10 Movies That Had MASSIVE Tomatometer Drops

Wonder Woman 1984 sank like a stone with critics.

Wonder Woman 1984
Warner Bros.

Though opinion on art is fundamentally subjective, there's no denying that the majority of movies are somewhat defined by their critical reception, particularly the rating they receive from critics' aggregator Rotten Tomatoes.

The website has been influential enough with audiences that studios have gotten into the habit of carefully planning their review rollout in order to minimise potential financial harm caused by negative notices.

In the case of these 10 films, each started out with a promising, even genuinely great Tomatometer score, only for a more concerning picture to emerge in the days and weeks later when the wider press pool got their hands on them.

These movies all saw their approval ratings fall off a cliff, ensuring that the early impression of a critical darling was totally obliterated in the process.

Whether the steep drop had any effect on the movie's box office or not, these cases are all worth remembering whenever a movie's opening batch of reviews are uniformly positive.

Often there are other factors at play, both innocent and nefarious, but a clearer picture of a film's true quality generally only emerges closer to release...

10. The Lion King (2019)

The Lion King
Disney

Initial Score: 67%

Final Score: 52% (15% drop)

Though a Tomatometer drop of "only" 15% might seem positively acceptable compared to every other movie on this list, it was still hugely a hugely disappointing decline for one of 2019's most anticipated films - Jon Favreau's "live-action" remake of Disney's The Lion King.

Given that Favreau's 2016 remake of The Jungle Book rocks a mighty 94% approval from critics, expectations were high that Favreau would deliver a worthy, crowd-pleasing re-imagination of one of Disney's most beloved animations.

When the review embargo lifted, the first wave of reviews made it clear that the 2019 The Lion King was no masterpiece, yet its 69% Tomatometer score still suggested it was a rock solid effort all the same.

By the time hundreds of reviews came pouring in, the score had slipped to 52%, granting it a most dispiriting "Rotten" status with critics, with many fixating on the "soullessness" of the near-photoreal animal CGI.

In a year where remakes of both Dumbo (46%) and Aladdin (57%) had fallen short of the critical mark, The Lion King's shockingly mediocre reception undeniably stung the worst.


9. Joker

Joker Joaquin Phoenix
Warner Bros.

Initial Score: 89%

Final Score: 68% (21% drop)

Joker has had one of the most fascinatingly unpredictable critical receptions of any major film in recent years.

After its premiere at the Venice Film Festival, Joker opened to a strong 89% with a ludicrous 9.08/10 average score, no doubt boosted by it unexpectedly winning the festival's coveted Golden Lion award.

When general critics saw the film in the weeks that followed and discussion about its controversial themes reached boiling point, the consensus tumbled down to 68%, with the average score settling at a far lower 7.3/10. This steep drop even resulted in the film losing its "Certified Fresh" status.

Though Joker was still largely well-received, the general critical sentiment was far more measured compared to those effusive early raves, which if nothing else proves that early festival reviews should always be considered within the excited context of the festival itself.

Still, director Todd Phillips ultimately had the last laugh, as Joker went on to gross over $1 billion worldwide, was nominated for 11 Oscars, and won two, for Best Actor (Joaquin Phoenix) and Best Original Score.


8. It Chapter Two

It Chapter Two Losers.jpg
Warner Bros.

Initial Score: 84%

Final Score: 63% (21% drop)

Expectations were through the roof for It Chapter Two, after the first part of Andy Muschietti's Stephen King adaptation scored a rapturous 86% with critics.

Many were nevertheless aware that the second half of King's novel would be decidedly more challenging to adapt to the big screen, and so tempered their anticipation.

Yet the first batch of reviews seemed to suggest there was nothing to worry about, with the sequel totting up an encouraging 84%, just a fraction shy of its predecessor's reception.

But in the days that followed, It Chapter Two dropped 21% down to just 63%, bringing it within spitting distance of being rated Rotten. Ultimately, many complained that the film was both too long and failed to recapture the mood of Chapter One.

Not a bad movie by any means, but just a moderate disappointment.


7. Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom

Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom Bryce Dallas Howard Chris Pratt
Universal

Initial Score: 69%

Final Score: 47% (22% drop)

Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom was actually released internationally more than two weeks before it finally landed in the U.S., and the early surge of reviews suggested it was nothing if not a consistent sequel, scoring a decent 69% compared to Jurassic World's 70%.

But over those two weeks, Fallen Kingdom's critical consensus steadily dropped until it settled at a thoroughly mediocre 47%, making it unambiguously clear that the sequel was a disappointment - and also the worst-reviewed film in the series, barely falling below Jurassic Park III's 49%.

It isn't easy to pinpoint the exact reason for the steep drop, beyond North American critics seeing it later and, for some reason, treating it harsher than their international colleagues.


6. Ghost In The Shell (2017)

ghost in the shell
Dreamworks

Initial Score: 65%

Final Score: 43% (22% drop)

The knives were out for the Scarlett Johansson-starring live-action Ghost in the Shell remake long before it hit cinemas, with particular concern over the "whitewashed" casting of Johansson in the role of The Major.

