10 Movies That Shockingly Switch Protagonist
From Psycho to 1917, these movies all hit us with the ol' switcheroo.
Some writers and directors can't seem to just settle on the one main character - so why not have them all?
So say Messrs Quentin Tarantino, Alfred Hitchcock, Steven Soderbergh and Brian De Palma, who have each contributed to the now long-standing tradition of starting a film with one protagonist and ending it with another.
For Hitchcock, Psycho provides a narrative jolt that fits the thrilling horror tone by murdering its heroine; Tarantino's Death Proof calls back to the convention-defying tricks of the old exploitation B-movies; and Bad Times at the El Royale by Drew Goddard has a mystery plot that is further compounded by making us wonder who the main character really is. In most cases, the best thing to do is just settle in and enjoy the ride.
Keep your head on a swivel because here come 10 films that swapped out their protagonist once the film was already well underway, changing the plot dramatically and dropping the floor right out from under us.
MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!
10. Bad Times At The El Royale
Daredevil's Drew Goddard returned to the big screen in 2018 with a mystery movie for the ages – Bad Times at the El Royale.
The film sees an all-star cast of seven strangers converge on a seedy motel that rests on state lines, for a night of mystery, murder and life-changing revelations.
Although Bad Times features an ensemble cast, we enter it very much through Special Agent Dwight Broadbeck's (Jon Hamm) perspective, attending the motel under the guise of a travelling salesman to uncover some state-level secrets. That is, until, he is slain with a shotgun halfway through.
Lost amid a sea of hustlers and two-faced good-fer-nothings, our perspective gradually settles behind the unlikely duo of robber-in-priest's-clothing Dock O'Kelly (Jeff Bridges) and struggling singer Darlene Sweet (Cynthia Erivo). And we're lucky it does, because the unlikely pair are the only ones to make it out of the film alive.
Though Bad Times was a commercial failure, it was well received by critics and, thanks to its irregular plotting, shocking twists, noir feel and – you guessed it – shifting protagonists, it is well on its way to becoming a cult classic.
9. The Place Beyond The Pines
It can be a serious shocker when a film marketed as a run-of-the-mill Oscar-bait drama takes some bold and ambitious narrative turns, but that is precisely what happened with Derek Cianfrance's Place Beyond the Pines.
Carnie motorbike stunt rider Luke (Ryan Gosling) botches a robbery and is shot dead around the midpoint, at which point the narrative is taken up by Avery (Bradley Cooper), the police officer who shot him.
Packing in not one but two major star leads, Place Beyond the Pines wrangles a challenging narrative that transitions from crime thriller into something more akin to a kitchen sink drama. Avery tries to make amends with Luke's widow and ultimately faces a reckoning some 15 years later when he comes face to face with Luke's son.
Audiences may have been uncertain about it at the time, but the film manages a difficult and moving story without ringing the melodrama bells, using its unusual form to tell a story not of cops and robbers but of the trials and mistakes of being a father. And, hey, he may not be in it for that long, but Ryan Gosling kills with bleached hair and stick n poke tatts.
8. 1917
Following a double stint at the helm of the 007 franchise, Sam Mendes returned in 2019 to a subject he hadn't laid hands on since 2005 - war. This time around though, the director cast his narrative eye back 100 years into the past and World War I, telling a story that fell on the third year of the conflict - 1917.
Inspired by stories told to Mendes' by his grandfather, 1917 follows soldier Tom Blake (Dean Charles-Chapman) on his mission to carry a message calling off an offensive attack the next morning that threatens the lives of 1,600 serving men, including his brother Joseph. Along for the ride is Lance Corporal William Schofield (George MacKay), veteran of the Somme and all-round survivor.
Thanks to some pretty serious, brother-shaped motivation, Tom appears to be the film's lead, utilising a rich backstory and purpose to drive the plot forwards, but after a close encounter with a rather ungrateful German pilot sees him to an early grave, William takes over to see their duty is done.
Although Mendes shot and edited the movie to look like one continuous long shot, the sudden and unexpected death makes 1917 very much a film of two halves.
7. Side Effects
Steven Soderbergh loves nothing more than to experiment across genres and forms, having contributed widely to most corners of the film canon throughout an illustrious career. True to form then, his thriller Side Effects ends up being a two-hander.
Emily Taylor (Rooney Mara) seemingly murders her husband in her sleep while on prescribed medication to manage her depression, but when she gets off scot-free, the blame (and the narrative perspective) shifts to her psychiatrist, Jonathan Banks (Jude Law), who has been ruined in the process for prescribing her the experimental drugs.
But all is never as it seems. Transitioning from the tragic story of a woman let down by a flawed system, to the struggle of a well-meaning but equally unfortunate psychiatrist, Side Effects uses the shift in protagonist to reveal the film's dark heart - Emily did it on purpose. Jonathan thus has to spend the remainder of the film clearing his name against our lying and deeply duplicitous original protagonist turned antagonist, discovering in the process that she has been in league with one of his colleagues all along.
6. Sympathy For Mr Vengeance
Sympathy for Mr Vengeance, the first film in Park Chan Wook's Vengeance Trilogy wasn't well-received upon release, less because of its narrative choices than its sudden and shocking moments of violence, the likes of which have come to dominate popular Korean cinema throughout the past few decades.
The film sees deaf-mute Ryu (Shin Ha-kyun) engaged in a desperate struggle to help his ailing sister receive the kidney transplant she needs to survive. After being conned out of his own kidney and left penniless and in pain, he kidnaps the daughter of wealthy businessman Park Dong-jin (Song Kang-ho) in a last-ditch attempt to get the money needed for his sister's operation. Wackiness ensues, as Ryu tries to make sure the little girl doesn't know she's been kidnapped while sending her father ransom notes and pictures of her crying.
