10 Planned Comic Book Movie Sequels (And What Happened)

The messy stories of how comic books' greatest franchises met their silver screen ends.

spider man 4 poster
Sony Pictures

You might be forgiven for thinking there are too many superhero films being made right now. The Marvel Cinematic Universe and the less-successful-but-still-trucking-along DC Extended Universe are keeping the market saturated so that audiences have always got something new to look forward to.

But this wasn’t always the case - the superhero zeitgeist only really began with The Avengers, and before that, superhero films were a risky prospect that led to a lot of cancellations of beloved franchises.

If things had been different, we could have had far more sequels, for better or worse, with some even getting into the planning stages before they were cancelled...

10. Green Lantern 2

Green Lantern Corps
Warner Bros.

The Planned Sequel

Green Lantern 2 was intended to feature the legendary Lantern villain Sinestro and the Yellow power rings. In the original film, Sinestro suggested the forging of the yellow ring from Parallax's essence of fear, but protagonist Hal Jordan argued it would corrupt the wearer.

This is exactly what happened in the end-credits scene, where Sinestro puts on the ring. The film was meant to be the second of a trilogy that would begin a new DC franchise akin to the MCU, but the plans didn't last for long.

What Happened?

The original film was sadly cursed with setbacks and delays in pre-production, and various directors, including Quentin Tarantino, were picked up and dropped before it started filming; the film was doomed to fail.

The high expectations for the original’s box office led Warner Bros. to scrap the planned sequel after barely making back its budget, and the slating it got from critics dashed any hopes for the story to continue. However, in 2015 DC announced a new Green Lantern film called Green Lantern Corps, which is set to debut in 2020!


9. Tim Burton's Batman 3

Batman Keaton Batmobile
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Planned Sequel

The Christopher Reeve Superman films can be thanked for making superheroes work on the silver screen, but it was Tim Burton’s edgy Batman films that really showed the artistic potential of the genre. The Gotham look of Burton’s Batmans are still iconic today, and both of the films were critical and box office darlings.

Everything was looking good for the trilogy to be rounded out with a third film that featured Robin Williams as The Riddler - an unusual casting choice, to be sure - while Billy Dee Williams would reprise his role as Harvey Dent to become Two-Face.

There were even rumours that The Scarecrow would be involved, and Michelle Pfeiffer would have returned as Catwoman once again. Plot details were never shared, but considering the ideas were later used in Batman Forever, the story may have had a similar premise.

What Happened?

With hindsight, three villains may have been too many, but there was a mixed reception to Batman Returns' violence, leading to a drop-off in toy sales. Warner Bros. then decided that the franchise needed a lighter tone, and greenlit the disastrous Batman Forever, still featuring The Riddler and Two-Face, but without the edge.

Later, the franchise would be put on ice (Mr. Freeze would be proud) completely after Batman & Robin, which many consider to be one of the worst films ever made, and Tim Burton's dream of a darker Batman with the Scarecrow and Two-Face wouldn't be realised until Chris Nolan stepped in years later with


8. Silver Surfer

Rise Of The Silver Surfer Poster
20th Century Fox

The Planned Sequel

Before the steaming pile that was the Fantastic Four reboot in 2015, 20th Century Fox had almost made a Fantastic Four franchise work with 2 movies in the mid 2000s. After Sam Raimi’s incredibly popular Spider-Man films and Fox’s own badass X-Men movies, it was hoped that Fox could make another one of Marvel’s other iconic properties work on the big screen.

Silver Surfer was meant to be a spin-off from the main series, and would answer lingering questions about the mysterious alien, like how he survived the encounter with Galactus in the post-credits scene for Rise of the Silver Surfer (you thought Marvel only started doing post-credits scenes recently?).

Actor Doug Jones was intended to reprise his role as the Silver Surfer, but very little is known about the full plot details - aside from the appearance of Galactus, confirmed by the post-credits scene.

What Happened?

If Rise of the Silver Surfer had succeeded, then with the Fox-Disney merge today, we might have had the iconic character appearing to fight Thanos, but reviews for the Fantastic Four movies were negative, and the box office let Fox down.

Rise of the Silver Surfer even made less money than the original film, and to avoid any more downwards trending, Fox axed the Surfer's spin-off before it got anywhere.


