10 Reasons That Prove Sylvester Stallone Is Underrated

Yo Adrian, he did it! Even if he doesn't get any of the credit he's due...

This month sees the release of Grudge Match, a film that pits The Raging Bull against The Italian Stallion. Had this film was made in the early eighties, it would break box office records, but in 2014 it has only grossed about $15,000,000 in the States so far, and the reviews have been mixed to negative and even the likes of Kevin Hart haven't brought in the younger dollar. Similar to 'Bullet in the Head' last year, the film is unfortunately another flop for Stallone in this age of super heroes, fantasy and indie hits. This isn't the full story though. Stallone's career has always had its ups and downs. In one way, his whole career is a Rocky Balboa story. Constantly fighting to be back on top when things are going against him. Also, in an age of Rotten Tomatoes, CinemaScore and Twitter, it seems bad word of mouth can spread quicker than ever. Is this fair though? Even when including the Best Oscar winning Rocky in 1976, has Stallone ever really gone after awards and kudos or is he simply a man, in an age of awards chasers, who simply wants to entertain us? In an age of vitriolic, online attacks against Stallone and his creaking action brethren, here are the ten reasons why he is underrated (spoilers included).

10. The Opening Of Cliffhanger

Many of Stallone's films have classic scenes - most Rocky fights or montages qualify, as does the brilliant silent showdown in Copland - but it's the opening to this, his early nineties action comeback, that can lay claim to not only being a great scene but also the start of the action hero admitting his weaknesses. The dramatic James Horner music soars above the shots of the aptly named Rocky Mountains (actually the Dolomites) as the camera closes in on Gabe Walker as he climbs a perilous overhang. So far, so indestructible hero. It's with the steel cable rescue of Hal and his girlfriend Sarah that events turn for the worst as her harness snaps and the only person that can save her from a 4000ft drop is Gabe but, in a horribly tense build, her hand slips from her glove and she falls to her death, staring up at her would-be rescuer. In the cinema at the time of release, the reaction was incredible: there were the expected gasps but, following that, there was the sound of people putting food on the floor, not able to eat anymore. It might sound silly now in a world a fallible heroes and dizzying special effects, but back then, the audience couldn't believe that Rambo had let an innocent fall to their death. Stallone, after a few years of bad flops like Rambo III, Oscar and Stop! Or My Mom Will Shoot not only came back with a great action film but also a classic opening that began to redefine not only his own career but that of the indestructible action hero. That alone should be saluted but many consign this film to 'Die Hard on a Mountain' and that's doing it a massive injustice.

9. He Writes And Directs

Many film-makers write and direct, and some actors do it too, and Stallone has regularly done it for years, since 1978 in fact with Paradise Alley. While you can perhaps look at some of the films he written and or directed as poor in comparison with a William Goldman or a Martin Scorsese but is he really aiming for the same audience? In terms of his directing duties, there's been four of the Rocky films, the four that grossed the most at the worldwide box office, and there was The Expendables, which ticked many boxes for the fans of eighties action cinema. And Stallone has also gathered screenwriting credits, and a good degree of acclaim for political trade union drama F.I.S.T, all three Expendables films and Jason Statham's recent Homefront. Admittedly, there have also been flops between the hits, including the ill-judged Saturday Night Fever sequel Staying Alive, Dolly Parton comedy Rhinestone and Rambo III, but which screenwriters can claim to have an unblemished copy book? The thing is, Stallone usually tries to write for a mainstream audience: his films are invariably fun, and always come with a commitment to engagement. Whether it's Rocky taking on Russian man-mountain Ivan Drago or punching Terry Funk through a window in Over The Top, he does at least try and play to an audience that wants to go to the cinema and switch off or a Friday night DVD with a takeaway. The Godfather films are perennial favourites among most cinephiles, but are they a good watch after a hard week at work? Probably not. Equally, Werner Herzog is great but you couldn't kick back and eat a pizza to Woyzeck. Stallone makes feel-good films for these moments, which is a fair old slice of the home box-office. Also, let's not forget, he was nominated for a Best Screenplay Oscar for Rocky too. Granted, we can't forgive him for Staying Alive, but still...

