10 Simple Fixes That Would Have Saved The Star Wars Sequels

They came so close, but landed so, so, far away...

Star Wars Sequels
LucasFilm

In 2015 Star Wars exploded once again onto the scene with The Force Awakens, a film that promised to take audiences back in time to the Star Wars of old, before the dark times, before the Prequels.

Episode VII showcased a Star Wars which was at once familiar and new, mixing classic elements ("it's another Death Star!") with exciting concepts that would make the franchise feel fresh again ("Master of the Knights of Ren").

Or, at least, that's what should have happened. Fans quickly realised that The Force Awakens relied too much on nostalgia to push the story forward, rehashing A New Hope rather than coming up with ideas of its own. Rian Johnson, who directed Episode VIII, was essentially handed a clean slate, and without a solid foundation to work on created a movie whose only original ideas were retconned when JJ took back the helms for the franchise's final film.

The once promising and exciting trilogy quickly became a disappointing mess, which at best provided some light moments of entertainment and nostalgia and at worst showcased the dark side of Disney, a multi-million dollar corporation who cared more about profit than creating compelling stories.

Still it wasn't all bad, and the cacophony of directors, writers, producers and story board teams came so close at times right before missing the mark. Here are just some of the things Disney and Lucasfilm could have done to save the Star Wars Sequels.

10. Have A Plan From The Beginning

Snoke Star Wars
LucasFilm

This might sound like a big ask, but really, this is the least the multi-billion dollar giant that is Disney could have done with as culturally significant a franchise as Star Wars.

Most of the issues on this list would have been solved had Disney and Lucasfilm's story team outlined at least a general trajectory for the Sequel Trilogy from the beginning. A blueprint would have avoided wasting characters and the back-and-forth retconning that made key plot points like Rey's parentage and the miraculous resurrection of the Emperor so awkward and unpalatable.

The Sequel Trilogy's biggest problem was a lack of cohesion between its constituent parts, leading to them feeling disjointed at times. Watching Star Wars' latest trilogy sometimes feels like watching a tug of war between different directors and producers as they all try to drag the franchise into their preferred direction, resulting in it going nowhere at all.

While it's true that the Original Trilogy also lacked a unified plan (despite what Lucas might have since said, this is especially obvious when considering Luke and Leia's questionable relationship in the first couple of movies), at least the writers and directors that worked on Episodes V and VI unveiled a story which more or less naturally followed on from the events and character motivations established in the previous films.

Instead, Rise of Skywalker retcons The Last Jedi which rectons, in turn, The Force Awakens. The trilogy feels less like a cohesive story than a series of experiments in maximising nostalgia and profit. The fact that The Sequel Trilogy effectively ends in exactly the same way as the Original showcases just how clueless Disney were, revealing they never had a plan for the Saga at all.

Seriously, Disney, you can do better than this.


9. Tease The Emperor At The End Of Episode VIII

Palpatine Rise of Skywalker
Lucasfilm

One of the major complaints of The Rise of Skywalker is that good old Emperor Sheev Palpatine (last seen being torn to shreds by the hand of his own Force Lightning as he fell down an endless shaft in a soon-to-be-destroyed Death Star) conveniently returned in the franchise's last movie with no better explanation than Poe Dameron's exasperating "Somehow, Palpatine has returned." Thanks for clearing that up, JJ.

While the Star Wars story team has since cleared up details of Palpatine's resurrection in other media, audiences shouldn't have to read books to enjoy a series which predominantly exists as a movie franchise.

The Emperor's shadow has always hung over Star Wars and his return wasn't a bad idea in and of itself, but Sheev would have been better utilised in a more minor role, maybe taking the form of a pre-recorded hologram as present in Colin Trevorrow's rejected Episode IX script.

The most exciting thing to come out of The Last Jedi was Kylo Ren's status as the new leader of the First Order. Unfortunately, Palpatine's resurrection meant that we never got to see Supreme Leader Ren unleash his wrath. This decision lead to Kylo following more or less the same story arc as Vader in the Original Trilogy, ensuring The Rise of Skywalker became as much a carbon copy of Return of the Jedi as The Force Awakens was of A New Hope.

To make this surprise appearance less disorientating, Disney really should have teased Palpatine's return at the end of Episode VIII (and no, his brief mention by Luke doesn't count). At the very least, Palpatine's return could have been revealed on-screen rather than being casually mentioned in the worst opening crawl of the franchise (yes, even worse than "The taxation of trade routes ... is in dispute").


