10 Roles You Didn't Know Robin Williams Almost Played

In his long and brilliant career, there were some 'what if' moments...

The late Robin Williams was, as everyone knows, both a revolutionary, incendiary comic actor and a nuanced, thoughtful character actor. Making his name in the seventies and early eighties with madcap sitcom Mork & Mindy, Williams would go on to become one of the most loved stand-up comedians of the eighties and nineties, as well as an endearing €“ and enduring €“ face on the big screen. His breakthrough role in feature film came with Good Morning, Vietnam, a perfect showcase for both sides of his talent. It wasn€™t just his later years or his rehabilitation from drugs and booze that mellowed Williams sufficiently to begin getting meatier dramatic roles €“ he was a feted graduate of the acclaimed and exclusive advanced drama programme at the Juilliard School in New York, in the same year as his lifelong friend Christopher Reeve. A man never shy about admitting when his own failures had cost him dear (he worked it into so many stand-up routines that, over the years, he€™d refined the confessional into another of his manic skits), Williams was famous for losing almost as many high profile roles as he actually gained. Let€™s count down the characters that the Hollywood legend, one of the funniest men of all time, could have played if the stars were right€

10. Frank Ginsburg - Little Miss Sunshine

A role originally written for Bill Murray (who declined), the gentle, suicidal Frank was probably the standout and best role in this warm, highly acclaimed road movie. Made with a modest budget, the original studio executives on the film wanted a higher profile star to anchor Little Miss Sunshine and allow for a wider theatrical distribution. Directors Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris had already selected Steve Carell, based on a long conversation in which, despite their reservations as to his lack of appropriate experience (The Office and The 40 Year Old Virgin being in the future at that time), he€™d won them over with his take on the character, which was identical to their own. Despite this, studio executives continued putting pressure on the duo for greater star power, and Williams was the name that came up the most for the role of Frank, the gay literary scholar who€™d lost the love of his life. It was a role Williams could have sunk his teeth into, but instead Dayton and Faris won out and were allowed to proceed. Steve Carell would go on to do a wonderful job, cementing his status as a face to watch. In the meantime, Williams would do rather less well with another, similar project €“ the predictable and far broader road trip family comedy, RV.

9. Harvey Milk - Milk

An Oscar-winning role for the remarkable Sean Penn in 2008, the character of gay rights activist and politician Harvey Milk was one that Williams was actually attached to in 1991. A long time gestating, the project originally had Oliver Stone slated to write the screenplay, but not direct the movie. Duly delivering the script to Warner Bros. the following year, then titled €˜The Mayor Of Castro Street€™, Warner signed Gus Van Sant to direct and Robin Williams to play the part of Harvey Milk. It was a gutsy move, with heavyweight actors James Woods, Al Pacino and Daniel Day-Lewis also considered for the meaty role. In the end though, Van Sant would refuse to use the script, citing creative differences over the story€™s direction, and the screenplay would return to development hell. Given the lack of forward movement, Williams gently detached himself from the project and moved on. In the meantime, Van Sant, still pursuing making the movie using a different screenplay, eventually approached Penn for the role. Bryan Singer would attempt to kickstart using Stone€™s script for €˜The Mayor Of Castro Street€™, but momentum had gone, and with no star attached and the writers strike looming, Singer would admit defeat. There were those who didn€™t believe that Williams€™ reputation as a broader comic actor gelled with the role. Those people should have remembered his own Oscar-winning turn in Good Will Hunting a decade earlier.

8. Jonathan 'The Duke' Mardukas - Midnight Run

Another role that Williams lost to a less famous actor that the director preferred, Midnight Run would become a cult classic years after its release in cinemas in 1988, and is today justly regarded as the template for most buddy action movies. Williams really wanted the role, seeing the potential in starring opposite Robert De Niro in an action comedy by Martin Brest, the director of the hit Beverley Hills Cop. However, Brest had used the gifted comic actor Charles Grodin to assist De Niro in screen testing for the role, and had noticed that the two already had excellent chemistry together. Paramount dug their heels in, but Brest had developed the script and was adamant: he wanted Grodin. Paramount passed in the end, and Brest, Grodin and De Niro would proceed to make the movie with Universal instead, with fantastic results. Grodin and De Niro€™s partnership still stands the test of time today, and it€™s unclear whether Williams€™ manic streak could have been restrained sufficiently to do a similar job as the hangdog, deadpan Grodin. Fortunately, Williams would get to work with De Niro two years later in the heartwarming drama Awakenings, which would prove a critical hit, but not a commercial one.

