10 Stupid Moments In Christopher Nolan Films

Christopher Nolan

There's little point denying the fact that Christopher Nolan is one of the most talented filmmakers working today; his films are without exception intelligently written and sharply directed, with each new film demonstrating even stronger technical proficiency. That said, probably the area the man is weakest in is his writing; he often lets some silly oddities slip through the cracks, yet the execution is so strong that it's easy to let him get away with it. But not today. It's time to dig down deep; here are the 10 stupidest moments in Christopher Nolan films...

10. The Batpod Flip (The Dark Knight)

The Dark Knight Ah, The Dark Knight, easily one of the best films of Nolan's 8 features to date, but it's also probably the one that subjects viewers to the highest number of idiotic moments. One of the most egregious slip-ups occurs during the climax of the excellent SWAT chase through the streets of Gotham. Batman rides his Batpod underneath the Joker's articulated lorry, and after using steel cables to flip it in spectacular style, performs a ridiculous flip off the side of a wall himself, looping around and landing back on his front tires, facing the flipped lorry. It's silly because the CGI looks jerky and weird, and it's just too daft even for a film about a man who goes around dressed up as a bat beating up criminals. Apparently Nolan put this in the film because he saw one of his sons playing with a toy that did something similar, and thought it would be fun; unfortunately, it's just dumb and goofy. This is accentuated by the fact that the score cuts out just prior to this, so it awkwardly has even more attention drawn to it.

9. Harvey Dent's Press Conference (The Dark Knight)

The Dark Knight This scene in The Dark Knight is supposed to be one fraught with tension, as District Attourney Harvey Dent announces that he is Batman in order to stop the Joker from killing anymore people, and also to protect the real identity of Batman. However, it's hard to pay attention to this when the scene seems to be chock full of reject extras who should have been given their marching orders as soon as they tried a line reading. One shouts out "Things are worse than ever!" in the most stilted, laughable, cringe-inducingly unnatural manner possible, and then a cop follows up by saying "No more dead cops!", which again is just something nobody would actually say in real life. Trying to concentrate on what Dent is saying when you're doubled over laughing at the horrendous performances Nolan actually let into his film is a tough demand; it's not like the film needed the dialogue - even if Nolan didn't realise until the edit that something was wrong, he could have easily cut them out.

8. David Bowie Plays Nikola Tesla (The Prestige)

The Prestige David Bowie I wouldn't dare to try and besmirch David Bowie for his performance as Nikola Tesla in The Prestige; it's a wonderfully spirited performance that's in sure contrast to the more outlandish turns the singer has given throughout his career. The blame, instead, lies with Nolan and his casting department for allowing such a blatant spot of stunt casting into their film. Though Bowie does well, I found myself constantly pulled out of his scenes and distracted by Bowie's presence - it seemed unnecessary and something employed just for a giggle. Given how crucially Tesla figures in the plot, this seems like something of a silly move by Nolan and his casting directors.

7. Bane's Mercenaries vs. Gotham PD (The Dark Knight Rises)

The Dark Knight Rises One of my biggest bugbears about the largely stellar The Dark Knight Rises is that the film so often feels like it should have been R-rated, even if it's easy to see why from a business perspective it wasn't. This is apparent no more so than in the final stand-off between Bane's mercenaries and the Gotham City Police Department's officers, who have just resurfaced from being trapped underground for several months. Largely without firearms and no doubt suffering from a severe vitamin deficiency, they nevertheless run towards the mercs at full speed, instigating what should be an epic, violent clash of two sides. However, the whole way the scene is directed makes it difficult to buy this; only the occasional police officer drops to the floor dead, while Bane's mercenaries appear to have graduated from the Stormtrooper School of Shooting, because the vast majority of their bullets seem to just ricochet off the floor. In reality, the ground battle would have been over in seconds, with Bane's men shooting dead all of the cops with total ease; instead we get this oddly neutered, bloodless showdown which just seems sort of silly in retrospect, even if the other elements of the scene - the scale, the vehicular mayhem, the bomb - all work superbly.