8. Make Kylo Ren's Motivations Clear

Star Wars The Last Jedi Trailer Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm

Kylo Ren is the most interesting character of the Sequel Trilogy, a fully-fledged realisation of what Anakin could have been in the Prequel Trilogy in the hands of a better writer than George Lucas.

Throughout the trilogy, Kylo struggles with the Light Side of the Force in a clear inversion of the temptation towards the Dark Side our protagonists felt in the first six movies. While Kylo is unsure about his place in the wider Star Wars mythos, the one thing that is clear is that he resents Snoke, who is holding him back from his true purpose.

Unfortunately, audiences never see what this true purpose is.

Kylo establishes that he wants to "let the past die," but he never indicates what he will replace it with; he asks Rey to take his hand, but never tells her to what end. In The Force Awakens, the Genocidal Murderer Formerly Known As Ben Solo promised his grandfather's molten helmet that he "will finish what you started", but we are never told what he means.

A redeemed Ben certainly helps Rey bring down the Emperor once and for all in the most minor way, but this can't be what he meant: Kylo didn't know the Emperor was alive until Episode IX. Maybe he wanted to kill the remaining Jedi, but why? He resented the Sith as much as the Jedi. Perhaps Kylo felt Luke's Jedi Order was repeating the same mistakes it had made during the Prequels?

The introduction of Palpatine in Episode IX and consequent re-establishment of Kylo as a minor henchman baddie means fans will never find out, nor will they see Ren's vision for a balanced Order come to life.

Kylo Ren's conflicting motivations might make him a more compelling character, but the fact that audiences are never told what he wanted is indicative of poor character design and lack of a fully fledged blueprint for the trilogy.


7. Don't Waste Cool Supporting Characters

Maz Kanata
Lucasfilm

The Force Awakens introduced a tonne of cool concepts and character designs neglected in future Sequel films.

Captain Phasma and the Knights of Ren are the two most obvious examples of underused ideas, their distinctive visual appearance and comparative lack of screen time indicating they were only ever created to shift action figures.

However, Maz Kanata was the most underused of the bunch. Introduced in The Force Awakens, Maz hints she is a Force user despite never alleging herself to the Jedi or the Sith: making her the first neutral Force-sensitive character in Skywalker Saga.

Unfortunately Maz, whose Force scenes were cut from Episode VII's theatrical release, was relegated to a minor contract-fulfilling cameo in The Last Jedi, and returned as nothing more than a minor supporting character in Episode IX.

Originally set up to be the Sequel Trilogy's answer to Yoda, Maz Kanata quickly became just another member of the Resistance performing meaningless tasks in the background as Rey and co took centre stage.

Not only do audiences never find out about Kanata's relationship to the Original Trilogy's Rebellion or just how she got her hands on Luke's Skywalker, poor Maz was reduced to the most overtly fan service moment of the entire Sequel Trilogy. Handing Chewbacca the medal he never received at the end of A New Hope, Maz is transformed from a character to a set piece in a meme before your very eyes. Ahh, the magic of cinema.


6. Swap Hosnian Prime For Coruscant

Star Wars The Force Awakens
Lucasfilm

One of the most emotive shots of Force Awakens is Starkiller Base's destruction of several planets we learn, in a passing throwaway line, to be the Hosnian system.

This line is easy to miss, so fans would be forgiven for thinking that the only planet we see being destroyed up close was Coruscant, capital of the Republic in the Prequel Trilogy.

After all, the tell-tale signs are there: monumental skyscrapers as far as the eye can see, senators looking startled from a balcony, the fact that this planet was given particular emphasis as opposed to the anonymised destruction of the others in the system.

But it turns out the planet was not the same one we had formed an attachment to in Episodes I through III but rather a new, almost identical, location we had never heard of before. Coruscant's destruction would have elicited more of an emotional reaction from the audience, as fans would watch a pivotal planet which had survived the Empire crumble under a new regime before their very eyes.

The destruction of Coruscant would have also helped cement the themes of "letting the past die" the entire Sequel Trilogy worked toward. If JJ really wanted to stick another stake into the corpse of the Prequels, he could have even included a shot of distraught New Republic Senator Jar Jar Binks looking to the sky as he realised his imminent doom in real time. Ah, the catharsis.


