10 Sequels That Stupidly Changed The Main Character

That... uh... was a... ah... bad idea.

Independence Day Will Smith Jeff Goldblum Jpg
20th Century Fox

I have to admit I was pretty sceptical about Finding Dory. Pixar's been hit-and-miss for a while now and the company's directors haven't been shy about the new wave of sequels (the next three years will see new entries from Cars, Toy Story and The Incredibles) being a corporately-mandated move (Dory is pretty much Andrew Stanton's apology to Disney for John Carter anyway). But my biggest problem was taking a supporting character from the original and bumping her up to the lead - that's a risky move.

Did it work? Well, kinda. We got to have a semi-repeat of the original film, but the new perspective made it fresh and added an underlying message about living with disabilities. But at the same time, the original characters you fell in love with, Marlin and Nemo, were sidelined to a cute-but-pointless subplot and their replacement didn't quite warrant Dory's expansion.

Of course, that's better than some cases. The trick of swapping out a main character is a staple of franchise cinema born out of necessity; actors don't want to return, a side character becomes a break-out hit or a new writer finds themselves taking the series in a new direction. Now it can work really well - Terminator 2: Judgement Day seems like the obvious one, although you can also rope in the likes of The Force Awakens too - but just as often can ruin what made the original so special. Here's ten of the dumbest examples.

10. Lightning McQueen To Mater - Cars 2

Cars Lightning McQueen Mater
Pixar

The Original: Cars is Pixar's most underrated movie. Not one of it's best, sure, but not the early mar on its legacy those who can't get past the "how does a world of just vehicles work?" question. A key part of that is the film's strong heart, which centres on the redemption of Owen Wilson's Lightning McQueen. It's a well-covered story, but the "big shot slowing down to appreciate the smaller things" arc is well done, especially thanks to an evocative turn from Paul Newman in the mentor role.

The Sequel: John Lasseter, the film's director, was clearly obsessed with the world of Cars more than most of his audience. When promoting the first movie, he started imagining what the film's heroes would do in the various global locations he was visiting, which rolled into the plot of the sequel. And, because at this point he was doing Cars for himself and he inordinately liked Larry The Cable Guy's Mater (a face only a creator could love), he made that hick the lead.

The result sidelined Lightning McQueen and saw dim-witted Mater attempting to stop an eco-terrorist cell with the help of Michael Caine's secret agent. Dumb is putting it lightly.

It sounds like Cars 3, due next year (sorry to be the bearer of bad news), will flip things back somewhat, with Lasseter saying the plot will deal with Doc Hudson's legacy.


9. Jack Traven To Annie Porter - Speed 2: Cruise Control

Speed Keanu Reeves Sandra Bullock
20th Century Fox

The Original: The Bus That Wouldn't Slow Down is simultaneously revered as a "so-90s-it's-good" guilty pleasure and an action classic, which is testament to its bonkers premise and excellent execution respectively. The plot is deviously simple, with a basic opening making way for the iconic bus sequence, although you don't want to overlook how Keanu's there to help you through it all. Now I'm not going to pretend that Reeves gave his best performance in Speed, but he served as a perfect action hero (and he and Sandra Bullock make a good pair).

The Sequel: I don't know what's funnier: that Speed 2: Cruise Control moved the franchise to the sea and in doing so managed to completely ruin the core concept, or that it could only get Sandy to come back and showdown against Willem Dafoe. Clearly the sex wasn't good enough to break the hard-fast rule about relationships based on intense experiences, because she's broken up with Jack and is now getting close to Jason Patric.

Speed was kinda stuck as a franchise thanks to its unreplicable plot - to continue it probably would have probably meant going the Die Hard route - but having Reeves in a sequel to anchor it and offering a character to be explored (rather than love interest gone tough) surely would have been better, right?


8. Taylor To Brent - Beneath The Planet Of The Apes

Beneath The Planet Of The Apes Taylor Brent Jpg
20th Century Fox

The Original: In Charlton Heston's Taylor, Planet Of The Apes has one of the best, most fitting protagonists in all of sci-fi. An overwhelming cynic who spends the entire movie waxing lyrical about how all of humanity's probably dead and that it'll likely have been at our own hand, he's in for a rude awakening when he strolls along a beach and discovers... exactly that has happened.

The Sequel: Charlton Heston didn't really want to do any more Apes films, so agreed to come back on two conditions; one, it be the last one and, two, he'd only be in part of the movie, with a new actor taking his place as the lead.

