10 Problems With The Avengers No One Wants To Admit

It's good, but it's far from perfect.

The Avengers is a critically acclaimed and financial masterpiece by most accounts, leaving many to feel that it is a flawless piece of cinema. It is the third highest grossing film of all time (without adjusting for inflation) and is part of the ever expanding MCU. It has received unparalleled levels of success in the comic book movie genre, and it is responsible for Hollywood's sudden infatuation with shared universes. The star studded cast of Robert Downey Jr., Samuel L. Jackson, Scarlett Johansson, Jeremy Renner, Chris Evans, Mark Ruffalo and countless others seemed to ensure that the film would be immaculate and nearly perfect. This is not quite the case. There are many issues which are not evident on the first viewing, but the more you watch it, the more you realise that there are a plethora of plot holes, poor plot choices or simply a lack of character development. It is easy to ignore these points because it was such a phenomenal film, and because comic book fans have waited a lifetime to see an event like this to be shown in cinemas. The accolades received by The Avengers are so high for a reason €“ it is a great film €“ but there are so many issues that we, as an audience, have chosen to willfully ignore because we don€™t want to take away the monumental achievement of the movie.

10. It Requires An Awful Lot Of Background Knowledge

Marvel released five films before The Avengers, introducing characters and plot devices, laying the groundwork which would culminate in this astonishing movie. This was a good thing to do, as it meant most people already had a rudimentary understanding of the concept of the shared universe and the characters that exist within it, as well as theoretically meaning that most of the plot devices had already been introduced. However, not everyone is as engrossed in the MCU as us comic book fans€“ average viewers would have been lost by many parts of the film. The first Thor film introduced the primary villain, and without seeing Captain America: The First Avenger you would have been completely lost as to what the tesseract is, why it is on earth and how it ended up in the hands of SHIELD. Iron Man 2 was pretty much a piece of required viewing as it introduced SHIELD, Black Widow and Nick Fury to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, as well as making Phil Coulson one of Marvel's most popular characters. Without seeing these films The Avengers makes very little sense, so it is hardly the most accesible of films for mainstream audiences.

9. It Takes A Good Hour To Heat Up

Considering the amount of time, effort and money that Marvel had invested in telling the background of characters through their own movies, as well as building up this overarching plot by weaving story points into different films, The Avengers takes quite a long time to get going. This is not to say that the first half of the film was unnecessary, but it was surprising that given the number of heroes involved, we did not really see any action until the Helicarrier was attacked midway through the film. This was the tipping point, and everything before this seemed pretty slow. We saw Iron Man fixing a pipe and flying around New York, and we saw a pretty underwhelming car chase, but most of the exciting scenes and iconic moments were from the final half - Agent Coulson€™s sacrifice, the Hulk battling the Chitauri and the iconic scene where the Avengers stand preparing to defend New York City all happen towards the end.

8. Hawkeye Felt Like An Added Bonus

Hawkeye is an amazing character, and Jeremy Renner has done an absolutely stellar job of bringing the character to life. That being said, it is hard to see him as anything more than a tag along in The Avengers. We€™d been €˜introduced€™ to the character in Thor €“ if you can call two minutes of pointing an arrow an introduction €“ but he isn€™t that important to the plot of The Avengers and his character was so underdeveloped that he felt like a highly paid extra compared to the rest of the superhero cast. He led the assault on SHIELD€™s Helicarrier, but that could have been done with anyone, it was simply more flamboyant to have it done with arrows and not bullets. There were attempts to give him and Black Widow a bit of character development, hinting at a romance, but this fundamentally failed to translate on screen - what was the bizarre "reminds me of Budapest" comment about? Nobody understood this line, and all it served to do was to tell us that these characters had a history, albeit one that none of the audience were aware of. This flaw looks set to be rectified in Age Of Ultron, with Hawkeye playing a major role in order to make up for his underwhelming position in The Avengers.

7. Coulson€™s Death Was Meaningless

The event that unified the Avengers was the untimely demise of SHIELD Agent Phil Coulson. Having featured in previous Marvel films, and clearly idolising Captain America, audiences were somewhat attached to Clark Gregg€™s character. When Loki€™s plan to divide the Avengers was nearly complete, Coulson took the biggest weapon he could find and shot Loki with it, however he was killed in this process. This was a heart-wrenching scene, and audiences were genuinely choked up by this heroic sacrifice. And then the Agents of SHIELD TV show happened. Coulson was revived with advanced technology under the orders of Nick Fury, and he is now the star of his very own TV show. This spin off struggled to find its feet at first, although it has improved with its second season, but the fact that Coulson did not really die completely negates his death and the unifying point of the movie. It has removed the emotion from a scene built on emotion.

6. The First Twenty Minutes Were Actually Pretty Bad

The underwhelming car chase, Hawkeye turning evil and Loki€™s arrival on earth all occured in the first twenty minutes. Loki€™s arrival and the conversion of Hawkeye are important plot points, but they did not need to happen in such a prolonged scene. Despite the long period of time that we spent in SHIELD€™s secretive laboratory, we did not actually learn much; we found out that the tesseract has cosmic powers that people on earth did not fully understand, and we found out that Doctor Erik Selvig from Thor was now doing work for SHIELD (who he had vehemently opposed in the Thor film). Considering the high level of expectation of this film, it is hard not to be disappointed by such a weak opening scene. After watching the film more than once, it becomes laborious and unnecessarily long - the introductory scene could have been five minutes in length, leaving more time for the Avengers to fight amongst themselves or for Loki€™s plan to come to fruition.

