10 Movie Scenes Everyone Gets Wrong

Social media has ruined Ghostbusters' "ghostjob" scene.

Ghostbusters Ray
Columbia Pictures

The beauty of film is that audiences are free to interpret scenes however they want, as often results in fascinating cinematic discourse online.

But sometime folks are just flat-out wrong.

Inspired by this recent Reddit thread on the subject, these 10 movie scenes have all been wildly misinterpreted by audiences en masse, whether because they weren't paying sufficient attention or simply failed to grasp what the filmmakers were actually going for.

In some cases the writing and direction was clearly at fault, while in others you might be compelled to question whether viewers at large were actually engaged with the story at all.

Either way, these 10 scenes have been hilariously and concerningly misread by vast swaths of cinemagoers.

From wildly misinterpreting the tone and intent of a scene to straight-up seeing something that isn't there and even getting a character's name wrong, it seems like just about everybody whiffed on these movie moments.

Of course we're not calling out everyone here, and no, failing to "get" these scenes doesn't make you stupid, but it is certainly troubling just how many people got the totally wrong end of the cinematic stick...

10. The "Khan!" Scene Isn't William Shatner Overacting - Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan

Kirk Wrath of Khan
Paramount

If you look up "overacting" in the dictionary, you'll rightly find a picture of William Shatner, but his most widely-mocked bout of scenery-chewing actually isn't at all. Or at least, not in the way so many people think.

Even people who've never seen a single episode of Star Trek might be familiar with Captain Kirk's (Shatner) infamous "Khaaaan!" scream in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan.

Kirk bleats the legendary villain's name in hilariously exaggerated fashion after Khan (Ricardo Montalbán) leaves him marooned on the planetoid Regula.

To the inobservant observer, this is simply Shatner hamming up his performance for the cheap seats in the most meme-worthy fashion.

But that's not really what's happening here. It's Kirk who is overacting, given that he knows full well that he and Spock (Leonard Nimoy) have set a trap for Khan, but he can't give any inkling of this, and so plays the part of being absolutely incensed just as Khan would expect.

Make no mistake, Shatner does plenty of overacting elsewhere throughout the movie, but in the scene he's been so regularly indicted for? Absolutely not.


9. "I'll Never Let Go" Isn't Literal - Titanic

Titanic Jack Rose
Fox

Folks love to make fun of James Cameron's Titanic for the climactic sequence where Rose (Kate Winslet) tells Jack (Leonardo DiCaprio), "I'll never let go," only to quite literally let go of him moments later as she's rescued.

Despite how widely-parroted this scathing reading of the scene is, it's of course completely wrong.

Rose isn't literally talking about the physical act of letting go of Jack as he freezes to death in the water, but of holding onto life, not giving up, and ultimately living the adventurous life she wants rather than the one that's expected of her by her family and her status.

And ultimately, that's what she does, with the moving final sequence showing the full, joyous life Rose ended up living.

This should all seem obvious enough to anyone who's actually watched the movie, and yet, it's basically the most low-effort putdown that gets fielded against Titanic whenever somebody feels like lazily slinging mud at it online.


8. Bond Isn't Being Callous About Severine's Death - Skyfall

Skyfall Bond Silva
MGM

Mid-way through Skyfall, 007 (Daniel Craig) and his contact Sévérine (Bérénice Marlohe) end up in the custody of villain Raoul Silva (Javier Bardem), where Silva shoots Sévérine in the head in front of Bond.

Silva then asks him, "What do you say to that?," to which 007 coolly responds, "A waste of good scotch," before launching into an assault against Silva's men.

At the time of Skyfall's release, many called out Bond's remark as excessively callous, that it was an overly detached, dismissive response to witnessing the brutal death of a woman he'd been intimate with - a woman who, as a former sex slave, has suffered a lot in her life.

Yet this of course ignores the fact that Bond simply isn't giving Silva what he wanted. Silva had been trying to break through Bond's psychological armour and rattle him, but in refusing to react and deflecting him with such a heartless one-liner, he doesn't give Silva an inch.

