10 Movie Sequels That Should Have Been Prequels

Sometimes it's okay to go backwards!

With writers and directors alike growing increasingly content with working on sequel after sequel after yet another sequel, the film industry has become somewhat stagnant of late. At least, that€™s the argument floated by those growing tired of Hollywood's lack of originality, and it€™s fair to an extent, though in reality this so-called obsession with sequels is nothing new. In fact, sequels have been around as long as the movie itself. The Keystone Cops put out no less than a dozen films between 1912 and 1917 and Universal€™s genre-defining monster movies dominated the 1930s and 1940s, with Dracula, The Mummy, Frankenstein and The Wolf Man all getting a number of instalments. This multi-film tradition is alive and well in modern moderns and has been seized upon by film makers of pretty much every genre, from huge ensemble actioners to family-friendly fantasy. It€™s a trend that doesn€™t look like stopping any time soon, though what the powers that be are yet to realise is that sometimes taking a step backwards is the best way to move forwards. It is easy to take the chief protagonists from a successful film and dump them into a new (or slightly tweaked) situation, though there are ways to expand on profitable characters without inflicting two hours of de-ja-vu on the audience. If the resurgence of the superhero genre has taught us anything it is that we all love a good origins story. The one thing more interesting than what happened next is what happened to get us here in the first place, and, as you're about to see for yourself, opportunities to explore the backgrounds of memorable characters are usually passed over in favour of an easy sequel...


10. Ocean's Twelve (2004)

Ocean€™s Eleven was new territory for Steven Soderbergh back in 2001, having previously directed nothing quite as commercially mainstream when he took on the remake of Lewis Milestone€™s 1960 film of the same name. It turned out to belong to a very small pool of movies €“ remakes that are actually more enjoyable than the original. Soderbergh successfully recreated the capers of gentleman thief Danny Ocean (George Clooney) and his cohort in a super slick and perfectly paced heist movie. Ocean€™s Twelve seemed like a no-brainer at this point. Keep the same director, create another exciting job for Ocean and his crew, add to an already impressive cast and you€™re on to a winner, or so you thought. The sequel takes place three years after Ocean and his boys robbed shady entrepreneur Terry Benedict blind, and someone has ratted them out. The resulting game of cat-and-mouse is lazy and illogical, and slick turns to smug. The sequel is mainly remembered for Julia Roberts€™ character Tess pretending to be Julia Roberts in one of the most self-satisfying, cringe-worthy moments in the history of cinema. Actually, scratch that, in history period. Writer George Nolfi would have been better off exploring the origins of Danny Ocean. What was he like before he met Tess? Was he always such an accomplished thief? Rusty Ryan (Brad Pitt) admits that he has known Ocean for many years, with one previous collaboration involving the theft of precious Incan matrimonial headmasks. Maybe this particular job would have come across a bit too Indiana Jones, but seeing a young Danny earn his stripes in the heist world would have been far more entertaining than simply moving Ocean's Eleven to Europe. Plus, George Clooney never ages, so there's casting sorted.

9. The Matrix Reloaded (2003)

Not that stealing thunder from Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is that much of an achievement, but that is exactly what The Matrix did in the summer of 1999. The Wachowskis took their love of Japanese anime and all things cyber-punk and turned it into something that western audiences had never seen on such a scale; a sci-fi action epic that combined ground-breaking special effects with bullet ballet and traditional martial arts. In the sequel, the action scenes went from mind-bending to straight up ridiculous and the longer Reloaded goes on the stronger your urge to pull the plug. The Wachowskis would have been better served going backwards down the timeline and showing us how the resistance began €“ a young Morpheus being freed from the Matrix, becoming captain of the Nebuchadnezzar and beginning his search for The One. This would have eliminated the need to bring chief antagonist Agent Smith back from the dead after being obliterated by Neo, and given the Wachowskis the chance to explore arguably the franchise's most iconic character in depth. Morpheus is known to have been romantically involved with fellow hovercraft captain Niobe in the past, who could have helped a young Morpheus spearhead the rise against the machines. A Morpheus-led prequel would have served up another dose of the Matrix while addressing how the hell they realised it existed to begin with. With any follow-ups, focus ought to have been on the underlying story, not on special effects as was the case with The Matrix Reloaded. Instead of pushing the boundaries they set with the first film, the Wachowskis just made a sequel that was slightly harder to comprehend and hoped that everybody would be too busy concentrating to realise it sucked.

