10 Sci-Fi Movies Where Evil Won

When the bad guys are too tough to beat.

oxymandias watchmen
Warner Bros.

Though movies are largely concerned with the triumph of good over evil, that of course isn't always the case, as much as mainstream audiences might loathe it.

The sci-fi genre is thoroughly rooted in the notion of good vs. evil, of the smart, resourceful heroes facing off against either a monstrous or bureaucratic enemy force which threatens the world's survival.

And while the good guys typically do prevail, sometimes they're not quite so lucky, because as we all know, happy endings aren't quite so common in real life.

As a genre, sci-fi has a habit of holding its mirror up to society despite its oft-heightened nature, and so in turn, movies which see an oppressive malevolent force dominate and destroy the heroes can strike an uncommonly strong chord with audiences.

And so, these 10 bold genre visions dared to hand a victory to the card-carrying villains who fought to enslave and flat-out annihilate humanity, whether for glory, monetary gain, biological impulse, or the sheer simple fun of it...

10. Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines

Claire Danes and Nick Stahl in Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
Warner Bros.

Though the third Terminator film was a sure step down from its masterful predecessors, even its ardent detractors were surely left blindsided by the ballsiness of its surprisingly bleak ending, which remains one of the most depressing ever tacked onto the end of a $200 million blockbuster.

After the T-X (Kristanna Loken) is destroyed in the film's climax, John Connor (Nick Stahl) and Katherine Brewster (Claire Danes) arrive at what they believe to be Skynet's core with the purpose of destroying it and stopping Judgment Day.

However, they soon realise that the location is in fact simply a fallout shelter, and because Skynet has already propagated itself throughout the Internet, Judgment Day is inevitable.

In a colossal bummer ending, John and Kate get to hole up in safety as Skynet launches a nuclear holocaust which wipes out billions of people.

Though it entirely contradicts T2's thematic that "the future is not set," it's nevertheless an impressively courageous ending for such a commercial juggernaut of a movie.

John Connor survived, for sure, but when so many were killed regardless, it's tough to consider it a win for anyone but the murderous robotic overlords.


9. Brightburn

Brightburn Brandon
Sony

Last year's subversive superhero flick Brightburn provided a grim answer to the question, "what if Superman was a murderous a**hole?"

The film follows the basic origin story beats expected of the Man of Steel, as infant child Brandon (Jackson A. Dunn) crashes to Earth and is adopted by a kindly couple (Elizabeth Banks and David Denman).

But it becomes increasingly clear throughout the movie that Brandon is being groomed for evil by a mysterious force calling out to him from his spaceship, leading to him turning full villain in the third act.

Yet rather than have Brandon be slain by his own distraught parents in a tragic finale, Brightburn goes in the total opposite direction: Brandon burns a hole through his father's head and drops his mother to her death from a great height.

Worse still, he causes a plane crash which kills everyone onboard in the film's final scene, and the end credits then reveal that he embarks on a worldwide rampage, while the existence of other similarly super-powered folk is noted.

With the implication that an Evil Justice League is about to tear the world asunder, it's safe to say that humanity is basically screwed. Given that Brightburn sequel isn't looking likely, that's the end of the story.


8. Alien 3

Alien 3 Ripley
20th Century Fox

Though the first two Alien films categorically end with Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) vanquishing the Xenomorph and getting to take a much-needed space nap, Alien 3 had far more final plans in store for the genre icon.

It's revealed later in the threequel that Ripley was impregnated by a facehugger after her escape pod crashed, and as such she's carrying a Xenomorph Queen embryo.

Though villainous conglomerate Weyland–Yutani suggests she undergo surgery to have the embryo removed, Ripley's well aware that they'll simply use it for nefarious purposes. And so, at the end of the film she commits suicide by jumping into a furnace, seemingly destroying both herself and the embryo.

While this might seem like a victory for humanity and a loss for Weyland-Yutani, the sequel, Alien: Resurrection, sees Ripley cloned 200 years later using blood taken before her suicide.

In a credibility-snapping twist, it's also revealed that Ripley's DNA was altered by gestating the Queen, resulting in each successful clone also growing up with an embryo inside it.

Basically, Ripley's efforts were ultimately for nothing, as the Xenomorph still wound up in the hands of unscrupulous scientists with anything but humanitarian endeavours on their minds.


7. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978)

Invasion of the Body Snatchers Donald Sutherland
United Artists

There are few more memorable instances of the villain winning in cinema than in the chilling conclusion to 1978's superb remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers.

While the original 1956 film ended on a more hopeful note that humanity was set to prevail over the Pods - an extraterrestrial force seeking to covertly assimilate humanity a person at a time - the remake wraps up with a shockingly bleak mic drop of an ending.

The film's chilling final scene focuses on two of the city's few remaining survivors, protagonist Matthew Bennell (Donald Sutherland) and his friend Nancy Bellicec (Nancy Cartwright), as they secretly meet up.

But a moment later, Matthew raises his finger to Nancy and opens his mouth wide, letting out an inhuman shriek, revealing himself to having been turned into a Pod also.

The clear implication is that Nancy too will be captured and replaced, and given that one of the film's final sights is a glimpse of the Pods preparing to move their operation to neighbouring West Coast cities, it's pretty clear that humanity is done.

Sticklers might argue that there's a creepy banality about the Pods' actions which transcends mere evil, but given their industrious attempts to wipe out humanity, it's tough to see them as anything but.