While the film's treatment of Sévérine as a character is certainly suspect in other areas, this line in of all its context isn't "problematic" at all.


7. The Joker Is Lying About Never Making Plans - The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight Joker
Warner Bros.

After Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart) is horribly burned by The Joker (Heath Ledger) and ends up in Gotham General Hospital, he's paid a visit by the Clown Prince of Crime himself, who is unforgettably disguised as a red-haired nurse.

The Joker tries to persuade Dent that he had nothing to do with him or Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal) being kidnapped, but Dent tells him, "Your men, your plan," to which The Joker replies, "Do I really look like a guy with a plan?"

The Joker goes on to compare himself to "a dog chasing cars," prompting many fans to point out the absurdity of the supervillain claiming he doesn't make plans when, clearly, everything he does throughout the movie is planned down to the very last variable.

This is to fundamentally misread this scene, though: The Joker knows he's a guy with a plan, but he's saying what he needs to say in order to push Dent over the edge, cementing his transformation into the corrupted, vengeful Two Face.

Even the mere act of framing himself as an "agent of chaos" to Dent is itself simply another part of The Joker's mind-meltingly elaborate plot to terrorise Gotham.


6. Harry & Hermione's Dance Isn't Romantic - Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows - Part 1

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1
Warner Bros.

Arguably one of the best scenes in the entire Harry Potter franchise occurs in Deathly Hallows - Part 1, when Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) and Hermione (Emma Watson) reach a major nadir in their quest to destroy Voldemort's (Ralph Fiennes) Horcruxes and find some levity by sharing a dance.

Harry gets Hermione to dance to Nick Cave's iconic "O Children," allowing the pair some much-needed human warmth during an extreme low point in their journey, where even Ron (Rupert Grint) has seemingly abandoned them.

For a few brief moments, they're able to forget their woes and enjoy each other's company - as friends.

Yet many fans, book lovers or not, interpret the scene as romantic, that it's teeing up a love story between the two, as though a male and female dancing can't ever be anything but sexually inclined.

It's clear the pair are finding comfort in one another at a majorly fraught time, and despite what some fans/shippers will swear blind, it's nothing more than a pure, wholesome sliver of light amid a mostly dour and depressing movie.


5. "Billy Enforcie" Is Actually "Billy In 4C" - Dumb & Dumber

Dumb And Dumber Billy
New Line Cinema

A minor but extremely memorable character in Dumb and Dumber is "Billy Enforcie" (Brady Bluhm) - a blind boy who Lloyd (Jim Carrey) sells Harry's (Jeff Daniels) dead parakeet to.

Despite Billy having maybe a minute of screen time in the movie, the whole gag is so hilarious(ly cruel) that his name certainly sticks in the mind.

Except, he's not called Billy Enforcie.

You can blame Dumb and Dumber being released before audiences en masse watched movies at home with subtitles on, because anyone who does turn the subs on today will come to learn that the boy is actually called "Billy in 4C." As in, apartment 4C.

It's an easy mistake to make considering how quickly Lloyd and Harry race through the words "in 4C" and how relatively uncommon it is to refer to someone by their apartment number.

Typing "Billy Enforcie" into Google or Twitter (sorry, X) brings up a large number of like-minded folk who got the kid's surname totally wrong, but again, you can't blame them at all.


4. "Let The Past Die" Isn't The Movie's Central Theme - Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Star Wars The Last Jedi Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm

Both those who loved and loathed Star Wars: The Last Jedi gave way too much credence to Kylo Ren's (Adam Driver) memorable one-liner, "Let the past die. Kill it if you have to."

For many, they interpreted it as Kylo Ren essentially being a mouthpiece for the movie's central thematic, that writer-director Rian Johnson wanted to "kill the past" of the Star Wars franchise by so radically shaking up the series' formula.

Even ignoring the fact that having the villain embody the film's message would be incredibly foolish on Johnson's part, that's not even really what The Last Jedi is all about.

