10 Movies That Unexpectedly Confused Audiences

Wait, what just happened?

Prometheus movie
Fox

Though we can all appreciate the joy of brainless, undemanding movies which let us unwind after a tough day at work, the virtue of an intelligent, challenging film also speaks for itself.

Yet there's certainly nothing surprising about, say, a David Lynch film tying audiences up in mental knots, or Christopher Nolan's Inception forcing audiences to pay close attention to its dream-hopping mechanics.

There are, however, movies which present themselves to audiences as relatively straightforward genre affairs, yet which for one reason or another, are deceptively complicated and, yes, ultimately quite confusing.

These 10 films, whether for better or more often for worse, left audiences quite unsure of what they'd just seen, scrambling to figure out the plot, the character motivations, and any potential deeper meaning.

In some cases that was clearly the filmmaker's intent, to get the audience asking questions, but in others an exciting movie premise was simply destroyed by poor writing and direction, turning dishy concepts into mentally exhausting, scarcely coherent cinematic gunk.

Whether you "got" these movies or not, they were miles away from what most viewers expected going in...

10. The Matrix Reloaded

The Matrix Reloaded The Architect.jpg
Warner Bros.

As much as the original Matrix was a triumph of jaw-droppingly innovative visual effects, perhaps its true achievement was in delivering an ambitious, literate, philosophical blockbuster to the masses that didn't also leave them cross-eyed.

Sadly the same can't quite be said for The Matrix Reloaded, an entertainingly OTT sequel which, while lacking its predecessor's clarity of vision, at least made good on a slew of insanely slick - or slickly insane? - set-pieces.

And then that damn third act happened.

Indeed, The Matrix Reloaded drives headlong into a brick wall during Neo's (Keanu Reeves) outrageous head-scratcher of a final confrontation with the "father" of The Matrix, The Architect (Helmut Bakaitis).

While on one hand you could argue the Wachowskis simply explained something that never really needed explaining, the Architect's impenetrable word-salad of an exposition dump left the vast majority of viewers feeling like they knew less about this world than when the conversation began.

Audiences wanted The Matrix 2 to deliver cool action and a reasonable expansion of the existing lore - not some Colonel Sanders knock-off vomiting a dictionary at us.

Ultimately this clunker of a "showdown" may have single-handedly sunk much interest in the third film, The Matrix Revolutions, which grossed barely half of Reloaded's box office.

The Architect's verbose chit-chat was so maligned by audiences that it even got parodied at the MTV Movie Awards, courtesy of Will Ferrell.


9. Only God Forgives

Only God Forgives Ryan Gosling
Gaumont

Though Nicolas Winding Refn's Drive is often criticised for not being the high-octane action film suggested by its marketing, it was nevertheless a moody, stylish art-house riff on typical Hollywood thrillers. Above all else, the simple narrative ensured nobody could be confused by it.

And so, when Refn announced his follow-up would be a Thailand-set thriller starring Ryan Gosling as a bare-knuckle boxer looking to avenge his brother's murder, it seemed like audiences knew exactly what to expect.

Except, Only God Forgives wasn't just a warmed-over Drive retread, but a slow, surreal, sparse thriller crammed with obtuse visual metaphors, bizarre Freudian allusions, and only the bare minimum dialogue possible. Seriously, Gosling has only 17 lines in this thing.

As a result, all but the most ardent Refn acolytes were left unsure what to make of the end result, for though Refn didn't simply repeat the success of Drive, many probably wished that he had.

The film's refusal to give the audience much concrete in terms of character motivation or narrative form is perhaps best characterised by the scene in which Gosling's protagonist Julian finds the corpse of his murdered mother, Crystal (Kristin Scott Thomas), before cutting her open and placing his hands inside. Yup.

At this point in time it's clear that Refn is an agitator who loves to toy with what audiences expect both of him and cinema as a whole, patently refusing to give them the catharsis and the sheer information they expect out of a movie.


8. Little Women

Little Women 2019
Columbia Pictures

Greta Gerwig's Best Picture-nominated adaptation of the legendary novel Little Women shouldn't have had much room to confuse people, given that it's been adapted to the screen countless times before and, all things considered, isn't a terribly confusing story.

