10 Recent Movies That Grossly Overestimated What Their CGI Could Do

9. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Rogue One A Star Wars Story Leia
Lucasfilm

Rogue One is a mostly well-assembled addition to the Star Wars franchise with exciting set-pieces bolstered by terrific visual effects. Legendary VFX house Industrial Light and Magic fatally over-reached, however, when they ventured into creating digital likenesses of actors both young and dead.

Firstly, Peter Cushing's iconic villain Grand Moff Tarkin is resurrected by wrapping a CGI model around a stand-in actor's body, the result of which is distractingly obvious. Though most of Tarkin's scenes are shot in low-light conditions in an attempt to mask the seams, director Gareth Edwards' foolish preference for close-ups makes the conceit almost immediately unravel.

And then there's the movie's final shot: the glimpse of a younger Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) receiving the Death Star's plans. Though it's a mercifully brief moment, the tight, brightly-lit close-up makes the CGI's flaws woefully apparent: the uncanny appearance of the eyes and mouth in particular make this look like a soulless Leia puppet rather than the real deal.

Considering the leaps the Marvel Cinematic Universe has made in recent years with digital de-aging tech, it's pretty surprising they didn't just bring Carrie Fisher in for the scene, rather than paste her younger face over a stand-in actress.

Either way, these digital recreations were among the more divisive aspects of Rogue One, constantly pulling fans out of an otherwise entertaining prequel.

Advertisement
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.