10 Movies That Almost Had Much Better Endings
When the alternate ending was actually better.

As a rule, alternate endings don't make it into the film because they were a bit naff; a back-up idea that clearly didn't past muster with the creative types. Heck, just a couple of weeks ago we looked at 10 Great Movies Almost Ruined By Their Alternate Endings, which highlights just how bad some iron-clad classics could have turned out.
But that isn't always the case. Whether it's a director not understanding the source material, of a major lapse in judgement, some movies can leave their best ending on the cutting room floor (or, more contemporarily, the recycle bin), leaving us with a rather compromised movie.
One of the biggest problems tends to be test screenings. In the months leading up to release, small groups of the general public with little experience in film are shown rough cuts of movies and asked for their input. A shocking amount of stock is put in this process, with the director's creative drive sometimes completely overridden by negative results; many downbeat endings have become happy when the test screenings found it "too depressing".
Today we're going to take a look at ten alternate endings that would actually have been better than the ones we got, in some way actually improving their movies.
10. Hannibal And Clarice Run Off Together - Hannibal

The Official Ending: Hannibal (the belated sequel to The Silence Of The Lambs, not the stellar TV series) was in development hell for so long that it lost both the director and actress from the original. The third act sees Lecter escape the clutches of revenge-bent paedophille Mason Verger and introduce law official Paul Krendler to self-cannibalism, climaxing with the bad doctor evading capture by severing his arm, leaving behind a drugged and traumatised Clarice Starling. A final scene sees a one-handed Lecter offering up some of his food to a kid, extolling that "it is important to always try new things." Haha, it's funny because it's brains.
The One We Almost Got: Like all other entries in the film series, Hannibal is based on a Thomas Harris novel, although Ridley Scott's movie diverges from the book in the final moments. In print, Lecter attempts to brainwash Starling into thinking she's his long-dead sister (that's a much more prevalent story beat throughout the books), ultimately failing, but not without the FBI falling in love with him. The ending sees the two run off together as a duo even more unnerving than Natural Born Killers.
Why It Would Have Been Better: Hannibal has some nice ideas and themes, but the ending, despite Ray Liotta eating his own prefrontal cortex, feels a little flat. The film already goes pretty morally corrupt with the sadistic disembowelling of Inspector Pazzi, so it makes little sense to not go the whole hog and bring this incredibly disturbing finale to life.
Check out Hannibal over at Amazon.
9. Harry's Pre-Victory Speech - Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows: Part 2

The Official Ending: The entire Harry Potter series comes to a close in spectacular fashion, with the splitting of the last book in two meaning the final movie is essentially one massive action sequence. Deaths, twists and tears come gushing out, with the whole thing climaxing with the epic confrontation between Voldemort and the boy who lived. The pair skirmish around the school, before one final round in the dilapidated courtyard, where Harry manages to inexplicably disintegrate the Dark Lord. Afterwards he explains that it was because he owned the Elder Wand, or something.
The One We Almost Got: In J.K. Rowling's novel, there's the same broad strokes of the battle, but the execution is much grander. The fight is in the Great Hall, with everyone watching it unfold, while Tom Riddle's body doesn't disappear (not a big change, it's just really dumb). But, biggest of all, the explanation of why Harry can't lose (he is the official owner of Voldemort's wand) is central, explicitly stated in a great speech before the fight, showing the end of his journey to become a hero and adult.
Why It Would Have Been Better: The book ending brings together the plot action and overall coming-of-age themes to present something that perfectly rounds off the character. The film has an elaborate light show.
Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Parts 1&2 is available to buy over at Amazon.
8. Audrey II Takes Over The World - Little Shop Of Horrors