But the film received blowback from audiences less-familiar with Louisa May Alcott's novel, who felt that Gerwig failed to sufficiently distinguish the film's two time periods set seven years apart, which she freely cuts between without title cards.

To make matters more complicated, the same principal cast is used for both sets of scenes, despite the titular characters all being young women who, realistically, would change drastically during those years. Hence, the weirdness of a 22-year-old Florence Pugh playing a 12-year-old Amy March in the flashbacks.

There is admittedly a visual "tell" to help audiences keep track of the two time periods, as the flashbacks have an almost sepia-style tint to them, while the present-day scenes are graded to look more stark and "realistic."

It certainly didn't prevent the film from being a critical and commercial success, even if many unacquainted with the source material found themselves struggling to keep up.


7. Terminator Genisys

Terminator Genisys Pops Sarah Kyle
Paramount

Despite the Terminator movies revolving around an increasingly convoluted series of time-hopping, continuity-resetting plots, the overwhelming majority of the films are actually relatively easy to follow thanks to their tidy internal logic - and that's true even in some of the lesser entries.

But Terminator Genisys is an example of a movie which only creates a bigger headache the more it tries to fill the viewer in on crucial information.

The more the characters attempt to "clarify" the timey-wimey shenanigans, the more the audience wishes they hadn't bothered at all.

Even after audiences get over the fact that Genisys effectively disregards the last two sequels, the film strains itself to explain why a new timeline exists where 1984's Sarah Connor (Emilia Clarke) is already a battle-hardened vet ready for action.

Ultimately, the new 1984 timeline is created after John Connor (Jason Clarke) gets "turned" by Skynet in the future, creating a "nexus point", as Arnie's Pops calls it - an event of such extreme importance that it creates a vastly different future. Right.

While it's easy enough to just sit back and soak in the mediocre, CGI-fuelled action, Terminator Genisys remains the only one of the six movies convoluted enough to invite a migraine.


6. The Snowman

The Snowman Michael Fassbender
Universal Pictures

It's relatively common for crime thriller movies to be intentionally twisty and convoluted, from the tradition of classic film noir through to more contemporary, Scandic-spiced neo-noirs like The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and, yes, The Snowman.

But this Michael Fassbender-starring, Norway-set adaptation of Jo Nesbø's novel proved especially tough to follow even for the slippery standards of wilfully messy crime fiction.

Despite the seeming simplicity of its central narrative - following detective Harry Hole (Fassbender) as he tracks down a serial killer - much of the film is rendered a scarcely coherent slog. Director Tomas Alfredson later confirmed this was due to 10-15% of the shooting script never actually being filmed.

A rushed shoot reportedly prevented The Snowman being completed to its expected standard, ensuring pivotal scenes needed to fill narrative holes didn't go before cameras, forcing Alfredson to piece things together as best possible during editing.

Clearly The Snowman was never going to be a great movie no matter if Alfredson got that extra 15% in the can, but at least the spine of the story might've been a tad easier to follow. As for the final film, it's only as nonsensical as it is deeply, terribly boring.


5. Sucker Punch

Sucker Punch Emily Browning
Warner Bros.

When the trailers for Sucker Punch first dropped, we all thought the same thing - how complicated could a Zack Snyder movie about young women in sailor outfits fighting giant samurai possibly be?

As it turns out, Snyder's film was decidedly more cerebral an action film than just about anyone expected, with the movie taking place in both the real world and the more fantastical non-reality within traumatised protagonist Babydoll's (Emily Browning) mind.

The narrative itself was actually relatively easy to follow, but many simply couldn't get their head around the tone and intent of Snyder's movie - was it sexist or not?

In one corner, many criticised Sucker Punch for its apparent tone-deafness, of blatantly sexualising young women who are themselves victims of sexual assault.

In the other, there are those who feel that the film is in fact a sly commentary on sexism in the entertainment industry, that the objectification within the film is just another layer of its examination of misogyny.

The latter is a reading which Snyder himself has supported - because of course he would - even if many feel that he's simply not a finessed enough storyteller to come up with something that clever.

Is it sexist or a film about sexism? Or could it be a messy, contradictory collision of the two? The debate continues.


