The saddest movies are not, contrary to popular belief, the ones that come packaged as tear-jerkers. Yes, The Notebook is a "sad" movie, but I'd be lying if I said it made me feel particularly upset or choked up. That's simply because I expected it to be dramatic and ultimately depressing. No, the saddest movies are the ones that we walk into believing that they're going to be something else. I'm talking about action movies, Adam Sandler flicks, and even some unexpected kids' movies, all of which are more likely to make us connect with the downfall of their onscreen characters because they take us completely by surprise when they hit us with those emotional beats. Of course, we don't want to admit that a kids' movie made us bawl our eyes out - that's sort of embarrassing, isn't it? Which is why I've formulated a list for you, being sure to point out some of cinema's most unexpectedly emotional moments. Hope you have a box of tissues nearby. Let the countdown begin...
10. Speed Racer
Yes, most people consider the Wachowski's version of 80s favorite, Speed Racer, a complete mockery of moviemaking itself. I too found some troubling faults within the setup of the movie itself, but it is about time I came out of the Speed Racer closet: I love this movie. It made me feel things, notably in the scenes that featured the father-son moments between Speed (played by Emile Hirsch) and his father (John Goodman). In the very beginning of the movie, the narrative attempts to introduce us to Speed Racer's world via a narration overlapping Speed's latest attempt at breaking his estranged brother's record. The scene itself is nothing special; it simply tells us who these characters are, where they came from, and why Speed is trying to live up to his sibling's potential. We find out that Speed's brother was shamed shortly before dying in a tragic crash, forcing him to leave behind a tainted legacy that haunts the entire family. The moment that catches us all by surprise, however, is when we discover that Speed is racing against the ghost of his brother. Not his actual brother, of course, but one that Speed is visualising thanks to his flawless memory of how his brother races. And then he lets the ghost win... in order to preserve at least some of his brother's positive legacy. And that's all within the first 10 minutes of the film. Pass me a tissue, please.
9. Click
When most people talk about Adam Sandler's performance in Click, they're using it as a reference for how downhill the man's career has gone since the days of Big Daddy, as if it were Citizen Kane or something. Click is a bad movie. The jokes are hit or miss, David Hasselfhoff's performance induces near-vomit for almost everyone who is watching it, and the main premise of the movie (controlling life with a remote control) is extremely under-utilized. Something interesting happens in Click, however, that made even the harshest of critics begin to cough back the tears. Adam Sandler's character realizes that he has been on a real "Autopilot" his entire life, grasping for the dream of money and wealth. In the process, he loses his wife, kids, and every other meaningful relationship he could've had. He discovers this as he accidentally propels himself forward in time, missing the events of his entire life. On his deathbed, he witnesses something truly tragic: his son is on the same path. Panicking, he leaves his deathbed to chase his son and plead that he doesn't make the same mistakes, and he obviously dies right there in the middle of the road. In the rain. It wasn't subtle, but the moment completely undercut all of the silly nonsense that had plagued the first two acts, though I can hardly say it redeemed the film overall.
8. World War Z
World War Z, the apocalyptic 2013 zombie film that was actually successful, is far from the type of movie you walk into expecting anything profound or heart-wrenching. It's a zombie movie, so we expected the typical "losing a loved one to a zombie bite" feels that have been exploited by every George Romero ripoff that Hollywood and Edgar Wright can come up with. But I am hesitant to admit that World War Z actually had me holding back the tears toward the end of the film, when Pitt was finally reunited with his family - whom we believed were as good as dead - with the triumphant cure underway. No, the resolution of the plot itself wasn't anything special, and to be honest, it felt quite rushed. Still, we have to hand it to an actor like Brad Pitt who can take even the most cartoony and played out premises and turn it into a serious movie we can sink our teeth into (zombie pun unintended). Watching him embrace his family once again was a moment that was unexpectedly heart warming enough to make our hearts cheer with tears.
7. Air Bud
It's sort of unfair how emotionally manipulative this film is, from beginning to end. It starts by showing off clear animal abuse, and it then depresses us further by showing us how awkward and lonely our 12-year-old selves were. Air Bud is wickedly deceptive because the trailer, movie poster, and tagline all suggest a family fun movie about how much of a gas it would be if a dog could play basketball. Instead, my mother came into my room while I was watching this and gasped in horror as we both witnessed a frustrated basketball coach chucking full speed basketballs and a gangly 12-year-old. We have to also point out the infamous courtroom scene at the very end, when the alcoholic clown attempts to reclaim "Buddy" from his new basketball-exploiting family. Boring legal battles were traded for what a judge considers real justice: just let the dog decide who he loves more. So Buddy goes to the clown and breaks the hearts of every child with a VHS player, only to rip the newspaper that the clown had in his hand to shreds (he used the paper to beat the dog earlier in the movie, and the director didn't want us to forget so easily). Simply put, I can't imagine what a child who has been watching the Air Bud spinoff sequels (one involves puppies in space) would think if they actually fired this up on their iPad.