The Official Ending: Little Shop Of Horrors, the big screen adaptation of the off-Broadway musical based on a minor 1960 horror comedy, is a pretty solid movie that is more than just another big screen musical. The songs are incredibly catchy, but the real selling point is the incredible puppeteering behind man-eating plant Audrey II. Revealed in the final scenes to be an alien with an eye towards world domination, it's stopped by the dweeby Seymour, who goes on to live somewhere that's green with the human Audrey I.
The One We Almost Got: If the ending, with Audrey II suddenly put down, seems out of the blue that's because it is. The original ending of Frank Oz's movie was going to be the same as the musical, which, putting it succinctly, sees Audrey II succeed in its plan, killing Seymour and, with other monsters made from its cuttings, wreaking havoc across the world. The ending did atrociously in test screenings, with the visually less impressive one we all know replacing it.
Why It Would Have Been Better: In the cut version the reveal of what Audrey II's up is much less overt and the overall effect is much stronger. Sure, it's a downbeat idea, but the execution fits in with the film's zany tone better than the saccharine ending we got.
Little Shop Of Horrors is available to buy over at Amazon.
7. Moscow Fight Scene - World War Z

The Official Ending: The Brad Pitt zombie epic that shocked everyone by not being a box office bomb ends its globe-hopping journey in Cardiff. Gerry, a UN investigator who suddenly becomes humanity's only hope, manages to figure out a way to become invisible to the walking dead. The film that sees zombies piling up to get into Jerusalem then gives us its final showdown, which features one lone walker, with Gerry escaping unscathed.
The One We Almost Got: The script for the adaptation of Max Brooks' beloved novel had gone through many hands in its long development, and yet made it all the way to post-production without a coherent ending. Before the low-key, sequel-baiting ending was settled on, extensive shooting had been done for a much bigger climax that saw a massive, Moscow-set skirmish. This was ultimately cut, along with various other references to global politics, including a theory that the infection began in China, in a bid to increase the film's international legs.
Why It Would Have Been Better: Fans of the book were disappointed to see an exemplar piece of zombie fiction that, like the genre at its very best, used the undead to explore social elements of our world reduced to a simplistic blockbuster. While the Moscow ending was a typical action beat, it would have been a much satisfying experience than a side-step to Wales.
Check out World War Z over at Amazon.
6. Humanity Is The Villain - I Am Legend

The Official Ending: Will Smith's Neville lives alone in New York, aside from his dog, Sam. Oh, and hoards of zombie-vampire things. Trying to find a cure for the virus that has created the monsters, he kidnaps one of their kind in an attempt to synthesise a cure. He succeeds, but not before his stronghold comes under attack from the evil infected. Helping fellow survivors Anna and Ethan escape, Neville sacrifices himself in a fiery explosion that takes out the attackers, becoming the legend of the title.
The One We Almost Got: This is probably the holy grail of alternate endings; one that is so infinitely better than the one in the finished film that it actually changes the whole meaning of the movie. It turns out the undead are only attacking Neville because they want the one of their own he's been experimenting on. That's right, Will Smith's the bad guy, a legend amongst the infected for terrorising them Bowser-style. He realises this just in time, letting his test subject go and forming some type of truce.
Why It Would Have Been Better: Do you even have to ask? The alternate ending takes a dumb film version of a highly revered novel and makes it something depressingly meditative. Expect the mooted remake to correct this massive oversight.
Watch I Am Legend over at Amazon.
5. San Fransisco Bridge - The Birds

The Official Ending: It was already impossible to see a cropduster or take a shower without getting a little on edge thanks to Alfred Hitchcock, but with The Birds he turned one of the most unavoidable, everyday things into a source of nightmares. In the final moments of the 1963 classic, Tippi Hedren goes up to the attic (classic horror trope there) and gets attacked by a giant flock of birds, before she and the rest of her small group of survivors leave, driving through a landscape dominated by seemingly docile crows and seagulls.
The One We Almost Got: It's not a massive change, with the general ambiguity of why the attacks began and what the fate of our heroes is maintained, but originally the film was going to run a little longer, seeing their car drive over a Golden Gate Bridge utterly covered in birds. Obviously, being made back in the early sixties, this was technically impossible to achieve and thus never made it beyond the concept stage.
Why It Would Have Been Better: In terms of iconography the Golden Gate Bridge makes climbing frames and telephone wires look paltry and would have really emphasised how wide reaching the film's attacks were.
The Birds is available to buy over at Amazon.
4. Tom's Punishment Is Paranoia - The Talented Mr Ripley

