10 Reasons Why Gladiator Is Still A Great Film
As we near the peak of awards season with the announcement of the Academy Award nominees later this week, I find myself plagued by a particularly potent case of Oscar fever. We cinephiles have a fickle relationship with the Academy Awards: on the one hand, we spend countless hours tracking the critics circles and guild awards, speculating which films will be nominated and eventually win, and of course, watching the ceremony in droves. But on the other hand, we can't seem to stop complaining about the results, particularly after the dust settles. Every year around this time, articles start cropping up listing the "most overrated Best Picture winners" - films that were huge smashes the year they were released and gathered enough support and momentum to eventually win Best Picture, only to go on to be all but forgotten in the years following their big win (in all honesty, does anyone actually remember Slumdog Millionaire anymore, or The Artist?) However, there is one film* that consistently shows up on such lists that I simply couldn't disagree with more: Gladiator, which won Best Picture at the 73rd Academy Award ceremony in 2001. Why is this film so derided? Perhaps people haven't seen it in a while, and are feeding off of the strong-voiced opinions of the film's detractors. Perhaps it's because other films from that year have proven themselves to be more culturally significant in the decade that has past since their release (films such as Requiem for a Dream and Memento - neither of which received Best Picture nominations that year). Whatever the reason, in this article I hope to try and change that opinion, burst the bubble of negativity, and maybe even convince one or two people to give the film another look, and hopefully see in it what I think makes it not only deserving of its Best Picture Oscar, but also one of the best films of our time. *another film that often appears on these lists is American Beauty, which in my opinion is actually the forgotten masterpiece of the 90's and one of the best films of all time. But that is a whole other article.
10. It Revived A Dead Genre
Nowadays, film studios seem almost exclusively invested in either young adult fantasy franchises or comic book properties. This may seem like a decidedly modern tendency. But back in the 1950's, the studios succumbed to trends as well. And one of the biggest, trendiest and most successful genres was the sword-and-sandals film: an historical epic often set in ancient Greece or Rome, or other ancient cultures. Only a select few of these films stood the test of time and remain beloved and relevant today - films such as Ben-Hur, and Spartacus. But in the period between 1955-1965, the studios produced hundreds of sword-and-sandal films, many of which cannot even be found today. As with the musical, the sword-and-sandals genre crumbled along with the Studio system in the mid to late 1960's, when the New Hollywood generation of filmmakers began to take over. Ridley Scott and Dreamworks took a huge risk trying to revive a genre that hadn't produced a notable film since the 60's. But the gamble paid off in spades, and Gladiator ended up joining the ranks of Unforgiven and Moulin Rouge!, both of which successfully revived genres that died in the 60's at the end of the Studio era as well. And what better sign of a successful genre revival other than inspiring subsequent films attempting to cash in...
9. It Inspired A Swath of Copycats
Not only did Gladiator revive a dead genre, but it inspired studios and filmmakers to make their own attempts at cashing in on the new sword-and-sandals craze. After Gladiator was released, ancient Rome (and Greece) became pop culturally relevant again, and nowhere was this more evident than in subsequent films from the past ten years. It seems clear that films such as Troy, 300, and the recent remake of Clash of the Titans (and its sequel) wouldn't exist had Gladiator not been released. But filmmakers were inspired by the film's visual style as well, as evident in subsequent historical epics such as King Arthur, and director Ridley Scott's own Kingdom of Heaven and Robin Hood, the latter of which particularly felt like a shameless attempt to recapture his past success. But the inspiration of Gladiator was not just felt in the film world. It is doubtful that the successful game series God of War would exist without the influence of Gladiator, and the television series Rome - not to mention the popular Spartacus series on the Starz network - would never have come to fruition had public interest in ancient Rome not been rekindled by Gladiator a few years prior.
8. It Has One Of The Best Film Scores Of All Time
Hans Zimmer is one of the most successful and popular film composers of our time, having provided memorable soundtracks to many contemporary films such as Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, Inception, and the Pirates of the Caribbean film series, among others. But I believe his best and most iconic work is from the 90's, starting from the stirring score for The Lion King (that won him his first and only Oscar) and culminating in his score for Gladiator, which is nothing short of a masterpiece. In the film's opening moments Zimmer, along with the unique voice of vocalist Lisa Gerrard, establishes themes and motifs that won't come full circle until the end of the film. After a brief intro, he segues directly into the heavy fanfare and infectious leitmotifs of the battle scene, reminiscent of the finest work of John Williams but with the unique Zimmer touch. Throughout the course of the film, Zimmer takes us on a journey through different cultures and peoples, but the iconic themes remain throughout. The instrumentations are thick and layered and the themes are rousing: As a stand-alone soundtrack, Gladiator is one of the most complete and encompassing ever recorded. It is absolutely possible to follow the progression of the film just by listening to the soundtrack album. And that says it all, really.