8. Rambo: First Blood Part II (1985)

Sylvester Stallone€™s Rambo films have an unfair reputation as a series full of blood-and-guts action and nothing more, though in reality they have a lot more to offer than just gun fights and explosions. First Blood, the first and best film in the four-movie franchise, is not so much a war movie as it is thriller, with Vietnam vet John Rambo forced into a psychological and physical battle with corrupt local police back in the States. Stallone showed the world that there was an actor underneath all those muscles for the first time, though he wasn€™t given much of a chance to repeat the performance with First Blood Part II three years later. The lacklustre sequel begins with Rambo banged up in jail following his escapades in the first movie, though he will be given a clean slate if he agrees to travel back to Vietnam to locate some American prisoners of war. We always had to see Rambo in action in Vietnam, though instead of a ludicrous premise in which a man who took on an entire police force during a mass manhunt is pardoned, we could have had a straight up Vietnam War movie. The most appealing side to Rambo€™s character is that he is fundamentally against violence, and showing him in the active line of duty would have given Stallone the chance to really flex his acting muscles. First Blood begins with a down-and-out Rambo finding out that Delmore Barry, the last surviving member of the Special Forces unit he served with in Vietnam, has died of Cancer due to Agent Orange exposure. A prequel could have jumped off from this, following the whole unit from the shores of the States to the jungles of Vietnam, where the battle against the Viet Cong made Rambo who he is.

7. Shrek 2 (2004)

Shrek was DreamWorks€™ first real declaration of war against Pixar, a film that rivalled everything that the Disney-backed studio had put out at that stage, Toy Story included. In fact, Shrek went out of its way to rub Disney€™s nose in it on more than one occasion, poking fun at some of the fairy-tales and characters made famous by the long-established studio. This film set a new standard in computer-animated movies; great to look at and, crucially, packed full of subtle adult humour. Shrek was showered with universal praise for its satire and the way it cleverly subverted so many children€™s stories, taking some of the most well-worn tropes in storytelling and presenting them in a new, thoroughly mischievous way. The problem with the first sequel (and all that followed) was that so many stories and fables were referenced in the original that it was a case of slim pickings when it came to taking the story forward. In place of subtle adult humour and tilts on old wives tales Shrek 2 turned its satire on pop culture, and the result felt neither as original nor satisfying as the first effort. Instead of going ahead with three more mediocre instalments, there should have been one brilliant prequel, showing our sulky hero abandoned by his parents at age 7 (an Ogre tradition according to the musical), revealing how he came to own his swamp and why the hell he speaks with a Scottish accent. This would have taken the emphasis off the exhausted satire and made Shrek's life the main focus. It's his gig, after all.

6. Saw II (2005)

The first instalment in the Saw series was a resounding success on many levels, making over $100 million from a budget of less than $2 million and opening the floodgates for visceral, ultra-violent, low-budget horror movies. James Wan€™s claustrophobic film is set almost entirely in a subterranean chamber where two men wake up tied to pipes with a third lying dead between them. The twist was brilliant, even if some of the acting wasn€™t, but hey, this is horror and hammy acting is traditional. Another unfortunate horror tradition is to milk every last ounce out of a successful film, and Saw fell victim to Hollywood€™s franchise mania. The problem with Saw II was that they lost the believability of the original. Waking up tied to a pipe next to a dead man in strange room is somewhat far-fetched, granted, but it isn€™t beyond the realms of imagination, whereas a Home Alone style fun-house filled with torturous gadgets and gizmos goes beyond those realms considerably. Instead of making what was essentially an exaggerated, almost slapstick version of the first movie with Jigsaw€™s €œlittle game€ involving more people this time, the film makers could have explored the antagonist€™s life around the time his failed suicide attempt turned him into a psychotic killer, ending with him donning the mask for the first time and helping us to understand how he got so messed up. It was established in the first film by Dr Gordon that he and fellow captive Adam were not Jigsaw€™s first victims, and a grittier, less over-the-top look at his previous murders would have been preferable to countless blood-spattered rehashes. The character always came across as some kind of omnipresent puppet master - it would have been to cool to have seen him getting his hands dirty slasher-movie style. We did eventually learn his backstory, but along with a lot of annoying forward momentum too.