5. It Focuses On Iron Man... A Lot

Marvel initially wanted to leave out supporting cast members from individual films, but at the request of Robert Downey Jr. they included Gwyneth Paltrow€™s Pepper Potts in the movie. Downey€™s loyalty to his supporting cast is laudable, but it was a waste of time within the film - Pepper gave us a look of exasperation on her private jet and had a quick conversation with Coulson, but she was not in any way moving the plot along or adding anything to the experience. Downey is one of the biggest stars of the MCU - Iron Man is one of the most popular superheroes on the planet, and the actor has become so synonymous with Tony Stark that it's hard to imagine anyone else taking the role. This gave him some leverage in negotiations, and he capitalised on the star power that the role has given him. Iron Man was the focus of the film - he was at the centre of the promotional image, he saved New York from the Nuclear Weapon, he stops the Helicarier from falling out of flight (you get the picture). By concentrating so much attention on Iron Man other characters, like Hawkeye and Captain America, were neglected in terms of character development and action scenes. The film originally had parts looking at how Cap dealt with modern life - these were cut to make room for the the flamboyant billionaire, philanthropist and playboy. Iron Man is a great character, but did the film need to focus so much on a hero who had already received two films when all the other characters had only been given one?

4. There Is A Lot Of Exposition

Movies are meant to show us what is happening, not tell us. The Avengers completely ignores this. Rather than having Loki€™s plan come to fruition, and then have the Avengers react to Loki€™s bizarre attack, Tony Stark gave us an expositional speech as to what Loki was intending to do, and how the mismatched superhero team would have to combat it. Considering the amount of groundwork that went into this phenomenal film, with a number of individual films each introducing crucial characters and details, Marvel€™s blockbuster failed to really capitalise on the strong foundation that they had built. To add to this egregious sin, the exposition was not even that useful; we didn€™t fully understand the tesseract and we didn€™t really need to know Loki€™s plan before he put it into effect. Unlike other films with a lot of exposition (like Inception) the film was not enhanced by it, instead feeling like wasted time. This exposition distracts from the incredible story, amazing effects, and spectacular acting of the film. While it may not seem like the biggest of blights, it is one of the niggling issues that become increasingly irritating the more times you watch Marvel€™s phenomenal movie.

3. The Chitauri Were Weak Enemies

It is no secret that the Marvel Cinematic Universe has long suffered from weak villains €“ Whiplash, The Mandarin and Malekith have all been rather forgettable. Loki is the only adversary who has managed to really test the superheroes and to help him with this he recruited an army of alien invaders - surely these would test our mightiest heroes, right? These aliens, the Chitauri, turned out to be the weakest of all the foes in the MCU - they were easily defeated and never really posed a threat to the stars of the film - even Hawkeye and Black Widow, without superpowers, managed to defeat many of them. Granted there was a veritable smorgasbord of alien invaders, and the unrelenting pace with which they passed through the portal made them hard to control, but the Avengers were hardly fazed by these empty enemies. They were crushed quickly and without any extravagance - when the planet was meant to be at stake, fans expected the film to have a formidable foe, but were given timid villains who could be defeated with ease.

2. Why Did Banner Lose Control?

The suspense over how Banner keeps control of his beastly alter ego was built as soon as Mark Ruffalo was introduced in the film. He, and SHIELD, were clearly wary of what would happen should he get angry, and he constantly teases about his €˜secret€™ for keeping control. Tony Stark, with whom Banner now has a bit of a bromance going on, even attempted to provoke a reaction in a bid to understand how Banner kept his green beast under control. Midway through the film we finally saw the Hulk unleashed, attacking the Avengers and damaging the Hellicarrier. This was amazing and has become an iconic moment within the Marvel Cinematic Universe. This action packed scene was captivating and engaging, but it distracted from a pretty big issue - if Banner is always in control, then why did he lose it when things went awry? By the end of the film, he seemed to be fully in control of his body and mind again, riding a motorcycle to New York to battle the weak invaders, transforming at a whim. The Hulk is a hard character to bring to screen, and although the Avengers certainly gave us the best Hulk ever, this plot point simply does not make sense.

1. Black Widow Was Wasted

Black Widow is clearly a big part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. She€™s starred in Iron Man 2, Avengers Assemble, Captain America: The Winter Soldier and will return in Age Of Ultron. She isn€™t a miniscule throwaway character, and is clearly a strategic and tactical genius within the fictional universe. And yet, despite her many assets, she was pretty much wasted in The Avengers. Her character development went as far as an obscure reference to Budapest, and she was simply used as eye candy and a token female character in a male dominated film, rather to enhance the story or action scenes. She certainly was better used than Hawkeye, but that is not exactly a hard job given how much of an injustice the film was to Marvel€™s expert archer. The character was developed well in The Winter Soldier, where Scarlett Johansson gave the character a human element that has been missing from her previous portrayals of the Russian femme fatale. The Age Of Ultron trailer shows the ex-KGB agent getting close to Banner, and it looks like the film will continue her development during The Winter Soldier. It certainly seems as though Age Of Ultron will fix this injustice, but it remains a major issue with The Avengers. What did you think? Are there any issues that were missed? Let us know in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

A 21 year old History graduate looking for someone to listen to his ramblings. Lover of comic books, movies and all other superhero related things. Published in The Independent, always looking for interesting things to write about...Follow me on Twitter at @samclements1993, and check out my blog: http://samuelclements.wordpress.com/