10 Seemingly Great Films That Unravelled On A Second Viewing

If you've only ever seen these "great" movies once, make sure to keep it that way.

"OMG! THAT WAS THE BEST MOVIE EVER! CAN YOU BELIEVE HOW GOOD THAT WAS?" Simmer down, passionate movie fan. Though you're well-entitled to your opinion, it might be a good idea to wait until you check out that movie you loved so much for a second time before you start telling everyone you've ever met - and those you're yet to meet - that it's the best and most accomplished slice of cinema to have ever graced this good Earth. Because sometimes we can find ourselves so blindsided by a motion picture experience that we totally lose a sense of its overall quality. That's another way of saying: it's entirely possible to love a movie all out of proportion when you've only seen it once, simply because you haven't been in close enough proximity with it to judge it in a proper manner. Liken it to a relationship. When you first meet that girl or guy of your dreams, they appear perfect to you: you're so enamoured with the idea of everything they stand for that you can't even begin to notice their many flaws... and why would you? After a few months, though, you begin to realise you might have been too quick to brand them "perfect." So to celebrate that love is horrible and depressing (uh, is that was this was supposed to be about?), here are 10 seemingly great movies that unravelled on a second viewing...


10. Inception

BRAHM!! BRAHM!! Hear that, everyone? It's Inception! Going by those horns, you can probably guess that this movie is super important or something, right? Uh, well, maybe - but maybe not. So Inception is one of those rare movie that pretty much blew everybody away when they first saw it in theatres everywhere - and on the surface, it's an incredibly complicated, well-thought out and exciting slice of sci-fi brilliance. Freakin' dream layers? WHAT? People flying around like they're in the f*cking Matrix? WHAT? A plot so confusing it's almost convoluted? DOUBLE WHAT? That last one's the problem. Watching Inception for a second time reveals a few things: firstly, it's mostly a movie about exposition. Other people telling people about other things so that we can understand what's going on. Secondly, it has nothing to say about anything (unlike the vastly superior Matrix). Thirdly, it's central concept - built around dreams - is questionable. Dreams aren't built with a rigid sense of architectural preciseness - they're weird and incoherent. In Inception, they feel like they've been constructed by somebody who builds hotels in Dubai.

9. Slumdog Millionaire

If you've only ever seen Slumdog Millionaire once, keep it that way: seriously, aside from being one of those movies that everyone loved the first time they saw it but haven't bothered to watch again (c'mon, you're guilty), it's also one of those intoxicatingly giddy and uplifting Best Picture wannabes that... well, won Best Picture. So whereas Slumdog Millionaire certainly has its good points, its bad points are emphasised to such a point when you sit down to it for the second time that it's actually kind of ridiculous. That's to say, the premise of the flick is downright horrific. For some reason, everybody willingly donned their super suspended disbelief hats for their first viewing of Slumdog - the quirky idea, that an Indian kids wins Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? because every single question has relevance to an incident in his life, was too intriguing to pass up. Revisiting the movie, you can't shy away from its absurd implausibilities and the fact that the main character is an awkward, gushing bag of dull. Not to forget that it's so stylised and fake in places that it kind of undermines its entire point. And, hey, it's actually a little boring, too.

8. The Sixth Sense

"I see dead people" - once a funny line you could say to people to get a cheap laugh up until about 2003 - has now joined the ranks of "I'll make him an offer he can't refuse" and "Run, Forrest, run" as one of those immortal movie quotes you never, ever want to hear again, because why, Dad? The Sixth Sense was the movie that made M. Night Shyamlan's career, and also the movie that has forced him to try and repeat his twisty tricks for the past 15 years. First time around, Sixth Sense was blowing minds left, right, and centre. HE WAS DEAD ALL ALONG?! So here's a movie that justifies Pauline Kael's rule that you should watch a movie once - simply put, The Sixth Sense is nowhere near as interesting once you know that Bruce Willis is a ghost. All the suspense and mystery of the situation has evaporated; it's vanished. There are many who like to claim that the movie still holds up, of course - that it's a great picture whether you know the twist or not. If that's to imply that it's beautifully-directed and well-acted, sure: but unlike, say, Se7en, there's not "enough" going on in the movie to reward viewers for coming back again.

7. Borat: Cultural Learnings of America For Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan

Okay, so Borat was hailed as one of the funniest movies of all time when it first hit theatres, and everybody spent the two weeks afterwards talking about all the hilarious scenes, and how dumb Americans were, and whatever else happened in the movie that made us guffaw so much for 90 minutes. Have you gone back to Borat, though, to check that it's just as funny all these years later? Not advisable: what at first seemed fresh and hilarious now seems a little stale. Though some of the sketches are hilarious, there's a sense of the dated about the flick. What happened? Well, to be entirely honest: Borat's original success can be linked to the fact that everybody first saw it in theatres, surrounded by hundreds - if not thousands - of other people who were laughing like maniacs. So, yes, whilst it's clearly funny, remove the movie from that context and it's not quite so brilliant. Whereas other comedies - like The 40-Year-Old Virgin, for example - seem to get better with every viewing, there's something oddly unappealing about Borat's annoyingly confused political approach. It's more repetitive than clever; more amusing than hilarious.