6. The Empire Strikes Back

empire strikes back
Lucasfilm

The greatest Star Wars movie to date is also by far the grimmest, no matter that it was only the middle entry into a trilogy which, of course, ultimately resolved well for the heroes.

But The Empire Strikes Back is nevertheless notable for handing a decisive - if temporary - W to the bad guys, given that it ends with Darth Vader (David Prowse) chopping Luke Skywalker's (Mark Hamill) hand off before announcing his parentage, while Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) is forced to watch as Han Solo (Harrison Ford) is captured and frozen in carbonite.

Despite clearly setting up a third film to restore the balance, Empire nevertheless saw the heroes physically and psychologically broken in the most intimate and intrusive of ways.

There's a reason why it remains the blueprint for franchise cinema's "dark middle movie," because the victory of the villains is so deeply felt, and fans had to wait a whole three years to see it finally resolved. Imagine if Marvel did that with Avengers: Infinity War.


5. Watchmen

Watchmen Ozymandias Matthew Goode
Warner Bros.

Watchmen is an especially interesting example of this trope because it's not so much about an evil force doing an evil thing for a selfish or destructive reason, but a more ambiguous character doing an undeniably evil act for the apparent "greater good."

We're talking of course about Adrian Veidt aka Ozymandias (Matthew Goode), who in order to prevent a probable nuclear war between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, frames Doctor Manhattan (Billy Crudup) for a series of energy reactor explosions worldwide.

These explosions kill millions, but also unite the U.S. and Soviet Union against Manhattan, in turn preventing a nuclear war and theoretically "saving" billions of lives.

And in order to further secure the secret of Veidt's deception and prevent World War III from taking place, an infuriated Rorschach (Jackie Earle Haley) is subsequently destroyed by Manhattan.

It's a brilliant and provocative dilemma, of Veidt executing a "necessary" evil for the greater good, as disgusting as it might seem to conventional morality.

Even if Rorschach's tell-all journal does indeed get published and reveal the truth as the film's ending hints at, it's clear either way that evil prevails, whether it's Veidt's plan or warmongers annihilating each other with nukes.


4. Cube

Cube Kazan
Trimark

Cult classic sci-fi Cube follows a group of people who wake up within an interlocking series of cubes, most of which contain deadly traps designed to kill them.

It's a terrifically taut and ambiguous piece of low-budget genre filmmaking, and ends with only one of the seven characters making it out of the cube alive - Kazan (Andrew Miller).

But the grimly amusing irony of the film's ending is that Kazan is a mentally handicapped young man, and so despite his survival, he lacks the means to verbalise the insanity he's just experienced.

That's even assuming Kazan truly does survive, of course, given that the straight-to-video sequel, Cube 2: Hypercube, seems to imply with its downer ending that those who escape are shot immediately after exiting by the shadowy organisation behind the cubes.


3. Brazil

Brazil Alternate Ending
Embassy International

Terry Gilliam's dystopian masterpiece Brazil follows low-level civil servant Sam Lowry (Jonathan Pryce) as he attempts to locate a woman from his dreams while facing off against a hyper-bureaucratic government.

In the film's haunting ending, Sam is captured by the government and charged with treason, before being informed that his love interest Jill (Kim Greist) has been killed and he's due to be tortured imminently.

Though Sam then appears to be rescued, it's eventually revealed that this is simply an imagined happy ending, and Sam is actually still in government captivity, having been lobotimised.

Sam may therefore be blissfully happy in the film's final moments, but it's an undeniable victory for the oppressive government, who have once again exerted their will over a pesky challenger. As it so often does in life, the depressing status quo endures.


2. A Clockwork Orange

A Clockwork Orange Malcolm Mcdowell
Warner Bros.

Stanley Kubrick's bold adaptation of Anthony Burgess' novel dares to deviate from the source material with its decidedly more pessimistic ending.

In the novel, thug protagonist Alex DeLarge (Malcolm McDowell) ultimately renounces his former life of ultraviolence and rape after being "reformed" by the government's experimental Ludovico brainwashing technique.

But Kubrick opted to change Burgess' ending, cynically concluding his movie with Alex's sexual and violent urges returning, as he ironically declares, "I was cured, all right!"

Even beyond Alex lapsing back in to his prior state, it's clear that the dystopian government desperate to control behaviour by any means necessary has the population firmly in its vice grip. A bad time for all, then.


1. 12 Monkeys

12 Monkeys David Morse
Universal

Terry Gilliam strikes again, with another expertly crafted, bleak vision of the future in which a virus is released in 1996 and wipes out the vast majority of humanity, forcing the survivors to live underground.

The great brilliance of 12 Monkeys is that the bad guys have already won when the movie begins, having nearly annihilated humanity.

As such, when protagonist James Cole (Bruce Willis) is sent back in time to try and track the origins of the virus, he's succinctly informed that the future cannot be changed - his mission is simply one to preserve what remains of the human race.

And so, it's a foregone conclusion that Cole's death at the end of the movie - a sight he himself witnessed as a child - must happen in order for the scientists to learn that Dr. Peters (David Morse) was behind the virus, and maybe, just maybe, keep the dwindling human race in the future alive.

Though there's a glimmer of hope for the scraps of humanity that remain, it's still an unchanging and inevitable victory for Peters.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.