10 Small Details You Missed In Dune

A look at some of the most interesting things that the movie glossed over for runtime!

Dune Mentat
Warner Bros.

The Dune series, created by Frank Herbert, has one of the most detailed, and at times confusing universes ever thought of in science fiction. That's the reason why so many people thought a movie adaptation could never work.

The 1980's Dune by David Lynch seemed to confirm this as, although it was a fun visual spectacle and definitely got the aesthetic right, huge parts of the plot were removed and the story was dumbed down into a basic hero narrative.

However, with the new Dune movie by Denis Villeneuve being split into two parts, many fans were optimistic that the extended run time would give the audience more time to get to know the world and the types of people who live in it.

Still though, with dozens of words like mentat, Sardaukar, Bene Gesserit, and spice melange being thrown around every five seconds, it can be hard for someone who doesn't already know the backstory to keep track of all of it, so today let's take a look at ten of the biggest details in the new Dune movie that you may have missed!

10. The Lack Of Computers (The Butlerian Jihad)

dune gurney halleck sword shield
Warner Bros.

Although much truer to the book series than David Lynch's Dune, the new movie still does leave out certain important details, mostly dealing with the backstory of how human society became structured the way it is.

Watching Dune, you may notice that something seems very different from your average sci-fi blockbuster. One of the biggest reasons is that in Dune, all computers (thinking machines) are banned. This is because thousands of years before the events of the movie, humanity lived in a world dominated by computers. Artificial intelligence had surpassed human intelligence and humans had become obsolete. Out of fear of being replaced, humanity rose up against the computers and destroyed them all in what became known as the Butlerian Jihad.

After the machines were all destroyed, all computers, even the most simple calculators were banned by the new empire. Only machines which did not use digital computations were allowed, such as basic engines and mechanical systems. Humanity realized that a computer is merely an artificial brain and, as the Orange Catholic Bible (created after the jihad) states, "thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind," both out of fear of being destroyed and being replaced.


9. Mentats & The Meaning Behind The Dyed Lips 

dune thufir hawat mentat
Warner Bros.

One of the consequences of destroying all computers during the Butlerian Jihad was that humans were now required to do all complex calculations themselves. This eventually led to the creation of the mentat order.

Mentats are basically human computers. They are trained and selectively bred for generations to be able to do extremely advanced calculations in their heads in an instant. They also have nearly perfect memory and a highly advanced perception which makes them valuable to military powers.

House Atreides (Paul's House) employs a mentat known as Thufir Hawat (pictured above). Like many mentats, Thufir's bottom lip is stained from his addiction to drinking sapho juice, a chemical that can greatly increase a mentat's mental abilities. His eyes are also rolled back, signifying that at this particular moment he is doing one of his mentat calculations, trying to analyze the situation from every possible viewpoint objectively and come to the absolute truth of the matter.

House Harkonnen also employed mentats but they were conditioned to ignore morality when it suited them. They were known as twisted mentats.


8. How Thumpers Actually Work

dune sandworm
Warner Bros.

The planet Dune (also known as Arrakis) is a desert planet dominated by giant sandworms that the local people, the Fremen, worship as gods.

The sandworms tunnel at high speeds beneath the sand and catch smaller animals in their mouths. However, many people may have missed the method that the sandworms use to detect their prey, as it was only mentioned briefly. The sandworms are able to detect the rhythm of the vibrations of footsteps on the surface. When they detect something walking with rhythm, they know it couldn't be just natural wind and they immediately attack.

For this reason, the Fremen of Arrakis have learned to walk without rhythm in a dance-like style that imitates the natural sound of the wind. They have also invented the thumper, a simple piston that pounds on the ground rhythmically, luring any nearby sandworms by making them believe there is something walking. The Fremen often use thumpers to lure sandworms away from their path while they walk without rhythm past them.

In the movie, Liet Kynes, the Judge of the Change attempts to call a worm with a thumper to ride it away to safety but when she is killed before being able to hop on, the worm arrives and consumes her and her attackers.


7. Shield Mechanics

dune shield paul gurney halleck training
Warner Bros.

While doing combat training with Paul, Josh Brolin's character, Gurney Halleck explains "the slow blade penetrates the shield." This isn't just a metaphor - this is because in Dune, all soldiers are equipped with personal energy shields that block anything fast-moving from touching them. Unfortunately, they still need to breathe, so anything moving slowly (oxygen, for example) would have to be permitted (unless the soldiers all had oxygen tanks, which is far more costly).

The invention of shields made all fast-moving projectile weapons useless which is why in Dune we see the return to traditional melee combat, with some slight changes. Soldiers must now get in close to their opponent and try to elegantly and slowly penetrate their shield before they can do any damage, all while trying to keep their opponent from penetrating their shield.

With these new conditions, combat had turned much more fast-paced with soldiers trying to stay moving as much as possible to avoid the slow blade penetrating the shield. the movie does an excellent job of showing this new style of combat. They effect of blue to show a block and red to show something penetrating the shield was a nice touch.


6. Bene Gesserit Impact On The Fremen Culture

Dune Rebecca Ferguson
Warner Bros.

When Paul passes his "Gom Jabbar" pain test, as the Reverend Mother speaks to Jessica she tells her "a path has been cleared." This is a small hint of the work the Bene Gesserit have been doing in the shadows on Arrakis.

