10 Reasons Why Superman Isn't An Interesting Superhero
Superman is one of the most iconic creations in fictional history and easily the most well-known superhero around the world. He is DC Comics' flagship hero and is beloved by millions for being a shining beacon of all this is good and just in this world. Basically he is the embodiment of all that humans should strive to be. This always left me feeling perplexed when I was a kid after watching or reading anything Superman related. I knew he was this amazing creation and that he stood for all these great things but I just couldn't bring myself to care about him even in the slightest. Now that I've gotten older and more knowledgeable about the various Marvel and DC characters I've been able to figure out just why I find him so boring despite the fact that there is so much evidence against this. I want to state right off the bat that this is in no way shape or form an article meant to bash the Man of Steel. It is simply an analysis of him as a character and what makes him different than all of the other superheroes. In fact, you may find your love for him being reassured by my points here and that is perfectly OK. Superman is an iconic character who will be loved for generations to come, whether people find him boring or not, because he has already solidified his place in the pop culture canon. He is the ultimate representation of hope and perseverance in a state of crisis and I really respect him even if I don't get excited about anything he is involved in. Although, I am looking forward to Man of Steel because I think Nolan, Goyer and Snyder have created a version of the character that we haven't seen before. Also, anything with Amy Adams in it is a must see for me. But I digress. Read on for 10 reasons why Superman isn't an interesting superhero...
10. He Has Too Many Powers
This is probably the most common criticism I hear about the nature of Superman. It becomes increasingly more and more difficult to become engaged in him as a character when you know that he will never lose a battle or never even come close to losing. All of the greatest superheroes have some kind of disadvantage that is always plaguing them that lies just under the surface of every encounter they have. Superman is the only major superhero who doesn't have any handicaps. Let's recount the most known elements of his powers. He is a solar battery, he has superhuman strength, invulnerability, instant healing, flight, superhuman speed, X-ray vision, superhuman intelligence, eidetic memory, heat vision, superhuman breath, hearing and vision as well as being a master combatant. He is almost laughably over the top in some scenarios and this, ironically, gives him a very boring factor because there is never any suspense involved in his character.
9. When You Take His Powers Away He Turns Into Any Other Superhero
If you were to remove all of the powers I just mentioned in the last entry you know what you're left with? A regular person. What's interesting is that the majority of the major superheroes from Marvel and DC are normal people who must overcome their darkest fears and conflicts in order to become heroes. Superman was just born with it, which is basically a get out of jail free card in the comic book universe. The Man of Steel often comes across as dull because there is never a sense that he has earned anything. Batman, Iron man, Spider-Man, Thor, The Hulk and Captain America are so engaging because they each have a specific fear or obstacle that is central to their character. Seeing them overcome the trappings of their problems and fulfill their role as a hero helps an audience connect with them. Superman doesn't have the realization that his weapons are being used for evil, like Iron Man, or the duality of The Hulk. All of the other A-list heroes have paths that evolve them as characters which Superman is sharply lacking in.
8. He Isn't Relateable
I'm going to branch off from that last paragraph for this entry. Yes, Superman's parents were killed which leaves him an orphan on a foreign planet. This could be the start of a character who becomes an outsider thus making him becoming relateable to anyone who has ever felt like an outsider. Most iconic comic book heroes take the orphan route and use it to help readers relate to the characters in the way that I mentioned. The writers of the Batman comics use the death of his parents as a catalyst for the anti-hero nature he can embody, while Spider-Man is built as an allegory for adolescence. The nature of Superman being an alien offers many new and inventive ways in which a writer could build his character in interesting and unique ways. He could have to overcome his loneliness just like people have to everyday and realize that, in order to be a hero, he must first find that ability in himself before he can help others. That's my biggest problem with Superman. There is so much potential with his origin story to build a truly complex and relateable character. Instead all of the complexity is pushed to the side and instead he is just presented as this godlike savior with no human, relateable faults. I'm really hoping that Snyder corrects this with Man of Steel given that the trailers seem well on their way to taking this route.
7. He Has No Internal Conflict
Batman works so well because he is carefully built as a vengeful hero who is constantly having to keep from breaking his one rule of not killing anyone. The idea that he struggles with himself just as much as any of his enemies make the outcome of his victories all the more interesting because we get to see how they affect him on a deeper level. The endings to his stories are predictable and everyone knows he is going to win the fight. What's not predictable is how that specific outing will influence his character development. Superman doesn't have any of that. He is good therefore he does good things and at the end of the day he is good and will always be good. Batman is the hero we need but don't deserve because he saves the citizens of a city who don't understand him. Superman is the hero we have and take for granted because his character doesn't offer any analysis as to why he is a hero. The lack of any internal conflict mixed with the obvious outcomes of all of his battles make him extremely boring and overly repetitive.
