10 Stephen King Stories That Wouldn't Work As Movies

Stephen King may be a best-selling author, but not every story deserves a theatrical release.

Stephen King It Chapter 2
Warner Bros.

Since the film adaptation of Carrie was released in 1976, Hollywood has steadily squeezed proverbial blood from Stephen King's creative stone. As of this writing, more that 50 live action adaptations have been made of King's work. King adaptations fall into a few different categories. Sometimes a good story spurs a good adaptation (Misery). Other times a good story spurs a lackluster adaptation (Thinner).

There have even been a couple of times when the adaptation is superior to the original text (The Shawshank Redemption). Regardless of quality, much of King's catalog has either been adapted, in the process of being adapted, or have had failed attempts of adaptation. In defense of the author, not all of his work was meant to be shown on screen. Some of King's most effective work takes place in the reader's own mind rather than on the page. The horror we imagine is worse than the horror we see.

King has produced a number of short stories that just work best as short stories. When the taffy is pulled too thin and the story too diluted to fill 90 minutes, even a solid narrative can lose its way. These ten tales are best left to the written page and our imaginations.

10. Mrs. Todd's Shortcut

Stephen King Mrs Todd's Shortcut
Redbook

Included in the short story collection Skeleton Crew, Mrs. Todd's Shortcut is a strange little sci-fi yarn about an aging woman who seems to violate the laws of space and time by finding shortcuts to wherever she goes in her car. Each trip also seems to de-age Mrs. Todd. The story is told from the perspective of Homer, who experienced these trips with Mrs. Todd firsthand.

The plot concerns Mrs. Todd, who is obsessed with finding shortcuts. Homer admires her persistence but begins to have doubts, as there are only so many shortcuts someone can find. Mrs. Todd compares the shortcuts to folding a map, suggesting she has discovered a warped version of reality, like a worm hole.

Homer joins Mrs. Todd on one of her trips and begins to suspect he's in another reality. He sees trees reach for him with humanoid hands and animals that don't belong on planet Earth. Rattled by the experience, Homer says he doesn't want to take anymore shortcuts. Nonetheless, Mrs. Todd is changing and growing younger with each trip she takes, and the appeal of this is too much for Homer to pass up. In the end, Homer gets into Mrs. Todd's car and presumably sets off to whatever strange world Mrs. Todd discovered.

While very effective as a short story, a bloviated feature-length version would likely only dilute the charm of the story in its original format.


9. The Sun Dog

Stephen King The Sun Dog
Scribner

Some of King's stories, like The Stand, need 1.000 pages to tell the whole tale. Some are small, slices of life within King's demented world. That's where The Sun Dog fits in. One of the novellas from Four Past Midnight, The Sun Dog is about 15 year-old Kevin Delevan. He receives a Polaroid camera for his birthday.

Kevin realizes that regardless of where the camera is aimed, it always takes the same picture; a street with a white fence and a black dog in the distance. Kevin turns the camera over to junk shop owner Pop Merrill, who continues to use the camera. With each shot, the dog in the distance gets closer. Eventually the dog finally pushes itself through the pictures membrane and into our world. Kevin is able to turn the Sun dog to stone by taking it's picture with another Polaroid camera.

Frankly, there just isn't enough to justify the Hollywood treatment. So much filler would have to be added that, again, it would be missing the point. The Sun Dog isn't meant to be epic. It's meant to shine a dim, flickering light on one small corner of King's universe. Like Reese cups, they are great in small doses, but you don't need fifteen of them.


8. Survivor Type

Creepshow Survivor Type Stephen King
Shudder

One of King's most unnerving short stories, Survivor Type is one that King himself said "goes a little too far, even for me." Survivor Type is presented as the diary of disgraced surgeon Richard Pine. While attempting to smuggle a large batch of heroin onto a cruise ship, Richard finds himself stranded on a desert island with little supplies and no food.

As Richard deteriorates, hunger takes over and he breaks his ankle in attempt to hunt a bird. He numbs the foot with heroin, then amputates. Realizing how dire his situation is, he eats the foot.