The Bene Gesserit work in the shadows to spread their Missionaria Protectiva, a codename for their practice of creating superstitions in less technologically advanced cultures in order to manipulate and control them. They spread myths and legends in these primitive societies (such as the Fremen of Dune) to prepare them for their chosen one, the Kwisatz Haderach.

This is why the Fremen people saw Paul as their possible savior and referred to him as Lisan Al-Gaib (their prophesied messiah), because they had been conditioned to expect him for thousands of years by the Bene Gesserit. The Fremen didn't know however that the Kwisatz Haderach was meant to be the male equivalent of a Bene Gesserit Reverend Mother with the ability to see into the future and guide humanity on a better path.

After arriving at Dune, Jessica even speaks to one of the religious leaders of the Fremen, Shadout Mapes (who gives her the crysknife), and knows the exact buzz words to use to gain her trust, as her entire world-view was conditioned by the Bene Gesserit.


5. Paul And Jessica Could Not Be Killed Directly

Dune Timothee Chalamet Rebecca Ferguson
Warner Bros.

After Dune is invaded and taken back by the Harkonnens, Paul and Jessica are tied up and brought into an ornithopter to be dumped into the desert. This leaves the audience wondering, if they intend to kill them, why not just get it over with? Shortly after though we hear an explanation from one of the pilots.

The pilot explains to the others that they can not directly kill Paul and Jessica because they may face a truthsayer, a specially trained Bene Gesserit who is able to detect lies based on the tiniest of facial movements and breathing patterns.

Although the attack on Dune was (unofficially) sanctioned by the Emperor, killing these two was off the table. However, House Harkonnen still wanted them dead so they were forced to have them die by other, less direct means so, if ever faced by a truthsayer, they could say "we didn't kill them."

The Harkonnens do not expect them to survive for more than a day in the deep desert, surrounded by sandworms and with no food, water, or stillsuits. Fortunately they are able to escape using the Voice.


4. Paul And The Spice

dune paul crysknife fight battle
Warner Bros.

The Bene Gesserit use the spice melange in many of their rituals and were bred to have a high sensitivity to it. Paul also has this innate sensitivity which is why, when helping the spice harvester workers escape the worm, he paused and fell to his knees. He had never been exposed to that much spice in the air and was having a vision of possible futures as a reaction.

Paul has this reaction many other times throughout the course of the movie. This is foreshadowing his prescient abilities that he is destined to one day gain by drinking the water of life or die in the process.

However, most of this is a mystery to Paul, which is why he is so surprised when he overhears Jessica speaking to another Bene Gesserit about the Kwisatz Haderach and grows suspicious of their plans. He knew he was destined for great things as the son of a Duke and spent most of his life training to be a warrior and a philosopher but as Reverend Mother Gaius Mohiam says to Paul while testing him, "you have more than one birthright, boy!"

Paul fails to realize how important he is to his mother and the Bene Gesserit.


3. The Future Is Not Absolute

dune paul jamis fight
Warner Bros.

Before the movie even starts, some viewers may have noticed the words "dreams are messages from the deep" with a deep throat-speaking voice (the voice of a Sardaukar). This serves as our introduction to Paul's future-sensing dreams. Prior to encountering the spice, Paul's visions of the future were limited to his dreams. We see clearly that he will dream things just as they happen but it is not always 100% accurate.

One scene that shows the flaws in Paul's prescience is when he is with Jessica in the desert and has a vision of his battle with Jamis, the Fremen at the end of the movie. In the vision we see Paul stabbed by Jamis and we also see a future of him and Jamis being friends and Jamis acting as Paul's mentor.

As we know, the events didn't play out like that. Jamis was killed by Paul in ritual combat. This is because Paul's visions are not of the absolute future but rather projections of what the most likely futures will be if he does certain things. His dreams are messages from the deep, the deep being the deep past, which Paul uses to inform his prescience.


2. Riding The Sandworms

dune sandworm spice harvester ornithopter
Warner Bros.

At the end of the film, just as Chani says to Paul, "this is only the beginning," hyping the audience up for part two, we see, for a split second, an unnamed Fremen riding atop a sandworm far off in the desert. After seeing how uncontrollable and dangerous the sandworms of Arrakis are to anyone else, watching the Fremen guide them with ease is quite a sight to behold.

The practice of riding sandworms to traverse the desert is common among the Fremen and all Fremen children must learn to control them as a rite of passage. This is also why, after Liet Kynes (a Fremen) summons a sandworm with a thumper, just before she is killed, she prepares her hooks. These hooks are used to guide the sandworms and are called maker hooks.

Unfortunately we only get to see a small clip of someone riding a sandworm in this first movie, mostly just to show the true desert power of the Fremen.


1. The Trees Of Arrakis

dune caladan paul water
Warner Bros.

In the Dune universe, terraforming (turning planets in more livable environments) is fairly common. Planets are seeded with plant and animal life from ancient Earth (which is now mostly lost to time) and given satellites which can influence weather.

Dune however, despite being the most valuable planet to own in the universe, has not been terraformed at all and remains a treacherous desert where finding water is a daily struggle. This is because if Dune were to be terraformed (more water and plant life added) the sandworms (who produce the insanely valuable spice melange) would all be killed. They need the dry desert to survive as water in large amounts is poison to them.

However, many Fremen still hold the dream that one day Dune may become a lush, tropical paradise with oceans stretching beyond the horizon. This is why they keep the tree's at the capitol building, despite being a waste of water. It's out of hope that one day Dune could be made into something beautiful.


In this post: 
Dune
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Marcia Fry is a writer for WhatCulture and an amateur filmmaker.