But the first swath of reviews seemed to suggest that the film, while not amazing by any stretch of the imagination, was basically a better-than-expected effort, landing a respectable enough 65%.

But after almost 300 reviews were in the bag, the score had fallen to an underwhelming 43% - less than half the original anime's 96% - with a greater majority of critics complaining about its generic storytelling, hollow-yet-stylish action, and an especially divisive decision to work the casting controversy into the plot itself.

Neither broadly praised nor critically panned, Ghost in the Shell wound up in that "bleh" middle-ground where movies are so easily forgotten - and indeed, it quickly was.


5. Kick-Ass

Kick Ass
Lionsgate

Initial Score: 100%

Final Score: 76% (24% drop)

Kick-Ass is an especially interesting case because it really didn't affect the movie's general reception with audiences all too much.

Nevertheless, Lionsgate chose to initially screen the film to a small group of "enthusiast" press who largely specialised in fanboy/superhero movies, resulting in the film sitting at a towering 100% rating after the first embargo lifted.

By the time general press were permitted to watch and review Kick-Ass, its perfect Tomatometer score had dropped to a more modest 76%.

Though still completely respectable, for anyone who saw the first wave of reviews and was expecting a top-shelf superhero satire, it was a little deflating to see the film's reception drop quite so drastically.


4. Wonder Woman 1984

Wonder Woman 1984 Gal Gadot
Warner Bros.

Initial Score: 90%

Final Score: 60% (30% drop)

Wonder Woman 1984 was by far the most high-profile blockbuster released in 2020, though the discourse surrounding the film was intensely focused on its baffling Tomatometer score.

When the review embargo lifted, all signs were good, with the sequel touting an impressive 90% after almost 70 reviews, just a few points below the original film's 93%.

But when the rest of the press were given access to the film, the Tomatometer score began to violently tumble downwards, briefly entering Rotten territory before settling at 60%.

In addition to losing its Certified Fresh status - which Warner Bros. had even included in the film's Christmas marketing - Wonder Woman 1984's average score had also dropped from 7.4/10 to 6.1/10.

Numerous articles were published about the suspiciousness of that early critical praise, with many suggesting that Warner Bros. had carefully hand-picked the first wave of critics, selecting those who were likely to be more favourable to the movie than general reviewers.

Given that discussions about the movie have been dominated by the subject of its critical reception, it's safe to say that the move most definitely backfired for the studio.


3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Amazing Spider-Man 2
Sony

Initial Score: 83%

Final Score: 51% (32% drop)

Much like Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was released internationally several weeks before it finally bowed in the U.S., and the early critical sentiment suggested it was actually an improvement over the non-entity that was Marc Webb's 2012 reboot, scoring an appealing 83%.

In a remark that aged like milk, the original critical consensus even read, "Thanks to Marc Webb's confident directing and talented cast, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 entertains in spite of its crowded canvas and occasionally stilted narrative."

By the time hundreds more reviews had been posted, the superhero sequel had sunk like a stone, settling at a lousy 51%, with a revised consensus now declaring, "While the cast is outstanding and the special effects are top-notch, the latest installment of the Spidey saga suffers from an unfocused narrative and an overabundance of characters."


2. Pet Sematary

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

Initial Score: 91%

Final Score: 58% (33% drop)

2019's Pet Sematary seemed set to be a major improvement over the divisive 1989 Stephen King adaptation, with early reviews from its SXSW premiere netting it a high 91% approval rating, complete with the pithy consensus, "Sometimes remade is better."

But by the time the non-festival crowd had set their eyes upon it and penned their reviews, the score had dropped 33% to a decidedly less impressive - and decidedly more Rotten - 58%, with the consensus rewritten as, "Pet Sematary takes its source material in a few different directions, but this remake feels like an exhuming almost as often as it does a revival."

Given that the remake's final score wasn't far off the '89 movie's 51% Tomatometer, the conversation around the movie changed drastically between the time of that initial review drop and when general audiences were able to see it for themselves.


1. Blair Witch

Blair Witch
Vertigo Entertainment

Initial Score: 100%

Final Score: 37% (63% drop)

But no film in history has fallen from the critical graces as violently - or deservedly - as 2016's Blair Witch reboot-sequel, which was shot in secret under the title "The Woods."

The film premiered at Comic-Con 2016 under that original title, serving as a surprise for screening attendees who quickly relayed the news to the rest of the world after the screening.

Those few formal reviews published following the premiere were largely universally positive raves, with Bloody Disgusting's trailer quote even calling it "one of the scariest movies ever made."

This resulted in Blair Witch holding a 100% Rotten Tomatoes score for the six weeks between its Comic-Con premiere and its next screening at the Toronto International Film Festival, ensuring the hype train had zoomed from the station.

But following its TIFF screening and public release a few days later, a more dire critical consensus began to form, with the film dropping a staggering 63% to settle on 37%.

If Lionsgate were hoping that their sneaky hype-building would result in box office glory similar to the 1999 original, they were in for a rude awakening, as Blair Witch was a commercial disappointment despite turning a modest profit, killing the studio's interest in a sequel in the process.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.