7. Charlie Chaplin - Chaplin

Yet another case of the director being convinced that a lesser known actor was better for the role, Williams would lose out on one of the greatest missed opportunities of his career to future Hollywood megastar Robert Downey Jnr. While the studio pressured director Richard Attenborough to go with a familiar face, a tried and tested comic actor like Williams, Steven Martin or Billy Crystal, the seasoned filmmaker was convinced that the young Downey Jnr, already saddled with the reputation of a troubled genius, was the man for the role. Seeing the movie now, and how completely RDJ owns the role and the film, it€™s difficult to argue that Attenborough was wrong €“ he even looks like Chaplin, while Williams was probably already too old. Nonetheless, the role was completely down Williams€™ street, incorporating aspects of the clown onstage and off as Williams had made his name doing for the last decade. A cinematic curio now, the €˜what if€™ potential for a Charlie Chaplin played by Robin Williams is still massive, even today.

6. The Genie - Aladdin: The Return Of Jafar

Robin Williams had voiced the Genie in Disney€™s Aladdin to considerable critical and commercial success in 1992. The film would go on to become that year€™s biggest hit, raking in well over $700 million in cinemas worldwide, and win several awards for its soundtrack. Williams would make Aladdin for scale, as a thank you for the studio taking a chance on him in his breakout success, Good Morning Vietnam. This decision rested, however, on a gentleman€™s agreement that his name and image would not be used to market the movie, as his own movie Toys was due for release only a few weeks later. Williams felt that his role was a supporting one and that two €˜Robin Williams movies€™ being released around Christmas would have his audience hitting saturation point. Disney would back out of the deal in order to maximise the publicity on their own movie, and Williams €“ incredibly aggrieved €“ vowed never to work for them again. Toys would be a disaster, barely making half of its budget back, while Aladdin€™s straight to video sequel would be made using Dan €˜Homer Simpson€™ Castellaneta. Disney would, upon a change of management, issue a public apology to Williams and bury the hatchet sufficiently that he would return to play the Genie one more time with the third Aladdin movie, replacing Castellaneta€™s contribution, who had already completed voice work on the film by that point.

5. Rubeus Hagrid - Harry Potter Franchise

One of the major tussles in developing the Harry Potter franchise for the cinema was author J.K. Rowling€™s ideas about how the characters should be represented onscreen, and one of the few things she was adamant about was that the major characters be played, without exception, by British character actors. Rowling€™s insistence caused problems with studio Warner Bros, who were after name American actors to play the roles of Harry€™s teachers. In particular, Robin Williams had been earmarked for the role of the giant groundskeeper Hagrid. For his part, Williams had already noted several parts in the large supporting cast that he was very interested in playing, and was happy to include Hagrid as one of them. Only the writer€™s approval was needed: and Rowling refused to consider it, the role eventually going to another Rob, Robbie Coltrane, who would proceed to make it his own. We€™ve no doubt that Williams would have made a fantastic Hagrid and an even better Dumbledore, and there are plenty of other American actors who would have been equally good€ but it€™s a move of great integrity, and completely in character, for the by now very rich Rowling to want to support her own country€™s film industry in having her ideas and properties converted to film, even if it held back production of the films.

4. Adrian Cronauer - 'Good Morning, Chicago'

Williams€™ breakthrough film, Good Morning, Vietnam, was a massive success for him creatively and commercially, setting in stone the persona for which he would be most famous throughout the eighties and nineties €“ the maniac with the heart of gold. The film would make over ten times its budget at the box office, and win Williams a Golden Globe and an Oscar nomination. Naturally a sequel was considered. A script was drafted, this time set after the Vietnam war, in Chicago, set in and around the Democratic National Convention in 1968. The convention was famous for dividing the Democratic party in the USA at the time, coming only months after the assassination of both Martin Luther King and Presidential hopeful Robert F. Kennedy, JFK€™s younger brother. The Republican party would seize their moment, and Richard Nixon would win the resulting presidential election €“ and we all know how that turned out. All the elements seemed in place, but something about the script didn€™t gel. Reminded of it years later, Williams said:
€œPart of it worked, Part of it didn€™t work because it€™d be him dealing with the politics of revolt in Chicago at the time€ but anyway, they did do but it didn€™t all work. It was also a matter of trying to find someone to back it. It was almost there.€
Williams and director Barry Levinson elected to drop the project, and it never resurfaced again.