6. Star Trek Into Darkness
To be fair, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan made me far more emotional than its follow-up, 2013's Star Trek Into Darkness. The difference is that for the most part, we look back fondly on Wrath of Khan, and it's generally understood that Spock's sacrifice was one of Star Trek's most important moments. Into Darkness isn't quite as beloved, so it's safe to say that their handling of the Khan storyline doesn't make Trekkies weep with any actual tears. Still, the movie does impress with a surprise twist: it is Kirk who must make the ultimate sacrifice. Yes, ultimately Kirk survives, but that still doesn't change the emotional power behind the scene in which Kirk and Spock say goodbye, perfectly mirroring Wrath of Khan down to the last "live long and prosper." It hits us because up until that point, the duo of Kirk and Spock felt invincible. "Surely, the writers behind this one wouldn't pull a Wrath of Khan and do away with a major character," we all imagined. But they did just that, and the final goodbye was handled almost perfectly, especially when we witnessed Spock's long-awaited rampage against Khan, which really should have just been the entire movie.
5. Top Gun
Going in, we all knew Top Gun was going to... take our breath away. What we didn't all realize, however, was that this campy movie with a horrendously cheesy soundtrack was going to make us actually weep for one of the characters. You probably know who I'm referring to.
This is a man's man of a movie, focusing in on lessons that include honor, being selfless, and honoring the legacy of the ones we've lost. These are themes Tom Cruise probably hasn't come face to face with while reading a script in a long time, but he nailed it during his performance here. I can still hear him screaming "Goose" 20 years later (yes, the movie is that old). It's not easy for me to tell people that a movie like Top Gun still makes me tear up every time it gets brought up in conversation, especially around people who only pretend to have seen it (most people under the age of 30). They scoff at the idea of an 80s action movie with Tom Cruise and F14's making you have real-life emotions, but any real fan of the movie will shake their head at these millennials.
4. The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers
If I was tremendously lazy, I could just open the floor here for comments and let you fill in the blank. I'm sure you could come up with scene after scene from the second movie based on Tolkien's masterpiece of a trilogy, in which we watch the fellowship recuperate after the events of the first movie. But this is an action movie, right? It's quite odd that a movie about swords, magic, and walking trees actually brought tears to our eyes, but that is just testament to the epic story that is told in The Two Towers. One of the most powerful scenes comes at the end of the book (you probably know where I'm going with this). During a harsh battle, Sam gives a long speech to Frodo - and Gollum, sort of - about how there is good in the world and that it is worth fighting for. After spending the last 3 hours watching entire armies get decimated in the name of preserving one hobbit's journey to protect one little thing like a ring, we needed something to remind us why all of this war was happening in the first place.
3. The Hunger Games
I was actually shocked by how desensitized this movie made me become to the idea of children literally killing each other. By the third act, thoughts like "So, when is the next innocent child going to get brutally murdered?" actually entered my head several times. That's not OK. But Hunger Games did that to all of us (I hope), and this is mostly because the movie spends most of its running time emotionally preparing us for the unspeakable violence we are about to witness. That is what made Rue's death so much more meaningful. Amid all of the violence and heart-stopping moments, none of us truly believed that Katniss wouldn't prevail. Sure, Peeta might have kicked the bucket, but no one really liked him after he joined up with the Careers. By the time Rue showed up, most of us in the audience who've actually watched movies before made the prediction that she was going to die a tragic death. I think her death was more powerful among all of the other ones because of Katniss's attachment to the young girl. Watching her sit there and weep over this kid that she was supposed to eventually kill was a flurry of emotional moments none of us were truly prepared for.
2. The Iron Giant
First and foremost, Iron Giant was the story of how children are capable of forming unhealthy relationships with literally anything, and that includes alien robots with amnesia during the 1950s. Most of the movie proves this point as we watch bumbling Hogarth hide his new best friend from his mom and that creepy red-haired man. The plucky adventure story shifts gears, however, when the giant reverts back to killing mode, presumably because that bump on his head that made him docile for the first two acts was where his "Kill All Humans" button was. The giant transformed into a gun-toting behemoth, blowing up cars and making every pre-pubescent child in the audience feel conflicted over whether or not it was OK that their onscreen friend had just become a walking murder machine (it was OK for most of us). But the giant reverts to normal, and everything seems fine until a nuclear missile is launched toward the small town he was just terrorising. Before our eyes, the giant selflessly flies into the sky and collides with missile, making every child in the audience cry tears of conflicted sadness, probably for the first time. Of course, nothing choked us up more than the final scene where the missing pieces of the giant are shown to be re-assembling in Antarctica. Too many emotions.
1. Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith
No one is embarrassed to admit that they felt a little teary after watching the original trilogy, so it wouldn't make sense to include those movies on this list. What is a littler harder to bring up as being a tear-jerker would have to be the best of the prequels, which obviously isn't saying much at all. Let's be honest: we only watched this movie for one or two scenes, the most important being the inevitable confrontation between Anakin Skywalker - now Darth Vader - and his long-time mentor, Obi Wan Kenobi. For some of us anticipating this fight, we had lofty expectations that this lightsaber duel would redeem the troubled movie franchise. I wouldn't say it redeemed the entire prequel trilogy, but it absolutely made Revenge of the Sith worth sitting through (also: Wookies). What made the final battle even more epic and heart-wrenching was the concurrent battle happening in Coruscant between Yoda and Emperor Palpatine, which suitably relied on the Duel of the Fates score to emphasise the epic confrontation. Were we tearing up because we were finally watching a Star Wars scene worthy of being included into Lucas's canon? Probably not, as I suspect that most of us were just surprised to see Ewan McGregor (Kenobi) giving it his all alongside the robot that is Hayden Christensen. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.
Jon is the author of the Pixar Theory, the narrative that combines all of the Pixar movies in one timeline. You can read more about his random nonsense on jonnegroni.com