10 Movies With Mind-Bending Plots

Entertaining, mind-twisting movies which will stay with you long after the credits roll.

stranger than fiction will ferrell
Columbia Pictures

Christopher Nolan's time-bending, mind-stretching Tenet ably justifies its place on this list but, if you're in the mood for equally challenging, and equally entertaining fare, there are a host of other great films to choose from.

Almost from the beginnings of cinema, film-makers have experimented with non-linear narratives and brain-twisting plots. Some of the greatest movies across the decades have pushed the envelope in terms of their structure, and you will find many of these included below.

It should come as no surprise that the ideas-rich world of science fiction contributes strongly here. The concept of time-travel, of course, has given directors scope to stretch, condense, overlap and otherwise play havoc with conventional formulas. We've restricted ourselves to just two entries from that particular genre, but honourable mentions must go to Time Crimes, Safety Not Guaranteed and Le Jetee, all of which could have featured.

Prepare to take a deep dive into parallel universes, altered consciousness, dream-like tales and realities-within-realities.

10. Je T'aime, Je T'aime (1968)

A director who could easily contribute more than one film to this list, Alain Resnais is probably better known for critically acclaimed works such as French-Japanese drama Hiroshima Mon Amour (1959), documentary Night And Fog (1956) and the enigmatic Last Year In Marienbad (1961), but this underrated sci fi gem easily sits alongside the latter in terms of depth and style.

Following an attempted suicide Claude Ridder (played by Claude Rich) is approached by a shadowy scientific organisation who ask him to participate in an experiment concerning time travel. Ridder, who feels he has nothing to lose, agrees. The procedure is intended to send Ridder back into the past, where he will stay for precisely one minute before returning.

Instead, Ridder is cast into the time stream, and begins experiencing, or re-playing, his life in a disjointed, jarring fashion. These scenarios sometimes last mere seconds, playing in a loop like a stuck record. At other moments the scenes are more expansive. At first, the viewer is never quite certain as to the order of events we are witnessing but, gradually, a story emerges. Previously obscure references begin to make sense, character's motives become clear and the drama plays out in thrilling fashion.


9. Upstream Color (2013)

Upstream Color
ERBP

The previous film by director Shane Carruth, 2004's Primer, could just as easily have made this list. That movie took the time travel concept and thoroughly twisted it inside out, charting a captivating and brain-stretching tale of two scientists and the consequences of their experiments. Audiences waited nine years for a follow-up and, when it appeared, Carruth unveiled a film which, if anything, is even more challenging than its predecessor.

The plot of Upstream Color revolves around a bizarre parasite and the effects which it has upon its human hosts. Carruth himself stars alongside Amy Seimetz, who plays Kris, the unwitting recipient of said parasite, after she is kidnapped and forced to imbibe larva by a mysterious and unnamed man. Kris then falls into an extremely suggestible state, and is manipulated by her captor into handing over the contents of her bank account.

She wakes up later with worms visibly wriggling under her skin, unsuccessfully attempts to remove them, loses her job, find her money stolen and is lured by infrasonics to a pig farm. In terms of weirdness, the above is simply the tip of the proverbial iceberg. Like Primer, Upstream Color has a lot to offer those willing to meet the film on its own terms.


8. Solaris (1972)

Solaris Film
Mosfilm

Science fiction aficionados and cinemaphiles alike will point to Solaris as an important landmark in movie history. The 2002 Hollywood remake, directed by Steven Soderbergh and starring George Clooney is a solid entry, but in terms of visual splendour and artistic achievement, the 1972 original is the one to watch.

Russian maestro Andrei Tarkovsky directs. For those yet to encounter this wonderful film-maker, all seven of his feature-length creations are things to be savoured. Tarkovsky has the magic touch, able to pack more pathos and meaning into a single ten-second shot than most movies do over their entire run-time.

Adapted from the novel of the same name by renowned Polish sci-fi writer, Stanislaw Lem, Solaris concerns psychologist Kris Kelvin (played by Donatas Banionis) who is tasked with travelling to a remote space station orbiting the mysterious titular planet. The three scientists manning this station have ceased communications, apparently due to emotional trauma. It is Kelvin's job to investigate and to help.

