10 Off-The-Wall Casting Choices That Were Somehow Awesome

Tom Cruise Cover

Oftentimes, casting an actor can be an easy job. You want scenery-chewing? Visit Daniel Day-Lewis. You want stern Britishness? Judi Dench is your woman. Need a nutcase, stat? Jackie Earl Haley's on standby. Really, it could not be any easier for casting directors €“ if they want somebody who's neurotic, you can bet damn sure that there's an actor out there who's got a reputation for doing such a thing (Christopher Walken's the bet here). Yet sometimes, film-makers just can't resist throwing us a curveball, casting stars so against type, they might as well be in another continent. Granted, this can go very wrong, very quickly €“ see Lindsay Lohan in The Canyons €“ but occasionally, someone out there in the industry sees something that we just couldn't. Whether it was that an actor used to playing buttoned-down parts can drop some comedy like it isn't even a thing, or that the renowned goofball can create powerful drama if they so wish, Hollywood is littered with these hidden talents ripe for the plucking. Those are just two examples of this off-the-wall casting €“ there are plenty of other ways actors can surprise us, and I hope I've catalogued a few here. Now obviously, a SPOILER WARNING is in effect. It's only a light one, so feel free to read on. Just don't say I didn't warn you.

10. Tom Hanks €“ Philadelphia

Tom Hanks - Philadelphia It feels strange to say this now, but there was once a time when all you would associate with Tom Hanks was comedies. That time was called the 80s, and Hanks was on a roll as a comedic presence, putting his efforts behind cult classic Turner and Hooch and of course, Big. Hilarious dogs and troubled aftermaths of man-boys put aside, this was basically it for Hanks €“ he had a career, and that career revolved around making you laugh. But then suddenly, Philadelphia. The shock at Hanks when he came out (pun unintended) with this was nothing short of astounding €“ here was a man whose very previous role had been the serviceable rom-com Sleepless in Seattle, and now here he was portraying an AIDS sufferer in a divisive Hollywood chin-stroker with normally taboo themes, the sort of piece the Academy goes nuts for. And go nuts they did, giving Hanks€™ portrayal of Andrew Beckett the Best Actor gong. It was just bizarre, the equivalent of seeing a clown car win at the F1 €“ impressive in itself, but impressively ridiculous to boot. Just watch the scene when he€™s talking about his favourite opera aria and try and marry that guy to the guy who was flouncing around in children€™s underwear during Big. It€™s very difficult to do, and it adds a whole new dimension to that comedy when you watch it again and realise that a truly excellent actor is foot-playing that giant piano.

9. Brad Pitt €“ 12 Monkeys

Brad Pitt - 12 Monkeys For the longest time, nobody took Brad Pitt too seriously. He was dismissed as a pretty-boy actor, a sort of Robert Redford-lite who got by through sheer photogenic power. These days, we know this does the man a disservice €“ he€™s consistently surprising in all sorts of dramas, and has rocked our worlds in many eclectic roles, be it Terrence Malick€™s auteur efforts, the pensive films of Andrew Dominik or quite simply, as Tyler Durden. Yet the 90s were a different time and place, filled with terrible cargo shorts and the Spice Girls. So when Pitt churned out 12 Monkeys, most people were surprised. Of course, there were the happy few who had seen him as Early Gayce in Kalifornia, and they got to feel incredibly smug with themselves. Yet in the most part, people just didn€™t know where this came from €“ Pitt went from a pretty boy to a damn serious actor, all through his tic-laden, sanity-churning performance as Jeffrey Goines. Paired with Willis€™ slightly subdued protagonist, Pitt had to do most of the scenery-chewing heavy lifting, and he did it with gusto. Not many people get to break their reputations, but from this point on, whenever anyone dismissed him as €˜just a face€™ he could point to the Golden Globe on his mantelpiece. That shuts most people up, really.

8. Leslie Nielsen €“ Airplane!

Leslie Nielsen - Airplane In the Citizen Kane of stunt-casting, I present to you Leslie Nielsen. Before Airplane came out, Nielsen was better known for serious, strait-laced roles such as the Captain of the Poseidon. Being fair, he was built perfectly for the part €“ tall, authoritative and in possession of that magical dramatic combo of a furrowed brow and soothing dulcet tones, he was practically built to be in charge and frown at everything. This combination made it even more hilarious when he finally decided to go off at the deep-end. Combining deadpan wit with terrific lines, the super-serious Nielsen could make anything sound hilarious, even if the zingers weren€™t half as good as they were here. Yet they were, creating a perfect storm of hilarity €“ whether he was telling you what a hospital was or if he simply didn€™t want you to call him Shirley, channelling all that nonplussed authority into an increasingly ludicrous situation made for comedy gold that you€™d never seen before. There€™s a reason Nielsen was able to launch a successful comedic career after this €“ he was just so damn good at it. But let€™s be honest €“ if you looked at his past roles, could you really see this coming? My answer would be no.

