10 Movie Scenes Everyone Always Gets Wrong
No, Black Widow wasn't talking about being infertile.
Ambiguity can be a wonderful thing in cinema - it allows people to bring their own experiences to movies and draw their own conclusions as a result, often inviting spirited, healthy debate in the process.
But sometimes people are just flat-out wrong about a movie scene, misinterpreting the author's true intent in a way which might even end up altering their opinion of the entire movie.
These 10 movie scenes, whether from mega-budget blockbusters or tiny dramas, have all been interpreted a very particular way by audiences at large despite strong proof to the contrary, if not confirmation from the filmmakers themselves.
You're of course free to engage with a film however you like - and invoke the Death of the Author principle if you so wish - but if you do cling to your long-held readings of these movie scenes, you're willfully keeping yourself in the dark.
Don't feel bad, though, because the common interpretations are more often than not relatively reasonable, and have largely endured in pop-culture as the dominant read. But ultimately, they weren't what was actually intended by those in charge...
10. Andrew Wasn't Really Rushing OR Dragging - Whiplash
The most famous scene in tenacious Oscar-winner Whiplash sees ruthless jazz instructor Terence Fletcher (J.K. Simmons) becoming increasingly frustrated with student Andrew (Miles Teller) as he seemingly fails to match his tempo.
Throughout the gut-wrenching scene, Fletcher calls Andrew out for either "rushing" or "dragging" to his beat, and to the layperson, it seems that while Fletcher may be an a**hole, he's also a strident perfectionist above all else.
But one curious fan actually decided to take a deep dive into the scene and analyse Andrew's timing for themselves. As it turns out, he's pretty much spot on, and Fletcher is just calling him a rusher or a dragger willy-nilly, presumably in order to get a rise out of him.
While the film makes no secret of Fletcher's near-psychopathic desire to push his students to greatness, many nevertheless assumed his critique of Andrew's drumming was in fact correct.
Ultimately Fletcher's method, of testing Andrew's patience and commitment to perfection, is defined by one line late in the movie: "There are no two words in the English language more harmful than 'good job.'"
9. Jango Fett's Head Flies Out Of The Helmet - Star Wars: Episode II - Attack Of The Clones
Ever since the release of Star Wars: Attack Of The Clones, fans have speculated about the scene where Mace Windu (Samuel L. Jackson) parts Jango Fett's (Temuera Morrison) head from his body with a swift slash of his purple lightsaber.
Moments later we see a young Boba Fett (Daniel Logan) pick up his "father's" helmet, causing many to note an apparent mistake, given that Jango's head should still be within the helmet.
Though the "gaffe" resulted in this hilarious R-rated fan edit, it's also easily resolved if you actually just pay attention to the scene: when Windu delivers the killing blow, there's a fleeting shot where the shadow of the helmet can be seen as it flies through the air.
You might also notice a second shadow, which is clearly Jango's decapitated head flying out of the helmet, ensuring that Boba doesn't get an added grisly surprise when he picks it up.
Still a disturbing scene, mind, but not quite as unsettling nor as mistake-laden as fans seem to think it is.
8. Two-Face's Coin Flip Isn't What You Think - Batman Forever
Comic book fans have plenty of issues with Joel Schumacher's Batman Forever, not least its treatment of iconic villain Two-Face (Tommy Lee Jones).
One scene which rankles fans involves Two-Face and The Riddler (Jim Carrey) invading Wayne Manor, blowing up the Batcave, shooting Bruce (Val Kilmer) and taking Dr. Chase Meridian (Nicole Kidman) hostage.
In the comics, Two-Face is noted for flipping a coin to decide a victim's fate and accepting the outcome no matter what, but in this scene, we see him flip his coin three times until he gets the outcome he desires, allowing him to fire a shot at Bruce.
But there's an alternate explanation for the scene, that Harvey Dent is actually flipping the coin each time for a different person currently inside Wayne Manor - Alfred (Michael Gough), Chase, and finally Bruce.
If it sounds far-fetched, remember that Aaron Eckhart's Two-Face did the exact same thing in the climax of The Dark Knight, flipping his coin three times in quick succession to determine the fates of Batman (Christian Bale), himself, and Jim Gordon's (Gary Oldman) son.
7. Upham Isn't A Coward, He's The Viewer - Saving Private Ryan
One of the many, many disturbing sequences in Saving Private Ryan sees Corporal Upham (Jeremy Davies) paralysed with fear while his comrade Private Mellish (Adam Goldberg) is overpowered and slowly stabbed to death by a German soldier.
The common audience response to the scene, sadly, is to find Upham's actions inexplicable, that his failure to save his teammate is an act of abject cowardice, and that we the audience would never behave in such a way.
Except, we almost certainly would.
The entire point of the scene, as is missed by so many, is that the average human being thrust into war would likely freeze up just as Upham did.
Our knee-jerk revulsion to his inaction only underlines the parts of our selves we'd prefer not to confront, that in a traumatic situation, heroism would be the last thing on our minds.
To say that Upham picks up the "idiot ball" in this scene is to bafflingly gloss over the effects of trauma on the human psyche.
6. Tom Has (Probably) Learned Nothing At The End - (500) Days Of Summer
Though (500) Days of Summer announces not to be a love story at the very beginning, it's also fair to say that many viewers seem to misinterpret the movie's emotional throughline, blaming Summer (Zooey Deschanel) for her and Tom's (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) breakup despite Tom clearly having unrealistic expectations from the outset.
Even Gordon-Levitt himself called Tom "selfish" in a recent interview, agreeing that he is effectively the "villain" of the movie.
