10 Scariest Horror Movie Twins

Things are scarier in pairs - most terrifying horror movie twins from The Shining to House of Wax.

The Shining
Warner Bros.

Horror movies with twins tend to fall into one of a few specific categories that make the most of their unique storytelling characteristics.

Often one twin is portrayed as inherently good and the other one as evil, leading to mistaken identities and stories of betrayal and revenge. Sometimes they even return from beyond the grave to exact their vengeance!

Twins are also frequently seen as being dangerously co-dependent, leading to violent mental breakdowns which spell trouble for the characters who get between them.

Arguably the most terrifying twin stories come from those characters who have developed telepathic or sometimes telekinetic abilities though, with directors presenting them more like supervillains.

Twins are so popular in horror as their similarities make us feel uneasy and suspicious that they are out to deceive us. They're also often used to deliver some brilliant and horrifying twists, but which movies did this trope best?

Let’s look at some of the scariest twins in horror movies and see what makes them so terrifying (warning – spoilers ahead!).

10. Bo And Vincent Sinclair - House Of Wax (2005)

House Of Wax
Warner Bros. Pictures

The House of Wax remake has been criticised as being a below-average horror film, but there is no denying that the story of the Sinclair twins is pretty disturbing.

Twins Bo and Vincent are introduced at the start of the film as children in 1974, with one of them nicely eating his breakfast and the other having a violent tantrum and having to be strapped to his chair. We never see their faces, so it is left to the viewer to assume that the normal-looking twin must be the better-behaved one.

Throughout the film, we find out that they were initially conjoined twins who were separated, and the twist is that the disfigured, hidden Vincent is actually the good twin who just wanted to make wax models. It's the handsome Bo who is the ‘evil’ twin who started murdering people to make mannequins from his still-breathing victims.

It is indeed a horrifying fate to comprehend - and that's before you even reach the infamous 'skin-peeling' scene.


9. Holly And Heather Dahl - A Haunting At Silver Falls (2013)

A Haunting at Silver Falls
Inception Media Group

This ghost story teaches us the lesson that people who look frightening are not always the ones we should be afraid of.

Twins Holly and Heather were murdered 20 years before the events of the film, and as far as the town urban legend is aware, their father was the killer, and is now on death row. The film sets the girls up as being out for vengeance on the town, with their terrifying rotting zombie-like appearance further enhancing this idea.

Protagonist Jordan encounters the girls after going to live with her aunt and uncle in Silver Falls. They haunt her and appear hostile, attacking her in the bath and telling her ‘you’re next’. The twins are clearly capable of enacting harm on the living, but it is only in the final act of the film that we realise their anger is not directed at Jordan, and they are just trying to warn her about their real killers: her aunt and uncle.

The final fate of the murderers is left to the imagination as the girls attack them off camera to the sound of their horrific screams.


8. Pim And Ploy - Alone (2007)

Alone Pim and Ploy
GTH

This scary Thai ghost story tells the tale of conjoined twins Pim and Ploy. When the girls both fall in love with a boy called Wee, he only wants to be with Pim. She demands that Ploy agree to an operation to separate them so she can be with him. Ploy dies in the operation and an apparently guilt-ridden Pim moves to South Korea to escape her remorse and marry Wee.

The twisty events that follow highlight not only a horrific betrayal that Ploy enacted on Pim, but how angry and full of vengeance Pim’s ghost is for what happened to her. It is revealed that Ploy murdered her sister and went on to pose as her to steal Wee. In an additional evil act, she then killed their mother when she thought she was going to reveal her secret.

Pim’s spirit gets more and more frightening, torturing and terrifying her sister before eventually intervening during a fight with Wee when he learns the truth. Pim finally gets her revenge, holding her sister down, making it impossible for her to escape a raging house fire.


