10 Movies That Picked The Wrong Twist

The Village should've made the monsters real at the end.

The Matrix Reloaded Neo
Warner Bros.

A twist ending can absolutely make or break a movie - get it right and the audience is both stunned and eager to watch the film again, but miscalculate it and it basically collapses the entire story.

Sometimes an unconvincing twist is additionally frustrating because it's clear that the filmmakers were onto something, but didn't quite get the finer details right.

That's certainly true of these 10 movies, all of which delivered plot twists which ended up landing with a clunky thud for most viewers.

However, there were definitely the seeds of a more interesting rug-pull sewn, only for the writers to spring for an altogether less engaging reveal.

With some fairly modest screenplay tweaks, these films could've all served up considerably smarter and more surprising twists that also made more sense in the grand scope of the story.

In some cases these twists were thought up by fans, while in others they were actually considered by the filmmakers, yet for whatever reason - typically executive intrusion - they never came to pass.

And so, we're left to consider how much better these movies would've been had they sprung for different plot twists...

10. Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman Ares David Thewlis
Warner Bros.

The Twist We Got

The Greek god of war, Ares, is revealed to have been Sir Patrick (David Thewlis), a member of the Imperial War Cabinet, all along, who plans to destroy humanity through war in order to bring "paradise" back to Earth.

However, this ploy is thwarted when Diana (Gal Gadot) defeats him in a CGI-slathered final battle.

The Twist We Wanted

It would've been infinitely more interesting if, after General Ludendorff's (Danny Huston) defeat, Ares never shows up and yet humanity continues to wage war regardless.

Having Diana realise that war is an ugly aspect of human nature, and one which doesn't need the influence of a deity, would've been a considerably more satisfying twist ending than shoving David Thewlis into a CGI costume for a garish, dull digital slug-fest.

It would've delivered both a welcome subversion of expectations and served up crucial character development for Diana, while the twist we ended up with instead felt like a cynical studio note.

"Needs more explosions!," you can practically hear Warner Bros. executives say while you're watching the final fight play out.


9. The Matrix Reloaded

The Matrix Reloaded Neo
Warner Bros.

The Twist We Got

In fairness, The Matrix Reloaded actually delivers two climactic plot twists for the price of one.

Firstly, that Neo (Keanu Reeves) has found a way to use his superhuman powers outside of the Matrix, harnessing them to disable a fleet of incoming Sentinels, and secondly, Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving) has managed to reach Zion by possessing Resistance member Bane (Ian Bliss).

The Twist We Wanted

While the precise mechanics behind Neo's ability to manifest powers outside of the Matrix were never explicitly explained in Reloaded or any other Matrix sequel, many fans took it as "evidence" of an altogether nuttier twist, that Zion was in fact another level of the Matrix.

After all, what better way to truly pacify humanity than giving them the illusion of escape and salvation?

It would've totally rewritten the rules of the franchise in a fascinating way, even if it admittedly may have opened a huge can of worms where plot holes are concerned, and certainly wouldn't have gone down well with all fans.


8. Big Hero 6

Big Hero 6
Disney

The Twist We Got

As it turns out, the Kabuki mask-wearing villain Yokai isn't tech guru Alistair Krei (Alan Tudyk) as expected, but rather Professor Robert Callaghan (James Cromwell), who was believed to have perished at the start of the story but in fact faked his death.

It's certainly not terrible as secret villain twists go, but the screenwriters missed a far more compelling version of the twist hiding in plain sight.

The Twist We Wanted

Yokai isn't Professor Callaghan but instead protagonist Hiro's (Ryan Potter) older brother Tadashi (Daniel Henney), who was also believed to have died in the fire alongside Callaghan.

Though in the final movie Tadashi is seemingly dead for real, bringing him back as the shadowy villain would've presented far more compelling dramatic possibilities than simply having Yokai be a relatively unremarkable character who had a brief role at the start of the film.

Having Hiro face off against his own brother, and having to talk him down from causing more mayhem, basically writes itself.