7. Tom Cruise €“ Tropic Thunder

Tom Cruise - Tropic Thunder You can pick out a Tom Cruise vehicle with very little effort. If the film is based in real life situations, he tends to be the hero (or the anti-hero). If it€™s an action flick, he€™s humanity€™s only hope. The point is that Cruise€™s films are very Tom-centric, and the diminutive actor tends to take ego-boosting roles. More often than not, they involve some scowling, some moral conflict and a whole lot of running, which has been lampooned so hard for so long it€™s not even worth making a joke about here. Yet then there was Tropic Thunder, and Tom was simply not himself. Not that he was ill or anything, but he was balding, fat, sweary and just an awful, awful human being. Usually, that might resemble all the traits of a midlife crisis, but not here. Here, Cruise was super-producer Les Grossman, and hot damn, he was hilarious. Terrorising agents, directors, lackies and actors, Cruise€™s presence was supposed to be a cameo, yet it almost ended up overshadowing the whole film. After all, if you€™re going to yell at a terrorist leader to €˜f**k his own face,€™ you€™ve got to accept that some of the spotlight is going to fall on you. But again, this wasn€™t a bad thing €“ Cruise was glorious, and picked up a well-deserved Golden Globe Supporting Actor nomination.

6. Robin Williams €“ One Hour Photo

Robin Williams - One Hour Photo Love him or hate him, you have to admit that Robin Williams is essentially harmless. Yes, he€™s manic and sometimes his comedy stylings can prove to be extremely annoying, but really, all he ever portrays is goofballs or occasionally maudlin softies. Even if they promise to €˜f**kin€™ end€™ Matt Damon in Good Will Hunting, you still can€™t get past the fact that he's a pretty cuddly person, really. Whenever he does embrace the darker drama, there€™s still this noble streak in his roles. With this in mind, nothing could prepare you for One Hour Photo. Williams had foreshadowed his step into the dark side with Christopher Nolan€™s big-screen debut Insomnia where he played a murderer, but this was another kettle of fish. It wasn€™t that Sy Parrish was worse than Insomnia€™s Walter Finch, he was just altogether more tragic. Nothing in Sy€™s life was good €“ an abuse victim who lived alone in a Spartan flat, who obsesses over a family because there's literally nothing else in his life. It was a role that required both pathos and unhinged psychosis €“ basically, two things you assume Robin Williams wouldn€™t have in his wheelhouse. But have them he did, and he dredged up something extremely unsettling €“ a monster you couldn€™t help but feel for, despite his heinous actions. Like I said, very unsettling.

5. Saorsie Ronan €“ Hanna

Hanna Ok, so this one€™s a bit of a cheat. The part of Hanna herself is so off-the-wall that it€™s quite literally insane €“ a young teenage girl who€™s lived as a hermit, has no idea of social norms and appears to have an innate mastery of martial arts, MacGyvering (seriously, look at the crossbow-thing she makes in the final act) and ridiculous gunplay. Casting anyone for this role would seem like a bonkers move, but going after Saorsie Ronan looked even more ludicrous. Up to that point in her career, Ronan was only really known for the title role in the flawed Lovely Bones adaptation and as a secondary character in buttoned-up period drama Atonement, so to cast her as an ass-kicking action hero would seem a crazy move, at best. Critics knew she was talented but were nonetheless prepared to sharpen their knives regardless, anticipating something a flaming car-wreck. Yet they shouldn€™t have bothered €“ the Irish teenager rocked in the part, somehow blending a child-like innocence with steely resolve as she bumbled through romantic situations with boys (they ended with submission holds) and married her love for fairy tales with her passion for blowing away rooms full of armed goons. It was a tricky balancing act to pull off, but she did it, and with aplomb.

4. Jim Carrey €“ The Truman Show

Jim Carrey - The Truman Show There comes a time in every actor€™s life when he realises he€™s not going to be taken seriously anymore, and that point usually comes after you sing out of your arse, especially when that arse is covered by some daintily-coloured trousers. This event horizon occurred with Jim Carrey around the time he played Ace Ventura, and he continued plumbing the depths afterward with such films as The Mask, Dumb and Dumber, Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls and the tremendous Liar Liar. Now, I know these films are good in their own right, but you€™ve got to make a distinction €“ as good as they were, such was their puerile sense of humour (again, there€™s nothing wrong with that, I loved all these films) that they would hardly ingratiate you to folks looking to make a serious drama. However, Carrey seemed to buck the rule by picking up the protagonist gig on The Truman Show, and then proceeding to be dramatically awesome. As you watch a man who just wants to explore struggle against his artificial life in a gigantic dome, you struggle to realise that this was the same guy who was yelling histrionically at a pen for being blue in Liar Liar. Seriously, I don€™t think Carrey gets the credit he deserves €“ he€™s consistently able to knock out decent dramatic fare (The Number 23 notwithstanding) and decent comedies like few before him, and that reputation was built off this film.

