10 Sci-Fi Movie Concepts That Shouldn't Work But Do
There's no way someone ever thought Being John Malkovich was a sane film to make...
Often in sci-fi we get so swept up in the flashing lights and the glamour of alien worlds that we miss the bigger picture.
It's so easy to get lost in the beautiful environments and intricate lore of each new universe, or to choose to let a few inconsistencies slide by in order to continue enjoying your favourite fantasy universe.
However, if you take a step back and look at some of your favourite films, you might realise that the concepts behind them make absolutely no sense at all- and once you've done this, there's no going back.
There’s a whole host of bold concepts and ideas that shouldn’t necessarily work but they do: A.I. girlfriends, insect bosses, dream diving, doppelgangers - the possibilities are absolutely endless!
Sometimes these wild ideas are pulled off because of amazing performances, incredible scene-setting or scripting, or sometimes just because they introduce a new idea to us that we hadn’t confronted before.
Which is part of the charm of sci-fi, right?
With this in mind, let’s go ahead and take a look at 10 Sci-Fi Concepts that Shouldn’t Work But Do.
10. Primer
Primer is a 2004 time travel flick with a twist.
And the twist is that it’s boring - but not in a bad way!
People have started talking about it again recently because of the release of Tenet, the new Nolan film which shares much of its high concept with Primer.
The difference between the two though, is that whilst both are known for their incredibly complex plots (which over the years have led people to create flow-charts just to even attempt to understand), Tenet is backed by a huge budget and big names, whereas Primer intentionally creates a down-to-earth presentation of scientific discovery.
The understated visuals and performances in the film help bolster its charm, which is a direct product of its low budget and director’s vision. For explosions and action and excitement audiences go to Tenet, but Primer is its quieter, smarter cousin.
Director Shane Carruth himself plays one of the two central roles after claiming he couldn’t find a single actor that wouldn’t deliver lines with ‘too much drama’. He insisted instead that he wanted the film to portray scientific discovery realistically.
Now this may not be for everyone: it’s more slow-burning and introspective than others like it. But nonetheless, Carruth proved to audiences that you don’t need big names and bigger budgets to bring an incredible, complex sci-fi idea to life.
9. Mandy
Even if you don’t know much about this film, chances are you’ve seen the still of Nic Cage smiling maniacally in a burning car, covered in blood.
Well, that’s not even the half of it.
The basic sci-fi premise of this film is that a bad batch of LSD turns a group of hippies into a cannibalistic cult. The bad guys in this film are demonic, drug-crazed bikers, which sounds more like the plot of a self-published horror novel than a legitimate sci-fi blockbuster.
It all goes to pot after the cult murders a logger’s girlfriend by burning her alive and making him watch, all whilst he’s tied up and gagged with barbed wire. It’s very tasteful stuff.
Obviously the logger, known as Red, isn’t too happy about seeing his girlfriend chargrilled right in front of his eyes and he becomes hell-bent on hunting down the murderous hippies.
It is a classic revenge tale, and as with all clichés there was a chance it could come off as over-done and cringeworthy. Mandy, however, has escaped this fate. (Mandy the film, not the girlfriend - she, unfortunately, didn’t escape anything… )
We watch as Red tracks down and rips apart the gang with a crossbow and a custom-made battle axe, which I think is an underappreciated weapon that we don’t see enough of these days.
Much of the latter half of the film is clouded by Red’s intense hallucinations, which only adds to the trippy visuals of the film as a whole and solidifies it as a weirdly successful example of a sci-fi revenge flick.
8. Donnie Darko
Admit it: if someone came to you and pitched a film revolving around a man in a bunny suit predicting the end of the world, you’d probably think they were on something.
Whilst most people have heard of Donnie Darko, few who haven’t seen it actually understand what it’s about. In fairness, some people that have seen it still don’t know.
In a nutshell: a teenager is visited by a man in a gross rabbit costume and told that the world will end in 28 days. After this, he has visions of the future, hallucinations and all kinds of weird experiences.
And a jet crashes into his house. Twice. What are the chances?
With such a loose plot and strange concept, it is not unreasonable to assume this film wouldn’t be a hit. It was opened on limited release, and after that it took a year to get it to international screens - six months of which was spent begging theatres to screen it at all.
Somehow though it became an unexplained success, and since its initial release has earned a director’s cut release, a two-disk special edition and even its very own underwhelming sequel in 2009.
7. Her
From the cover and title of Her I would’ve guessed it was colourful romcom about a romantic Parisian man. The actual concept however lands just south of that.
A lonely man named Theodore, who recently went through a breakup, falls in love with his AI assistant, Samantha. However, unlike Ex Machina, she’s not a cute robot lady; Samantha is literally just a disembodied voice, which I think is what makes this difficult.
It’s hard to imagine a film where you get to know and love two central characters, where only one of them has any physical presence. Just as Theodore falls in love with Samantha as only a voice, the audience has to as well. Which has some serious potential for failing.
Looking at the concept on paper, I’m surprised it didn’t get laughed out of the pitch. ‘Man falls in love with phone, slash, robot, slash, unattainable woman’ is such a simple, overdone idea that you can probably find replicas of it in about a million student films. But they pull it off!