5. Taken 3 (2014)

Liam Neeson€™s foray into the Paris underworld turned him into a fully-fledged action star overnight, with the guttural and extremely dangerous Bryan Mills now the character he is best known for portraying. In Taken, Mills goes on the hunt for his daughter after she is kidnapped by human traffickers in a pretty formulaic story, though where Taken differs from your everyday revenge flick is in the quality of the action sequences. Too often are films of this type described as high-octane and fast-paced, but once Taken gets going the 91 minute runtime disappears faster than Neeson€™s prey. The same couldn€™t be said for Taken 2, which served up more of the same and could well have been a film made up of deleted scenes from the original. Still, Neeson remains fun to watch as Mills and it has something to say about the futility of vengeance. The less said about Taken 3, the better. The entire franchise is centred around the very particular set of skills that Neeson has acquired over a long career. Instead of carting him out for a slightly-tweaked version of the previous films in which his wife (who, let€™s face it, was a complete bitch) is bumped off, they could have shown us exactly how many asses Bryan Mills had to kick to become such a hard case. It was established on screen that at age 21 Mills enlisted in the United States Army, and at 23 joined the Special Forces before going on to work for the CIA as a so-called "preventer". A prequel should have spanned the length of the character's notorious career, the birth of his daughter and the breakdown of his relationship with his wife. This would have freshened up the formula and worked as a homage to what could have been a new cult action hero.

4. The Chronicles Of Riddick (2004)

Pitch Black, the first film in the Riddick franchise, was created on a much smaller budget than the sequels that followed, and it benefited greatly from it. The small-scale attitude enforced on the project meant that actual effort had to be put into the characters and premise, and the result was a smart and suspense filled science fiction that your imagination was more than willing to meet halfway. The torrent of big-budget effects that was missing from the first film was unleashed in the second, however. Chronicles of Riddick was always going to struggle to appease the growing cult fan-base of the original movie, and while it ticked all the relevant boxes in terms of being a bog-standard action movie, it failed as a sequel to Pitch Black. With more plot holes than black holes, The Chronicles Of Riddick made little sense in the cinematic cut and somehow even less sense in David Twohy€™s director€™s cut. Instead of having Riddick come out of hiding after five years to avenge a conveniently murdered friend in painfully formulaic fashion, Twohy and Vin Diesel ought to have delved deeper into the character€™s fascinating back story and avoided the blockbuster route. Twohy did say that he saw Pitch Black as a prequel to the larger Riddick trilogy, though he may have missed a trick by not going back further and exploring the anti-hero€™s dark past. Pivotal canonical events that were only alluded to should have been fully played out on-screen - the prophecy of the Furyan male (Riddick, of course) who would defeat the Necromonger Zhylaw, and that same Necromonger subsequently strangling most of Furya's newborns with their own umbilical chords. Not exactly blockbuster material, but definitely the direction in which this franchise needed to go in order to stand out from the crowd.

