesy of the gimmick “Emergo”, the onscreen ghosts were manifested in theatres as wire-supported inflatable skeletons that emerged at crucial moments to frighten the audience.

The Remake: William Malone’s 1999 version ditches the inflatable skeletons, soups up the special effects and keeps its tongue firmly in its cheek as “Steven Price” (Geoffrey Rush) invites six people to his haunted mansion, unaware that one of them has an ulterior motive.

Made in the spirit of William Castle’s wonderful original, this is one of the most most loving tributes to a “B” picture you’ll ever see. Full of atmosphere, in jokes and most of all, fun, House On Haunted Hill is part ghost train ride, part ghost movie parody and never less than entertaining. Given Hollywood’s current fixation with blah remakes of ghost movies (Poltergeist), it already looks like a classic.


2. Heat

Heat Movie De Niro Pacino
Warner Bros.

The Original: Shot in two weeks, L.A. Takedown is a rare TV movie from Michael Mann, who at that point in his career was still coming to terms with the box office failure of The Keep and Manhunter. It’s essentially the same cops and robbers story he later retold in Heat, only on a smaller scale and with fewer name actors. The biggest “names” in the cast are Michael Rooker and Daniel Baldwin.

The Remake: Running nearly three hours, with a cast that’d do a Quentin Tarantino movie proud, Heat is the crime melodrama that other movies want to be when they grow up. It’s remarkable in so many ways, from the insight it gives into the lives of criminals to the way Mann juggles the multiple plot lines simultaneously, that it’s easy to overlook the solid supporting cast that includes Natalie Portman, Danny Trejo and Henry Rollins.

Front and centre, though, is the relationship between Al Pacino’s cop and Robert De Niro’s thief, and it’s a sign of how taut Mann’s direction is that one of the most memorable scenes involves a meeting between them in a coffee shop where nothing really happens.


1. The Little Shop Of Horrors

Little Shop Of Horrors
Warner Bros.

The Original: Legendary as “The Film Shot In Two Days”, Roger Corman’s 1960 cheapie tells the story of Seymour Krelborn (Jonathan Haze), a florist’s assistant (and full-time loser) who finally gains respect for his “unusual” new plant, little realizing it needs blood to survive.

The Remake: Rebooted as a musical, this 1986 version outdoes its predecessor in every way, from Lyle Conway’s incredible creature design to the casting, with Rick Moranis a perfect Seymour and Ellen Greene (reprising her stage role) just right as his would-be girlfriend. The supporting cast is also excellent, with amusing cameos from Bill Murray, John Candy and Christopher Guest. Steve Martin, as the dentist, should’ve gotten his own movie.

In this version, the plant (“Audrey II”) speaks with the voice of Levi Stubbs of The Four Tops, and in one of the standout scenes performs “Mean Green Mother From Outer Space”, which became the first song containing profanity to receive an Oscar nomination (it lost out to Top Gun – boo!).

“You can keep The Thing, keep the It, keep the creature, they don’t mean sh*t!” sings Audrey II. They really don’t remake them like they used to, do they?

Agree with these picks? Which remakes are your favourites? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'