10 Not-So-Traditional Christmas Flicks

It's a Wonderful Life, A Christmas Story, the Rankin & Bass stop-motion specials and many timeless others all the way up to December 25th. But, this Yuletide, we here at WhatCulture would like to give you the chance to branch away from the norm and introduce into your annual tradition some movies that are either a little off-kilter, may not be quite suitable for the little ones, or that you didn't even know had anything to do with Christmas. Here's a list of not-so-traditional Christmas flicks for those a little tired of Charlie Brown and friends.

10. Gremlins (1984)

If this was a list of my personal favorite Christmas films, Gremlins would be the undisputed champion. While it has taken a while to get the recognition it deserves around this time of year, Joe Dante's madcap horror-comedy finally seems to be joining the illustrious ranks of the Grinch and the Muppets, and it rightly deserves it. The tale of the adorable mogwai Gizmo and his owner/friend Billy is one of the best films to come out of the 1980's and easily one of the best movies to show to a kid in an effort to get them into horror films. While the titular creatures are often terrifying, they are also unabashedly silly and offer the audience as many laughs as they do screams. This is one the whole family can enjoy, if your family finds a miserly old woman being rocketed out of a window as funny as mine does.


9. Batman Returns (1992)

Often being forced to hide in the shadow of its predecessor, Batman Returns is actually an even darker and more twisted vision of the Caped Crusader from the demented mind of Tim Burton (an obvious fan of Christmas. Just check out his filmography), and it happens to take place during the most mirthful of seasons! The holiday backdrop and the German expressionistic art direction clash to create a visual interpretation that, in my opinion, outshines the original 1989 film's imagery by far. The movie is also anchored by two delightfully decadent performances by Danny DeVito as the monstrous Penguin and Michelle Pfeiffer as the sadistically seductive Catwoman. You throw in Christopher Walken and a plot to drown all of Gotham's firstborn children and you have a Batman motion picture that could very well be classified as a horror film. But, I guess having penguins firing missiles off of their backs helps to alleviate some of the grimness.

8. Black Christmas (1974 and 2006)

Usually cited as the original slasher movie (predating John Carpenter's Halloween by almost half a decade), 1974's Black Christmas is oozing with atmospheric unease and a feeling of true malice towards the season of giving. It comes as a bit of a surprise to some that it was directed by Bob Clark, the man behind a more family-friendly holiday classic, A Christmas Story. But, the man cut his teeth in the genre with such flicks as Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things and the highly underappreciated Deathdream (a.k.a. Dead of Night). However, the movie is light on onscreen gore and if you like your slasher flicks red and messy, the 2006 remake by Glen Morgan may be more up your alley. Filled with plenty of gruesomely fun kills and a more gonzo spirit than the haunting original, it also stars a handful of notable actresses such as Michelle Trachtenberg (Harriet from Harriet the Spy), Mary Elizabeth Winstead (Ramona Flowers from Scott Pilgrim vs. the World), Katie Cassidy (Dinah Lance from the CW's Arrow) and Lacy Chabert (Meg from Family Guy). Either movie has its strengths and it all depends on whether you want a moody chiller or a wacky bloodbath to go along with your Christmas Eve candy canes.

7. Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale (2010)

Considering that the mythological figure we know as Santa Claus originates from the Nordic regions of Europe, it's refreshing to see a movie made in his "homeland" that is a complete butchering of the jovial interpretation he's morphed into today. Rare Exports is a Finnish film that reimagines Santa as a supernatural creature that punishes naughty children instead of rewarding nice ones. When a local family manages to catch this creature in a trap, they decide to make a profit off of it by selling to a scientist that may be unearthing something even more sinister. Expertly crafted and original as sin, Rare Exports manages to be a movie that is both scary and fun (often at the same time) that also functions as a film about the closeness of family, which is another tenet of the Christmas season. Destined to be a cult classic, it serves as a good reminder that the jolly old elf wasn't always so jolly.

6. Tales from the Crypt (1972 and 1989)

The notorious EC comics have been adapted to the small and big screen a number of times, originally in 1972 by British production house Amicus. In their outing of Tales from the Crypt (an anthology film consisting of five separate stories and a wraparound), there is an adaptation of the killer Santa story called "...And All Through the House" in which a wife (played by a sultry Joan Collins) kills her husband and tries to hide the body while a news report announces that a lunatic wearing a Santa suit is running loose. Of course, the two cross paths and it turns out that the wife just made Santa's naughty list this year. While the Amicus film's take on the tale is serviceable, the real version to watch is the 1989 HBO television series episode. Directed by Robert Zemeckis, it's an almost pitch perfect realization of the gallows humor the comics were known for, and Larry Drake's performance as the murderous Saint Nick is a treasure to behold. If you don't squeal with dark glee at his ending delivery of the line, "Naughty or nice?", I don't want to know you.

