10 Reasons Why The Bourne Legacy Sucks
10 reasons why Tony Gilroy's fourth Bourne film disappointed.
Having sat down in a chilly Central London screening room last night to soak in the fourth instalment of the Bourne franchise, The Bourne Legacy, I emerged unsurprised that the film wasn't a particularly satisfactory outing, and felt like an attempt to ape the style and sophistication of the previous Matt Damon-starring films. You can read my review of the film HERE. Feeling pretty vocal about the film's misgivings, I have concocted ten reasons below - some obvious to the sight unseen viewer, and some less so - as to why The Bourne Legacy was such a tremendous failure. 10. Jeremy Renner
While Jeremy Renner did indeed garner a Best Actor Academy Award nomination for his work as the protagonist of the Best Picture-winning The Hurt Locker, that film, for all of its propulsive action, focused on a subdued protagonist who didn't have to be charismatic. In fact, the opposite was true; Bigelow's sinewy action thriller won Academy honours because amid all of the warfare, it had subtle character inflexions, and an out-of-nowhere performance from Renner that demonstrated his fine acting chops. For Bourne, however, when you're going to inevitably be scrutinised against and compared to Matt Damon's fantastic portrayal, you need to in some measure live up to that. Unfortunately, Renner doesn't yet seem able to convince as a charismatic and sympathetic action star who audiences can get behind; he is the strong, silent type, which is fine for a brooding thriller - the type that director Gilroy would typically write for himself - but for a thriller that wants to be smart and exhilarating, the character needs more pep. Thus, when he eventually does spring into action, there's little emotional attachment to what is going on, because we cannot identify with such a thoroughly bland and characterless protagonist. He is a cutout that could be matched by most blockbuster leads; we are told he is stronger and smarter than everyone else, but the gravity of that is never really played out, though this admittedly is not Renner's fault alone. However, he has always seemed more comfortable as a supporting player - as in The Town and The Avengers - and so the first mistake the film made ultimately was casting someone who wasn't quite ready for this sort of blockbuster, lead star limelight. Who they could have cast instead, though, is anyone's guess...
9. It Won't Let Go Of Jason Bourne
I would not dare to criticise the film simply because it references Jason Bourne; that would be patently unfair given the mythology that we are steeped in at this point. He is the fixture upon which all else rests, and in wake of his departure, Bourne has left quite a mess, and indeed, quite a legacy. The problem is that every two minutes, the script makes references to Bourne's activities - with part of the film even taking place during his Waterloo station excursion from Ultimatum - and the shitstorm he and Pamela Landy caused last time. This is problematic because, simply, it's a lot more interesting than the plot Gilroy came up with for this film, and the constant reminders of how awesome Matt Damon was in the last three films only detracts from Renner's already middling screen presence. Just when there's a moment in which we feel like we're going to warm to Aaron Cross, Bourne is mentioned again, and we're pulled out of the picture. The feeling this approach invites is that Gilroy was not confident enough in Aaron Cross to simply reference Bourne at the beginning and then create a branched off, separate story about Operation Outcome. Rather predictably, Bourne is leaned on as a crutch, to give the film a false sense of credibility, and to - in vain - try and give it the same feel and continuity as the previous three films.