3. Next Friday (2000)

Although we€™re used to seeing him in things like Ride Along and the Jump Street movies nowadays, Ice Cube and comedy weren€™t words you were used to seeing in the same sentence when Friday came out back in 1995. Two decades later and the tale of Craig getting fired on his day off and Smokey trying to duck Big Worm after smoking all of his weed is as funny as it ever was, though the same cannot be said of the sequel, which was hard work even at the first time of watching. While Friday had an excess of attitude and energy, Next Friday was severely lacking in both, abandoning the dialogue-heavy approach for stale sub-plots that seemed to go absolutely nowhere. When Chris Tucker failed to sign up to reprise his role for the sequel (which is a red flag right at the get-go) Mike Epps was brought in to play funny to Ice Cube€™s straight, but he just wasn€™t Smokey. With Tucker out of the picture, Cube and his regular co-writer DJ Pooh should have opted to stay behind the camera and bring in some younger blood to portray teenage versions of Craig and Smokey. If spending the entire day on and around your porch in South Central Los Angeles can be so eventful, a day in high school must be off the charts. A prequel should have shown us Craig and Smokey on their first day of school and how the friendship that made the first film work so well was born. Both actors were in their early twenties when Friday came out and could have even chosen to appear as younger versions of their characters, seeing as most Hollywood high schools are filled with a bunch of 30-something extras anyway.

2. The Woman In Black: The Angel Of Death (2014)

James Watkins€™ adaptation of Susan Hill€™s 1983 horror novella The Woman In Black was traditional to a fault, a vintage ghost story that relied not on blood and gore, but mystery and suspense. Fresh out of Hogwarts, Daniel Radcliffe got to work on shaking off his type-cast by appearing as young widower Arthur Kipps. The London lawyer is sent to a remote countryside village on a job, though his poking around in the old Eel Marsh House sets the villagers, and the audience on edge. Sadly, Angel Of Death lacked the superbly paced tension of the first film. Set 40 years after Kipps visited Eel Marsh, the sequel follows a group of orphaned children forced to move in after War makes London unsafe and, sure enough, they begin to mysteriously disappear. Director Tom Harper has enough horror know-how to make the audience jump on cue, but the sparse script and dull dialogue certainly lesson their impact. The writers had a ready-made story to work with if they had chosen to go down the prequel path instead of creating a host of new characters that failed to live long on-screen or in the memory. Jennet Humfrye was a malevolent presence in the seaside town of Crythin Gifford long before Kipps showed up on her doorstep, and the story of how she became the Woman in Black certainly could have been explored in more depth. Instead of a terrifyingly predictable sequel, the filmmakers should have kept us guessing and given the title of house terror to Jennet Humfrye's sister in life, Alice Drablow. Alice was the real horror in the story, declaring her sibling mentally unstable and adopting her child against her will. Seeing the whole story from Jennet's point of view would have been a bold curve-ball that could have given the series a new tilt while keeping it creepy.

1. The Hangover Part III (2013)

After the success of the first two Hangover movies, a third instalment was always inevitable. The original is rightfully considered to be the best film in the trilogy, but, despite a hammering from critics unimpressed with the same plot in a different location, Part II actually made a staggering $587 million at the worldwide box office, some feat for an R-rated comedy. When it came to Part III, however, writers Todd Phillips and Craig Mazin took the criticism a little too literally and eliminated the whole concept of solving the mystery of the night before by removing the actual hangover from the equation all together. In place of the tried and tested formula, the Wolfpack are sent on a road trip that ends up in them being kidnapped by the most unconvincing mob boss in the history of mob bosses. The third and final film is such a detour from what came before it that it barely warrants being part of the franchise. In what is essentially the Lesley Chow show, the chief characters take a back seat to the series villain and his tiresome antics all too often. There was never room for yet another wedding/bachelor party gone wrong, though an exploration of Allen€™s (Zach Galifianakis) past could have taken the series in a new direction without sacrificing the style or the humour. Galifianakos was the stand-out performer in the first two films, with every memorable moment involving him in some way. We know from seeing his police record (which, if you€™ll recall, included one charge of masturbating on a public bus) that Allen had gotten into his fair share of scrapes before the events of The Hangover, and a standalone Allen Garner movie could have really been something. Perhaps even the start of a whole new franchise. Which other disappointing sequels should have been prequels instead? Shout out any more down in the comments.

Contributor

Phil still hasn't got round to writing a profile yet, as he has an unhealthy amount of box sets on the go.