10 Recent Movie Twists That Fell Totally Flat

George Clooney's Batman left fans more confused than amused.

The Flash George Clooney
Warner Bros.

When they work, plot twists can elevate a good movie to greatness, leaving audiences genuinely surprised and eager to rewatch the film with new information in mind.

But when filmmakers get them wrong, they can ruin a whole damn movie, or even make a mediocre one damn-near unwatchable.

Basically, if you're going to deploy a game-changing twist in your film, you need to be really sure that it makes sense within the established logic of the story's world, and that it's not so blindingly obvious that viewers roll their eyes when the penny finally drops.

These 10 recent movies, for one reason or another, just didn't get it right, ensuring these "shock" reveals all landed with a damp thud.

Perhaps the twists were just too predictable, were motivated by cynical behind-the-scenes reasons, betrayed everything leading up to it, or left audiences unintentionally laughing their asses off.

Whatever the cause, these plot twists all fell totally flat, ensuring everyone wondered quite what those involved were thinking. How these twists made it through the script approval process and into major released movies is anyone's guess...

10. Barney Faked His Own Death - Expend4bles

Expendables 4 Sylvester Stallone
Lionsgate

There's somehow one thing worse than the utterly appalling visual effects throughout the fourth Expendables movie - that groan-worthy plot twist.

In the film's first major action sequence, Expendables leader Barney Ross (Sylvester Stallone) is seemingly killed by villain Rahmat (Iko Uwais), who shoots the heroes' plane down, leading Lee Christmas (Jason Statham) to discover Ross' smouldering corpse amid the flaming wreckage.

Christmas spends the rest of the film avenging Barney's death, but during the final confrontation with terrorist Ocelot (Andy GarcĂ­a), Ocelot is suddenly mowed down by Ross, who re-appears in a chopper, revealing that he faked his death the whole damn time.

It's an embarrassingly lame twist which was seemingly engineered solely to give Sylvester Stallone a reason to sit out most of the movie without killing him off for real, given that his screen time ends up totalling around 15 minutes, apparently due to creative differences with producers.

And beyond that, it's also revealed that Ross faked his death by switching places with a minor comic relief character, Jumbo Shrimp (Mike Moller), who didn't seem even remotely worthy of effectively being murdered by Ross. What a hero.

It's probably fitting that such a low-effort sequel comes complete with such a lousy, deeply inane twist.


9. Bailey, Quinn & Ethan Are The Killers - Scream VI

Scream VI
Paramount

Scream VI is a perfectly solid sequel for the most part - and certainly for the standards of most long-running horror franchises - yet it nevertheless falls apart when it comes time to reveal the movie's masked killers.

In the third act we learn that there are three Ghostfaces running around - Detective Bailey (Dermot Mulroney), his daughter Quinn (Liana Liberato) and son Ethan (Jack Champion) - who are avenging the death of prior killer Richie Kirsch (Jack Quaid), who was a member of their family.

The problem? The series has never been this predictable with its killer reveals. For starters, given that the new Ghostface is dropping classic Ghostface masks at every crime scene, the overwhelming likelihood is that a cop is the one doing it, with their easier access to such evidence.

And with the film's totally unconvincing attempts to paint FBI agent Kirby Reed (Hayden Panettiere) as a possible killer, it really only leaves Detective Bailey as the plausible ringleader.

Then there's Quinn, whose "death" scene earlier in the movie should immediately raise red flags with genre-savvy fans, considering that we don't actually see her be stabbed by Ghostface, but simply stumble out of her bedroom covered in blood. Lo and behold, she faked her own death.

Ethan is meanwhile the least predictable of the three, but given that he basically dips out of the movie after tending to Mindy (Jasmin Savoy Brown), it wasn't exactly a shocker either.

The ease with which the twist can be guessed coupled with the rather underwhelming, played-out revenge motive ensures that the movie basically just fizzles out in its third reel.


8. Anders Is The Bomber - Retribution

Retribution Matthew Modine
Lionsgate

Nobody would blame you for skipping out on Liam Neeson's most recent action-thriller dud Retribution, where he stars as Matt Turner, a financier who gets trapped in his car with his two children, as a caller informs him that the car will blow up if he attempts to get out.

