10 Star Wars Moments You'll Never See Again
George Lucas made sure you'll never see these Star Wars moments (officially) ever again.
Star Wars is undeniably one of the most successful franchises in the history of not only cinema but pop-culture as a whole, and though the series has created many lifelong memories for fans both young and old, there are also some that you'll never be able to officially see ever again.
It's no secret of course that George Lucas has used modern technology to "revise" the earlier Star Wars films over the last 25 years, and rather than continue to offer both the original, untouched versions and the newer editions, Lucas has basically done away with what came before.
Unless you're lucky enough to own an old VHS or DVD of the earlier releases, you're left resorting to YouTube clips or less-savory means to watch the films in their original release state.
Given that Lucas sees these new versions as "definitive", and they're also the only versions viewable on Disney+, it's incredibly unlikely that the original versions will ever be re-released.
While it's fair to say that not all of Lucas' changes were sacrilegious - some, in fact, were actually pretty smart - it nevertheless stands that these moments can't be officially seen in their pristine initial form ever again...
10. Han Shoots First - A New Hope
Let's kick things off with the single most infamous change instituted by George Lucas across the entire Star Wars franchise.
In the original version of A New Hope, Han Solo (Harrison Ford) memorably guns down bounty hunter Greedo (Paul Blake) in the Mos Eisley cantina - an act which demonstrates his cunning ruthlessness, taking out a threat before said threat can get the drop on him.
Yet for the 1997 Special Edition of the film, Lucas made the decision to digitally alter the scene, showing Greedo firing at Han first, before Han awkwardly dodges it and then fires back, killing him.
Fans argued that this diminished Han's character arc over the course of the original trilogy, softening his personality as originally presented, while Lucas has since maintained that he never intender to portray Han as a "cold-blooded killer."
Though the scene has received mild revisions in subsequent home video releases, Han shooting first has never been restored to any official version of A New Hope, and given Lucas' passionate stance on Han's rules of engagement, surely never will be.
9. Sebastian Shaw's Anakin Force Ghost - Return Of The Jedi
Return of the Jedi of course concludes with a triumphant Rebel celebration, where Luke (Mark Hamill) notices the Force spirits of Obi-Wan (Alec Guinness), Yoda (Frank Oz), and Anakin Skywalker (Sebastian Shaw) observing nearby.
In the original release, the Anakin Force ghost was played by Sebastian Shaw, who also portrayed Anakin during his iconic unmasking scene earlier in the film.
But for the 2004 Special Edition re-release, Lucas re-edited the scene to replace Shaw with Hayden Christensen, who of course played a younger Anakin in the prequel trilogy.
While the logic here is at least understandable, that Lucas wanted to create a greater sense of visual continuity between the prequels and original trilogy, does it even make sense to have Anakin's Force ghost resemble his younger self?
Some attempt to explain this away by suggesting that Anakin truly "died" when he became Vader, but it's a bit of a stretch.
Some took further issue with the not-great compositing job, where Christensen's head was just blatantly superimposed over the top of Shaw's body.
And then there are those who simply object to Hayden Christensen being injected into the original films in any form on pure principle.
8. The Proto-Palpatine Hologram - The Empire Strikes Back
But here's a change that actually has its fair share of supporters, even as some would prefer that Lucas simply left the original trilogy alone.
In The Empire Strikes Back, Emperor Palpatine makes his first appearance in the series via a hologram, though at the time of the film's release, Ian McDiarmid hadn't yet been cast in the part in earnest.
And so, the cameo was physically portrayed by Marjorie Eaton under heavy layers of makeup - complete with chimpanzee eyes superimposed over the eye sockets - while the voice was provided by Clive Revill.
From the 2004 Special Edition onwards, however, Eaton and Revill's work has been deleted, with the hologram footage being re-shot with Ian McDiarmid in place, with alterations also being made to the original dialogue.
Again, the effort to create visual continuity throughout the series makes sense, and the original Palpatine makeup doesn't exactly look great, yet many fans argue that jettisoning Eaton and Revill's work from the franchise is cruel and unnecessary.
Plus, changing Leigh Brackett and Lawrence Kasdan's original dialogue added nothing worthwhile to the scene.
7. Puppet Yoda - The Phantom Menace
Here's another change that's actually a bit less controversial than it might at first seem.
If you saw The Phantom Menace in the cinema or watched the earlier home video releases, Yoda was actually portrayed as a physical puppet for the most part, but dissatisfied with the results, Lucas opted to replace him with a digital double from the 2011 Blu-ray release onwards.
It's an interesting choice - though Star Wars fans generally do bang the drum for the original, charming puppet Yoda, in the case of The Phantom Menace the puppet really doesn't seem up to snuff, and clashes harshly with the film's pervasively digital aesthetic.
As such, while not everybody loves the CGI Yoda throughout the prequels, this is one alteration which isn't exactly infuriating, even though many surely wish the puppet version was still readily available without seeking out a 20-year-old DVD.
6. Lapti Nek & Yub Nub - Return Of The Jedi
Two majorly involved changes that Lucas made to Return of the Jedi continue to infuriate fans to this very day. The film's initial release included two songs which were ultimately replaced in more recent releases.
Firstly in Jabba the Hutt's palace, the Max Rebo Band and Sy Snootles perform a song called "Lapti Nek," which Lucas swapped out for the more contemporary-yet-obnoxious "Jedi Rocks."