Enter James Franciscus as Brent, another astronaut so randomly inserted into the film that it feels like a last-minute rewrite from Taylor; they look so alike apes mistake them for each other. Beneath The Planet Of The Apes isn't a bad movie (and still ranks as the best non-original Apes flick), but the faff this switcheroo introduces is rather unorganic and gets in the way of a fascinating monkey vs mutant (yes, seriously) plot.

At least Heston got to blow up the world at the end. Unfortunately for him, Fox found a way (via time travel) to go the prequel route and three more movies were made (and eventually a remake, in which he had a damned, dirty cameo).


7. Clarice Starling To Hannibal Lecter - Hannibal

Silence Of The Lambs Hannibal Clarice
Orion Pictures/MGM/Universal Pictures

The Original: Hannibal Lecter is certainly the most striking part of The Silence Of The Lambs - chianti, face mask, friend for dinner - but as any trivia-lover who hasn't actually seen the film exhaustedly points out, he's not in that much. The story instead belongs to Clarice Starling's, and the film itself is as bothered with her suffocating fight against underlying oppression as it is extreme gore. She one of the screen's strongest female heroes, made all the more interesting thanks to her ambiguous link to Hannibal.

The Sequel: A follow-up to Silence was in development for so long that Jodie Foster dropped out and had to be replaced by Julianne Moore, although the biggest change from the previous film was the bumping of Lecter up to top billing. He drove the plot this time, with everything circling around him and Ridley Scott taking a lot more joy out of the violence than Jonathan Demme ever dared. Perhaps losing Foster motivated that somewhat, but it seems that Scott (and writer Thomas Harris) just got too caught up in the Hannibal hype.

Hannibal was followed up by prequel Red Dragon, which put the focus back on an FBI agent questioning the doctor (this time the doctor's captor, Will Graham), but that didn't stop Brett Ratner from massively expanding Hannibal's limited role.


6. Bud Fox To Gordon Gekko/Jake Moore - Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps

Wall Street Bud Fox Gordon Gekko
20th Century Fox

The Original: Wall Street is a bit like The Silence Of The Lambs, in that it was a movie whose villain became the biggest thing about it. The protagonist is Charlie Sheen's Bud Fox, who gets ensnared by Michael Douglas' Gordon Gekko, before eventually turning snitch and bringing his empire down. The big distinction between the two is that, compared to Hannibal, Gordon Gekko was even more lauded; everyone knows that eating human flesh isn't a good idea, but many people found a genuine allure in the high flying banking lifestyle and chased it.

The Sequel: Also like The Silence Of The Lambs, the sequel bumped the former villain up to leading man status. Again though, it went further, trying to unashamedly retrofit Gordon into a redemptive hero role (something that actually came out of that obliviously positive reaction to Gekko and his "greed is good" ethos) and also bringing in a new, Bud Fox-esque character played by Shia LaBeouf (which should tell you all you need to know).

What burns so much is that Sheen actually does reprise his role for a short cameo, only for Fox and Gekko to act like old pals reminiscing about the good old days, rather than bitter rivals who destroyed each other's lives.


5. Obi-Wan Kenobi To Anakin Skywalker - Star Wars Episode II: Attack Of The Clones

Star Wars Anakin Obi Wan Jpg
Lucasfilm

The Original: OK, as the Mr Plinkett reviews famously pointed out, there isn't any clearly defined protagonist in The Phantom Menace, but let's use logic to figure out who it's intended to be (as I always say, the prequels are good ideas poorly executed, not rotten to the core).

Given the trilogy is about Anakin's fall, you'd expect it to be him, yet lil' Ani doesn't turn up until halfway through the film. That leaves Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan. Because Liam Neeson goes ashore on Tatooine, he gets the most screentime, but in terms of arc and future, it's Ewan McGregor. Mystery solved.

The Sequel: There's no such debate in Episode II; the lead is clearly the future Darth Vader, smooching his way through bad dialogue and supposedly being the emotional core of the story and serving as the character side to this massive, global conflict. The problem is, Lucas really flubs the love story (and, as a result of lack of focus, the emergence of the Clone Wars too). He really should have kept the focus on Obi-Wan; the Jedi detective stuff is the most interesting part of the film and shows Ewan McGregor's Kenobi at his best.

In truth it's an overall bigger problem with the prequel trilogy; making Anakin the lead means you're stuck telling a known story, so of course the telling would struggle.


4. Alan Grant To Ian Malcolm - The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Jurassic Park Ian Malcolm Alan Grant
Universal Pictures

The Original: Jurassic Park had everything. On the one hand, you've got gigantic dinosaurs that'll rip your arms off, while on the other you've got a set of characters/potential victims you actually care about (this is where Jurassic World didn't quite hit it). At the centre is Alan Grant, and this curmudgeonly paleontologist works as the perfect guide through the theme park gone wrong.

