10 Movie Rules That Make No Sense

No-kill policies just aren't realistic.

Harry Potter This Makes No Sense
Warner Bros.

In the fantastical world of Hollywood filmmaking, it's not so much important that films be "realistic," but simply that they adhere to their own internal logic - that is, lay down some clear rules and stick to them throughout.

But as we all know, that's a lot easier said than done, especially in franchise cinema which potentially invites a diverse array of different voices lending their own knowledge (or lack thereof) to a project.

But sometimes it's also simply a case of a single screenwriter failing to fact-check their own movie, or perhaps even trying to slip a contradiction past audiences in the hope they either don't notice or don't care.

Yet care audiences certainly did where these 10 movie rules are concerned. Each is a firmly established rule which governs its respective movie, and yet, each also fell apart like wet toilet paper the moment audiences stopped and thought about them for more than a few seconds.

While in most cases the movies are good enough to survive the internal rule-breaking, they're nevertheless all major sticking points for the most committed die-hard fans...

10. Don't Feed Gremlins After Midnight - Gremlins

Gizmo Gremlins
Amblin

The Gremlins movies are of course governed by three seemingly specific rules: don't get the cute creatures wet, don't expose them to bright lights, and most importantly, don't feed them after midnight.

We all know what happens when these rules are inevitably broken - Gizmo spawns mogwai out of his back which eventually transform into evil Gremlins - and while the first two rules make perfectly simple sense, the third remains a major point of contention among fans.

The issue is that "after midnight" is a vague and relative term. When does the post-midnight period end? And as briefly, hilariously mentioned in the sequel, what happens if a mogwai crosses time zones?

Sure, fans have theorised that a mogwai can't be fed again until sunrise, but this isn't information that the movie gives us, and so the precise mechanics of their physiology are left needlessly ambiguous.


9. The Xenomorph Gestation Period - Alien

Alien Xenomorph
20th Century Fox

The Xenomorph is unquestionably one of cinema's most terrifying antagonists, yet it's also fair to say that the creature's physical characteristics have been inconsistent at best across the Alien series' tenure.

By far the most-tinkered with aspect of the Xenomorph is its gestation period within a host's body before inevitably bursting out of their chest.

The original Alien made it clear this took place within a few hours, yet throughout most other entries in the series, this time is basically adjusted to suit a specific film's dramatic needs.

For example, Alien 3 sees Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) survive for several days before being chestbursted, and while some fans have argued that this is due to her being impregnated with a Xenomorph Queen, that feels like a stretch to justify iffy writing.

Things pretty much go all over the place from this point: the atrocious Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem boils the gestation period down to probably less than an hour, and Alien: Covenant follows a similar time-frame.

Again, you can argue that the gestation period differs depending on the biology of the host, but even then, the wide disparity between human hosts is pretty ridiculous.


8. The Rules Of Quidditch - Harry Potter

Harry Potter Quidditch
Warner Bros.

Quidditch is of course the famous broomstick-riding sport featured in the Harry Potter franchise, yet the rules of the game are nebulous and confusing enough that even the hardcore crowd will have difficulty making sense of them - let alone mere casuals.

For starters, students are able to use their own broomsticks, effectively allowing wealthier students to come to the field with a massive advantage due to their superior wares.

But by far the biggest issue consistently raised by fans is the sport's scoring system.

A mere 10 points are awarded for throwing the Quaffle - a leather ball passed between players - through one of the opposing team's hoops, while if a team's Seeker manages to catch the enchanted ball known as the Golden Snitch, they'll score 150 points and end the game immediately (potentially even causing their own loss in the process if they're still behind on points).

Placing so much importance on the Golden Snitch not only undermines the Quaffle but also the team-based nature of the game itself, given how it centers the game around the actions of just a single player.


7. The Laws Of Ageing - X-Men

X-Men Apocalypse 14.jpg
20th Century Fox

The X-Men franchise may be a load of silly fantasy hooey at the end of the day, but audiences nevertheless expect the movies to adhere to basic aspects of human existence - like ageing, for example.

Since the X-Men prequels kicked off with First Class, the series has increasingly stretched credibility by leaping forward a decade with each new movie, while the focal superheroes all look more-or-less the same age.

