10 Phenomenally Talented Actors Who Have Never Won Oscars

It's the highest stamp of approval that lasts an entire career, yet these ten acting greats don't have a golden statue decorating their house.

The Oscar nominees have been the talk of the town for the past few weeks. Coming off the momentum of his Golden Globe win for The Wolf of Wall Street, could this finally be the year for Leonardo DiCaprio? He's been nominated by the Academy three times (Gilbert Grape, The Aviator, and Blood Diamond) to no avail. He even entered the race in 2004 with a Golden Globe win for his portrayal of Howard Hughes, another Martin Scorsese effort. The Academy Awards are a funny thing, though, aren't they? I mean, don't they just seem kind of silly? I know it's not exactly original of me to point out the absurdity of the film industry gathering together for a night of self-congratulation, but there's something else about it... People can't stop talking about it. The Oscars have poised themselves in a way that, even though we all know they don't matter, they totally matter. If they were so superfluous, why do we debate whether or not CGI heavy movies should even be eligible for Best Cinematography? Do they deserve the recognition? Their own category? Of course, the main attractions for the event are the stars. Part fashion show, another part inner-industry back-patting, most people tune into the Academy Awards for the glamour of it all. But a win is another thing: It's the highest stamp of approval that lasts an entire career. These sort of high-stakes decisions often leave film fans divided, taking to the message boards for healthy doses of "They got robbed!" and "her?!" Now, allow me to do just that. But I will say 10 is a very low number for this category and I wish I could've included many more and maybe should be on here if I'd be slightly more objective in my decisions. Some people on the ensuing list haven't only not won, but not even been nominated. One in particular hasn't been nominated for anything or had his name on the Walk of Fame. With that air cleared, I invite you to leave your own favourite Oscar-less actors in the comments.

10. Jim Carrey

Based on what I just read on the IMDB message boards, Jim Carrey needs Tarantino to resurrect him. After his NRA themed Funny or Die and coming out against the violence in Kick-Ass 2, people seem to have a lot of vitriol towards the man. I'm not here to speculate on how much his views on gun control have affected him professionally or on his mental state. All I know is Carrey has done some impressive work in his career. Maybe it's not consistent, but hell even Bill Murray had a couple of Garfields. Despite Jim Carrey first garnering a lot of attention for (literally) speaking out of his rear, there are some real performances of breadth and weight in his portfolio. As much as I appreciate the dark and tragic way he portrays The Cable Guy, his turn as Truman Burbank in 1997's The Truman Show, was his first real statement as a serious actor. Even though the role won him his first Golden Globe, Carrey wasn't nominated for an Academy Award. His next role to win him a Golden Globe nomination was 1999's Man on the Moon in which he humanised performance artist Andy Kaufman. Still, when it came time for Oscar nominations, Carrey didn't receive any recognition. After another dramatic turn in 2001's misunderstood The Majestic and the highly successful Bruce Almighty, Carrey tackled the role of Joel Barish in Michel Gondry's Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, written by Charlie Kaufman. With Bill Murray fresh off his Oscar win for Lost in Translation, it seemed that if there ever were a time for Jim Carrey to even be nominated, this was it. It was not. Fast forward to 2009, with his career beginning to quiet a bit commercially, I Love You, Phillip Morris slides into release just under the radar. In this true story, Carrey plays conman Steven Russell, who - after discovering his homosexuality - quits his safe job in produce, leaves his wife and kids, and moves to Florida to start playing the field. Floundering financially in his attempt to keep up with his lifestyle, he turns to fraud and finds himself in jail. The film chronicles his many successful escapes as well as his love interest with fellow inmate Phillip Morris (Ewan McGregor). As an actor, Carrey hits every note and gets to showcase his talents from broad humor to subtle drama in a way almost no role has provided before. His performance in this film is almost so perfect, the fact so few have seen it almost overshadows all lack of Academy consideration.