The caller's digitally distorted voice makes it clear that audiences are in for a big reveal later on, and given that the only other major actor of note in the film is Matthew Modine, it's laughably easy for viewers to guess who might end up being the Big Bad.

Though the movie attempts to throw off suspicion by having Modine's character, Anders Muller, die in an apparent bombing, the fact that we don't see any sign of Muller's burning corpse, and the explosion happens just as a freight train conveniently passes by, makes it all immediately feel pretty fishy.

And so, when Muller unmasks in the film's climax to reveal that he was behind Turner's torment all along, it's met not with a gasp but a yawn.


7. Giselle Is Still Alive - Fast X

Fast X Gisele
Universal

Fast X certainly ended in head-scratching fashion, and not merely because of its jarring cliffhanger ending in which the lives of Dominic Toretto (Vin Diesel) and his son Little B (Leo Abelo Perry) are left hanging in the balance.

After that, the movie drops an additional twist which didn't quite land with the triumphant pomp the filmmakers clearly expected.

Letty (Michelle Rodriguez) and Cipher (Charlize Theron), who have spent the bulk of the film trapped in an Antarctic prison, are rescued via submarine by none other than a back-from-the-dead Gisele (Gal Gadot).

First and foremost, it's patently absurd that Gisele survived her brutal fall from a plane at the end of the sixth movie.

Along with prior character resurrections, it proves that this franchise has no interest at all in establishing life-or-death stakes or making mortality matter, ironically ensuring nobody watching actually believes that Dom or his son might die either.

And secondly, the movie vastly overestimated how much the audience cares about Gisele or Gal Gadot.

Sure, Gadot is objectively a high-profile actress, but her role in the franchise was never particularly interesting, nor does she possess the star wattage to muster much excitement about her return.

This invited more groans than applause, and was then totally upstaged by the more invigorating mid-credits reveal that Luke Hobbs (Dwayne Johnson) is also back in the mix.


6. Everything Is A Construct - Hypnotic

Hypnotic Ben Affleck
Relativity Media

Hypnotic revolves around Detective Danny Rourke (Ben Affleck), who is haunted by the disappearance of his seven-year-old daughter three years earlier, and follows an increasingly peculiar mystery which may unveil the truth of her whereabouts.

But the third act reveals that Rourke has actually been under a state of hypnosis for most of the movie.

Basically, Rourke isn't a detective, but had his and wife's memories wiped in order to protect their daughter - a powerful psychic who a government organisation, the Division, wishes to use as a weapon.

The events of the film have been a hypnotic construction created by the Division in an attempt to make him remember where he stashed his daughter before having his memory wiped.

It's an intriguing idea, if certainly highly derivative of Inception, Memento, Shutter Island, and countless other mind-bending thrillers, but beyond that, it totally falls apart on the execution front.

As the twist unfurls, we're shown the reality of the hypnotic exercise, where Rourke thought he was driving around in a car earlier in the film but was actually being driven around the Division facility in - wait for it - a golf cart.

It's absolutely impossible to take seriously, which wouldn't be a problem if the film at least had some awareness of its own absurdity. But alas, it clearly thinks it's a genuinely cerebral piece of work, which only makes it that much funnier.


5. Katherine Gets Dragged To Hell - The Exorcist: Believer

The Exorcist Believer
Universal

The most recent Exorcist film ends with a cruel twist intended to shock the audience with its devilish cleverness, but director David Gordon Green doesn't quite pull it off.

The movie revolves around two teenage girls, Angela (Lidya Jewett) and Katherine (Olivia O'Neill), who become demonically possessed all while their parents fight to save them.

In the climactic exorcism sequence, the demon asks the parents to choose one of the girls to live and the other to die, while a failure to choose will result in both dying.

At this point, Katherine's father Tony (Norbert Leo Butz) shouts that he chooses Katherine, causing Angela to start flatlining.

But after a moment, the demon reveals that the one chosen will die, not live, with Katherine being dragged to Hell while Angela rouses back to life.

It's clearly intended to be a clever, jolting rug-pull, yet given the inherent dishonesty of demonic entities, it never feels nearly as surprising as the filmmakers clearly thought it would.

That the film then ends with a weirdly hopeful, optimistic montage, despite an innocent child just being dragged to Hell, makes it feel that even more off-key.


4. Clifton Is The Killer - The Blackening

The Blackening
Lionsgate

The Blackening is a modestly entertaining horror film in which a group of Black friends are targeted by a masked killer.