The Official Ending: It sounds like a particularly sadistic logic puzzle. Tom Ripley, murderous sociopath, finds himself on a boat with both his male lover and an acquaintance who knows him as one of his victims. The two sides of his life are coming dangerously close, with the risk of his crimes being unveiled high, so he must decide which person to do away with. He ultimately chooses the former, strangling Peter and forced to accept a lonely life.
The One We Almost Got: Patricia Highsmith's source novel has neither Peter or Cate Blanchett's acquaintance in any form, with this entire dilemma totally absent. Instead, the ending is more subtle, with Ripley having to resign himself to a life of paranoia; he discovers he's got away with the murder of Dickie Greenleaf and the subsequent inheritance scam, but can't shake the feeling that he'll end up in the hands of the law. It's typically down-played by the psychological thriller master.
Why It Would Have Been Better: The representation of Ripley as a gay man misses much of the almost asexual elements represented in later novels, while the whole dilemma feels a little on the nose. It may be more simplistic, but in terms of character the novel gets it spot on.
Watch The Talented Mr Ripley over at Amazon.
3. Esther Escapes - Orphan

The Official Ending: For much of its run time Orphan is an incredibly chilling film, keeping its cards close to its chest. There's a creepy child with a murderous bent and incredibly unnerving look, but even when she's hammering nuns to death it's all in the name of building tension. Then, in its final twenty minutes, everything steps up a gear. We learn little girl Esther is actually a diminutive thirty-three year old psychopath in disguise and the whole thing devolves into a stalking killer set piece, with Vera Farmiga having to fight her adoptive daughter to the death.
The One We Almost Got: Instead of going for broke and trying to kill the witnesses at the stake of her identity, Esther simply reapplies her child make-up after the initial fight, walking calmly into the hands of the police, assumedly ready to continue with her charade and making Farmiga's mother look deranged.
Why It Would Have Been Better: Orphan would have worked much better with the psycho 'child' getting away with it (think The Omen) and unlike the official ending, it feels a lot more in keeping with the previous ninety minutes.
Watch Orphan over at Amazon.
2. Globo-Gym Win - DodgeBall

The Official Ending: It's the worldwide showdown between big business and the little guy embodied in the form of a high school favourite sport. Vince Vaugn's Average Joes take on Ben Stiller's Globo-Gym at a dodgeball game and, because this is a film, they win. But it's not just a sense of pride they get; every supporting character gets their own happy resolution, while Stiller's White Goodman sees himself jobless and humiliated. Ah, the movies.
The One We Almost Got: Globo-Gym win. And that's literally it. The bad guys beat the good guys, they celebrate and the film cuts to the credits. Well... that was unexpected.
Why It Would Have Been Better: It initially seems a bit of a flat finale, undercutting all the development in the film, but could have actually stood as DodgeBall's best joke. After sticking so close to the genre clichés this is an original stroke of genius. It'd no doubt leave people a little disgruntled at first, but on rewatch (after all, DodgeBall is layered) it'd become increasingly funny as the ridiculousness of the film can be better appreciated. It also makes the subtitle, A True Underdog Story, a little more truthful.
Watch Dodgeball over at Amazon.
1. John Connor Becomes A Machine - Terminator Salvation

The Official Ending: After spending almost a whole movie doing less with the apocalyptic future than James Cameron did in two minutes in the first film, Terminator Salvation's climax actually offers up some interesting ideas. It's revealed Sam Worthington's Marcus Wright was actually created with the explicit intention to bring John Connor to Skynet so the machines could finally kill him (that's a lot simpler than time travel). They almost succeed, but Marcus ends up sacrificing himself, giving the future resistance leader his heart.
The One We Almost Got: An alternate ending had the same idea, but took things further. John Connor was beyond help, but to keep the idea of the great leader alive his skin was going to be transplanted on top of Marcus' machine skeleton, making the central figure fighting the machines a machine himself. But that's not the genius part; a last minute twist would see Skynet take over Connor, killing Kyle Reese, Kate Connor and all the other important resistance players.
Why It Would Have Been Better: It wouldn't have made up for the rest of the film, but having the series seriously shook up would have given the franchise an exciting new direction, rather than leaving it dead in the water awaiting a reboot.
Watch Terminator Salvation over at Amazon.
Which other movies would have been improved by their alternate ending? Let us know your picks in the comments below.