8. Where Is The Action?
The original Bourne trilogy is distinguished not only for its intelligent plot, but its scintillating action scenes, particularly in Paul Greengrass' latter two contributions to the franchise. Matt Damon also brought an incredible physicality to the role, enhancing the intensity of Greengrass' "shaky cam" direction. The expectation, of course, was that Legacy would follow suit, mixing an intelligent plot with visceral set-pieces, essentially pleasing both camps - those looking for a frenetic thriller, and those after a little food-for-thought.. Legacy, however, is largely bereft of action for its first two acts, and like too many action films, segments and compartmentalises the mayhem into small 30-second-or-so bite-sized chunks throughout. The opening hour is particularly frustrating, as it situates Cross in the wilderness, where he faces off against an unmanned fighter drone, shooting it down with a sniper rifle, but the scene is too sedentary and stoic; there is no sense of thrill to what is going on. While a fight against a wolf is convincingly choreographed, it's over in a heartbeat, and allows Cross to fake his death, keeping him out of the action arena for another long stretch of time. The vast majority of the money shots have been given away in the trailer, particularly the ridiculous scene in which Cross dives down a tiny alleyway and dispatches two guards who are chasing Rachel Weisz's Dr. Shearing. Again, though, this is one brief moment that doesn't get in the thrall of a chase; it is stifled, and just when it begins to feel exciting, it is over. To Gilroy's credit, he does save the best for the last, and the final chase sequence - which sees Cross and Shearing in a motorbike chase with a fellow pill-popping assassin - is quite excellent, but still not enough to compensate for the relatively action-free first two acts
7. The Plot
Perhaps it might have been easier to forgive the dearth of action if the plot were more involving, but it mostly recycles ideas from the previous films and expects them to work once again. With Jason Bourne having disassembled Operation Blackbriar at the end of The Bourne Ultimatum, we are told that there are more operations that the CIA need to close down as they attempt to keep their noses clean from media investigation. One such operation is Operation Outcome, and so to tie off the loose ends, all of the operatives are assassinated, except, of course, for Aaron Cross, who evades it and decides to enlist Dr. Shearing - who helped test the participants - to help expose the truth, and more specifically, keep his supply of pills going. Though the initial half of the film mostly composes of Cross' training exercises, and his avoiding assassination, this is all pretty generic thriller fare, and it's only once Cross makes it to the US that the story begins to take off. However, Cross never really makes an effort to go after Ed Norton's Eric Byer, and instead the bulk of the film's second half has him simply trying to track down a stash of pills so that he doesn't lose his mental acuity. Also, there are some rather absurd scientific plot points that strain credibility, such as Dr. Shearing's ability to "viral out" Cross, by means of injecting him with a virus that would "lock off" his mental aptitude at whatever level the pills had to-that-point elevated it to. During the film his physical abilities have already been locked off - as conveniently services the action scenes - but he needs to secure his cognitive function, or he'll not be of much use to anyone. The problem is that such a personal story does not work when we're not given a developed protagonist to root for, and a revenge story against Byer and the other stuffed shirts would likely have gone down easier. The political element, meanwhile, involving Byer and his cohorts trying to clean up their acts, is layered but ultimately contrived and poorly explained, mainly serving as a buffer between scenes to give Gilroy something to bounce Cross off of. When it finally gets to the more visceral elements of this operation, these also borrow from the last film especially, as another operative comes after Cross and Shearing, just as Paz and Desh came after Bourne and Parsons in Ultimatum. It just feels rather unimaginative and obvious, and right up to its ending, follows in the same tradition as the previous films, concluding with Cross and Shearing on a boat having escaped the bad guys for now, as a new mix of Moby's Extreme Ways hits. Part of the reason the plot seems so bloated and mundane is because...
6. Too. Much. Talking.
I am, like any good critic, not at all averse to wordy dialogues, but only if they are interesting and entertaining. However, Gilroy's script is only intermittently interesting at best, and eschews entertainment value frequently with overly verbose dialogues which drain the fun and intrigue out of the fraught situation that he is trying to create. What's really noticeable is an over-abundance of scenes in which characters stare at screens in rooms, talking to each other about the smaller details of Cross' movements. Though Gilroy does successfully depict the meticulous manner with which government agencies track persons of interest, it's only effective in as much as replicating the ennui it creates. Gilroy is a technical writer, but here he goes a little over the top; he indulges fully in some of the battier elements of his premise, relating to physically-enhanced super-soldiers, bombarding us with technical medical dialogue, which seems a tad over-the-top, and is likely to invite laughter rather than admiration. The prevailing feeling, however, is that this problem could have been remedied if the next issue had been a little more up to scratch...
5. Poor Editing
Though Gilroy's action scenes are edited well enough - despite lacking the flair of Greengrass' ones - it is the overall scope of the edit that feels unfussed and careless. With a running time of 135-minutes, the film feels excessively long, especially when considering the lengthy prologue portion, and the focus on verbose dialogue. Were the film a dense 135-minutes, this might not have come up, yet one can't help but think Legacy is slack and could have been easily trimmed back by a good half an hour. The opening section especially, which introduces us to a silent Cross for 15 minutes, and leaves him stranded on his own for a good deal longer, could have been contracted into no more than 30 minutes, making the main focus of the film his trip to the States to procure Shearing. At 105 minutes, the film would feel much tighter, and the lack of action in these opening portions might not seem so bad. One suspects this is because Gilroy is first and foremost a writer, not a director, and though Michael Clayton never felt overstuffed, his divisive Duplicity, which ran in at 125 minutes, certainly did. With his brother, John Gilroy, taking editing duties - and he also worked on the incredibly long Warrior - perhaps he is in need of a more judicious force in the editing room to make tough calls. Though frankly, there's a lot of airy silence and scenes of leaden dialogue that could have been trimmed entirely and made the film substantially more watchable. As it stands, 135-minutes is quite a sit, and if the film is merely not awful, that's not a particularly ringing endorsement to audiences.