Plus, if Hiro successfully brings Tadashi back to his side by film's end, they'd make one hell of a team for the sequel - a sequel we're all still waiting for, admittedly.


7. Antebellum

Antebellum 2020
Lionsgate

The Twist We Got

Antebellum revolves around a Black woman, Veronica Henley (Janelle MonĂ¡e), who is kidnapped and imprisoned on a Southern slave plantation.

Until film's end, we're left in the dark as to what exactly has happened to Veronica, before it's revealed that the plantation is part of a modern day Civil War reenactment park, where racists can live out the fantasy of owning slaves, "played" by kidnapped Black people.

The Twist We Wanted

The marketing for Antebellum actually implied something far more interesting, that Veronica had been sent hundreds of years back in time to an actual slave plantation.

The idea that Veronica had been forcibly sent back to the past by a crazy racist cabal would've made for a far more intriguing twist than the Black Mirror-lite reveal we actually ended up with.

The Village twist didn't work that well when M. Night Shyamalan first did it almost 20 years ago - a movie we'll be discussing later on this list, in fact - so rehashing it, even through the lens of the slave trade, was always a recipe for disaster.


6. Terminator Salvation

Terminator Salvation
Warner Bros.

The Twist We Got

As was pointlessly spoiled by the movie's marketing, mid-way through the fourth Terminator film we learn that Marcus Wright (Sam Worthington) is actually a human-hybrid cyborg.

And at film's end, Marcus lays down his life in order to keep John Connor (Christian Bale) alive, allowing for his heart to be transplanted into a dying John.

The Twist We Wanted

Shortly after Salvation's release, director McG revealed two alternate twist endings for the movie that didn't make the cut, yet both of which would've steered the flagging series in a bold and intriguing new direction.

Firstly, Salvation was going to end with John Connor dying, but in order to maintain his status as the iconic figurehead of the human Resistance, his skin would then be grafted onto Marcus, effectively allowing Connor to live on as Marcus-in-disguise.

The idea of the Resistance leader secretly being a man-machine hybrid would've been a deliciously ironic - if undeniably divisive - way to close things out.

The other, even ballsier ending, went further by not only having Marcus assume a deceased John's identity, but once Marcus/"John" was in the presence of the Resistance's high command, Skynet's programming would kick in and have him murder the lot of them.

Skynet wins, and we cut to black. The End.

It's of course easy to see why a franchise hoping to leave the audience eager for a glut of sequels didn't pick either of these endings - especially the latter one - but considering the sorry state of the Terminator series for the last 15 years, it would've probably been a tender mercy.


5. A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)

A Nightmare On Elm Street 2010
Warner Bros.

The Twist We Got

2010's A Nightmare on Elm Street remake actually restores an aspect of Wes Craven's original concept for the character which was ultimately abandoned, that rather than being a serial killer, Freddy Krueger (Jackie Earle Haley) was a child molester.

Later in the film the remake suggests the possibility of Freddy being innocent, before whipping back around and confirming that - surprise! - he was indeed guilty as charged.

The Twist We Wanted

Yet shortly after the film's release, co-writer Eric Heisserer confirmed that his original version of the script featured a jaw-dropping third act twist, that Freddy was indeed an innocent man tracked down and burned to death by an angry, illogical lynch mob.

The notion of a collective of emotional parents creating the very monster they thought they saw in their midst is certainly fascinating, and while it'd make for an incredibly tough sell in today's climate, back in 2010 it would've lent Freddy a truly unique reinvention.

Instead, we got a half-assed suggestion that Freddy might be innocent, before quickly circling back to predictable business as usual.


4. Sunshine

Sunshine Pinbacker
Fox Searchlight

The Twist We Got

Late in Danny Boyle's sci-fi horror film Sunshine, physicist Robert Capa (Cillian Murphy) learns from the spaceship's onboard computer, Icarus, that there is an unexpected fifth person aboard the craft, whose oxygen use will prevent the mission's completion.