Given that Dark Phoenix takes place in 1992, some 30 years after First Class, we're left to assume that the likes of Professor X (James McAvoy) and Magneto (Michael Fassbender) are now in their early 60s. Right.

While you might play the mutant card and argue that their ageing is slowed by that process, that makes no sense at all considering that, in Dark Phoenix, Xavier and Magneto are suppose to be just a few years away from looking like Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen respectively.

The only major character where this defense truly applies is Mystique (Jennifer Lawrence), given both her shape-shifting abilities and Beast (Nicholas Hoult) flat-out saying in First Class that she ages slower than your average person.

It gets even sillier when you consider non-mutant Moira MacTaggert (Rose Bryne), who appears in both First Class and Apocalypse which are set 21 years apart.

Despite this, she barely seems to have aged at all - because the films were actually made just five years apart, of course.

This is one of those things that fans just need to roll with if they're going to actually enjoy the series without nitpicking it to death, but it's undeniably distracting all the same.


6. The Prime Directive - Star Trek

Star Trek Into Darkness Chris Pine Karl Urban
Paramount

In Star Trek, Starfleet is governed by the underpinning principle of the Prime Directive, which prevents personnel from interfering with the natural advancement of alien civilisations, even at the cost of a Starfleet vessel or crew member.

Fans have passionately debated its philosophical merits ever since it was first introduced in Trek's original series, and it's endured as a thematic mainstay of the various Trek shows and movies.

The problem, however, is that its treatment has proven thoroughly inconsistent across all Trek media, largely a by-product of the huge number of writers who have worked on the colossal sci-fi empire over the decades.

Without the Prime Directive ever being presented in its entirety to viewers, they've been left to debate whether it's as strict as some Trek media seems to imply, or more of a moral guideline.

This debate was ignited again with the release of Star Trek Into Darkness, which saw Kirk (Chris Pine) removed from commanding the Enterprise after violating the Prime Directive to save an indigenous species from an erupting volcano on their planet.

Comparatively, Captain Picard (Patrick Stewart) seems to hold the Prime Directive in extremely high regard, as seen in both The Next Generation series and the movie Star Trek: Insurrection, in the latter case being threatened with a court martial for refusing to disobey it.

The simple answer is that the Prime Directive is discretionary from captain to captain depending on their own respect for it, but more than a half-century on, we still don't have a concrete grasp of its full scope and utility.


5. Time Travel Logic - Looper

Looper Bruce Willis Joseph Gordon Levitt
TriStar Pictures

Time travel is a tough logical nut to crack at the best of times, so for Rian Johnson's sci-fi hit Looper, he basically decided to throw his hands up and accept the contradictions.

Many complained about the film's various logical issues per its timey-wimey shenanigans, particularly the sequence in which young Seth (Paul Dano) has his limbs dismembered and these effects immediately appear on old Seth's body (Frank Brennan). After all, if this always happened to Seth as a young man, wouldn't he always be mutilated as an older man?

And so, in order to hang a lampshade over all this "nitpicking," Johnson literally put a scene in the middle of the movie where old Joe (Bruce Willis) tells young Joe (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) that his logical questions aren't important and he shouldn't overthink it all.

Considering how the overwhelming majority of time travel movies are totally unwilling to confront their paradoxes, it's at least refreshing that Looper decided to embrace its inevitable non-logic.


4. The Double Jeopardy Law - Double Jeopardy

Double Jeopardy Ashley Judd
Paramount Pictures

1999's Ashley Judd-starring crime thriller Double Jeopardy was a huge hit with audiences, despite being built on a fundamental misunderstanding - whether wilful or not - of the American legal system.

The film's protagonist is Libby Parsons (Judd), a woman convicted of her husband Nick's (Bruce Greenwood) murder. But before she's sent to prison, she comes to realise that Nick most likely framed her and faked his own death.

After being paroled, she invokes the Double Jeopardy Clause, which according to the film's logic means a person can't be convicted of the same crime twice, apparently allowing her to hunt Nick down and kill him without legal consequences.

Of course, anyone with even a basic understanding of the law will appreciate how ridiculous this is, as the real Double Jeopardy Clause only actually applies to prevent people being convicted again for the specific criminal event they've already been tried for.