Bit by bit, we get to know and love Samantha, just to experience the same simultaneous heartbreak as we realise there’s no way this could ever work.
They’re not gonna have their moment where they run into each other’s arms - she has no arms. And no legs. And no body. You get the idea.
6. Mad Max: Fury Road
There’s a whole host of reasons why this film shouldn’t work: its unclear place in the Mad Max universe, the lack of dialogue and the fact that 90% of the film is just one long car-chase.
A desolate wasteland setting is certainly not new to audiences; a million other dystopian movies have been there and done that. Fury Road also has the disadvantage that any worldbuilding has to be done whilst on the move and with almost no verbal exposition.
Even with experience directing previous instalments, by 2015 George Miller wouldn’t have been my first choice for working on a film like this. When it comes down to it, he’d spent the years in between Fury Road's production working mostly on animations - the most well-known of which probably being Happy Feet.
Evidence was not pointing towards him being able to pull off a live-action R-rated epic. But clearly there’s something about Charlize Theron and Tom Hardy coming together in a magical union that somehow made that all OK!
The film is one wild ride (no pun intended) and is filled with energy from start to finish. There are some really interesting themes and ideas, alongside equally intriguing characters.
The stunning visuals and performances helped make this weird idea into a spectacular success; it even received ten Academy Award nominations including Best Picture and Best Director.
5. Altered States
Wild drug trips and hallucinations can get old real quick, and aside from coming up with new ways to exploit body horror and choppy camerawork, innovation in this area is pretty slow-moving.
This film took it all a step further than we thought it could reasonably go. Instead of just wandering around in a drugged-up daze, main character Edward actually undergoes physical and anthropomorphic changes right in front of our eyes.
It’s a strange concept to have someone experience a trip so intense that they literally become a caveman and then turn “into an amorphous mass of conscious, primordial matter”.
There are some interesting questions and themes that get brought up throughout, and director Ken Russell managed to keep it all engaging despite the heavy material.
Taking the risk and pushing things further than they usually go paid off for Russell, and the film continues to be enjoyed today in all its nonsensical glory.
4. Naked Lunch
The title is misleading, I’ll say that much.
The plot makes so little sense that they had to make up for it somehow, and they chose to do that with bugs. Lots of bugs.
The story follows an exterminator who gets so high on his own insecticide that he hallucinates being a secret agent. Not a regular secret agent, mind, but one working under a boss who just so happens to be a giant beetle.
It’s essentially James Bond if Judy Dench was a ladybug.
His mission is to take down a corporation that produces drugs made from bugs, and along the way he encounters… more bugs. And also, his wife’s doppelganger. But that’s a whole other thing.
It has become somewhat of a cult classic, being praised for its surreal visuals and underlying themes. Really, I just think audiences love the idea of giant beetles wearing clothes and getting shot. Each to their own, I guess.
3. Arrival
It was a risk to make an alien movie that was less about the aliens themselves, and more about international relations and language learning. Because when you think about it, all that sounds incredibly boring.
Often, audiences want alien films to be heavier on the sci-fi elements and visuals. In the age of blockbusters like Interstellar or anything that Marvel pumps out, you’re taking a risk by putting out a sci-fi film more interested in being thoughtful than visually intense.
It has elements of politics and linguistics, and the higher concept of reading the alien’s language gifting you the ability to see the future. Really, it’s more about the people than it is about the aliens, and this could mean it would flop big-time with audiences.
However it was one of the biggest films of 2016! That seems to be a theme here though: you take a risk and challenge what audiences normally want to see, and often you can create something way more impactful.
2. Inception
It was a bit of a meme when Inception came out that it was so complicated that no one could understand it, and that it is the literal blockbuster personification of the “and I woke up and it was all a dream” trope. However, in the years since its release it has arguably become one of Nolan’s best-loved films.
Whilst any Nolan film was always going to have a bizarre, extreme high concept, this one was really daring. The concept of infiltrating someone else’s subconscious for a sort of espionage activity, and eventually to plant a whole new idea in their mind was definitely new.
It’s carried by the emotions behind it all - including the additional storyline of main character Cobb’s late wife haunting his subconscious.
Fundamentally, a film known for being too complicated for its own good (much like Primer) shouldn’t be successful - especially when the plot relies so heavily on a universally hated cliché.
Yet Nolan managed to toe the line just enough to create a masterpiece that challenges viewers but also leaves them completely satisfied overall, even distracting us enough to forget that dreams are generally the weakest premise to any story.
1. Being John Malkovich
There is no way that any part of this was a good idea.
You climb through a tunnel, live in a celebrity’s brain for a bit and then get spat out by the New Jersey Turnpike. But it’s not just any celebrity, it’s specifically John Malkovich, and apparently there’s enough people who want to pay to have this experience that it soon becomes a problem.
I’m sorry but how is that a plot to a film?
There’s so much more madness that I can’t even begin to summarise without just telling you to watch it. With a premise so ridiculous, I’m unsure to this day how it earned three Academy Award nominations and a reputation as a bit of a classic.
It’s one of those ones you have to see to believe, and if you have a bit of spare time amongst all the madness at the moment, I’d highly recommend experiencing it yourself. There really is nothing like it.