Lucas didn't stop there, though: he also replaced the puppet of Sy Snootles with an obnoxiously cartoonish CGI equivalent, and added nine more members to the Max Rebo Band.
And secondly, there's the climactic Rebel celebration, which was originally scored to the song "Yub Nub," but later replaced with a new John Williams track entitled "Victory Celebration."
While the original songs aren't exactly masterpieces by any metric, they do hold a special place in the hearts of fans who grew up with Return of the Jedi, and so replacing them with more "modern" music only undermined that initial feeling.
Sadly, CGI Sy Snootles is here to stay.
5. Boba Fett's Original Voice - The Empire Strikes Back
The Empire Strikes Back of course introduced audiences to bounty hunter Boba Fett, and until the 2004 Special Edition, Fett was voiced with acid-tongued delight by Jason Wingreen.
But in order to reflect the prequel revelation that Boba was a clone of Jango Fett (Temuera Morrison), Lucas had Morrison record Wingreen's original lines and then plugged them into the 2004 re-release.
As much as we all love Morrison and his portrayals of both Jango and Boba Fett, there's just no contest between him and Wingreen.
Listening to the two side-by-side, Wingreen's line readings are imbued with a greater sense of menace and mystery that truly made the audience want to know more about this masked man.
Morrison's delivery, on the other hand, sounds weirdly casual and off-the-cuff, like Lucas just had Morrison record a single take and decided that was good enough.
4. Vader Silently Betrays Palpatine - Return Of The Jedi
Here's a change that really pisses a lot of fans off, because it basically dilutes the intensity of one of the series' most iconic moments and arguably even renders it unintentionally comical.
Originally in Return of the Jedi, Darth Vader (David Prowse) silently betrays Emperor Palpatine and throws him to his death, but seemingly because Lucas felt the scene needed to spell every emotional beat out for the audience, he added some extra vocalisations to it.
For the 2011 Blu-ray re-release, Lucas added Vader saying "No" as he watches Palpatine torture Luke with Force lightning, and then letting out a more prolonged "Noooooo" as he picks Palpatine up.
For one, it just makes everyone remember Vader's laughable "Nooooo" from Revenge of the Sith - perhaps Lucas' baffling intention, in fact - and needlessly spells out Vader's emotions which are already made perfectly clear by his body language and actions.
It's an incredibly awkward addition that shows a lack of faith in the audience to intuit basic, obvious emotion, and surely makes fans the world over cringe every time they're forced to endure it.
3. The Victory Celebration Without Gungans - Return Of The Jedi
Even with the changes made to its music throughout the years, Return of the Jedi's Rebel celebration is an undeniably triumphant cinematic moment, right?
Yet George Lucas made an arguably even more egregious change to the scene for the 2004 Special Edition, when he decided to add the thing every single Star Wars fan surely wanted to see included in the scene: Gungans.
In yet another attempt to tie the prequels and original films together, the celebration montage is extended to show a giant celebration in Naboo, complete with Gungans visible atop a building as one of them screams ecstatically, "Wesa free!"
Given that the Gungans remain one of the most divisive aspects of the prequels, throwing them into the originals where they had no presence previously was always going to ruffle a lot of feathers.
Had they simply been a silent part of the celebrations it would've been fine enough, yet the moment we hear one of them bleating from the rooftops, we're instantly pulled out of a euphoric moment and reminded of just how damn annoying Jar Jar Binks (Ahmed Best) truly was.
2. The Creepier Sarlacc Design - Return Of The Jedi
Another divisive change Lucas made for the Special Edition release of Return of the Jedi was digitally altering the sarlacc from its original design, adding CGI tentacles, a beak, and a tongue.
Yet this ultimately reeks of over-design that gives far too much away.
As originally presented in the movie, the sarlacc was made all the more terrifying in its ambiguity and mystery, but by making it seem more recognisably animalistic through its physiology, the sarlacc was too made considerably less interesting.
Lucas has stated that he revised the design to make the sarlacc seem more "alive," but wasn't that precisely what made the sarlacc so damn creepy in the original version of Return of the Jedi?
By making it more obvious and cartoonish, much of that initial cosmic horror vibe was aggressively ripped away.
1. The Original Mos Eisley Introduction - A New Hope
There are few Star Wars scenes more distinctive, memorable, or straight-up iconic than the introduction to Mos Eisley, and yet George Lucas evidently wasn't entirely happy with how it initially panned out, so decided to make it "busier" for the Special Edition re-release.
While we'll give Lucas some minor credit for cleaning up some shots that looked a little scratchy in the original cut and adding some not-bad establishing shots of the area, Lucas just couldn't resist but drown Mos Eisley in garish, overbaked CGI chaos.
In an attempt to make Mos Eisley seem like a more bustling place, Lucas added new digital creatures to many shots while also using VFX to extend the backgrounds.
The most egregious change occurs when Luke, Obi-Wan, C-3PO (Anthony Daniels), and R2-D2 (Kenny Baker) are stopped by Stormtroopers and Obi-Wan performs the Jedi mind trick.
For reasons that will never become clear, a gigantic CGI Ronto walks in front of the frame for several seconds, obscuring our view of the scene in a misguided attempt to make it seem more teeming.
CGI is a wonderful tool in the right hands, but as Lucas has proven so often, it can also be a source of frustration and even destruction when wielded without due diligence.