What follows is an intriguing and astonishing exploration of memory and the nature of reality which will expand your mind and delight your eyes.


7. Altered States (1980)

Altered States
Warner Bros.

This unsettling yet highly enjoyable movie sits as an early entry in the now-popular 'body horror' genre. The plot centres around an American psychopathologist, Edward Jessop, who theorizes that alternate states of consciousness may, in fact, be as real as our perceived 'waking' state. To further his research, Jessop visits a mysterious tribe in Mexico and partakes of a sacred potion which induces an extreme hallucinogenic experience.

Returning home, Jessop begins to experiment with sensory deprivation, via a flotation tank, in an attempt to replicate the drug's effects. Terrifyingly, Jessop's visionary journeys begin to manifest as real physical changes. After one such 'trip' he emerges transformed into a savage caveman-like figure, and is uncontrollable.

Maverick Ken Russell (The Devils, Women In Love) directs this disturbing feature, which marks the screen debuts of both William Hurt (Body Heat, Avengers) and Drew Barrymore (Donnie Darko, Grey Gardens). It's a punishing watch but, unlike many of the films on this list, there is at least a happy ending to this sorry tale.


6. Tenet (2020)

Tenet John David Washington
Warner Bros.

Director Christopher Nolan has built a reputation for inventive, often convoluted plots. Ever since 1998's Following, Nolan has entertained and challenged in equal measure, displaying a fondness for experimenting with cinematic time which, with 2020's Tenet, seemed to reach its inevitable conclusion.

In his previous film, Interstellar (2014), Nolan mixed known laws of physics with leaps of imagination to explore the possible effects of long-distance space travel. With 2010's Inception, the director played with notions of both time and consciousness to create an unforgettable, multi-layered experience. Even his historical feature, Dunkirk (2017), utilised three distinct, overlapping windows of duration - one week, one hour and one day.

With Tenet, all rules fly out the window as we enter a parallel universe in which time flows backwards. Protagonists and antagonists alike are able to jump from one to the other although, and this is where the brain-twisting originates, whilse in the 'reverse' world, they themselves are still moving 'forward,' at least from their own point of view.

If you didn't quite grasp the above, then you're in good company. Many viewers have come away from this visual spectacle with far more questions than answers, and debate is still on-going as to why, or if, Tenet makes any sense.


5. Exterminating Angel (1962)

When it comes to critical praise, Spanish director Luis Buñuel stands among a select group of world-wide film-makers who are universally acknowledged as the greatest of all time. He wrote, produced and directed many enduring classics, and will be known to many as the co-creator, alongside surrealist painter Salvador Dali, of the experimental short film, Un Chien Andalou (1929) one of the earliest examples of its kind, infamous for a shudder-inducing razor-blade-across-an-eyeball moment.

Exterminating Angel, made some three decades later, sees the director in top form, delivering an equally sharp critique of the aristocracy. The protagonists are Señor Edmundo Nóbile and his wife Lucía, together with the esteemed guests they invite to dinner at their lavish mansion. The assembled characters retire to the music room, where the party drags on into late evening, then night, and eventually early morning as the guests find themselves inexplicably unable to cross the threshold and leave.

This turns into a bizarre survival situation, as both food and water being to run short. Tempers explode, arguments ensue and factions emerge as one member of the group, Dr. Carlos Conde, struggles to prevent a full-on descent into madness. It's a wonderful set-up, acutely observed. The finale is as shocking as it is unexpected.


4. El Topo (1970)

El Topo
ABKCGO

A notorious film from a notorious film-maker. Avant-garde Western El Topo is directed by controversial Chilean-Frenchman Alejandro Jodorowsky, who also stars as a violent black-clad gun-slinger, roaming the wild desert (accompanied by his young son) in a quest to defeat four legendary marksmen and win the love of a slave-woman.