But the end of the film goes one step further by having Tom move on from Summer and meet a new romantic interest named Autumn (Minka Kelly).
While a superficial reading would say that this a mere cute wink to the audience that Tom has moved on to someone new, an altogether darker interpretation is that Tom actually hasn't grown as much as he thinks.
The fact that the film's ongoing day counter resets from 500 to 1 seems to suggest he's going to repeat a similar cycle with Autumn.
This isn't to say Tom learned nothing from his time with Summer, but that he may well fall into a similar pattern of unhealthy, obsessive romantic behaviour with his new prospect. Again, it isn't a love story.
5. Superman Didn't Make Earth Spin Backwards - Superman (1978)
Few who've seen Richard Donner's original 1978 Superman will forget the iconic scene where an enraged Superman (Christopher Reeve) turns back time in order to undo Lois Lane's (Margot Kidder) death.
Superman is seen flying around the Earth to reverse time, and because we're shown Earth spinning backwards on its axis, many chose to believe that the Man of Steel literally exerted enough force on the planet itself to reverse the flow of time.
But the real answer is a lot simpler and less-silly than that: Superman is actually flying around the Earth in order to reach the speed of light, allowing him to travel back through time. It's still relatively ridiculous, of course, but makes far more sense.
Showing the Earth rotating backwards is just an easy visual shorthand to explain to the audience what is happening to time, though it is at least easy to appreciate why so many people have gotten the scene wrong over the decades.
4. The Ending Doesn't Glorify Jordan Belfort, It Critcises The Audience - The Wolf Of Wall Street
The Wolf of Wall Street was another expertly crafted winner for Martin Scorsese, though invited spirited discussions about the tone and intent of the piece, which some criticised as overtly glorifying Wall Street fraudster Jordan Belfort (Leonardo DiCaprio).
Especially polarising was the film's final scene, where Belfort is released from prison and embarks on a new career hosting seminars on sales technique to regular folk.
Many have interpreted the scene, in which Belfort asks his gawking audience to try and sell him a pen, as effectively deifying him as a one-in-a-million talent with a peerlessly unique knack for salesmanship, but the scene isn't doing that at all.
Really, the ending is a critique of the audience - both those at the seminar and those watching the movie - who hang on Belfort's every word and find his story of crooked greed aspirational.
Scorsese's final pan to a sea of blank, clueless faces is a pitch-perfect reflection of the movie's audience themselves, and that if we found Jordan's personality charming or his chaotic lifestyle appealing, his sales pitch clearly worked on us too.
3. Bonnie Discarding Woody Doesn't Sour Toy Story 3 - Toy Story 4
Though most fans were pleasantly surprised by the wildly unnecessary Toy Story 4, there were nevertheless those who expressed frustration at the actions of young Bonnie, who despite "inheriting" Woody (Tom Hanks) from Andy at the end of the third film, ends up neglecting him in the follow-up.
Some went as far as to call Bonnie the real "villain" of Toy Story 4, that in discarding Woody and moving on to other toys, she not only broke her promise to Andy but actively soured the perfect ending of Toy Story 3 in the process.
But neither of these claims are true at all. Beyond the fact it's ridiculous to hold a small child to account for such a benign promise, it's important to remember that what was an epochal passing-of-the-torch moment for Andy and the audience was likely a minor footnote for Bonnie.
It's unreasonable to expect a young child to remain attached to one toy indefinitely, and in the end Bonnie's "abandonment" of Woody only allowed him to realise his own sense of agency outside of ownership, becoming a "lost toy" capable of charting his own path.
As wonderfully bittersweet as Toy Story 3's ending was, expecting Bonnie to be Andy 2.0 was always obscenely optimistic, if not flat-out unfair.
2. Black Widow Calls Herself A "Monster" For Being An Assassin - Avengers: Age Of Ultron
Avengers: Age of Ultron received a ton of blowback upon release as many fans took issue with the scene where Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) tells Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) that she was sterilised as part of the Black Widow program, only to follow up by calling herself a "monster."
While you can't really blame people for not giving Joss Whedon the benefit of the doubt here, and the scene absolutely could've been handled more tactfully, the intent isn't at all to imply she's an abomination because she can't bear children. To quote her exact dialogue:
"They sterilise you. It's efficient. One less thing to worry about. The one thing that might matter more than a mission. Makes everything easier. Even killing. You still think you're the only monster on the team?"
If you actually break down the exchange it's clear that Natasha is referring to herself as a monster only in the context of being a blunt object, a hired assassin shaped to murder people above all else.
If she's a monster at all, it's because of the countless people she's killed and all the "red in her ledger." Say what you will about Whedon, but even he wouldn't make such a blunt statement about sterility.
1. Jimmy Doesn't Commit Suicide - Quadrophenia
Cult classic drama Quadrophenia concludes with an ending which, depending on your viewpoint, is either ambiguous or absolutely cut-and-dried.
In the final scene, protagonist Jimmy (Phil Daniels) is seen riding a scooter to the edge of Beachy Head, before we cut to the scooter flying over the cliff, albeit without any sign of what happens to Jimmy.
Many regardless believe that Jimmy committed suicide by riding his scooter off the cliff edge, while forgetting the ever-important fact that Jimmy can be seen standing by the cliff at sunset right at the start of the movie - a scene which clearly takes place chronologically after the scooter ride.
Jimmy's survival is backed up by not only director Franc Roddam and lead actor Phil Daniels but numerous other cast members. The future is likely still a bleak one for Jimmy, but a little less so than immediately hurtling himself into oblivion.