He continues to amputate his own limbs for food, taking the heroin for anesthesia each time. His last few diary entries, barely comprehensible, indicate he has cut off and eaten everything below his waist, as well as his ears, and drools uncontrollably as he ponders which body part to consume next.

This story has actually been adapted into shorts by independent filmmakers. It bears inclusion on this list, however, because it's odds of a major release are not bloody likely (pun intended). A good short story can make a good short film, but audiences aren't likely to slog through an hour of drug-addled self-surgery.


7. A Very Tight Place

Stephen King A Very Tight Place
Angry Mule Productions

This novella was included in 2008's Just After Sunset. Again, it is a fine story, but the trials and tribulations of a man trapped in a public port-a-john is a tough sell to studio executives.

That's right kids. A Very Tight Place is the story of Curtis and Tim, two neighbors who are at odds after Curtis' dog was killed by Tim's electric fence. As one might expect from such a situation, Tim forces Curtis into a port-a-john and leaves him for dead.

After spending the night trapped in the privy, Curtis takes his only way out and climbs into the toilet tank. He uses his dead dog's ID tag to unscrew the bolts and escape. Curtis then goes to Tim's house, confronts Tim while he's in his hot tub. Curtis first scares Tim by tossing an unplugged hair dryer in the water, then leveling a threat at him. A week later, Curtis kills himself by gunshot. Tim, hearing the shot and knowing what it meant, then considers getting a new dog.

Ah, to be a fly on the wall in that studio pitch meeting.


6. The Reaper's Image

Stephen King Skeleton Crew
Hodder Paperbacks

Another story from the Skeleton Crew collection, The Reaper's Image is another of King's stories that stands well on its own. At best it could work in an anthology of shorts, but a story about a guy buying a magic mirror can only sustain interest for so long.

This tale starts with an antique collector named Johnson Spangler and his visit to the Samuel Claggert Museum. Spangler's goal is to buy the legendary Delver's Mirror. The museum curator, Mr. Carlin, explains that many attempts have been made to destroy the mirror. This was because many people claimed to see an image of the grim reaper in the mirror. Each person then mysteriously disappeared.

The skeptical Spangler notices duct tape in the mirror's corner, but when he touches it he only feels glass. When he looks again, the tape is gone. As Mr. Carlin relates a story of a teenage boy who went missing after seeing the reaper, Spangler suddenly becomes sick and rushes out of the room.

At best, The Reaper's Image would have worked as an episode of Tales From The Darkside. At worst, it would be compared to Maximum Overdrive.


5. The Last Rung On The Ladder

The Last Rung On The Ladder Stephen King
Husson University

Originally published in 1978's Night Shift, this is another of King's short stories that was adapted into a short film. The live action short was well done, but this story wouldn't translate to feature length based on how unwaveringly hopeless it feels throughout.

Larry learns that his sister Kitty has committed suicide. The news makes him think of a time from when they were children. The two were taking turns climbing to the top of a ladder in their barn and jumping off into a haystack. On his last turn, Larry realizes that the ladder is about to give out. By the time he lands in the hay, Kitty is already climbing up again.

The ladder then breaks, leaving her clinging to the last rung. Larry piles hay below her. When Kitty cannot hang on any longer, he tells her to let go, and she does. The hay breaks Kitty's fall and saves her life, leaving her with only a broken ankle.

Fast forward to adulthood. Kitty has two failed marriages under her belt, becomes a call girl and decides to end her life. After the fact, Larry receives a letter from Kitty which reads, "It would have been better for me if that last run had broken before you could put the hay down".


4. Here There Be Tygers

Here There Be Tygers Stephen King
Night Frizz Productions

Here There Be Tygers is included in the 1985 collection Skeleton Crew and is another entry that has been produced as a live action short. This story reads like a Stephen King stream of consciousness that he decided to put on paper. It is the story of a third-grade boy named Charles who believes a man-eating tiger is lurking in his elementary school restroom. Not an easy concept to stretch into two hours.

One day, Charles really needs to go to the bathroom and his "mean" teacher Miss Bird embarrasses him. Arriving at the loo, he looks around the corner, and sees a tiger lying on the bathroom floor.