Don't expect to find any sense here, but do expect outrageous visuals, disturbing scenes and bizarre happenings. A mysterious woman with a male voice, dwarfs, maimed performers, demented outcasts and liberal references to Christian symbolism and Eastern esoteric knowledge abound. Caution is advised concerning a particular episode, where El Topo encounters hundreds of dead rabbits. These are not props. Jodorowsky initially claimed he had killed them himself, by hand, although he later denied this.

Certainly, animal cruelty is a theme in the director's work. El Topo is not his only movie to be highly criticised for such. Intriguingly, Jodorowsky came close to directing Dune for the big screen, and worked closely with author Frank Herbert before the project stalled for financial reasons.


3. Alice (1988)

You could choose anything by surrealist Czech animator Jan Švankmajer, whose undeniable talents veered sharply toward the avant-garde. He produced several equally off-the-wall and wonderful live-action films, but is his stop-motion endeavours which capture the film-maker's imagination at its peak. Like much of the director's work, Alice features a mixture of live-action and animation, and it does so quite brilliantly.

The film is loosely based on the original Alice In Wonderland book, following the adventures of a little girl who follows a white rabbit into an astonishing and frequently disturbing fantasy world. Švankmajer's white rabbit, however, resembles a creature from a nightmare, a badly-stuffed, blank-eyed thing which scuttles and scurries about with menace.

In truth, this may be the most on-point adaptation of Lewis Carroll's fiction in movie history. Where other versions play out like fairy tales, Švankmajer's Alice brims over with all the wonder, fear and fascination of childhood.


2. Miracle Mile (1988)

Miracle Mile
Hemdale Film Corporation

Director Steve De Jarnatt helmed television episodes of The X-Files, ER and Alfred Hitchcock Presents, but it's his feature-length project which concerns us here. You'd do well to check out De Jarnatt's later cult scifi movie Cherry 2000 (1987) which is a fun slice of offbeat action, but the more-serious Miracle Mile ably lives up to its status as a beloved fan favourite.

Set in Los Angeles, the film follows musician Harry (played by Anthony Edwards, who later starred in Zodiac and Northern Exposure) who meets and promptly falls in love with waitress Julie (Mare Winningham). They spend the afternoon together, and arrange to meet again at the coffee shop where Julie works, after her shift ends at midnight.

An electrical outage leads Harry to oversleep. He rushes to the coffee shop only to find that Julie has already left. When a payphone randomly rings and Harry answers, a sequence of events begins with literally apocalyptic consequences. Without wishing to spoil the plot, Harry must find Julie and escape the city within a strict time limit.

What makes this film special, aside from the highly likeable protagonists, is the surreal nature of Harry's encounters as he desperately tries to beat the clock. Denise Michelle Crosby (aka Star Trek's Tasha Yar) also stars.


1. Stranger Than Fiction (2006)

stranger than fiction will ferrell
Columbia Pictures

This reality-bending romantic thriller is by some way the most warm-hearted entry here, although German-Swiss director Marc Forster, who also gave us The Kite Runner, Quantum Of Solace and World War Z, never lets things descend into schmaltz. Written by Zach Helm (Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium), the plot follows Harold Crick (Will Ferrell), a disillusioned IRS agent who lives a hum-drum life, until he finds himself enchanted by cafe owner Maggie Gyllenhaal.

That's just one side of the story, however. The real tension arises from the voice in Crick's head (Emma Thompson), who appears to be narrating Harry's life. When Harry's watch stops working and he asks a bystander for the correct time, resetting it, the narrator casually mentions that this simple action will eventually lead to Harry's death.

We have three strands at work here – a will-they/won't-they love story, the mystery of Harry's forthcoming demise and Harry's quest to discover the true nature of the narrator inside his mind. Ferrell puts in a fine and restrained performance, ably assisted by Dustin Hoffman's excellent turn as a literary expert who tries to help the lovable IRS agent.


Contributor

Chris Wheatley is a journalist and writer from Oxford, UK. He has too many records, too many guitars and not enough cats.