Sure, Johnson wanted to wipe away the franchise's more sentimental cobwebs and show fans things they hadn't seen before, yet so much of the movie is still about embracing the past rather than assassinating it.

Yoda (Frank Oz) literally tells Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) in the movie, "The greatest teacher, failure is," indicating a need to learn from the past rather than obliterate it.

Even people who generally defend The Last Jedi to the hilt get this totally wrong, bafflingly.


3. John's Dog Isn't Looking At John In The Graveyard - John Wick: Chapter 4

John Wick Chapter 4
Lionsgate

One of the most infuriating facets of modern cinema discourse is how so many fans can't just let their heroes stay dead. Even if they expire on screen, they need to come up with an explanation for how they could possibly have survived.

Case in point, John Wick: Chapter 4 ends with a mortally wounded John (Keanu Reeves) dying from wounds sustained during the climactic duel with the Marquis Vincent Bisset de Gramont.

Sure, we don't see him get decapitated, blown up, or thrown into a volcano or anything, but there's not much ambiguity about John keeling over, asking Winston (Ian McShane) to take him "home," and a memory of his late wife (Bridget Moynahan) flashing before his eyes.

All the same, many online maintain that the final scene, where Winston and the Bowery King (Laurence Fishburne), visit John's grave, contains a telling clue that John is still alive.

The "evidence"? John's pitbull suddenly turns its head and looks off into the distance during one shot, which far too many fans have interpreted as the dog noticing John watching them in the distance.

No, just no.

While it's certainly possible that Lionsgate sees how much money Chapter 4 made and throws enough cash at Keanu Reeves to return for a fifth film, as this story was conceived and executed and until we're told otherwise, John Wick is definitely dead.

Folks don't want to hear it, but finality and stakes are a good thing in storytelling.


2. The "Ghostjob" Scene Is A Dream - Ghostbusters

Ghostbusters Ray
Columbia

Ghostbusters is one of the most beloved comedies of all time, but in recent years as younger generations have been exposed to it for the first time, there's been increased attention paid to its most risque scene.

We're talking of course about the "ghostjob" sequence, where Ray Stantz (Dan Aykroyd) appears to receive oral sex from a female ghost - a scene which has been reposted on social media ad nauseum in recent years with new viewers expressing disbelief that such an insane moment made it into a "family-friendly" movie.

They're ignoring one part of the equation, though - it's a dream sequence. Literally at the start of the scene, the screen goes wavy - the universally agreed visual language for the start of a dream - and once the "job" is done, we cut back to Ray sleeping in reality.

This is in part a symptom of modern Internet culture, where movie scenes are listlessly reposted online devoid of their context, often with crucial elements selectively removed.

Nuance may be hard, but c'mon, it's Ghostbusters - it's kinda shocking how many people have genuinely forgotten that, no, Ray didn't get noshed off by a ghost "for real."

Fun fact, though: this wasn't originally a dream, but part of a subplot where Ray romances a ghost.

When the wider subplot was deemed superfluous and cut, though, they decided to include this brief gag as a dream in the mid-film ghost-busting montage.


1. Batman Injects Himself With Adrenaline (Not Venom) - The Batman

The Batman
Warner Bros.

If you ask most people what Batman (Robert Pattinson) injects himself with at the end of The Batman after being critically injured by one of The Riddler's (Paul Dano) goons, they'll probably say Venom.

As in, the bright green steroid-like substance which has been used to give Bane his enhanced strength and size in the Batman comic books.

During The Batman's release weekend, fans couldn't be dissuaded otherwise, yet when the film hit home video, pausing the scene in question confirmed beyond any doubt that the vial had "adrenaline" written on the side.

Even so, many fans remain in denial about it to this very day, insisting that director Matt Reeves intentionally coloured the vial green to at least hint at Venom existing in this universe, and perhaps even Bane being a major fixture in the impending sequel.

Bane may or may not appear in The Batman 2, but seriously, everything you need to know about this scene is in the scene itself, as long as you actually accept what it's showing you.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.