7. Todd And Terry Simmons - Blood Rage (1987)

Blood Rage - Terry and Todd
Film Limited

Blood Rage is a classic ‘good’ versus ‘evil’ twin story, with young angelic-looking Terry brutally killing a man with an axe and then, without missing a beat, blaming his innocent brother Todd who is too stunned by what he has seen to object.

Terry’s hatred of Todd is never fully explained, leading us to assume that it is not so much the case that he dislikes his twin, more that he has no feelings for him at all, seeing him as a convenient scapegoat. He has no remorse for his actions sending his brother to an insane asylum.

Todd’s escape from the institution is only motivated by trying to clear his name and to stop his twin committing more attacks. Terry, on the other hand, has managed to avoid killing anyone for ten years, so sees his ‘psychotic’ twin’s escape as the perfect alibi for him to give in to his urges and go on a murderous rampage.

Terry is such a manipulative psychopath that his mother is absolutely convinced that he is the good twin, to the point that she heartbreakingly takes her own life when she thinks she has accidentally killed her virtuous son at the climax of the final battle.


6. Kelly And Terry Fairchild - The Initiation (1984)

The Initiation
New World Pictures

The evil twin aspect to this film is the big twist finale, but actually revealed in the opening scene and heavily hinted at throughout the story. College student Kelly is an amnesiac who has recurring nightmares of walking in on her parents in bed as a child and stabbing her father before he pushes an intruder into the fire.

It turns out that this event actually happened, but not quite the way Kelly remembered it. She was so traumatised by seeing her twin sister stab the man her mother was having an affair with, who then horrifically burned her father, that she completely forgot she had a twin or who her real father was.

Kelly’s twin Terry was sent to an insane asylum following the attack and built up incredible rage against her sister, jealous that she got to live a normal life. Their still-alive father helps her escape while working as a gardener at the hospital. The two of them go on the hunt for Kelly on the night of her sorority initiation, brutally attacking anyone who gets in their way.

The final showdown between the girls highlights the animosity Terry feels for her sister. Even though she was justifiably institutionalised for her actions, she feels she didn’t deserve to be labelled the bad twin because, in her eyes, she was defending their father.


5. Jonah And Seth Trimble - Seconds Apart (2011)

Seconds Apart Jonah and Seth
After Dark Films

Jonah and Seth Trimble are a particularly horrible duo. Blessed with telepathic and telekinetic powers, the downside is they are unable to feel emotion. They spend their time reading people's minds, then telekinetically forcing them to harm themselves, hoping to elicit some sort of reaction from themselves.

Played by actual real-life twins Gary and Edmund Entin, they are handsome but incredibly creepy. They dress the same and have identical mannerisms and voices and desire no other companionship other than each other.

A detective investigating their case discovers that their mother had submitted herself and the boys to experiments at a fertility clinic in order to become pregnant, which led to their abilities. A truly disturbing flashback shows us their terrible home life, which stemmed from them forcing their parents to disfigure each other when they were children.

The seemingly unstoppable twins do finally get their comeuppance, but it is a bitter-sweet resolution for the viewer as the prospect of their death seems to please them as they finally get to experience fear.


4. Holland And Niles Perry - The Other (1972)

The Other
20th Century Fox

Twin boys, sensible Niles and mischievous Holland are cared for by their Russian grandmother Ada on her farm after the death of their father the previous year, with their grieving mother refusing to leave her room.

Ada teaches Niles a 'game' where he learns to astrally-project his mind into other beings, but unfortunately Niles isn't very responsible with his new power, and with Holland's increasingly evil influence, soon grisly fates start to befall anyone who the twins take a disliking to.

It is horrifyingly made clear how scary such a power is in the hands of someone who is still too young to have developed a moral compass.

The twist to the movie is fantastically delivered, with it being revealed that Holland has been dead since he fell down a well on their birthday the previous year, and Niles used his ability to speak to his brother just before he died, keeping him 'alive' in his mind ever since.

Niles wrestles with his brother's influence, but he ultimately proves unstoppable, with his family, including his mother and grandmother all suffering as he completely loses himself to him.