4. The Hunt

The Hunt Betty Gilpin
Blumhouse

The Hunt may be far from a perfect movie, but it sure is one of the boldest and most provocative films to be released this year, a satirical horror film which left many critics fumbling to get a read on its specific intent.

The film follows a group of conservative-voting "deplorables" who are rounded up and hunted to the death by the bloodthirsty liberal elite, which prior to its release seemed to suggest The Hunt was learning on the right side of the political spectrum.

But the final movie itself is actually far more ambiguous about its politics, choosing instead to poke equal opportunities fun at both "sides," while ultimately conceding the absurdity of "us and them" politics.

That naturally didn't stop people of all persuasions bearing their own political biases by damning it as either fiercely left-wing or right-wing, creating a muddy yet fascinatingly passionate discourse with no clear consensus.


3. Prometheus

Logan Marshall Green, Noomi Rapace and Michael Fassbender in Prometheus
20th Century Fox

From one confusing Damon Lindelof movie to another now with Prometheus.

On paper, people seemed to have a pretty good idea of what the movie was going to be: a direct-ish prequel to Ridley Scott's Alien, which would probably explain how the Space Jockey ended up on LV-426 and also the origins of the Xenomorph.

The marketing for Prometheus absolutely played on the audience's expectations that the film would dovetail directly into Alien, and so major confusion abounded when the movie turned out to be something a little different.

Though Jon Spaihts' original script for Prometheus was indeed a straight prequel, Lindelof's rewrites ultimately re-imagined it as a tangential storyline in close proximity to the events of Alien, taking place instead on the moon LV-223.

While it's easy to see how the movie's events could so easily have fed directly into Alien, for reasons unknown the decision was made to create a buffer between them, leaving fans understandably baffled and frustrated.

Some suspected this was done in order to leave room for sequels which would inch closer to actually connecting to Alien, but whatever the reason, fans couldn't quite get their heads around such a bizarre bait-and-switch.


2. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice

Batman V Superman Martha Ben Affleck
Warner Bros. Pictures

Batman v Superman is one of those movies which really just needed to deliver what was on the tin: two of the most iconic superheroes in history beating the ever-loving snot out of each other.

But Zack Snyder being Zack Snyder, he of course decided to turn a seemingly straight-forward grudge match for the ages into a shockingly convoluted, over-plotted 151-minute slog.

Though the movie's three-hour Ultimate Edition does clarify some of the nagging plot discrepancies, it doesn't really elaborate on Lex Luthor's (Jesse Eisenberg) nebulous motivations for making the heroes fight one another, nor the totally bungled execution of that infamous "Martha!" moment.

Given the appeal of the titular attraction, this is absolutely a film that didn't need dozens of characters and almost as many subplots.

All it needed was a setup, an end-of-first-act fight which Superman (Henry Cavill) won, an end-of-second-act fight which a more-prepared Batman (Ben Affleck) won, and then a third-act team-up against a bigger villain.

Instead it was obsessed with senate hearings, an offputtingly mopey Man of Steel, and being basically anything but the stripped down mano-y-mano superhero slugfest it should've been.


1. Brahms: The Boy II

Brahms The Boy 2
STX Entertainment

And finally, we have a film which from the ground-up is just a completely baffling creation, the recent sequel to 2016's surprise horror hit, The Boy.

The first film revolved around a woman (Lauren Cohan) being hired to serve as the nanny to Brahms, a porcelain doll which has been serving as a stand-in for the real boy who perished in a fire 20 years earlier.

The obvious implication is that the doll is haunted by the real Brahms, yet the big twist is that Brahms is actually alive and living inside the mansion's walls. Yup.

By film's end, the doll is smashed but the real Brahms survives, yet the sequel unexpectedly ditches this continuity entirely and reverts back to the notion that, yes, the doll really is haunted.

For the few people who were actually interested in a sequel, it was a bizarre slap in the face, to throw out the established lore and needlessly re-jig the continuity.

In addition to making no mention of the human Brahms, the sequel also ret-cons the doll's properties, revealing that underneath its porcelain exterior is a demonic face, rather than it being hollow as established in the original.

The movie is a boatload of WTF, and despite the first film's writer-director team returning for the sequel, they clearly had no regard for what little they got right the first time around. Likely as a result of this, the film tanked at the box office, killing a low-key cash cow in the process.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.