5. Actually Show Us Anakin's Force Ghost Instead Of Just Using A Voice

Anakin Skywalker Darth Vader ghost Star Wars: The Force Awakens art of
Lucasfilm

Of all the many, many criticisms levelled against The Rise of Skywalker, the most vocal was that it undermined Anakin Skywalker's legacy, tarnishing a franchise that had once been about the rise, fall, and redemption of the Jedi who would become Darth Vader.

Not only did the Sequel trilogy fail to acknowledge the original Skywalker's pre-Darth Vader persona (seriously, there's no way Kylo Ren would have been unaware of his grandfather's redemption), it also gave Anakin's disembodied Force Ghost the most worst line in the film.

The first six movies in the Skywalker Saga were all about Anakin, so it makes absolutely no sense that he didn't make a significant appearance in the Sequel Trilogy. Return of the Jedi established that Anakin could appear as a Force Ghost, so his absence in the Sequel movies is startling, especially when you'd think he'd want to put a few things right after all the damage he caused.

Surely he would have seen that Luke's Jedi order was repeating the mistakes the Jedi made in the Prequel Trilogy, and warned him to change his ways? Episode IX made clear Force users need to open themselves up to communication to Force Ghosts, but you'd think Kylo Ren would have longed to speak to the grandfather he idolised, listening to his lessons about why following the Dark Side of the Force might not be the best decision someone can make.

Sure, a novel will probably explain this plot hole away by stating that Emperor Palpatine cut off Ren from Anakin's spirit, but seeing Hayden Christensen reprise his role would have been enough to salvage the trilogy. Concept art for The Force Awakens showcased an Anakin Skywalker Force Ghost still corrupt with the Dark Side of the Force, half-human and half-machine.

Not only would this have been the perfect visual analogue to Kylo Ren's wilful removal and wearing of his helmet, this interesting take on a Force Ghost would have embodied the key idea Anakin Skywalker and the Saga have always been about: bringing balance to the Force.


4. Change Anakin's Force Ghost Line

Star Wars Hayden Christensen Ghost Anakin Skywalker
Lucasfilm

Despite being a comparatively minor change, this would have had the biggest implications not just for the Sequel Trilogy but the Skywalker Saga as a whole.

Amongst the voices of disembodied Jedi at the end of The Rise of Skywalker, Hayden Christensen's Anakin Skywalker can be heard saying "Bring balance to the Force, as I did." This line was clearly included by the filmmakers to easily explain away any argument about Anakin's role in the first six movies being undermined, effectively telling fans that the so-called Chosen One did "bring balance to the Force" (whatever that means) but the Force simply fell out of balance again less than thirty years after his death.

It's short enough to be disregarded, but this throwaway line only serves to highlight just how meaningless Anakin's sacrifice at the end of Return of the Jedi was.

The idea that the Force had been balanced so soon before needing balancing again raises questions of its own. Does the Force periodically get thrown out of balance every few decades, needing a new Chosen One to come around and set it straight again? Throughout the entire Saga we are never told what "balance to the Force" actually means, and this line does nothing to clarify this concept.

Instead of telling Rey to "bring balance to the Force, as I did," Anakin's force ghost should have told her to "Finish what I started, and bring balance to the Force".

As well as maintaining the meaningfulness of Anakin's legacy (he weakened the Emperor so that Rey could destroy him), this line would have recalled Kylo's promise to his grandfather that he "will finish what you started". Not only would this have introduced some of the classic cinematic "poetry" Star Wars loves to indulge in, it would have clarified Kylo Ren's motivations, making him a more interesting character in the process.


3. Show Off Vader's Castle

Star Wars the Rise of Skywalker Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm

Turns out the anonymous-looking red planet Kylo Ren made a very brief trip to at the start of The Rise of Skywalker was actually Mustafar of Revenge of the Sith fame, not that you'd notice if you haven't read the film's visual dictionary.

You'd be forgiven for not realising, of course, as Mustafar looked nothing like it did in its last Skywalker Saga appearance. Lava fields have been replaced by dark trees thrown against an ominous red mist, and there's none of the symbolic "more machine than man" metal structures which helped make Obi-Wan and Anakin's final fight so visually compelling.

In fact, Mustafar looks so different that it might as well not be Mustafar at all.