6. His Story Arcs Are Too Predictable
Superman wins, good triumphs over evil. That's the greater moral to be taken from the majority of any Superman comic or movie. He punches things until they aren't evil anymore then he continues on just being good. Even when he is given an outcome to one of his stories that isn't predictable, like Lois Lane dying in the excellent Richard Donner Superman films, he still finds some way to save her. In that case it's reversing time, which enforces my earlier point about him being far too powerful to have any legitimate consequences to his actions. The best thing about The Dark Knight was the fact that Batman couldn't save Rachel Dawes. The same goes for Spider-Man when he inadvertently gets Gwen Stacy and Uncle Ben killed. Seeing them have to deal with the true repercussions of their actions makes for an infinitely more pleasing and human story. Once again, there is so much lying just under the surface to make Superman thought provoking that isn't explored. Just imagine a Superman story where he has to grapple with the fact that no matter how bad he wants to he can't save everyone. Seeing him actually have to choose who he is going to save adds a moral complexity to an otherwise bland character.
5. He Doesn't Represent Anything
All of the best superheroes have something behind their actions that they stand for. Captain America fights for the love of country and the innate goodness that people can display, Iron Man fights to stop his own inventions from being used in a way he never desired and Spider-Man begins a quest for vengeance that turns into a fight to protect his loved ones. Superman protects people because he is good and being good is the right thing to do. That's the most basic character trait in the book and is literally the essence of being a hero. If you're not fighting for the greater good you're a villain or an anti-hero. In this way Superman doesn't really stand for anything. He just kind of exists with no greater backing for his actions and this lends his stories a tone of boredom. Heroes are only interesting because they have motives that intricately connect with them as characters that influence why they do good deeds. If you skip the "why" of a story all you're left with is the "what" and that makes any story tonally inconsistent and boring.
4. He Has No Weaknesses
Another major factor that makes superheroes work as realized characters instead of one note ideas is their innate weaknesses. The audience can become invested in a character that has a crippling outside hindrance or an internal affair that plagues them. Superman has no weaknesses other than a rock that's located thousands of miles from Earth and in increasingly short supply. If you're a villain and you can't get your hands on this incredibly rare mineral then you have no chance at all of your grand, evil scheme resulting in a success. Kryptonite doesn't even fully cripple Superman's powers unless it's very close to him and even then it still doesn't physically hurt him enough to be a true weakness. Compare that to Thor who is still an incredibly overpowered superhero but also one who relies on his hammer for his power. Thor's weakness is also his greatest strength, which serves to keep him intriguing. Loki is very important to Thor's development as well. Superman needs a Loki to balance him out so he isn't just this un-stoppable godlike force of nature.
3. He Has No Personality
This one is a no brainer. Superman is the personification of everything nice and that's as far as his character development goes. Like I've mentioned before, he's good because it's just who he is. He has no character arc where he learns a lesson or has to go through a great loss to realize his full potential. Superman is just good all the time no matter what is happening to him or what the circumstances may be. It's this part of his character that is most alien. Yes, he isn't a human and shouldn't act like a human but he needs to have some link to humanity that presents a challenge he must go through in order to develop. He may be fun to watch in his movies but there is no deeper significance that keeps them lingering in your memory. Superman is too distant and too perfect to be a compelling hero.
2. There Are No Stakes In Any Of His Battles
This entry can be discussed in two ways. The first is the fact that Superman has no physical stakes in any of his battles but also no emotional or moral stakes to compliment that. Sure, it's a great deal of fun to watch things blow up in brilliantly choreographed set pieces but it rings hollow if there is no payoff emotionally. Whenever Superman has to defeat an enemy we already know he's going to win but the real question is what it will all mean for him to win? What will he have to sacrifice to win? The problem isn't that the audience knows the outcome of the battle. That much is a given. The hero has to win but it's why they have to win that is so exciting to watch. When Batman defeats The Joker he is proving the inherent goodness in humanity, which is something he fights to protect. He is also stopping The Joker from continuing his reign of terror because he has lost Rachel. This gives Bruce Wayne a moral stance in the fight as well as an emotional one. Whenever Superman fights Lex Luthor or Zod he is fighting to save the city because it's the right thing to do and he wants to save Lois. As I mentioned earlier, there are no stakes even if Lois is involved. If she dies he'll just reverse the Earth's rotation and still end up saving her. There are no stakes because we obviously know he's going to win but that excitement of why he has to win is missing. Superman has no grand moral stance or emotional affiliation to make his heroics anything other than hollow and predictable.
1. He Has No Enemies Who Are Worthy Of Him
The above mentioned Lex Luthor and Zod are easily Superman's most famous enemies and also infinitely weaker than he is. The idea of having the villain being weaker than the hero is a great one but not if the don't have a legitimate way to challenge the hero. For example, just about every villain that The Hulk ever faced paled in comparison to him but it was the nature of Bruce Banner as a character that kept those villains compelling. Banner was like a ticking time bomb whenever he wasn't The Hulk so in reality he was his own villain. Superman is not only the most overpowered being in existence but Lex Luthor is literally a normal, human man who has a lot of money and resources. His evil plans always involve destroying something major and when Superman arrives to thwart him there is always Kryptonite. Lex Luthor may have the brains to back up the brawn that he lacks but it doesn't matter because Superman has both. This all goes full circle because it reinforces my first point about Superman just being too powerful to make him an interesting superhero. Thanks so much for reading. I'd love to hear your thoughts and opinions in the comments.