5. Lethal Weapon (1987)

For most folks, John McTiernan's seminal Die Hard has become the only action movie even worth mentioning during the Christmas season. While Die Hard is great fun and a great film, I have to argue that Lethal Weapon is not only a better picture but also has better performances from both its heroes and villain. Maybe it's the everyman charm of Bruce Willis that makes John McClane so easy to like, but I think Mel Gibson's maniac with a death wish Martin Riggs is a much more fascinating and watchable character. Plus, you get Danny Glover in a role that pretty much defined his career, and the chemistry between him and Gibson make for the quintessential buddy cop movie of all time. Written by Shane Black (another filmmaker who seems to love Christmas. This spot on the list could have easily gone to his brilliant directorial debut Kiss Kiss Bang Bang) with a razor sharp wit and glorious action sequences, Lethal Weapon is more than a worthy successor to Die Hard's unchallenged Christmas action movie throne. And in the end, Gary Busey trumps Alan Rickman every time. Every. Time

4. The "Silent Night, Deadly Night" series (1984 - 1991)

Believe it or not, there are a ton of movies that are a variation on the "Santa starts offing folks" idea. I could have populated this whole list with killer Santa movies. But, if I'm going to mention only one, it has to be Silent Night, Deadly Night. It's infamous for being banned from theaters due to parents groups objecting to its use of Santa holding an axe in the promotional posters and other advertising. The movie is fairly decent and offers up a few unwanted chuckles, but it has more value for its history rather than its content. The sequels are another story. While the law of diminishing returns does take effect, the good news is that the progressive films get nuttier and more bizarre, ending with a movie completely removed from the original's storyline. Part 2 alone is a wacked out masterpiece that includes the well known "Garbage Day!" scene that made the rounds on the Internet many cycles ago. With a remake of the original now upon us (simply titled Silent Night), it's a very good time to rediscover the only existing Christmas horror franchise.

3. Brazil (1985)

On the surface, Terry Gilliam's fever dream dystopian science-fiction comedy would seem like it has nothing to do with Christmas. Until you watch the opening scene of a father being abducted in front of his family with a Christmas tree happily blinking in the background and you realize that Gilliam is using the holiday trappings to rip into consumerism and the disguising of exploitation as tradition. It's the very definition of "subversive" and it works like gangbusters. There's a group of people carrying a banner proclaiming "Consumers for Christ" that just nails the cynical nature of the film on the head. It doesn't hurt that the film is brimming with masterfully comedic performances by the likes of Bob Hoskins and Robert DeNiro. If you like a little 1984 with your Christmas ham, Brazil is the side dish for you.

2. Elves (1989)

To try and explain the transcendent awfulsomeness of something like Elves is a failed enterprise. It is something that must be seen to be believed. The plot goes something like this: an ancient evil elf is awakened by an Anti-Christmas pagan ritual. The elf is part of a neo-Nazi scheme to realize Hitler's dream of creating half-human/half-elf hybrids that will construct the true master race and take over the planet. Our lead girl is the last of a specific bloodline that the elf must mate with in order to create the ultimate life-form. Meanwhile, an alcoholic ex-cop is slumming as a mall Santa and ends up being the sole protector of the girl. Go back and read that synopsis again. If that doesn't make you need to see this movie, what are you doing reading this list? I haven't even mentioned that the elf creature is just a single bust reused throughout the entire film, or that the acting is like some kind of accidental comedy/Andy Kaufman level of awkwardly bad. If you see only one movie from this list for this Christmas, make it Elves. Just make sure you have a lot of friends and plenty of intoxicants and I guarantee a sublime experience. So after all these off-the-wall movies, what could possibly claim the number one spot. Well, down another couple glasses of eggnog and prepare yourself because this time, it's personal...

1. Jaws the Revenge (1987)

Jaws is my favorite movie and I wouldn't be alone in that sentiment. This means I've seen all the sequels multiple times and while they all have their respective merits, Jaws the Revenge (the fourth and final in the series) is an indefensible travesty. Except for one scene, and it happens to be the opening. Sean Brody (son of Roy Scheider's chief from the first two films) is trying to clear a floating piece of debris from a shipping channel and is attacked by the shark (who is personally killing members of the Brody family. Yeah, don't ask) while a group of Christmas carolers drown out his screams of agony. It's surprisingly effective and violent, but it's all downhill from there. The film primarily takes place in the Bahamas, so the Christmas setting is almost non-existent, but it decorates the background and a key few scenes. Jaws the Revenge is almost universally regarded as one of the worst studio releases of all time, and it happens to feature both Bruce Wayne's butler (Michael Caine) and the kid from The Last Starfighter (Lance Guest). But, if you have a taste for junk cinema and plenty of eggnog in your system, Jaws the Revenge is an easy target for relentless riffing and a worthy candidate for the best worst movie of the season. Take a sip of eggnog each time the shark's skin wrinkles and when you can see the shark's mechanical apparatus under its belly and you'll be drunker than most of your relatives in no time. There are a plethora of unknown Xmas movie gems waiting to be unearthed. What are some of your nontraditional Christmas movies that we may have missed? Sound off in the comments below and have a Merry Movie-watching season!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Drew Dietsch is an Entertainment Editor at Fandom.com. He's written for CHUD.com, the News-Press, WhatCulture, and releases a weekly podcast about his media consumption called The Drew Reviews Podcast.