This isn't the first time Disney Star Wars has smuggled in Mustafar without acknowledging its existence. The planet last appeared in 2017's Star Wars Story Rogue One, a movie which made a big deal of labelling the names of its planets on screen. The staggeringly short shot of Mustafar, however, didn't get the same treatment.

Maybe director Gareth Edwards didn't want to spoil Vader's appearance too early (we saw the lava, guys, we knew what was about to happen), but more likely Disney was following its trail of Prequel erasure by reusing assets from the universally panned trilogy without overtly acknowledging its existence.

Either way, it turns out Kylo Ren was looking for the Sith wayfinder amongst the ruins of Vader's castle, which had somehow become a forest overrun by trees in the space of about thirty years. Seeing Vader's castle in all its sinister glory would have not only made it obvious that this opening planet actually had a connection to other movies in the franchise, but also would have been a pretty cool backdrop to an action-packed scene.


2. More Exciting Planets

Star Wars Attack Of The Clones Anakin Padmé
Disney

Say what you like about the Prequels, but at least George Lucas' ill-fated second trilogy introduced interesting planets to the mix, rather than delivering the same mono-environment locations featured in the first three movies.

Seriously, revisit Episodes IV through VI and you'll find that the only remotely interesting planet is Bespin. Sure, Tatooine had its moments, but aside from its infamous Mos Eisley Cantina and Jabba's Palace, it really was just a vast sea of sand.

Anakin would have hated the Sequel trilogy as it introduces not one, but two all new sand planets. Jakku and Pasaana remain the most uninteresting locations in the entire franchise, and there was absolutely no reason that Rey should come from a planet with more than a passing resemblance to Tatooine: except, of course, to explicitly mirror Anakin and Luke's story arcs.

Compare the Sequel Trilogy's dull locations to vibrant planets like Naboo, which treated us to palatial cities coexisting with a symbiotic underwater kingdom; Coruscant, a planet-sprawling metropolis with its buzzing criminal underworld; and Kamino, with its startlingly white Clone factory and its dramatic seascape. Ach-To was pretty nice visually but there wasn't much there, and the most exciting planet introduced in the entire Sequel trilogy was Canto Bight, which was wasted at best.


1. A More Original Start To The Trilogy

starkiller base
lucasfilm

Although The Force Awakens was universally praised by audiences and critics upon its release, over the last few years fans have begun to realise that the movie relied a little too much on what had come before.

Being essentially a soft reboot after the disappointment that was the Prequel Trilogy, it was inevitable that Disney's punt at a trio of Skywalker stories would lean heavily on what made the Original Trilogy such a lovable cash cow in the first place: namely, props and sets that imitated a lived-in world rather than shoddy CGI, character-centric stories, and a compelling mythos which left no room for Midi-chlorians.

But JJ Abrams and crew might have taken their exercise in nostalgia a step too far. Rather than just imitating the film-making techniques and principles that cemented the 1977 Star Wars as a classic, they copied the whole story all together.

Of course, some things are different ("This was the Death Star," Poe Dameron says, "And this is Starkiller Base." "Wow!" the audience screams, "it's a completely original idea!"), but the similarities between The Force Awakens and A New Hope are too obvious to overlook.

There's the old mentor figure (Obi-Wan Kenobi, Han Solo), the evil military regime (The Empire, The First Order), the hero from a desert planet (Luke, Rey), ... the list stretches on and on for so long that it warrants an article of its own.

While The Force Awakens served as the perfect franchise reset after the sour taste of the Prequels, in hindsight a lot of its story decisions are just uninteresting. What's more, Episode VII's decision to retell the story of A New Hope only makes the Original Trilogy redundant. All of the Resistance's sacrifices are rendered null given that the galaxy reverted back to the exact same state they had found it in. Boring.

The most interesting part of the trilogy (Kylo and Rey's relationship) could have been maintained in a lower-stakes scenario. The decision to retread A New Hope plagued the rest of the Sequels from the start, as its following movies almost inevitably had to then follow the pattern set out in first three movies.

We get Star Wars is about, well, Wars, but maybe this could have involved a different threat rather than a third galactic civil war? That's a conversation for the next three movies...


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Wars
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

When Matteo isn't cashing in on a lifetime of devotion to his favourite pop culture franchises and indie bands, he's writing and publishing poems and short stories under the name Teo Eve. Talk about range.