9. Sigourney Weaver

To ask a rhetorical question: Who doesn't love Sigourney Weaver? Her breakout role as Ripley in 1979's Alien was crucial in conveying the story in an engaging way. Five years later, her improvised banter with Bill Murray would be immortalised in Ghostbusters, showing the first glimpses of her comedic chops. It wasn't until James Cameron's 1986 Aliens that she was nominated for her first Oscar, the winner that year being Marlee Matlin for her portrayal of Sara Norman in Children of a Lesser God. In 1988, Weaver found herself nominated for two Oscars: Best Supporting Actress (Working Girl) and Best Actress for her role as Dian Fossey in Gorillas in the Mist. Up until that year, every actor or actress nominated for two Academy Awards in the same year had won one. Sigourney Weaver would be the first not to win either. A decade later, she was nominated for a Best Supporting Actress Golden Globe for playing Janey Carver in The Ice Storm, a pensive Ang Lee film entirely neglected at the Oscars.

8. Samuel L. Jackson

In 1995, Samuel L. Jackson received a nomination for Best Supporting Actor in Pulp Fiction, but lost to Martin Landau, who won for portraying Bella Legosi in Tim Burton's forgotten Ed Wood. Watch the announcement on YouTube (you'll have to add insult to injury and search "Martin Landau acceptance speech"). You'll see Jackson, at the utterance of the first syllable that doesn't sound like "Samuel L. Jackson," express his displeasure with a bitter expletive. Later, he found himself nominated for a Golden Globe after working with Tarantino again in the underrated Jackie Brown. While it's currently streaming on Netflix this film should be revisited. Not to impugn his famous work in Pulp Fiction, but his performance of Ordell Robbie has a range that wasn't written into the character of Jules. There's a subtlety and attention to detail in the way he carries the Ordell character it's a pity the film seems dismissed, even by Tarantino fans.

7. Jeff Daniels

Known mostly for his broader performances in 1990's blockbusters, Jeff Daniels is a truly gifted dramatic actor. In 1985, he received a nomination for a Best Actor in a Comedy/Music Golden Globe for his first starring role in Woody Allen's The Purple Rose of Cairo. The next year, he was starring in Jonathan Demme's exciting romantic-comedy meets psychological thriller Something Wild for which he was also nominated for a Golden Globe. 1994 gave his popularity a boost with the releases of Speed and Dumb and Dumber, but it was in 1998 that Daniels gave a strong portrayal of Bill Johnson, a malt-shop owner in the fictional television town of Pleasantville who discovers a passion for painting. The performance is often overlooked as it's separate from the main plot of the story, but is certainly worth a second look. It wasn't until 2006 that Daniels found himself nominated for another Golden Globe, this time as Bernard Berkman in Noah Baumbach's extremely personal The Squid and the Whale. With a budget of just $1,500,000 and a runtime of only 82 minutes, The Squid and the Whale might seem a bit small for Oscar consideration, yet Baumbach was nominated for the screenplay, so why no Daniels? The Squid and the Whale is truly Daniels at his best: A bitter, jealous, and frustrated writer estranged from his more successful wife. The film examines the mind games divorced parents play with their children and former spouses, Daniels playing Berkman with a quiet, narcissistic rage that's ready to break. The role paved the way for a later stage of his career as an indie-film regular, but The Squid and the Whale was truly lightning in a bottle.

6. Laura Linney

Laura Linney's first substantial role (save for her part as Dr. Ross in Congo, which we can pretend never happened) was in 1997's Truman Show in which her performance, along with everyone else, was overshadowed by the "Jim Carrey-does-drama" hype of the time. Maybe not a truly "meaty" role, Truman Show gave Linney a chance of some range outside of "school teacher" and "good-looking scientist." Most probably know her from her role as overly-devoted sister in Love Actually, by 2003 she'd already been nominated for Best Actress for her turn in the 2000 indie-drama You Can Count On Me. In it, she plays a single mother whose life is thrown into upheaval when her younger brother returns home after a long absence. In 2005, she was nominated for her supporting role in Kinsey, but lost to Cate Blanchette's work in The Aviator (they really do love biopics). Linney was nominated one last time in 2008 for her work in The Savages, opposite Philip Seymour Hoffman. That year, the Oscar went to Marion Cotillard for Le Vie en Rose. But what is most criminally underrated in her body of work is her supporting role in 2005's Squid and the Whale, for which she wasn't even nominated. Still, this is an actress with plenty of fine work left to do and perhaps she will find herself giving an acceptance speech one of these days.