And so, if Libby killed her husband in real life as she does in the movie, she'd be opening herself up to all sorts of legal action. Not smart.


3. The Rule Of Two - Star Wars

Palpatine Rise of Skywalker
Lucasfilm

Much like Star Trek's Prime Directive, Star Wars' Rule of Two is vaguely defined and interpreted with a varying degree of faithfulness by different parties.

At face value, the Rule of Two is a Sith philosophy stating that only two Sith Lords can ever exist at one time: one master and one apprentice.

The rule was first concocted by the legendary Sith Darth Bane, who felt that an overabundance of self-serving Sith Lords led to the order's downfall through betrayal and infighting.

And the Rule of Two endured for a long time, allowing the Sith to operate undetected while maintaining a status quo whereby the apprentice inevitably killed their master and found themselves their own apprentice to mentor.

Star Wars media in general has found ways to conveniently hand-wave the Rule of Two over the years, such as The Clone Wars' Asajj Ventress being presented as more of a Dark Jedi than a formal apprentice to Count Dooku, who was himself Darth Sidious' apprentice.

Since its first mention in The Phantom Menace, the Rule of Two has become increasingly fluid and ambiguous, and much like the Prime Directive, has generally bent to the whims of various storytellers with their own visions for the IP.

The rule became even more strained with the release of The Rise of Skywalker, which presented an entire fleet of Sith acolytes residing on Exogol with zombie-Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid).

However, the movie's recent junior novelisation retconned the Rule of Two to mean "rule by two," basically implying there can be many more Sith, but only two Sith rulers.

Either way, the waters are murky enough that it'd be no surprise if this was re-worked again in the future. Basically, like Looper's time travel, don't overthink it lest you get a pounding headache.


2. The Superhero No-Kill Policy

Man Of Steel Henry Cavill Scream
Warner Bros.

Given that most superhero movies are designed with younger audiences in mind, it's little surprise that a few frontline movie heroes like Batman, Superman, and Spider-Man tend to be profoundly moral people with a major aversion to killing.

This is especially true in the case of Batman, who in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Saga in particular has held a steadfast promise not to take the lives of his foes, for fear of crossing the line from heroism to criminality.

Except, of course, the Caped Crusader is shown killing several people throughout the trilogy, whether blowing up the League of Shadows' HQ, leaving Ra's al Ghul (Liam Neeson) to twist in the wind, tackling Two-Face (Aaron Eckhart) to his death, or blowing Talia al Ghul (Marion Cotillard) to holy hell.

The point isn't that these actions were wrong in any sense, but simply that rigid no-kill policies make no sense whatsoever, especially in a movie series desperately trying to seem as grounded and "real" as possible.

Though it proved divisive with fans, this is exactly why Man of Steel's decision to have Superman (Henry Cavill) kill Zod (Michael Shannon) was so effective, because it trampled over unrealistic binary morality and asked a bulletproof man to make an impossible decision.

The fact that most superheroes these days don't make a big song and dance about the lack of bad guy death on their conscience really underlines how unrealistic and unfair it is to hold anyone in their position to that sort of pristine standard.


1. The Aliens Are Allergic To Water - Signs

Signs M. Night Shyamalan
Touchstone Pictures

M. Night Shyamalan's Signs revolves around an alien invasion on Earth, and concludes with a characteristically barmy Shyamalan twist, that the aliens are actually deathly allergic to water of all things.

Ever since the film's release, fans have questioned why an alien species would dare try to invade a planet where 71% of its surface is covered by the very thing that kills them.

Dumb aliens are one thing, but this perceived "plot hole" actually overlooks the movie's true logical fallacy: the inconsistency of the water rule itself.

Late in the movie, we see that a glass of water severely scalds an alien's skin, and so, considering that there are 37.5 million gallons of water in the Earth's air at any one time, shouldn't the aliens' sheer presence on our planet cause them some measure of discomfort?

Even if you argue the aliens need to be hit with a greater concentration of water in order to be harmed, you'd think the residual water in the air would at least singe their skin if a light spill can make them resemble a third-degree burns victim, no?

Signs is a perfectly entertaining movie up to this point, so it's a shame Shyamalan invites so much second guessing from the audience so late in the game.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.