8. He's Not Afraid To Parody Himself

Granted, this is something that's come with age, and the earnest mumbling of Rambo II probably wouldn't suggest the banter with Schwarzenegger in Escape Plan or the meat punch joke in Grudge Match but Stallone has learnt to self-mock. It probably started with Tango & Cash, but the run of late eighties/early nineties flops probably helped Stallone with the realisation that the days of Rambo and Rocky taking on whole countries had passed. Demolition Man is probably the best example of this as he completely deconstructed his action persona by freezing his John Spartan for 36 years before thawing him out in a world where weapons are banned, vices are outlawed and the only way to can wipe your backside is with a shell (no, I don't want to think about it either). It's essentially an action comedy, something you'd never find Rambo in and Spartan must find his way around this brave new world by destroying things in his clunky, 1996 ways. Later examples include various animated voice-overs and, most obviously, in The Expendables series, which completely parodies the careers of all those involved either through action set-pieces or by (admittedly clunkily) inserting dialogue from earlier action franchises. If nothing else though, Stallone can laugh at himself now and his career is the better for it.

7. He Admits His Mistakes

On the UK promotional tour for Rocky Balboa, Stallone was asked about Rocky V to which he replied that it was a mistake and that Rocky needed a proper send-off. That was so refreshing to hear from a man who was a Hollywood money-printing machine in the eighties. He knew the film didn't work and he wanted to do something about it for his best loved character. He even admitted that he was 'greedy' when returning to Philadelphia...
"I'm greedy €“ what can I tell you? It was a mistake because the audience didn't want to see the downside of the character. They wanted him to remain on top. I should have known that."
He's also admitted to making "some truly awful movies" such as forays into comedies and musicals. It's fair to say that many big stars, who don't need to make money to put on the table, ever set out to make a movie they don't care about, but maybe they do get lazy. Stallone admits this. Also, want to know what he considers his worst movie? "'Stop! Or my Mom Will Shoot' was the worst. If you ever want someone to confess to murder, just make him or her sit through that film. They will confess to anything after 15 minutes." Harsh words but I'm sure Golden Girl Estelle Getty could give as good as she got.

6. Copland

This film came out of left-field for all those that forgot that Stallone could act. James Mangold assembled a brilliant, seventies tinged cast of actors and needed a "soft, vulnerable guy". When he was presented with Stallone, he didn't want Judge Dredd in his film. What's great is that Mangold, still new in Hollywood and many years away from franchise blockbusters like The Wolverine laid down a series of rules to Stallone, "(don't) take control... (don't) change it... and get fat". Stallone agreed to all three and turned in one of the best performances of his career. Essentially a western character, Stallone's half-deaf, overweight Freddie Heflin is the sheriff of Garrison, or Copland, a safe haven for New York cops to live, where corruption and bribery has created a lawless community. Freddie is a laughing stock to bullying cops including Harvey Keitel's Ray Donlan and Robert Patrick's Jack Rucker. It's only with the introduction of Robert de Niro's Internal Affairs officer Moe Tilden that Freddie finds a purpose as he aims to take down the corrupt cops. The film ends with a brilliant silent western gunfight. Freddie, deaf in both ears after a gun shot fired next to his head, appears at Donlan's house where he knows a murder will take place. In muffled silence we see Freddie take down the gang, and after Freddie shoots Donlan, he looks down as he fires obscenities back up at the overweight, deaf and injured lawman to which Heflin replies, "I can't hear you, Ray." It's a brilliant end to a film that surprised many.

5. The Expendables Films And Casts

This series of films, perhaps more than any other, show that Stallone simply wants to have a bit more fun now. Gone is the grimacing, tooth-pick chewing anti-hero of Cobra and in comes Barney Ross and his large gang of mates. Granted, similar to Grudge Match, these films would have been a far bigger deal in the eighties, or even the nineties. What we would have got then though would have been egos bashing against each other and no humour, but what we have in the noughties is a group of actors, most past their prime, coming together and simply wanting to entertain the masses. Looking at the films, the plots are never going to set the world on fire. Yes, Stallone does deserve praise for writing and directing crowd-pleasers, but all you have to do is look at Jean-Claude Van Damme's weak villain in the first sequel to see there are some missed opportunities. It is, however, an action franchise in a super-hero age of spandex and CGI, which isn't afraid to give those that grew up in the 80's and 90's a chance to grin as Chuck Norris walks in slow motion or Stallone and Stone Cold brawl in the midst of a fire fight. These films are the ultimate Friday night DVD takeaway experience. Perhaps they're completely forgettable but when they're on, they tick all the boxes we need as we see action legends trade blows.