Too afraid to go in, Charles waits at the door. A child named Kenny comes to get him. Charles begins to cry and Kenny leads him in, saying that the tiger was in his head. Charles runs out of the bathroom, and when he forces himself to go back in, he sees the tiger has a torn piece of shirt on its claw. Charles decides to relieve himself in the sink, but the wicked Miss Bird catches him. She goes around the corner to find Kenny, and Charles leaves her for the Tiger to deal with.


3. Sneakers

stephen king nightmares and dreamscapes
Scribner

Another inclusion from Nightmares and Dreamscapes, Sneakers is a genuinely creepy tale that could only suffer from a big screen treatment. Sneakers is about a record executive named John Tell who goes to the restroom at work, only to notice a dirty pair of sneakers under the door of a toilet stall.

when John visits the john again throughout the week, he notices that the shoes have moved and are are now surrounded by the bodies of dead bugs. Eventually, Tell discovers that the shoes belonged to a local drug dealer who was killed in the bathroom stall during an apparent robbery.

John finally confronts the man's ghost. The ghost tells him that he was brutally killed by Jannings, Tell's boss. Jannings was a drug addict who was heavily in debt to the dealer at the time. Jannings used the stolen drugs to fund his rehabilitation and rise to executive management. This prompts Tell to quit his job, telling Jannings he is a "worthless bastard" before leaving. When he arrives home, he resolves to find other work, pulling out the want ads and reading them while sitting on the toilet, of course.


2. Chattery Teeth

Stephen King Chattery Teeth
Simon & Schuster

Included in the 1993 collection Nightmares and Dreamscapes, Chattery Teeth was adapted for television in the anthology Quicksilver Highway in 1997.

Salesman Bill Hogan notices a large, metal pair of walking "Chattery Teeth" in a convenience store. The clerk gives Hogan the teeth, claiming they had been broken. As he leaves the convenience store, Hogan reluctantly gives a ride to a hitchhiker standing outside. His reluctance is validated when the hiker tries to carjack and kill Hogan. During the ensuing struggle, Hogan wrecks the van, and before the hitchhiker can recover, the teeth come to life and bring the criminal's life to a gruesome conclusion. Hogan passes as he sees the Chattery Teeth dragging the hitchhiker's body off into the desert.

Nine months later, Hogan stops again at the same convenience store, where he is unexpectedly reunited with the "broken" teeth again. Hogan realizes the teeth likely never intended to kill him, but rather to protect him. The store owner gives him the teeth again. His theory is proved correct when a dog snarls at him as he leaves and the teeth rattle in his pocket.

Chattery Teeth is a fun read at 16 pages. This is a story best kept at all killer, no filler.


1. Rage

Stephen King Rage
Signet Books

Rage was a story first published in 1977 under King's pseudonym, Richard Bachman. Nothing against the quality of the writing, but Rage focuses on a teenage school shooter. Even King himself allowed the story to fall out of print after the story was connected to real-life shootings.

Charlie Decker, a high school senior, is called to the principal's office after assaulting a teacher with a pipe wrench. The principal expels Charlie, prompting him to fetch a pistol from his locker before setting the locker ablaze. Charlie returns to his classroom and fatally shoots his teacher. The fire triggers an alarm, but Charlie forces his classmates to stay in the room, killing another when he attempts to enter.

Over the following four hours, Charlie holds his fellow students hostage in the school. He makes demands to the negotiators and threatens to kill his classmates. We see narrative flashbacks of Charlie's troubled childhood and history of abuse throughout the story. The students begin empathizing with Charlie and even gang up on a fellow student, leaving him beaten on the floor-just one more reason this will never see a theatrical release.

Charlie releases the students, and when the police chief enters the room, Charlie moves as if to shoot him, attempting suicide by cop. The chief shoots Charlie, but he survives and is committed to a psychiatric hospital.


In this post: 
Stephen-King
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

George is a life-long fan of genre, wrestling and guitars. He is an actor, writer, CrossFit trainer and former WWE storyline writer. He currently works as talent development for PWX wrestling and resides in the birthplace of the zombie movie, Pittsburgh, PA.