5. John C. Reilly

When John C. Reilly first made a name in Hollywood, he was commonly regarded as the next Gene Hackman. Appearing in dramas throughout the early 90's, his first leading role was as John in PT Anderson's debut film Hard Eight. Throughout the 90's, Reilly found steady work as a go-to character actor, breaking out mostly in PT Anderson's other two films of the decade: Boogie Nights and Magnolia. After turns in The Perfect Storm of Mike White's underrated The Good Girl, Reilly began a working relationship with Academy favorite Martin Scorsese. His first Scorsese film was Gangs of New York in 2002, but it was his role in Chicago that same year that earned him his only Oscar nomination ever. After appearing in Scorsese's The Aviator and Robert Altman's final film A Prairie Home Companion, Reilly's career took an odd left turn. In 2006, Reilly appeared in Talladega Nights, sparking a long working relationship with the Will Ferrell, Adam McKay and Judd Apatow camp. But this shift really isn't as odd as it seems at first glance. Reilly had always been a master-improviser, even in his dramatic roles. His character in Magnolia was created based almost entirely on improvisational experiments in which Reilly dressed up like a cop and was filmed by PT Anderson interacting with his environment and the people around him. A lot of the dialogue in the film came from these videos, and you can bet some of the other dialogue was improvised on set. Still, Reilly's comedic work is hardly "Oscar Bait." But between his brilliant work on Tim and Eric or his performance as Dewey Cox (in which he performs all the songs, even writing a few), he's still doing incredible, dramatic work. In 2011, he appeared opposite Tilda Swinton in the dark thriller We Need to Talk About Kevin. But the role to see, in which Reilly's performance provides a surprising amount of warmth, is the film Cyrus. In it, Reilly plays opposite Academy Award Winner Maris Tomei in a love triangle between her and her overly-attached adult son.

4. Amy Adams

Like DiCaprio, Amy Adams enters the Oscar race this year hot off a win for her role in American Hustle. The actress has been on a bit of a winning streak since her first collaboration with David O. Russell on 2010's The Fighter. Their most recent effort, the lauded American Hustle, is creating all the right kind of "Oscar Buzz" for its cast and crew. If she were to be recognized again, it would make five nominations without a single win. Her first nomination came in 2006 for her portrayal as Ashley in the low-budget Junebug. The recognition helped transition her from supporting television roles to films. In 2009, she was nominated for Doubt. Her third nomination coming in 2011 for her role as Charlene Fleming in The Fighter. With 2013 came another nomination for PT Anderson's The Master and Adams' subdued performance as Peggy Dodd, wife to burgeoning religious leader Lancaster Dodd, played by Phillip Seymour Hoffman. Opposite Hoffman's showy, charismatic leader, Adam's Peggy appears to just blend into the scenery. After multiple viewings, it becomes more apparent what she's doing with her eyes: casting skeptical glances towards Joaquin Phoenix's Freddy Quell and quietly pulling the strings of her supposed leader husband. The entire performance is an exercise in restraint.

3. Julianne Moore

After a career of small roles in film and television, Julianne Moore broke out in Robert Altman's acclaimed 1993 masterpiece Short Cuts. In it, she plays Marian Wyman, an oil-painter at odds with her husband and their boring relationship. In 1994, the cast won a special award at the Golden Globes for Best Ensemble. In 1998, she garnered nominations from both the Golden Globes and the Academy for her turn as Amber Wavves - estranged mother, drug addict, and porn star - in PT Anderson's Boogie Nights. The following year, she gave a wonderfully operatic performance as Linda Partridge in Anderson's next movie, Magnolia. Her next nomination came in 2000 for her role as Sarah Miles in the adaptation of Graham Greene's The End of the Affair, but her big year came in 2003, in which she was nominated twice: Best Actress in a Supporting Role for her part in The Hours and Best Lead Actress for Far From Heaven. Like Sigourney Weaver before her, Julianne Moore left that year empty-handed.