The big twist reveals the killer to be one of the group, Clifton (Jermaine Fowler), who sought revenge against his "pals" due to them often doubting his level of "Blackness" in college.

That's all well and good, except the reveal was painfully obvious to anyone aware of the pervasive trope that villains aren't allowed to use iPhones in movies.

As Rian Johnson famously pointed out following the release of Knives Out, Apple is fiercely protective of its brand and won't allow movies or TV shows to have their products placed in the hands of antagonistic characters.

And so, early on in The Blackening, Clifton goes out of his way to mention that he owns an Android phone, much to his friends' disgust.

This seems like such an obvious indication that Clifton is the killer that viewers might assume they're being misdirected, but no, he really is the murderer. How disappointingly obvious.


3. Noah Gets Invited To Join G.I. Joe - Transformers: Rise Of The Beasts

Transformers Rise Of The Beasts GI Joe
Paramount

Few expected the most recent Transformers movie to have a plot twist to speak of - beyond, y'know, the possibility of it actually being good - but it nevertheless bamboozled audiences with a wildly unexpected final tease for coming attractions.

After the Terrorcon army is vanquished and the day is saved, human protagonist Noah Diaz (Anthony Ramos) goes to an interview for a security job.

Upon being offered the gig, the interviewer (Michael Kelly) hands Noah a business card while revealing a secret military facility concealed inside the building.

Noah then looks down at the card which reads "G.I. Joe." The End.

Hasbro and Paramount have been teasing a Transformers x G.I. Joe crossover for many, many years, enough that most surely assumed it would never come to pass, especially with all three G.I. Joe movies to date underperforming or outright flopping at the box office.

And so, while this tease was certainly a surprise, did it actually get many folks excited for what's to come? More than anything, it felt like a desperate attempt to boost the box office might of two ailing franchises by colliding them together.

And given that Rise of the Beasts was itself a commercial disappointment, there's absolutely no guarantee whatsoever that this crossover movie ever actually happens.


2. George Clooney's Bruce Wayne Shows Up - The Flash

The Flash George Clooney
Warner Bros.

It's no secret that The Flash was severely tinkered-with during post-production - it is a DCEU movie after all - and that's never more apparent than during the film's hilariously bizarre final scene.

After saving the day and saying farewell to his mother, Barry (Ezra Miller) returns to his timeline to witness his father Henry's (Ron Livingston) release from prison, and on the courthouse steps encounters Bruce Wayne.

Except, this Bruce Wayne isn't played by Ben Affleck as expected, nor even Michael Keaton - it's George freakin' Clooney from the Schumacherverse Batman movies, seemingly as a result of changes Barry made to the timeline.

In theory it's a fun subversion of expectations, to have Bruce now played by the least-popular Batman actor of all, but it ultimately just ended up confusing vast swaths of the audience.

Some were left assuming that this was intended to establish Clooney as the official Batman of James Gunn's upcoming rebooted DC Universe, while many debated whether the implication was that Barry was now banished to the Schumacherverse forever more.

If it was simply intended to be a cute wink-wink gag for the audience as the DCEU winds to a close, the twist categorically failed by inviting so much earnest speculation about its real meaning.

And finally, if you haven't seen it yet, MAJOR SPOILERS will follow for Five Nights at Freddy's...


1. Steve Is William Afton - Five Nights At Freddy's

Five Nights At Freddys Matthew Lillard
Universal

Even accepting that Five Nights at Freddy's is a horror movie made for teenagers, that final unmasking is some lazy-ass filmmaking.

Ever since the marketing rollout for the film began, fans have questioned the conspicuous absence of franchise villain William Afton, but let's be honest, who among us didn't peg Matthew Lillard as the twist villain from the first moment they saw him on screen?

Lillard plays a seemingly minor role in the film as Steve Raglan, the career counselor for troubled protagonist Mike Schmidt (Josh Hutcherson).

It's a suspiciously small part in fact, enough that it's blindingly obvious he'll be revealed as the real antagonist later on, and hell, why not make the horror icon William Afton himself?

That's of course precisely what happens, and while Lillard's clearly having fun with the part - he's one of the movie's few bright spots, even - basically zero attempt is made to make this reveal feel in any way surprising.


In this post: 
Scream VI
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.