10 Star Wars Scenes Everyone Gets Wrong

You're (probably) wrong about these Star Wars scenes.

Star Wars The Last Jedi Luke
Disney

The Star Wars franchise is such a gargantuan beast of an IP that it's basically impossible for everyone to know every single thing about it.

All the same, sometimes fans en masse miss the mark on a scene for one reason or another - whether bad filmmaking, audiences not paying enough attention, or an unfortunate combination of the two - resulting in half-truths and flat-out misinformation being held up as fact among the fandom.

And that's certainly true of the following ten Star Wars scenes, which despite mostly ranking among the more distinctive moments from their respective movies, have all been wildly misinterpreted by a vast swath of the fanbase. Again, Star Wars is a complex, labyrinthine enough entity that you can't really be blamed for spacing out on some of the finer details, though in others, the movie in question basically spells out the right answer, only for a great majority of viewers to totally gloss over it.

So, we offer up a refresher of ten oft-misread Star Wars scenes while plainly explaining what they're really about. You're free to prefer your own interpretation of course, as long as you remember that it's not technically correct...

10. Balance To The Force Isn't A Numbers Game

Star Wars Revenge of the Sith Obi-Wan
Disney

Let's kick things off with one of the single most misinterpreted aspects of Star Wars lore, that "bringing balance to the Force" isn't - contrary to popular opinion - a simple numbers game. 

That is to say, the Force isn't in balance when there are two Jedi and two Sith. 

Despite what some fans might think, the Force definitely isn't in balance at the end of the prequels simply because we have Obi-Wan (Ewan McGregor) and Yoda (Frank Oz) on one side, and Anakin (Hayden Christensen) and Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) on the other.

The mere existence of the Sith is imbalance, with George Lucas himself even referring to them as a "cancer" which needs to be removed in order to achieve balance. The Dark Side of the Force can never die, but the Sith who indulge in it absolutely can.

Only when the Jedi prevail over the Sith and the Dark Side is kept at bay, can true balance be realised.


9. The Stromtroopers Were Ordered To Miss

Star Wars: A New Hope Stormtroopers
Disney

Even the most casual Star Wars fan is well aware of the enduring trope that the Stormtroopers are apparently terrible marksmen who can't hit anything to save their lives. And their inability to hit the heroes during their escape from the Death Star in A New Hope is often cited as a prime indication of their incompetence.

Yet this completely ignores the fact that the Stormtroopers were very clearly ordered to miss Luke (Mark Hamill), Leia (Carrie Fisher), and Han (Harrison Ford) during their exit.

This is bafflingly missed by many fans despite Leia literally saying out loud, "They let us go. It's the only explanation for the ease of our escape... They're tracking us." In the very next scene, Grand Moff Tarkin (Peter Cushing) says to Darth Vader (David Prowse), "You're sure the homing beacon is secure aboard their ship?"

There really would've been nowhere to go had the Stormtroopers wounded or killed the heroes; the plan was always to shoot wide, let them escape, and then learn the location of the Rebel base on Yavin 4.

Basically, of course they were ordered to miss!


8. "Kill The Past" Isn't The Last Jedi's Goal

Star Wars The Last Jedi Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm

It's fair to say that The Last Jedi broke a good portion of the Star Wars fandom, and though many fans had totally reasoned criticisms of Rian Johnson's divisive sequel, much of the ire stemmed from a patent misinterpretation of the movie's themes.

To many, Kylo Ren's (Adam Driver) memorable one-liner about the past - "Let the past die. Kill it if you have to" - was seen to represent Johnson's own designs on the Star Wars franchise, that he wanted to kill the series' past by subverting audience expectations and then quite literally killing Luke Skywalker at the end.

But first and foremost, it's important to remember that Kylo Ren is a card-carrying villain, so why would any filmmaker let an antagonistic figure become the mouthpiece for the movie's Big Message?

Did Johnson want to ditch the dustier, more unearned sentimentality of prior Star Wars movies and do something different? Absolutely, but if you pay much attention to the film at all, it's very clearly about embracing and learning from the past - Yoda even memorably tells Luke, "The greatest teacher, failure is."


7. Jedi Can't Marry (But They Can Have Sex)

Star Wars Attack of the Clones Anakin
Disney

Attack of the Clones introduced the notion that Anakin's romance with Padmé (Natalie Portman) was strictly forbidden, with Padmé pointing out that Jedi aren't allowed to marry. 

This led many fans to assume that the Jedi aren't allowed to have romantic entanglements of any kind, and that they're basically functionally celibate. Yet this isn't true at all, and Anakin straight-up says it in the movie himself, noting that attachment and possession are what is forbidden by the Jedi Order.

However, the Order never said anything about casual romantic relationships with a healthy amount of emotional distance, and certainly not one-night stands.

George Lucas confirmed as much to be true in a 2002 CNN interview, reiterating that celibacy isn't something the Jedi are policing. Rather, it's the more emotionally involved relationships which are forbidden, where a Jedi could potentially be lured to the Dark Side to protect it. Case in point, Anakin.


6. C-3PO's Right Leg Was Silver In The Original Trilogy

Star Wars C3PO R2D2
Disney

Here's something so many people get wrong about the original trilogy that it's basically become a Mandela Effect phenomenon in its own right on social media.

If you confidently assert that C-3PO (Anthony Daniels) is coloured entirely gold in the originals, you'd be dead wrong. Wait, what?!

Threepio's right leg is actually painted silver from below the knee, but because the silver finish is incredibly reflective, in many shots it simply reflects the gold from the other leg, making it also appear gold. Couple this with the few low-angle shots we actually see of Threepio's legs and ankles at all, and it's easy to see why so many fans get this one wrong.