As it turns out, this stowaway is Pinbacker (Mark Strong), the captain of the first Icarus mission, who has been horribly disfigured and driven insane by his contact with the sun, which he believes to be God.

And like that, Sunshine transforms into a disappointingly familiar slasher movie for its remainder, as Pinbacker tries to slaughter the rest of the crew.

The Twist We Wanted

Ditch Pinbacker and instead reveal the fifth crew member to be Icarus itself, with the ship's computer becoming murderously self-aware and then attempting to prevent humanity from saving themselves.

Throwing a rogue AI into the mix may not be the most original twist in the world, but it would've been considerably more interesting than just having the remaining crew fending off a crazed murderer.


3. Jigsaw

Jigsaw Logan
Lionsgate

The Twist We Got

There's two twists for the price of one here - firstly, that the central game in Jigsaw took place 10 years in the past, and that the killer is actually pathologist Logan (Matt Passmore), who survived said game a decade prior and has been waiting in the wings as Jigsaw's (Tobin Bell) original secret apprentice ever since.

The Saw franchise has wildly overused the timeline-rejigging and shadowy apprentice twists over the years, so enthusiasm for Jigsaw's finale was unsurprisingly pretty low.

The Twist We Wanted

Keep it simple and reveal Logan as the killer but not an apprentice. Basically, the twist from Spiral would've worked much better for Jigsaw, that Logan is an independent Jigsaw copycat seeking to test corrupt police officers.

Given that Jigsaw even ends with Logan brutally killing Detective Halloran (Callum Keith Rennie) for freeing a man who later murdered his wife, it fits pretty neatly, but the apprentice and timeline twists just felt like unnecessary, convoluted dead weight.


2. The Village

The Village Bryce Dallas Howard
Buena Vista Pictures

The Twist We Got

Of course an M. Night Shyamalan twist was going to make it onto this list, and he's never pulled off a more infamous rug-pull than in The Village.

Despite marketing and presenting the film as a period thriller set in a remote 19th-century Pennsylvania village, we find out in act three that the story is in fact set in the modern day, and the village was created by a group of grief-stricken individuals keen to insulate themselves from the outside world.

The twist has remained hugely divisive in the near-20 years since, and for many marked the first sign that Shyamalan couldn't always tell a great twist apart from a bad or underwhelming one.

The Twist We Wanted

But Shyamalan could've won audiences back by dropping a double twist. Sure, reveal that the village is fake and that the "monsters" in the woods are just villagers in disguise, but just then the real twist occurs, as actual monsters show up to terrorise the village.

At this point the third act completely flips the script again, as Ivy (Bryce Dallas Howard) and the other villagers attempt to fend off the monsters, and it's fair to assume that the commotion will probably attract unwanted attention from the outside world.

It'd certainly have made for a more chaotic and entertaining finale than the rather anti-climactic resolution we ended up with.


1. Red State

Red State Michael Parks
Lionsgate

The Twist We Got

Kevin Smith's Red State is a surprisingly entertaining little horror film in which a group of horny teenagers end up preyed upon by a fundamentalist conservative church sect, led by Pastor Abin Cooper (a brilliant Michael Parks).

During a climactic raid on the compound by the authorities, a strange trumpet sound blares out, with Cooper's followers insisting that the Rapture has occurred.

Moments later, though, it's revealed that the sound was in fact a prank facilitated by a group of local college students who didn't take much kindly to the practises of Cooper and his cult.

The Twist We Wanted

But Kevin Smith soon enough revealed his original intended twist, that the Rapture would indeed come to pass.

ATF Special Agent Keenan (John Goodman) would watch as both members of the church and his own colleagues exploded from the inside out, before witnessing a 10-foot tall angel arriving and running one of the churchgoers through with a giant sword.

And best of all? The final shot would show the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse riding through the sky before the film cuts abruptly to black and rolls credits.

Smith's fans immediately lamented that this awesome-sounding twist ending didn't come to pass, but by Smith's own admission, the film's svelte $4 million budget couldn't accommodate such an ambitious sequence.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.