7. It Pushed The Boundaries of CGI technology
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is often credited as being the first film to truly successfully integrate both live action and CGI characters into environments comprised of live set components and CGI enhancements. But Gladiator did this a full year and a half before Fellowship of the Ring hit theatres - and quite successfully, I might add. The CGI by British post-production company The Mill holds up surprisingly well, even today. One of the most iconic shots is without a doubt the 360 degree entering the Colosseum scene, which was shot on a practical location that extended up to the top of the first level of seats. The rest of the structure was created entirely in CGI, but you would be hard-pressed to locate exactly where the transition occurs. Huge crowds were created with the help of CGI as well, and photo-realistic tigers that are impossible to tell apart from the live tigers used on set. But the most notable use of CGI is without a doubt the recreation of actor Oliver Reed, who tragically passed away before filming of his scenes for the film could be completed. Using a body double, archival footage of Reed and some CGI wizardry, an entire new scene with the actor was created after he had already passed away. Setting aside the moral implications of this, it was a major milestone that led to technology that would be used in Spider-Man, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, The Avengers, and many more.
6. It Is (Mostly) Historically Accurate
I will preface this entry by emphasizing that yes, it is difficult to call a film historically accurate when its main protagonist is a completely fictional character. True, there was no one Roman general named Maximus who was stripped of his rank and forced to become a gladiator only to work his way back into the heart of Rome and eventually seek vengeance against the now-emperor who betrayed him. However, Maximus is an amalgamation of several historical characters, including Narcissus (the gladiator who actually did end up murdering emperor Commodus) and Spartacus, who raised a slave revolt and also fought as a gladiator. That said, Scott and company set out with a clear mission to create the most historically accurate depiction of this period in history, certainly with more accuracy and attention to detail than any other previous films that took place in this period. Indeed, the political climate of the time - senators secretly calling for the reinstatement of the Republic against severe opposition from the emperors and their supporters - as well as little details such as the presence of female gladiators (a controversial choice in the film that does in fact have historical backing) help lend authenticity to the film's setting. Sure, much artistic license was taken to make scenes, settings and events appear more dramatic than they actually were, but this is inevitable when translating history (which tends to be rather dull and underwhelming) into a dramatic medium. All these details and more all contribute greatly to this next entry...
5. It Created A Truly Believable, Immersive World
Once again, The Lord of the Rings tends to take credit for something that Gladiator succeeded in doing well before those films came out (For the record, I don't mean to rag on The Lord of the Rings - they are amazing and groundbreaking films in their own right). Nowadays we have become quite accustomed to fully believing in CGI-enhanced environments that take us to different, exotic worlds. But back when Gladiator first came out, films set in that period had to rely on practical sets, none of which could truly capture the scope of something as grandiose as the ancient city of Rome at its peak. As a result, many of these films tended to look stagey, and very obviously filmed on soundstages and artificial sets. But with the advancement of new CGI technology, top-notch production design, computer-enabled digital color correction and other tools in his arsenal, Scott was able to open the film up, showing us vast cityscapes and environments that, together, succeeded creating one of the first truly immersive and believable nonexistent worlds - a tool that would subsequently become a staple of Blockbuster filmmaking.
4. It Has Incredible Action Sequences
Speaking of Blockbuster filmmaking, I think one thing people tend to overlook or forget when it comes to Gladiator is that it was released in May of 2000, kicking off the summer Blockbuster season. Many pundits complain that the Academy Awards too often ignore the action genre, and instead tend to reward boring historical dramas, a category to which many people seem to believe Gladiator belongs. But have we all forgotten that, at its core, Gladiator is an action film? And one of the best of the genre, at that! It starts off with a ten-minute battle scene on a massive scale, echoing imagery that we would later see in - yes, here it is again - The Lord of the Rings trilogy, among others. Subsequently we are treated to what are undoubtedly the best, bloodiest gladiatorial combat scenes ever filmed, from Maximus' first arena match ("Are you not entertained?") to the chariot battle to the iconic tiger fight. Sure, Gladiator spends a lot of time developing character and allowing its plot to unfold. But for extended stretches of time in the film, Scott puts all that aside and pulls an assortment of stylistic tricks out of his hat to craft some of the most riveting, exciting and brutal action scenes to grace a mainstream film.
