10 Scumbag Horror Movie Protagonists We STILL Rooted For

They're bad people, but we cheered them on anyway.

Deadstream thumb
Shudder

Generally speaking, a horror movie protagonist should be at least somewhat likeable, because how can filmmakers expected audiences to cheer on their survival otherwise?

After all, who among us doesn't love seeing thoroughly detestable horror movie characters get hacked to pieces by the masked murderer? 

It's a cornerstone appeal of the entire genre, but it's also generally expected that the Last Man Standing or Final Girl will be a "good" person who "deserves" to make it to the end.

But these 10 horror movies all did the most daring of things - they refused that convention and instead delivered protagonists who, well, were basically human trash.

Sleazy, morally bankrupt, and just straight-up gross, these "complicated" horror movie protagonists were all guilty of some very, very bad things, and yet, we still were persuaded to cheer them on to the end.

This was either due to the actors' charming lead performance, their sheer gutsy will to survive torrid circumstances, or perhaps because the filmmakers found someone even worse for them to face off against.

Whatever the reason, these horror movie protagonists were all sure scumbags, but it's a serious credit to the cast and crew that we rooted for them anyway...

10. Rocky - Don't Breathe

Don T Breathe Rocky
Sony Pictures Releasing

It doesn't get much scummier than breaking into the house of an old Gulf War veteran to steal his money, especially when the guy also happens to be blind.

But that's precisely what Rocky (Jane Levy), the protagonist of Don't Breathe, does, plotting with her two buds Alex (Dylan Minnette) and Money (Daniel Zovatto) to steal the $300,000 in Norman Nordstrom's (Stephen Lang) home.

Even accepting that Rocky desperately wants to escape an abusive home life, it doesn't quite excuse victimising someone else who is themselves in a highly vulnerable position.

But the genius twist of Don't Breathe is that, despite his visual impairment, Nordstrom is decidedly better-equipped to take on the thieves than anyone expected, using his heightened hearing and superior strength to put up one hell of a fight.

Yet the real kicker that makes us root for Rocky? The revelation that Norman isn't quite so innocent - she eventually discovers that Norman kidnapped the young woman who killed his daughter in a car accident, chained her up in his basement, and forcibly inseminated her to produce a "replacement" child for his late daughter.

Yep, that'll do it alright.

Rocky is far from a saint, but after what Norman is eventually shown to be, it's incredibly easy to root for her throughout the third act.


9. Seth Gecko - From Dusk Till Dawn

Clooney From Dusk Till Dawn
USA Films

The bonus of casting George Clooney in your movie as a villain is that he can't help but be a damn charming bastard even when he's busy murdering people and taking others hostage.

In Robert Rodriguez's From Dusk Till Dawn, Seth Gecko (Clooney) and his brother Richie (Quentin Tarantino) are a pair of fugitive bank robbers who leave a pile of bodies in their wake as they try to make their way across the Mexican border.

We should absolutely despise both Gecko Bros., then, but Seth has such swagger, and seems positively angelic compared to his utterly unhinged sibling Richie, that he's tough not to like regardless.

It doesn't help that the Geckos and the family they've taken hostage in order to sneak across the border are assailed by a pack of vampires mid-way through the movie, at which point the very notion of villainy is flipped on its head.

When survival against blood-thirsty creatures is the order of the day, Seth suddenly doesn't seem like such a bad guy to have on your side. 

That he progressively forms an uneasy bond with one of his hostages, Kate (Juliette Lewis) - and that they end up the only two survivors of the whole shebang - doesn't hurt either.


8. Esther - Orphan: First Kill

Orphan First Kill
Paramount

It seemed like a basically impossible task for Orphan prequel First Kill to make us root for its villain protagonist Esther aka Leena (Isabelle Fuhrman), who in the first film was revealed to be a serial killer posing as a young girl, aided by a hormone disorder which makes her resemble a child.

But for all of its issues, First Kill did have one brilliantly devious gambit up its sleeve, by revealing that there was another killer in Leena's midst.

Leena spends the movie posing as Esther, the missing child of the Albright family, only for it to eventually be revealed that the real Esther actually died four years earlier during an argument with her older brother Gunnar (Matthew Finlan), which mother Tricia (Julia Stiles) then covered up without her husband's knowledge.

And so, the seemingly affable Tricia reveals herself to be a cunning femme fatale who poses a genuine threat to Leena, enough that one actively looks forward to seeing her die by Leena's hand at film's end, as she does.

It doesn't cancel out every horrible thing Leena has done throughout both movies, but it sure was fun to see her take out the trash regardless. 


7. David Collins - The Guest

The Guest Dan Stevens
Picturehouse

It's a testament to how damn likeable Dan Stevens is as an actor that despite killing a metric crap-ton of people throughout The Guest - some of them unambiguously innocent - we probably still don't want him to die at the end.

Former U.S. Army soldier David (Stevens) is introduced as an incredibly wholesome, charming, and bloody handsome chap who immediately bonds with the Peterson family. 

He even rights some wrongs, like hilariously setting straight the bullies picking on the Petersons' son Luke (Brendan Meyer), but it's ultimately revealed that David was a subject in a military experiment. 

As a result, he's programmed to kill anyone who threatens to expose his identity, eventually even the Petersons themselves, and while we don't want him to succeed in that mission, there's still enough humanity poking through David's cold-bloodedness that we don't want him to die either.

And so, it's quite apt that director Adam Wingard decided to end the movie with David being "killed," only for him to return from the dead moments later, making for a grimly hilarious fist-pumping final "gotcha!"