3. Willy Wonka - Charlie And The Chocolate Factory

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Arguably a role tailor-made for him, Tim Burton€™s adaptation of Roald Dahl€™s children€™s classic Charlie And The Chocolate Factory was at one point going to be a Robin Williams vehicle. Perhaps that€™s why it fell through and Johnny Depp would step in, yet again €“ Burton is famous for preferring the films he has a hand in to be Burton movies, and Burton movies alone. Depp was, as usual, Burton€™s first and only choice to play the role, and Burton was the only filmmaker that Dahl€™s estate were completely happy with to tackle the film. They had been delighted with his work on the adaptation of James And The Giant Peach (although Burton only produced the film €“ Henry Selick, the genius behind The Nightmare Before Christmas and Coraline, directed). Given Burton€™s preferred status, as soon as he became attached to the project every other actor considered for the role was off it. A private man, Burton much prefers to enter into the mammoth process of creating a feature film with people that he€™s already familiar and comfortable with. Robin Williams, however, was by far the more natural choice to play Willy Wonka, the eccentric and possibly even disturbed reclusive genius behind the chocolate factory. Where Depp played the character as a weird amalgamation of game show host and guru, all plastic faced twitches, Williams would have brought the flair and character of the original novel to life: been more like a mad uncle.

2. Jack Torrance - The Shining

Although Jack Nicholson was director Stanley Kubrick€™s first choice to play the central role of Jack Torrance, at once point Williams was also on the shortlist to play the character. Allegedly, so was Harrison Ford and Robert De Niro. In the end, Nicholson would be the only choice that author Stephen King would approve, although King would later deride Kubrick€™s efforts, apparently unhappy at the liberties taken with the story and characters, and seventeen years later would carefully shepherd a more faithful adaptation into being, in the form of a television miniseries. It€™s true that, in 1980, Robin Williams didn€™t have the pedigree of Jack Nicholson, only really being known for Mork & Mindy by that point in his career. However, while both Williams and Nicholson brought similar edgy, nervous magnetism to their roles, Jack Nicholson is not the recovering family man that Torrance is supposed to be at the beginning of the story. In retrospect, Williams would have been a far better choice, being able to play both the reformed alcoholic attempting to write a play, and the possessed maniac that the haunted hotel has crafted by the end of the story. Nicholson already appears to be dangerously insane in the interview for the caretaker job, and in the drive down to the hotel. However, the part would prove iconic for Nicholson, and would have been considerably different in another man€™s hands.

1. The Joker/The Riddler - Tim Burton's Batman Franchise

Robin Williams The Riddler Let€™s face it, Batman€™s rogues€™ gallery are, to a man (and occasionally woman), disturbed and psychotic freaks and ghouls, as befits a terrifying, crime-obsessed gothic city like Gotham, whose Arkham Asylum must contain half the town by now. Robin Williams had been after a part on a Batman movie since they started thinking about making Batman movies again in the late 1980s. Towards the end of his life, it had become almost a running gag in interviews that he was still in the running to play either the Joker or the Riddler, or anyone else in the Batman mythos. Movie scuttlebutt has it that Williams was up for consideration in Tim Burton€™s 1989 version of the story, before Jack Nicholson once again skated past him to secure the role €“ yet another that would become synonymous with him, although it€™s easy to imagine the spin that Williams would have put upon it Jack Napier. The same was true of the Riddler in Joel Schumacher€™s Batman Forever. At one point, Williams was actually offered the role, but allegedly took his time signing the contract, and lost the role to Jim Carrey. The Joker came up again when Christopher Nolan set about rebooting the Batman Franchise, and Williams was considered once more, having worked with Nolan to great effect as the villain in his previous movie Insomnia. Of course, it€™s difficult to imagine anyone other than Heath Ledger in the role now, but it€™s likely that, with the Batman franchise rebooting once more, Williams was being considered for an older Joker once again €“ perhaps one more in the vein of the character€™s portrayal in Frank Miller€™s seminal Dark Knight Returns. Now that would have been interesting€

Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.