3. It Tells A Timeless, Flawlessly Structured Story
That said, in between the action scenes Gladiator does tell a compelling character-driven human drama, and does a stellar job at doing so. This is one of the film's aspects that seems to get the most flak, but I can't for the life of me understand why. Sure, at its core Gladiator tells a revenge story the likes of which we have seen many times before. But it tells it so damn well, I fail to see what all the fuss is about! Structurally, Gladiator adheres to Joseph Campbell's Hero's Journey as strictly as Star Wars or Harry Potter did: The call to action, the elderly mentor (Oliver Reed's character), the false victory at the end of act II that is swiftly shut down, putting the protagonist in a place even lower than ever before (in Gladiator, Maximus is imprisoned) before launching into the third act climax. But by maximizing the stakes and the obstacles for the characters, Scott and screenwriter John Logan ensure that the most dramatically satisfying story unfolds before us. These elements are too often ignored in modern Blockbusters for the sake of spectacle and fan service - which is a shame, because they are essential for emotional investment in a film. Maximus isn't just some guy - he's a general, the star of the Roman army, and the poster child of emperor Marcus Aurelius. Commodus' betrayal is caused not by blind evil, but by jealousy - just one of the factors contributing to Commodus's status as one of the great cinematic villains of our time. Maximus is not just stripped of his rank and sold in the slave trade. No, his wife and child are brutally raped and murdered as well. We are dying for him to seek vengeance... and yet here he is, a slave, stuck in the middle of some godforsaken village in North Africa. There is no fat, no extraneous material or unnecessary scenes. Every single beat in the script is flawlessly planted to further the story and to maximize stakes and obstacles for the characters - and not a single beat is missed.
2. It Showcases Career-Best Performances From Its Cast
Gladiator also often receives criticism for being the film that won Russell Crowe his first and only acting Oscar. For a time in the late 90's and through the 2000's, Crowe was one of the most consistent actors working in the industry, delivering a string of successful and resonant performances in a variety of films. Sure, his performances in L.A. Confidential, Master & Commander, Cinderella Man, The Insider and A Beautiful Mind (the latter two also landing him Academy Award nominations) are phenomenal. But so was his performance in Gladiator! And I would argue that, in agreement with the Academy, I believe it is his finest performance to date, demonstrating more charisma, passion, emotion, as well as technical and physical skill than he has ever shown before or since. Although not his best performance, Joaquin Phoenix's villainous turn as Commodus certainly ranks among his best and most memorable. And fellow cast mates Connie Nielsen, Djimon Hounsou, Oliver Reed, and more have never been better. Rounded out by classical players including Derek Jacobi and Richard Harris, Gladiator features an impressive ensemble of familiar and less-familiar faces, all of whom do a phenomenal job of delivering both the emotional and physical content of the story.
1. They Don't Make Movies Like It Anymore
Thinking about it now, it really is amazing that a film like Gladiator was even produced at all, not to mention becoming the critical, box office and awards success that it was. Nowadays, the only films that gross around $500 million worldwide (the amount that Gladiator made) are PG-13-rated action-adventure films (often with built-in fan bases), PG-rated family films, or the occasional R-rated comedy. Gladiator is truly an anomaly: an action-adventure film for adults, with thrilling (and bloody) action set-pieces supporting a serious, complex dramatic narrative. It's sad to think that, if this film were to be made today and be expected to make the same amount of money that it did, it would undoubtedly turn out to be a watered-down, over-simplified PG-13 tentpole, with a thin, meaningless narrative supporting big action set-pieces - the exact opposite of what the film really is. I know there are some people who will remain unconvinced, and stand by their criticisms of the film. And if they saw it recently and still didn't like it, that's their prerogative - some people have trouble accepting melodrama as a legitimate form of storytelling, but I personally happen to find it riveting. So if it's not your cup of tea, I can't argue with that. But I can certainly hope that some of you will read these words and be inspired to give the film a second chance. I think you'll be really surprised with what you'll find. Do you agree with my assessment of Gladiator as an unfairly maligned modern classic? Or do you think I'm completely off the mark? Feel free to get the discussion going in the comments below!