The Sequel: Ian Malcolm is everyone's favourite character from the original because, well, it's Jeff Goldblum and you don't need any more explanation, but that doesn't necessarily mean he should be leading a full movie. To do that you'd need to introduce love interests and family and wider ambitions and he'd wind up a far cry from the man everyone fell in love with.

And guess what they did? To be fair, the focusing on Malcolm wasn't The Lost World's biggest issue (that'd be the complete lack of focus on what the hell the plot is), but it does precipitate the problems and, when you get down to it, really only happened because Goldblum was the actor most interested in returning.

Then again, it's not like Alan Grant coming back worked wonders for the series either (unless talking dream raptors are your thing).


3. Walter To Kermit - Muppets Most Wanted

Muppets Kermit Walter
Disney

The Original: The Muppets is just brilliant. Yes, it's a near pitch-perfect legacy-quel, but taking away love for part-mop part-puppets it's still one of the greatest musicals of the past decade and an alternatively hilarious and affecting film. A critic recently used it as an example of why Rotten Tomatoes is unreliable, to which I say "Mahna Mahna!" What makes it so universal is its accessible characters; Muppet fans Gary (Jason Segel) and Walter (Walter the Muppet) are the purest audience avatars imaginable.

The Sequel: Almost immediately Jason Segel chose to leave the franchise, deciding that after so successfully bringing it back from the brink his job was done, although he's not the character I'm talking about.

The Muppets was all about fanboy Walter becoming a proper member of the gang, but when we got to Muppets Most Wanted, set mere seconds after the original, he was already an established part and focus had shifted to new villains, Kermit and Sam the Eagle. All fair enough, but it snapped the franchise back to the murk it had been in before James Bobin's reboot; the film wasn't up to much and talk of a third is muted.

This is a common problem for long running franchises with eclectic casts; once-leads will end up a background part of the ensemble after a while for no clear reason (see Jessie in Toy Story 3).


2. Steve Hiller To David Levinson - Independence Day: Resurgence

Independence Day Will Smith Jeff Goldblum Jpg
20th Century Fox

The Original: There's not really a single main character to the first Independence Day. It's an ensemble, with the film spending pretty much equal time with David Levinson, President Whitmore Randy Quaid and more. But c'mon, if we're being serious, it's really Steven Hiller. He may be the last one introduced in the film, but from the moment he sees the saucer of LA he's the dominant force, fully embodying the semi-serious tone of the film and giving the generic sci-fi inflections real energy.

The Sequel: Here's another follow-up that Jeff Goldblum wound up taking lead duties on simply because the real original lead chose to not come back, and the result makes The Lost World look like Independence Day (and Independence Day like Jurassic Park). Golblum is the arrow-head of the ensemble this time, but simply doesn't have the same Will Smith charisma to hold up a very bland set; he's linked to all of them - Liam Hemsworth's pilot, Jessie Usher as Will Smith's pilot son and Maika Monroe as Whitmore's pilot daughter (Roland Emmerich has a thing for pilots) - but it never feels real, and the film fumbles on a character level as a result.

Levinson worked great in the original, but he's just not got enough to carry a full movie (exactly like Ian Malcolm).


1. Jason Bourne To Aaron Cross - The Bourne Legacy

Jason Bourne Aaron Cross
Universal Pictures

The Original: The Bourne Trilogy was a major action powerhouse in the mid-naughties, revolutionising the genre's style to the point even Bond aped it for a while. Central to all this though was Matt Damon's amnesiac hero, blasting through the fights almost unaware of how he was able to kick so much ass and always striving to discover his past. Which he did at the end of The Bourne Ultimatum, tying everything up in a nice, tight little bow. Series over, right?

The Sequel: Because neither Damon (nor Greengrass) wanted to return, but Universal wanted to spin Bourne out into a bigger franchise, they opted to go the universe building route and follow a different spy, Aaron Cross, played by Jeremy Renner (otherwise known as the cinematic universe also-ran). Renner wasn't terrible and Legacy not the car-crash some Damon completists claim, but it's just such a trawl. A non-Bourne Bourne movie is intrinsically weakened from a plot standpoint, forced to create a whole host of Treadstone-esque programs, and it doesn't help the hero they chose is so bland you don't want to know his past (which he fully remembers).

Everyone finally got Jason Bourne back in the imaginatively titled Jason Bourne, although despite me thinking the movie was pretty good, many weren't too thrilled about this one either.

Which other movies changed the main character to less than positive results? Share any more we missed down in the comments.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.