Heck, some fans even go beyond the Mandela Effect to suggest that George Lucas must've changed C-3PO's leg colour in more recent years, which considering all the tinkering Lucas has done with the original trilogy over the decades, actually isn't that wild a theory - but still totally untrue.

Hilariously, the silver leg not only slid past millions of fans, but also the folks in charge of Star Wars merchandise, as the original C-3PO action figures had no hint of silver whatsoever.


5. Bombs Can Fall In Space (With Some Help)

Star Wars The Last Jedi Paige
Lucasfilm

Because the polarising response to The Last Jedi caused dissatisfied fans to approach every single scene with the least charitable mindset imaginable, of course we have to discuss the very concept of gravity.

In the film's opening sequence, we see Paige Tico (Veronica Ngô) drop bombs from a ship in zero gravity, but as anyone with even a cursory understanding of physics can appreciate, this should be impossible. This prompted many fans to disparage the scene for disobeying basic science, except that's not really the case at all.

In a post-release interview, the film's visual effects supervisor Ben Morris clarified that he and filmmaker Rian Johnson decided that the bombs were magnetic and launched out of the ship, ensuring they would travel downwards and hit their target.

Hate on The Last Jedi all you want, but in a movie about space wizards wielding laser swords, are magnetically propelled bombs really a stretch, like, at all?


4. Luke's "Force Kick" Wasn't A Mistake

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Luke
Lucasfilm

For all of the dozens of times we've all seen Return of the Jedi, many fans keenly sneer at the "mistake" when Luke Skywalker whiffs kicking one of Jabba the Hutt's lackeys in the face while attempting to rescue Leia.

As many have pointed out over the decades, Luke's foot doesn't get even close to connecting with the soldier's face, but this isn't even remotely a case of the stunt team screwing up the action beat.

Storyboards for the scene confirm that Luke was always meant to kick from afar, as was later entered into Star Wars canon as a "Force kick" - albeit more recently relegated to the Legends continuity.

Sure, the actual choreography of the scene still looks pretty clumsy, but when comparing the final shot to the storyboard, they totally nailed what Lucas had in his head. Hilariously, Mark Hamill himself couldn't resist but recently post a joking tweet about the "widely celebrated, perfectly executed Force kick."


3. Obi-Wan Isn't An Absolute Hypocrite

Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith
Disney

One of the most widely-memed moments from the Star Wars prequels occurs in the climax of Revenge of the Sith, when Obi-Wan tells Anakin, "Only a Sith deals in absolutes" prior to their historic battle.

Many fans have relished mocking the "hypocrisy" of Obi-Wan's statement, that he's chiding Anakin for making an absolute statement while making one himself. And more to the point, we've heard the Jedi make absolute statements before, such as Yoda's "Do or do not, there is no try."

But context is a thing, and with that in mind, there's nothing wrong with what Obi-Wan says.

It's first important to note that Obi-Wan was replying to Anakin after he said, "If you're not with me... then you are my enemy" - as blunt an absolute statement as they come, and one which was entirely unbecoming of a Jedi.

Secondly, Obi-Wan says "deals" not "speaks" - a small but significant distinction, reflecting Anakin's decision to not merely speak out the situation, but strategically destroy any prospect of a middle-ground between the Jedi and Sith.


2. Luke Considering Killing Ben Wasn't Out Of Character

Star Wars The Last Jedi Luke Skywalker Ben Solo flashback
Lucasfilm

One of the more intriguing - if controversial - flourishes in The Last Jedi is the Rashomon-inspired manner in which we see three different accounts of the fateful night that Luke drew his lightsaber against a young Ben Solo aka Kylo Ren.

The first flashback, told by Luke, suggests that a rage-filled Kylo simply turned on his master, while the second, relayed by Kylo, claims that he acted in self-defense after Luke activated his lightsaber out of fear of Kylo's powers.

And then there's the third (and presumably correct) version, told by Luke to Rey (Daisy Ridley), where he claims he sensed the darkness building in Kylo and instinctively drew his lightsaber only to immediately regret it, at which point Kylo responded in self-defense.

Many complained that this was a deeply out-of-character moment for Luke, that the hero of the original trilogy would never dare consider killing a Jedi student. But first and foremost, it's naive and just plain wrong to suggest that people don't change massively over the span of decades.

More to the point, the original trilogy didn't exactly paint Luke as a purely squeaky-clean hero either. We saw glimpses of fleeting darkness within him - such as when he snapped on Vader during their climactic fight in Return of the Jedi - and so a moment of instinctual weakness which he instantly regretted isn't remotely inconsistent with who Luke is.

It just adds further shade and dimension to his character, honestly.


1. Anakin's Infamous "Sand" Line Makes Total Sense

Star Wars Attack of the Clones Anakin Padme
Lucasfilm

And finally, there's surely no more ridiculed line in the prequels than Anakin's infamous sand speech to Padmé, where he says, "I don't like sand. It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere."

Now, are there reasons to take umbrage with this scene? Absolutely - the acting is wooden and the dialogue clunky, adding up to a "romantic" scene that's admittedly tough not to snigger at - but Star Wars fans were so quick to jump on the bandwagon and rip this scene to shreds, many without at least appreciating the context of Anakin and Padme's conversation.

It's important to remember that Anakin isn't going off on a goofy non-sequitur here - he's comparing his experiences with sand growing up as a slave on Tatooine to Padme's privileged childhood, where she went swimming on Naboo and let the sun dry her off while she rested on the sand.

Does this mean you're wrong for smirking at the execution of the scene? Absolutely not, but for all of the context-free mockery this scene gets, it's still worth appreciating the full content of what Anakin is actually saying here, awkward though it is.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Wars
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.