3. Matthew McConaughey €“ Killer Joe

Matthew McConaughey There was once a time when Matthew McConaughey was the poster boy for mediocre film-making €“ starring in risible rom-com after risible rom-com, all he seemed to do was take his shirt off and make eyes at the womenfolk in the audience. Personally, I didn€™t mind €“ a lot of actresses make their money from taking their clothes off when given the slightest opportunity, and we€™re nothing if not supportive of equal opportunities here at What Culture. In fact, I don€™t think anyone though it as too great a tragedy €“ he was staying in his wheelhouse, and that so happened to involve flexing to the camera. Yet strangely, this didn€™t appear to be what he was best at at all, and Killer Joe made this extremely apparent. Granted, he€™d already struck gold dramatically with The Lincoln Lawyer €“ playing the titular car-dwelling character €“ but people tended to see this one as a bye because all he was doing was playing yet another charming guy, but with a little more murder involved. Yet when Killer Joe rolled around, no-one could make that same judgement again. Simply put, he was gosh-darned terrifying, and it was made all the more disconcerting by the fact it was Mr. Charming himself in the lead role. You€™ve got to see it to believe it, but have to tip your hat to a performance which oozed malevolence and put you off chicken for life as well. If you€™ve seen the film, you€™ll know which scene I mean. What€™s even better about this part is that it seems to have sparked a run of great roles for the actor, who now seems to be running shoulders with big beast directors such as Christopher Nolan and Martin Scorsese without seeming one bit out of place.

2. Justin Timberlake €“ The Social Network

Justin Timberlake - The Social Network These days Justin Timberlake is established as the showbusiness €˜triple threat€™ €“ he can dance, he can sing, and he can act. However, the third part of that trinity took far longer to establish than the first two. Timberlake had been singing and dancing forever, whether on the Mickey Mouse Club, with nSync or during his highly successful solo career. When he started to act, nobody really took it too seriously €“ his debut came in a direct-to-DVD release, he starred in Richard Kelly€™s ultraflop Southland Tales, lent his voice to the forgettable Shrek The Third and just looked sort of moody and constipated (moodstipated?) in Alpha Dog and Black Snake Moan. So when it was announced that he taking the part of Shaun Parker in David Fincher€™s upcoming Facebook origins story The Social Network, eyebrows were understandably raised. However, they really shouldn€™t have been €“ Timberlake went and smashed it out the park, coming off one part charismatic bastard, one part master manipulator and one part awful human being. He was nothing less than a tour-de-force €“ you knew he was terrible, but when he started giving monologues about what Facebook should do, you were drawn in and enthralled by his delivery. Though he wasn€™t Oscar-nominated for this, it was impressive enough that he€™s managed to launch an A-list career in another field.

1. Christoph Waltz €“ Inglorious Basterds

Landa In the movie business, big names tend to sell big films. Though one might say that this doesn€™t apply to Quentin Tarantino to the same degree €“ after all, the man does make a concerted point out off resurrecting dead careers €“ his films have always come stacked with big names. Reservoir Dogs had Harvey Keitel, Pulp Fiction had Bruce Willis, Jackie Brown had Robert Di Nero, Kill Bill had Lucy Liu (and Uma Thurman again, I guess), Death Proof had Kurt Russell, Inglorious Basterds had Brad Pitt and Django Unchained had Leonardo Di Caprio, proving that while Quentin does stack his deck with genre actors, he still keeps aces in the pack. But what was remarkable about Inglorious Basterds was that though it had the pull of Pitt, the pivot around which the whole plot was based was a different character entirely €“ Hans Landa. Tarantino has said that Landa represented the most impossible part he€™s ever cast €“ a suave German, French, Italian and English speaker capable of great menace and charm, the specifications trimmed down the CV herd to a practically non-existent level. After Leonardo DiCaprio (who Tarantino originally had in mind for the part) couldn€™t take the role, even coming-into-form Michael Fassbender was rejected for €˜not being f**kin€™ German enough€™ (technically untrue, the man€™s half-German). It looked like he might have to scrap the juicy part, but then, enter Christoph Waltz. Amazingly, the guy was only starring in Austrian soaps before picking the role as the lynchpin of a Tarantino film, a rise to prominence both amazing and staggering. Yet what was even more insane was that Waltz wasn€™t just good in the part, he killed in it (metaphorically and literally(. The man picked up an Oscar, thus proving that perhaps when the next British blockbuster roles around, perhaps we should eschew the A-List and go straight to Eastenders. Agree or disagree? Can you think of any more? Feel free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

Durham University graduate and qualified sports journalist. Very good at sitting down and watching things. Can multi-task this with playing computer games. Football Manager addict who has taken Shrewsbury Town to the summit of the Premier League. You can follow me at @Ed_OwenUK, if you like ramblings about Newcastle United and A Place in the Sun. If you don't, I don't know what I can do for you.