4. Shoehorned Cameos
Joan Allen has been a thrilling presence in both the second and third Bourne films, and in Ultimatum, David Strathairn's appearance as the villainous Noah Vosen was also deliciously entertaining to watch. Albert Finney, as the key to Jason Bourne's condition, was meanwhile a vital part of wrapping up that story. That all three appear in Legacy for a total of less than one minute each, then - despite appearing prominently on posters and other advertising - gives it a very forced feel, as though to provide the film with a greater passing continuity with the previous film, and therefore a greater sense of credibility. But moreover, it feels crass given the film's trailers heavily implying that the characters of Pamela Landy and Noah Vosen would be figuring prominently in the fourth film; that they may as well have not even appeared at all makes it seem tacky and a calculated studio-orientated move. What would have made sense is to actually give them strong supporting roles; as familiar characters greatly immersed in the series thus far, they might have made the transition over to a new character slightly easier to take, though of course, there is the danger that they would just draw attention away from Cross, and right back to Jason Bourne.
3. Malnourished Love Story
While the previous Bourne films had a romantic element, with Jason Bourne ending up with Franka Potente's Marie before she was assassinated, it felt natural, owing to a certain relaxed chemistry between Potente and Matt Damon. While Legacy doesn't go overboard in this respect, it's the desperate insistence to hint at a romantic entanglement between Cross and Shearing that feels needless, with countless shots zooming in on their hands touching, not suggesting a certain emotional closeness given the extreme circumstances, but clearly something more, given that, at the end, they sail off together into the sunset. Though Weisz easily does the best job of anyone in the film, her relationship with Cross is mostly not pitched as a romance, such that the various hand touches seem awkwardly forced and almost laughably manipulative, because studios believe that we need this in our films, which, of course, we don't.
2. Misuse of Edward Norton
If you're going to cast an actor of Edward Norton's calibre in your film, you'd better have something interesting for him to do. In fact, one has to wonder what would entice Norton to take a role which would mostly see him standing in a brightly-lit room staring at surveillance footage and chewing out his subbordinates, other than perhaps an admiration for the franchise as a whole. Norton definitely gives his turn as antagonist Eric Byer a firm shot, but from the safety of his building, he's not a particularly threatening foe, and though Norton rinses the dialogue with his trademark cadence and inflexions, there's the feeling that he should have been given more to do, or the role should have been handed to a lesser actor. In fact, the character feels so minor in the scope of the story that it's not an immediate thought to label him the villain, and this is more Gilroy's fault than anything, as he has Cross spending most of the film searching for his precious pills. Though the likes of Noah Vosen rarely ventured beyond their offices in the previous films, they at least had an active engagement with the manhunt, whereas Byer seems to sit permanently in the sidelines.
1. No Paul Greengrass
And the prime factor why The Bourne Legacy failed? Paul Greengrass' absence. The British director is renowned for his stunning action direction, as well as his capability of handling more stoic, dialogue-driven scenes, and this certainly seems something he has trumped Gilroy on if this latest effort is anything to go by. The action doesn't feel anywhere near as in-your-face and intense, and the dialogues drag on beyond what is necessary, creating of it a slack experience that feels like a director not quite sure of what he is making, nor sure how to handle the mix of action and drama. With Greengrass balking at the project, he caused Matt Damon to leave, as their partnership indicated a certain stamp of approval unto one another, and with both departing, the project endured a severe credibility crisis that has been quite predictably resolved now that the film has been seen by critics, and will be unleashed upon audiences from August 13th. Do any of these points surprises you? And have you seen the film yet? Let us know if you agree or disagree once you have in the talkback below.