6. Jigsaw - Saw X

Saw X Tobin Bell
Twisted Pictures

Despite the previous nine Saw movies making it painfully clear that John Kramer aka Jigsaw (Tobin Bell) is an unforgivably cruel human being who, directly or indirectly, caused the deaths of dozens of people, Saw X did a fantastic job of making us cheer him on anyway.

The brilliance of this prequel, set between the first two movies, is that like Don't Breathe and Orphan: First Kill, it makes a morally repugnant character face off against someone even worse.

Case in point, the film's big hook is that Kramer takes aim against a group of con artists who took his money while falsely claiming to have cured his inoperable cancer.

Throughout the film, Kramer is only victimising unambiguously awful people who are doing something even sicker than he - siphoning money from the weak, dying, and desperate.

Kramer's horrifying past and future actions are never far from our minds while watching Saw X, and yet, given who he targets throughout the film - especially the scam's vile leader, Cecilia Pederson (Synnøve Macody Lund) - it's shockingly easy to cheer him on.


5. Sadie & McKayla - Tragedy Girls

Tragedy Girls
Gunpowder & Sky

There's no denying that Tragedy Girls' two protagonists are real pieces of work alright, given that McKayla Hooper (Alexandra Shipp) and her bestie Sadie Cunningham (Brianna Hildebrand) are a pair of true crime bloggers turned serial killers. Yup, there's no excusing that.

They're blatant sociopaths, then, yet while we should hate them, the performances from Shipp and Hildebrand are so damn entertaining, and their chemistry so pitch-perfect, that it becomes hard not to queasily cheer their rampage on.

Granted, it helps that the film pits them against another, altogether more detestable serial killer, Lowell Orson Lehmann (Kevin Durand), but even so, make no mistake - they're awful people who leave a massive pile of bodies behind them by film's end.

And yet, they're frequently hilarious and weirdly likeable, enough that it's tough not to root for them as each new wrinkle presents itself and we wonder how they're gonna extricate themselves from it. 


4. Royce - Predators

Predators adrien brody
Fox

2010's Predators has quite the juicy hook, that each of its central characters are degenerate killers in one form or another, seemingly making them viable "game" for the Predators to hunt.

The film's out-and-out protagonist is Royce (Adrien Brody), a gruff, hard-edged mercenary with a whole lot of blood on his hands. 

More to the point, he's quickly established to only be looking out for number one, and will gladly throw the rest of the group to the wolves if it'll save his own hide.

But over the course of the film it becomes tough not to warm to Royce, due to not only his fierce intelligence and cool under pressure, but how he bonds with IDF sniper Isabelle (Alice Braga) and basically grows a soul over the course of the story.

He's still got one hell of a tarnished past, but at least he's trying to be better.


3. Shawn Ruddy - Deadstream

Deadstream
Shudder

Deadstream impressively does the inverse of Dashcam, by presenting us with an obnoxious Social Media Personality who is so thoroughly put through the wringer that it becomes increasingly difficult not to cheer on their survival.

The found footage film's protagonist is Shawn Ruddy (played by co-director Joseph Winter) - a disgraced Internet personality who attempts to win his audience back by spending a night in a haunted house.

And indeed, Shawn is a grating character from the first moment we meet him - a cringe-worthy clout chaser pandering to hyperactive teenage boys on YouTube, and willing to do anything to claw back his dwindling revenue stream.

Shawn is absolutely an a**hole, then, but as the supernatural shenanigans begin steadily ramping up, it becomes increasingly difficult to wish ill upon this guy, who evidently has to deal with far more than he bargained for.

He's just endearing enough to root for by film's end, even if you probably wouldn't want to hang out with him in real life.


2. Dr. Dan Challis - Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween III Season of the Witch Tom Atkins
Universal

Dr. Dan Challis (Tom Atkins), the protagonist of Halloween III: Season of the Witch, is the sort of sandpaper-rough hero we don't see much of nowadays.

He's an alcoholic who has a strained relationship with his ex-wife and two kids, drinks on the job, and is an unrepentant horndog who sexually harasses his female colleagues and even beds a woman 20 years his junior, Ellie (Stacey Nelkin), the day after her father is murdered.

Oh, and he only thinks to check that Ellie's not underage after hooking up with her. Nice.

Challis' behaviour would make him a totally unworkable protagonist in a modern horror movie, but there is something to be said for the infectious charisma of Tom Atkins which makes Challis tough to actually hate.

He is at least believably flawed for a man from his era, and gets really damn close to stopping the villains from winning, even if he's ultimately too late. 

He's a dirtbag, but also tries to do the right thing when it matters most.


1. Max Renn - Videodrome

James Woods Videodrome
Universal Pictures

Videodrome's embattled protagonist Max Renn (James Woods) is an undeniable sleazebag - the president of a Toronto TV station specialising in sensationalist content, and who can barely contain his giddiness when he discovers the titular snuff film broadcast he decides to illicitly transmit on his own station.

Max may be an unrepentant peddler of brain-rotting trash, but at the same time, he couldn't have anticipated that Videodrome would literally rot people's brains, least of all his own.

Given that Max quickly gets in way over his head and is ultimately helpless to fall victim to the culture war unfolding around him, it's tough not to feel for him and wish him a fate better than, well, what eventually happens.

It helps that James Woods gives a charismatic and somewhat charming performance in the role, even though Max is a shameless, morally fringe opportunist at the best of times.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.