6. Up

Putting Up, perhaps one of the most beloved animated movies of the last 10 years, on a list like this will surely make for a hugely controversial pick - but it's legitimate choice, just hear us out! Before you take to the comments section, drunk, and with pitchfork in hand, consider the fact that this beautifully animated and wonderfully poignant flick from Pixar contains its greatest scenes at the very beginning of the movie.... that's right: after that, Up - and excuse the pun - begins to go downhill, offering up fun and frantic - but ultimately unmemorable - second and third acts. Which is to say, the first time you watch Up, it transfixes you with its subtle beauty - even when the second half of the movie loses a sense of focus and begins to drag, you're still thinking about the movie's tragic and touching montage from the beginning. On a second viewing, then, aware of said masterful sequence already, the rest of Up feels light and frothy in comparison - to the point where it almost seems like the film has been given way too much credit. Ask yourself: would Up be anywhere near as good without its brilliant "Married Life" sequence? The answer is: "Uh, no."

5. Kill List

On first viewing, Kill List presents itself as a strange, cerebral, unnerving fever dream of a movie - it's uncomfortable, tense, and by the end of the flick, you're left with the sense that there's so much more to work out... you know, things you missed the first time around that you didn't have time to appreciate originally. Simply put, it's the sort of movie that implies that multiple viewings are warranted, when in fact, it's the complete opposite: Kill List wants to feel like a movie you should watch again, but actually becomes more vague and frustrating with a second viewing. Why? Well, because there's nothing more to work out. The plot, which - on its most basic level - concerns two hitman who take on a killing contract and get much more than they bargained for, seems like it's a lot more complicated than it actually is, and the subtle clues and hints scattered throughout are meaningless... there to give you the impression that the film is more dense that it actually is. As a result, a second watch not only exposes Kill List to be a film that is best enjoyed in a single, gut-wrenching viewing, but one that is most effective watched just once. And alone.

4. Hugo

Martin Scorsese's much adored foray into the realms of children's films was met with universal praise - innovative and spellbinding in equal measure, Hugo showed the master filmmaker at the height of his powers, moving with ease into a new genre. Or so that's what everyone wanted you to think. Truth is, for all Hugo's visual brilliance, there's something not quite right about the movie - its clockwork precision, arguably employed on purpose, actually becomes noticeably jarring upon further viewings. It's worst crime, though? It's actually a fairly boring experience. Once you get past all its neat special effects and the nice cinematic tributes scattered throughout (which most cinephiles embraced wholeheartedly on the first viewing), what you're left with feels a little bit ridiculous - and boy does it drag. So away from the 3D and the fact that this is a Scorsese film, Hugo reveals itself to be rather hollow, emotionally-lacking, and crammed with bad accents. Presumably everyone was so taken with the lovely gliding 3D shots the first time around we all forgot that, in actuality, it's a slow, thin and dull slog. Avoid having seconds.

3. The Avengers

First things first: The Avengers isn't a bad movie, but given this article's premise - movies that unravelled on a second viewing - it would be just darn wrong not to include it. So the overarching problem with this flick isn't noticeably apparent during a first viewing of the movie - we know that the movie has to put the pieces into place, assemble the characters, and introduce a threat for them to fight against. And the first time we saw that, it was downright awesome: watching our Marvel heroes meeting one another was what we've been waiting to see for half a decade. But consider the second viewing of this movie, which is now - for the most part - a motion picture that basically exists to bring all those heroes together. Watching that happen for the second time, quite simply, just isn't fun. What was once exciting and hilarious proves itself to be a little building block-ish the next time around - we're waiting for the huge battle, but we've got to put all the pieces together again, and watching that happen, extended scene by extended scene, doesn't give the movie the natural feel of an isolated story. So it's really just half a great movie.

2. Star Wars: Episode VI - Return Of The Jedi

Okay, so maybe it took more than two viewings - and perhaps "adulthood" - for people to realise that something wasn't quite right about Star Wars: Episode VI, but it's probably true to say that most people thought that was a good Star Wars flick the first time they sat down to watch. Aside from the Ewoks, it was cool, right? If you've only seen this movie once, though, and retain fond memories of it, seek out a copy and prepare to be shocked: Jedi is a surprisingly lame episode, all said and done: it's kind of cheesy, is badly-plotted and is - on occasion - totally cringe-inducing. Obviously enamoured by the fact that this was the last Star Wars movie - it was the one that tied up the saga with a nice neat bow, cemented the relationship between Luke and Vader, and allowed Han and Leia to finally become a couple, after all - it's almost as if everybody forget that this was nowhere up to the standards of Episodes V and IV. There are some good parts: the opening sequence on Jabba's sail barge; the final space battle (but even that's a reprise), but it's noticeably lackluster. Worst of all, it made Han Solo a wimp - nobody wanted to see that!

1. Gravity

Oh, no, right? Gravity? The Gravity? As in, that movie that everyone is in love with right now - the movie that kind of actually blew us away when we saw it in the cinema? Yes, that's the one. So, okay, let's get this out the way: Gravity is a good movie. In a lot of ways, it's a great one. But how many of have had time to actually go back for seconds? Not because we don't want to, but because it's not time yet - we've only just seen it, after all: let the damn thing sink it. Unfortunately, the bad news is that - viewed outside of its cinema context - it's nowhere near as good. Which, in a way, seems like a somewhat redundant thing to say: aren't all movies technically "better" when viewed on the big screen? Perhaps, but watching Gravity for a second time exposes many of its narrative flaws, whereas other movies don't really suffer in the same way. So, yes, this visually stunning - but otherwise light - film feels far less impressive on a second viewing, the tension and claustrophobia noticeably artificial. Is it one of those movies that, ultimately, works better as a one-time experience? Watching it twice, it's hard to feeling anything but regret. Like this list? Agree or disagree with the choices? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.