However, in a tragic sequence of pure circumstance, Ryu's sister takes her own life, the little girl drowns, and the perspective shifts, becoming all about her father's quest for vengeance. Dong-jin hires investigators, uncovers clues, and tortures his way to Ryu's door, while Ryu's quest to exact his own revenge on the cartel who stole his kidney quietly continues in the background.
But there are no happy endings, and this all leaves us wondering which Mr Vengeance we are meant to feel the most sympathy for.
5. Damsel (2018)
Not to be confused with the upcoming Millie Bobby Brown vehicle, David Zellner's Damsel is a Western with a black comedy core that tramples over most of the usual cowboy clichés in order to access a twisted tale of a defiantly liberated woman.
A spin on the damsel in distress trope set in the Old West, Penelope (Mia Wasikowska) is kidnapped from her beau Samuel (Robert Pattinson). Thinking himself the captain of his soul and hero of his story, Samuel goes on a mission to rescue the woman he loves, haphazardly killing her captor in the process.
Alas, he discovers she doesn't actually want to be with him at all and staged her kidnapping in the hope of getting rid of him. Distraught, Samuel kills himself and Penelope becomes the protagonist, fending off advances left and right while trying to survive and get maybe just a little of what she wants.
Not only did none of the marketing for Damsel suggest it was anything but a Pattinson project, but the comedic tone all but assured audiences the main character couldn't possibly kill himself halfway through. More fool us. But the film is all the better for it.
4. Death Proof
After a string of hit movies, Quentin Tarantino used his industry pull to fund a passion project back in the mid-2000s. Gazing fondly back to the exploitation flicks of his youth, the director brought us Death Proof, a grindhouse, B-movie homage about a serial killer stuntman named Mike (Kurt Russell, with a luxurious bouffant, a dynamite wardrobe and an indestructible car).
Stuntman Mike is not, however, the main character; the four young women he stalks take that honour, and around the midpoint of the movie, he wipes them off the face of the earth in one grisly "accident".
Yep, Death Proof sees all of the main cast except for the antagonist ceremoniously bite the dust, to be replaced in the subsequent half by a hardier foursome – Rosario Dawson, Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Tracie Thoms and real-life stuntwoman Zoe Bell – who prove to be Mike's undoing.
The second section of the movie shows Mike attempting to pull the same murderous antics with his car, but this time the ladies are ready for him and won't be run off the road without a fight. Though not Tarantino's best, Death Proof showed he still had the skills to make work the kind of disjointed (and potentially alienating) storytelling that made his early movies a hit.
3. Dressed To Kill
While Brian De Palma has all but faded into obscurity these last few decades (most recently helming Domino, a straight-to-video thriller that was annihilated by critics), the 1970s and '80s saw him churn out megahits like Scarface and The Untouchables, alongside smaller but still acclaimed erotic thrillers like Body Double and - the subject of this entry - Dressed to Kill.
The film follows Angie Dickinson's Kate Miller, who is bored with her home life and ready for some excitement that doesn't involve her husband rolling off her after a rigid three-minute missionary. But following a steamy encounter with a stranger, she is hacked to death in his apartment's elevator with a straight razor. The prostitute who witnesses the murder - Liz Blake (Nancy Allen) - becomes the film's focus, as she tries to find out precisely whodunnit before they get her too.
Changing the tone and genre of the film sharply, from erotic psychodrama to psychological thriller, Dressed to Kill is indubitably De Palma's homage to Psycho - one of the very first films to pull such a trick. The bait-and-switch of the female protagonists is far from where the similarities end, too.
2. Psycho (1960)
The film that started it all, Alfred Hitchcock's chilling classic Psycho took audiences by storm in the 1960s and is still recognised as not just a cornerstone feature of horror cinema, but a thoroughly original excursion into the possiblilities of narrative storytelling.
In a brisk opening act, Marion Crane (Janet Leigh) steals money from her work and makes a hasty getaway to her fancyman's place. On the way, she stops for the night at the Bates Motel, and things take a turn for the unexpected.
Marion is slain, suddenly and brutally, by "Mother" in the motel shower, passing the narrative torch to her sister and the detective investigating her murder. The story then focuses on the horrors that surround Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins) and the film goes from potential crime caper to bloody disturbing horror.
1. Barbarian (2022)
Barbarian crept onto our screens last year and proceeded to drag all of our common understandings about horror cinema through the mud.
The film sets off as a psychological thriller in a rented house in Detroit that two people have booked, bringing Tess Marshall (Georgina Campbell) into collision with Keith Toshko (an immediately creepy Bill Skarsgard). As the evening progresses, the pair unwind and it seems Keith isn't such a bad guy after all. The night goes smoothly and the pair head out for the day, safe in the knowledge that they will be returning not to a psychopathic killer but a new friend.
This sets up a one-two-three punch: Keith turns out to be neither antagonist nor protagonist and is killed in the first act, Tess is kidnapped by a creature living under the rental house, and we are then flung many states away from the action, characters and established plot.
Writer-director Zach Cregger piles on the tension by having the film switch on a whim to the life of sleazy TV actor AJ Gilbride (Justin Long), who owns and manages the rental from California. Fired for sexually harassing his co-stars, he makes the cross-state journey to inspect the place before he can sell it to cover legal costs. The film pivots to a creature feature flick as AJ uncovers the subterranean maze under the house, where he finds Tess and has to fight dirty to make it back out with his life.