3. Elliot And Beverly Mantle - Dead Ringers (1988)

Dead Ringers 1988
20th Century Fox

This David Cronenberg psychological horror stars Jeremy Irons as twin gynaecologists Elliot and Beverly Mantle who run a fertility clinic together. It is a twisted story where confident Elliot seduces their patients, then passes them on to shy Beverly when he is bored of them. When one of the women catches on, Beverley is unable to mentally cope with the situation and descends into madness and drug addiction.

Cronenberg had already proven he was quite the visionary with movies such as The Fly, and demonstrated his talents again with his invisible joining of Jeremy Irons' terrifying performances. Irons manages to wonderfully create two distinct personalities, with the confident Elliot convincingly dominating the nervous, quiet Beverly. His acting really carries the film and invests the viewer in their chaotic relationship.

Beverly goes on to hallucinate and imagine deformed women in his office and creates disturbing gynaecological instruments which he uses to operate on them to the horror of his theatre staff.

Elliot finally intervenes to stop his brother, but the sad climax film shows them killing each other. Their deaths enable them to break their co-dependence, but neither one ends up getting the freedom they craved in life.


2. Alexie And Alexa Grady - The Shining (1980)

The Shining Twins
Warner Bros. Pictures

During Jack Torrence’s interview for the position of winter caretaker at the Overlook Hotel, hotel manager Stuart Ullman tells him that the previous caretaker Delbert Grady lived at the hotel with his family until he went crazy with cabin fever and murdered his two daughters with an axe before killing his wife and then himself with a shotgun.

It is suggested that the twins were innocent victims of their father's attack, with summer caretaker Bill Watson describing them as 'cute as buttons'. Jack encounters Grady’s spirit in the hotel, and he tells him that one of his daughters stole a pack of matches and tried to burn down the hotel, requiring him to 'correct' her.

This leads to the possibility that one or both of them had 'The Shining' and were able to sense the nefarious intent of the hotel, so Grady killed them to protect it.

The girls are terrifyingly encountered by Jack’s son Danny when he is exploring the hotel. Their appearance suggests that they have been affected by the hotel's sinister influence and are now evil. They urge Danny to "come play with us, forever and ever and ever...", trying to tempt him into letting the hotel take him over. Their synchronised voices and outfits coupled with the flashes to their grisly deaths make them iconic as horror twins.


1. Duane And Belial Bradley - Basket Case (1982)

Basket Case
Analysis Film Releasing Corporation

Frank Henenlotter’s cult classic about separated conjoined twins Duane Bradley and his basket-dwelling brother Belial is as inventive as it is gruesome. The basic premise is similar to so many others on this list: the brothers were born as conjoined twins, with Duane looking normal, while Belial is more conventionally sinister. They were separated against their will as children and seek revenge against the doctors that forced the operation on them.

Despite the low budget, the relationship between the twins has a surprisingly interesting arc. Duane attempts to be perceived as a normal person, having the added effect that people are not suspicious of him and are unaware of the terrifying Belial hiding in the basket ready to brutally attack. He repeatedly tries to keep his brother safe, while trying to stop him killing people.

The sequel sees Duane and Belial seeking refuge from the police and reporters at Granny Ruth's house of 'unique individuals'. We witness Belial's feelings of rejection and jealousy of Duane attempting to build a life with Ruth's daughter Susan.

Duane faces the internal conflict of desiring a regular life while not wanting to desert his brother. Just when it looks like he might escape though, it's all snatched away from him and we see him finally giving in to accepting his life with his brother by horrifically sewing him back on to his side.


Watch Next


The Scariest Horror Movie Quiz You Need To Try!

Hellbound Hellraiser II 20
Cinemarque Entertainment BV

1. Exactly How Many Pins Are There In Pinhead's Head?

In this post: 
The Shining
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Acclaimed horror novelist and screenwriter... just kidding, eats pizza and watches horror movies with her cat