2. Joaquin Phoenix

Remember way back to my introduction when I called the Oscars "a little bit silly"? That was almost entirely with Joaquin Phoenix in mind. His not receiving a nomination for his work in Her (he was nominated for a Golden Globe) is a perfect indication of just how petty and political the awards circuit can be. The actor, who openly hates the press circuit, seems to have a penchant for burning bridges. That might just be what's so darn likable about him, though. In 2001, he was nominated for his role in Gladiator (which won Best Film). Half a decade later, he was nominated for his portrayal of Johnny Cash in the biopic Walk the Line. That year, he lost to another masterful actor portraying a historical figure: Philip Seymour Hoffman in Capote. After the Oscars that year, amidst all the publicity of his success, Phoenix "quit" acting to start a new career as a rapper. The Andy Kaufman-esque performance was documented and released as the mockumentary I'm Still Here. Again, Phoenix was incredibly committed, but all it really proved is that most people don't like the idea of a film where the joke is on them (have we learned nothing from Eyes Wide Shut?). His first film back was PT Anderson's The Master, in which he appeared as Freddy Quell, an 'Id' incarnate. The performance had a new power that Phoenix hadn't really displayed before, going deep into the character of Freddy Quell and creating a feeling of uncertainty as to what was going to come next. Again, he found himself nominated, but called the Oscar not just a "carrot," but "the worst-tasting carrot I've ever had in my whole life...I don't want this carrot." They must have listened, because he lost out to another biopic: Daniel Day-Lewis in Lincoln. He still has, hopefully, a long career ahead of him and maybe he will be recognised for his work by the Academy once more, but their relationship seems strained at best.

1. Phillip Baker Hall

You might not his name, but you certainly know his work. The embodiment of "Professional Character Actor," his credits include M*A*S*H, Say Anything..., Ghostbusters II, Cheers, The Rock, Seinfeld, The Truman Show, Rush Hour, Enemy of the State, Bruce Almighty, The West Wing, The Amityville Horror, Zodiac, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Modern Family, The Newsroom andArgo...plus many, many more. What you might also be unfamiliar with (apart from his name) are some of his large roles in films that really gave his talent a big enough outlet. The first role that really made me stand back and take notice of his dramatic talents beyond "There's that really great actor that's in everything", was his performance as Jimmy Gator in PT Anderson's 1999 epic Magnolia. In it, the consummate professional brings a humanity to a character who is almost entirely undeserving of the audience's pity on paper. His first major breakout, however, was as Richard Nixon in Robert Altman's Secret Honor in 1984. Hall was already 53 years old. Having a long career of stage acting in NYC under his belt before moving out to LA, Secret Honor was based on a one-man show Hall had been performing live. Altman attended a show and approached the playwrights about adapting it into a film. Reprising his role, Hall performs a condensed version of the live show entirely alone in a single room. And he just kills it. (Watch it on Hulu). Despite this powerhouse performance, it was more than a decade until he had another starring role. This time it was as the titular role in PT Anderson's debut Sydney (later renamed Hard Eight ). Again, Hall brings his inherent likability and meticulous professionalism to the character, finding each cadence in the dialogue. Here, he plays down as opposed to the theatricality of Secret Honor. The perfect example of his subtlety is during a game of craps when he encounters a young loud-mouth played by Philip Seymour Hoffman. Not only has Hall not even received a single Golden Globe or Academy Award nomination, his only official recognition has been for his ensemble work in Boogie Nights, Magnolia, and Argo. The man hasn't even received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, an honor so indiscriminate it's bestowed upon fictional characters (I'm looking at you, Kermit the Frog). Seriously. Can someone get this guy a life-time achievement award or at least his own flavor of Arizona Iced Tea? How about just a BAFTA? Is there no justice in the world? Won't somebody please think of the children?

Contributor
Contributor

While studying English and Philosophy at Rutgers University, Andrew worked as a constant contributor to the The Rutgers Review. After graduating in 2010, he began working as a free-lance writer and editor, providing his input to numerous areas including reviews for the New York Film Series, The Express-Times, and private script and story consulting. He is currently the Director of Film Studies at The Morris County Arts Workshop in New Jersey and publishes essays on the subject of film and television at his blog, The Zoetrope.