4. The Cult Classics

Again, not every film Stallone has made has been an instant hit, and indeed, some such as Avenging Angelo and the remake of Get Carter will never be looked at in this way. It's easy to forget now though that films such as The Terminator and Highlander were hardly cinematic favourites when first released though, and to that end, some of Stallone's cult classics deserve a hearty defence. Most bank holidays I enjoy watching Pele score a wonder goal (seven times in slow motion) as Ossie Ardiles makes a jinking run and Michael Caine puffs and pants all over the pitch with the 1981 Ipswich team in Escape To Victory. It's also great because we get to see Stallone in goal defending a penalty against a Nazi footballer. All this from an American actor who couldn't understand why he couldn't save the penalty and go up the other end and score the winner. And then there's Cobra: perhaps rightly maligned even now but it's a dark, nasty little film as Marion Cobretti, of the Zombie Squad, takes down the New Order of criminals who want to kill the weak in society. There's nothing subtle about this film and, okay, it's not actually that good, but it feels like a cheap seventies exploitation film and Stallone didn't really go there very often. Finally, Over the Top: how can you not love a film about a truck driving, arm wrestling championship guy called Lincoln Hawk? I love the premise. I love Robert Loggia being 'all evil and that'. I love the 'realistic' interviews at the championship. I love Bull Hurley. I love Terry Funk. And so should you.

3. In The PG-Age, He's Not Afraid To Make Adult Films

This is an interesting one because I don't just mean the eighties retro Expendables series or the OOT violence of Rambo, but rather an adult film like Rocky Balboa. Here's a movie that isn't afraid to discuss what it means to grow old. What it's like to be a spare part in society. How it feels to be a forgotten part of the history of a sport you were a champion in. Yes, it ticks all the Rocky boxes with training montages, inspirational speeches and a grandiose fight at the end, but it also shows a man who has been beaten down by life and fights to prove he can still be worth something. It's a theme Stallone appears to be wanting to investigate more with Grudge Match and even, to a point, Escape Plan. Again, we live in an age where to make films for the 'grey dollar' you have to cast Judi Dench and Penelope Wilton but, with complete respect to them, Stallone wants to make a very different sort of film for people who are ageing and, if nothing else, Stallone himself knows 'how hard life hits'.

2. First Blood

It's easy to forget, as John Rambo took down Vietnam, Afghanistan and Burma that he actually started as a quiet Vietnam War veteran that simply wanted to see an old friend as he passes through the small town of Hope in Washington State. When picked up by Brian Dennehy's sheriff as a drifter, Rambo decides that he won't be treated this way by the state and is promptly arrested for walking back into town. He is then bullied by the cops before a Vietnam flashback prompts a violent attack and escape from the police station. He is then chased into the mountains where he defends himself from the cops and the National Guard. Based on David Morrell's 1972 novel, this film might be less subtle than the book it's derived from, but it is still a stark reference point for how Vietnam veterans were treated and the small town bullying which is given to outsiders. Again, after various jungle and desert wars, seeing Rambo in the mountainous forests of British Columbia is great to see as he uses the environment to his advantage at every point. It also includes perhaps Stallone's finest moment as, weeping on the floor of the police station, he tells his ex-Colonel about the death of a friend in Vietnam. A moment that has scarred his memory for life.

1.The Rocky Films

This series of films is the obvious pinnacle of Stallone's career. In Rocky Balboa he created an everyman character we can all relate to. In the first film, he's a no-hoper who is given a once in a lifetime bout against the Heavyweight Champion of the World, Apollo Creed. To that end, inspired by the love of pet-shop counter worker Adrian, he goes the distance and shocks the world. Yes, the films got more 'over the top' as he took down Thunderlips (The Ultimate Male), Mr T and Ivan Drago but, more than any other films in his career, these movies are for warmth and entertainment. We cheer and support Rocky through each trial and tribulation, even those of his own making. Again, the part has become so indelibly linked with Stallone that many think they are one in the same but a Best Actor Nomination and films such as Copland put paid to an intelligent movie-maker who knows what he's doing. Each film takes a different premise, the fear of loss in Rocky III to the revenge style drama of Rocky IV, but every film allows the characters to grow. We see Adrian become a strong woman in the face of Paulie's descent into spiteful old age. Through it all, Rocky is the heart which keeps everyone going. Even Rocky V, the weakest of the series, has a strong end with a street-fight and the announcement that Rocky, 'loves almost everybody'. It's easy to disregard Stallone and his films. Again, he's not trying to be a Scorsese or a Tarantino. He's making films that will entertain us. What I love though is that, through entertaining us, he can still ask some very big questions which can really make us think. The fact that he's underrated perhaps is a good thing because, like Rocky, he knows, 'it ain't how hard you hit but how hard you get hit and keep moving forward. Keep moving forward'. Do you think Stallone receives more than his fair share of criticism? Share your opinions in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Suit. Wine. Sport. Stirred. Not shaken. Done. Writer at http://whatculture.com, http://www.tjrsports.com and http://www.tjrwrestling.com