7. Superman V

Superman Fire
Warner Bros

The Planned Sequel

The 1978 Superman film is, simply, great. If you can look past the campy Lex Luthor and that whole spinning-the-world-backwards-to-reverse-time, it’s a really great movie, and helped kickstart the superhero movie’s popularity in Hollywood.

The sequels continued the story for four films, and Superman V was on the cards for a while. There’s conflicting reports on what the film was meant to include, but Brainiac was definitely meant to be a part. One draft says he would shrink Metropolis down and fight a micro-sized Superman, while another had Superman die and be resurrected in the shrunken, preserved Krypton city of Kandor.

(Fun fact: the death and rebirth of Superman was unheard of in the comics before this; the infamous Death of Superman arc happened years after Superman V was cancelled due to the poor reviews of its previous two films.)

What Happened?

It was the Superman sequels that ended up causing the film's cancellation. They had gotten progressively worse and worse - the Rotten Tomatoes score for the original was 94%, and the fourth film at an abysmal 12%. Ouch.

The box office records were failing, too - after a huge $300 million on the original's $55 million budget, Superman IV couldn't even make back its cost at $15.6 million gross on a $17 million budget. It took almost another 20 years before production companies had the bravery to try giving the man of steel another go with Superman Returns.


6. Fantastic Four 3

Fantastic Four
Fox

The Planned Sequel

When Fantastic Four released in 2005, it was always intended to be a long franchise - the main four cast had signed a three-movie deal.

So, while the Fantastic Four themselves had committed to returning, Julian McMahon was also set to return as the legendary Dr. Doom for a third film, although no solid plot ideas ever materialised.

Interestingly, though, Djimon Hounsou, who you should now know as Korath the Pursuer from Guardians of the Galaxy and the upcoming Captain Marvel, was slated to introduce the Black Panther to film audiences, over 8 years before T’Challa’s first appearance in the MCU.

What Happened?

Like the Silver Surfer standalone, Fox believed that the Fantastic Four franchise could carry itself into a much longer series, like X-Men, but similarly to Silver Surfer, it was the previous film’s bad box office performance that halted its production, as well as the blasting it received from critics.

Rise of the Silver Surfer was even nominated for two Razzie awards, in "Worst Actress" for Jessica Alba and "Worst Screen Couple" for Alba and Ioan Gruffudd, and that might not have been too encouraging for Fox.


5. X-Men Origins: Magneto

X-Men The Last Stand Magneto
20th Century Fox

The Planned Sequel

It was another failed Fox project - an origin story focused on Magneto. With Magneto as one of the all-time greatest comic book villains, this movie could have been amazing.

Pitched as “X-Men meets The Pianist”, the film would have shown Magneto and Xavier becoming friends before their relationship fell apart due to their different views of humanity. Ideas were thrown about for using CGI to 'de-age' Sir Ian McKellen so that he could still portray a young Magneto, and seeing him and Patrick Stewart flex their acting muscles in a more dramatic and less action-packed film could have been epic.

What Happened?

The X-Men series was going strong, after 2 great starting movies and one kinda-meh third film, but X-Men Origins: Wolverine was not the followup Fox wanted. The movie was clichéd and boring, and certainly wasn’t the big financial success they were betting on.

This, and a healthy dose of development hell, led to them deciding to scrap the planned sequel, and instead rework these ideas into the excellent X-Men: First Class - so it wasn't a complete loss!


4. Sinister Six

Spider Man Sinister Six
Marvel Comics

The Planned Sequel

Sony’s Amazing Spider-Man series could have been alright if only we didn’t have such amazing movies as Spider-Man 2 and Spider-Man: Homecoming to compare it to. And also if they hadn’t made The Lizard look like scaley Voldemort. Andrew Garfield wasn’t a bad Spider-Man, either... he was just outdone by Tom Holland in every way.

The Sinister Six were a group of Spidey’s greatest villains, often lead by Doc Ock, but in this pitch for an Amazing Spider-Man spin-off it was going to be a revived Norman Osborn bossing The Gentleman and The Vulture around to try and finally defeat Spider-Man.

No names were attached, except for the obvious Chris Cooper as Osborn and Andrew Garfield as the webslinger himself. But this really shows that Sony didn’t know what they were doing with the franchise - between this and Amazing 3’s plans to make Peter into a “mad scientist” who “brings Gwen Stacy back from the dead”? Yikes. Thank goodness Kevin Feige stepped in.

What Happened?

Both Sinister Six and The Amazing Spider-Man 3 had the go-ahead until Disney made a deal for Spider-Man in the MCU, and so both Amazing 3 and Sinister Six were cancelled.

Instead, the character would be collaborated on by top producers from Disney and Sony, and we now have the best iteration of Spider-Man yet with Civil War, Homecoming and Infinity War fleshing him and his world out more than Sony alone ever did.


3. Dredd 2

Dredd Karl Urban 2012
Lionsgate

The Planned Sequel

No, not the Sylvester Stallone movie - the badass low-budget Karl Urban flick. Dredd remains one of the most underrated comic book films ever, with the most faithful version of the character so far and some of the most stylish sequences in action film history.

In a genius move by writer Alex Garland, the protagonist is actually a trainee Judge, meaning there’s still a meaningful character arc on display without having to get Dredd to take his helmet off.

Garland had actually signed on for 3 Dredd scripts, with the followups set to continue exploring more of the Judge's crackdown on crime in Megacity One, and Karl Urban was set to appear in all three. Presumably, Olivia Thirlby (the psychic Judge Anderson) would have also returned to help Dredd, too.

But work on the sequels' scripts would have only begin progress once the original film's box office returns were finalised.

What Happened?

The producers said they would only greenlight sequels if it made a meager $50 million at the box office. Sadly, it barely broke $40m, and so the planned trilogy was tossed out, and all hopes of a sequel movie are still gone.

Luckily, there has been talk of a Dredd show being planned for streaming services, and screenwriter Alex Garland instead went on to make Ex Machina and Annihilation, two of the best sci-fi films of the decade. So it’s not all bad!


2. Hellboy 3

Hellboy Ron Perlman
Columbia Pictures

The Planned Sequel

Guillermo Del Toro has become a legendary name in modern fantasy cinema. Along with making one of the most critically adored movies of all time with Pan’s Labyrinth, he’s also made Blade II, Pacific Rim, Crimson Peak and Best Picture winner The Shape of Water.

Almost everything he touches seems to turn to gold, and the same went for his Hellboy films. Both movies were loved by fans and critics alike, and you really can’t get better casting for Hellboy than Ron Perlman.

After The Golden Army was a success, plans for a third film moved ahead. Bringing back the iconic Perlman and his supporting cast, the film was set to end the trilogy and wrap up any and all loose ends. It could have been a rare thing in comic book movies - a finale that feels natural, complete, and doesn't necessitate any more sequels.

What Happened?

But Del Toro was instead pulled towards making The Hobbit films. After working on them for nearly two years, he was suddenly kicked off for no clear reason. This was the perfect chance for him to finish his Hellboy trilogy, but unfortunately, producers weren’t interested, and Del Toro couldn’t find someone to finance the last film.

But if you still want your Hellboy fix, this year Lionsgate confirmed they’re rebooting the franchise with Stranger Things’ David Harbour as Hellboy and director Neil Marshall at the helm. Here’s hoping it lives up to Del Toro’s high standards.


1. Spider-Man 4

Spider Man 4
Marvel/Sony

The Planned Sequel

And not only 4, but 5 and 6 too. Sony greenlit 3 more Sam Raimi Spider-Man movies, even after the middling critical response to Spider-Man 3. It was instead the incredible box office results that convinced Sony to extend the franchise.

There were plans for The Lizard, Vulture, and more to be featured in the upcoming films, and without a doubt Gwen Stacey would have made an appearance to heighten the romantic tension between Peter and Mary Jane.

Truly the greatest loss of these films, though, was JK Simmons as J. Jonah Jameson and Rosemary Harris as Aunt May. Nobody has yet topped these legendary portrayals of the characters.

What Happened?

But even as work progressed on the 4th film, it suffered delay after delay, and Sony became impatient. With Iron Man and more of the Marvel characters showing that superhero films were the new hot trend, Sony wanted films soon, and The Dark Knight proved that audiences enjoyed a less light-hearted tone than Raimi was known for.

Eventually, Raimi left the projects and Sony decided to reboot the character with the Amazing Spider-Man films - something they had been considering doing even as he was formulating his plan to make Spider-Man 4.

It was a huge letdown that Raimi would never get a chance to redeem the missteps made by Spider-Man 3, but after Tom Holland donned the suit, it’s hard to want to go back - and with Avengers 4 and Spider-Man: Far From Home on the horizon, we’ve still got plenty of great stuff with the webslinger to come.


In this post: 
Spider-Man 4
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ben Trangmar hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.