6. Fight Scene Editing (Batman Begins)

Batman Begins Liam Neeson The first Batman Begins was a superb, refreshing slap in the face for Batman fans everywhere, but it also demonstrated Nolan's biggest weakness as a filmmaker, one that permeates through a lot of his films even though it has improved considerably lately - his editing. While this isn't directly his fault, it's something he should have pulled editor Lee Smith up on, because the action scenes in Batman Begins especially really suffer for it; particularly when Bruce and Ducard (aka Ra's) are fighting on the ice during the early training sequences, and then when the Batmobile is fending off cars through a tunnel, the money shots are all too frantic and scattered. It's difficult to make spatial sense of what's going on, and this only became worse for those who bought the Region 2 DVDs; the 4% speed-up from NTSC to PAL means that the slack editing is even more disorientating. Most of Nolan's subsequent films aren't saddled with the same problem - some of Inception's editing was a bit spotty (watch when Cobb is walking through the streets with Ariadne), but on the whole Nolan and Smith have managed to strengthen their working process.

5. Ken Watanabe's Expository Dialogue (Inception)

Inception Ken Watanabe I love Ken Watanabe; the guy's a great actor and had superb screen presence in both Batman Begins and Inception, but his role in the latter clearly wasn't very well thought out. Simply, Watanabe's English is not the greatest, and so it's probably best to keep his dialogue minimal, or at least ensure it's simple stuff that can be easily read, and won't matter so much if audiences miss it. Well, Nolan just went ahead and cast Watanabe in a role that is pivotal to our understanding of the first 10-15 minutes of the film, ignoring the fact that audiences struggled to understand what the Hell he was saying. This isn't ideal at the best of times, but given that Watanabe is explaining some of the more complex mechanisms of the plot, it becomes downright infuriating. When I got the Blu-Ray, I actually had to put subtitles on, and it was only on my second viewing of the film that I properly understood those opening scenes. This just makes no sense whatsoever.

4. Nervous SWAT Team Guy (The Dark Knight)

The Dark Knight And now we have more stupid characters who are a combination of crappy writing and bad acting. Take the awesome SWAT scene in The Dark Knight, in which Harvey Dent, who has just admitted to being Batman, is hauled off in a SWAT van just as The Joker shows up to try and kidnap him. The scene's awesomeness is stymied by one factor - this annoying rookie SWAT team officer who says ridiculous lines like "I didn't sign up for this!" (you're in a SWAT team, of course you signed up for this) and, "Is that a bazooka!?" (I don't think anyone's called a rocket launcher a bazooka since about 1973). There are countless other cheesy lines ("We're like turkeys on thanksgiving / We're like sitting ducks"), but the two above are easily the worst. They're pointless and add nothing to the scene; I don't know why Nolan insists on stuff like this.

3. Goofy Cops Galore (Batman Begins & The Dark Knight)

Batman Begins It gets worse, though; it makes me think that Nolan must have something against cops because he consistently writes them as such awful, idiotic caricatures in all of his films (with the exceptions being Jim Gordon and John Blake). Let's start with Batman Begins; during the Tumbler chase, the cops are all portrayed as gormless buffoons. One is looking out for the Tumbler and says, "At least tell me what it looks like ...Never mind", and then there's the horribly cringe-inducing cop who says through his radio, "He's comin' right up on yer butt!", moments before the Tumbler destroys the cop car and speeds past. The Dark Knight isn't much better; one cop, while hurling one of Maroni's men into a cop car near the start of the film, says, "Have a nice trip, see you next fall", a laughably bad pun that's funny for all the wrong reasons.

2. The Microwave Emitter (Batman Begins)

Batman Begins One of the most frequently cited problems with Batman Begins is the plot hole surrounding the Microwave Emitter device that Ra's Al Ghul intends to use to evaporate Gotham's water supply and cause the Scarecrow's nerve gas to be freely dispersed throughout the city as an inhalant. However, this plan overlooks one basic fact of human physiology, that the vast majority of the human body is water, and so setting off the Microwave Emitter in Gotham would in effect cause everyone to die instantly, rendering the device - which was intended to turn everyone crazy and therefore raze Gotham - totally pointless. It's one of those annoying plot holes that once you realise it, it's impossible to watch the film the same way again; it just seems like such a silly oversight for such a talented, cerebral filmmaker. Maybe Nolan just didn't care and wanted us to gloss over the science in favour of the dramatic heft of the scene. Is it still a great movie? Of course, but there are countless other ways the toxin could have been dispersed that didn't fly so brazenly in the face of science.

1. The Batman Voice (The Dark Knight & The Dark Knight Rises)

Batman Begins Ah yes, perhaps the most consistently maligned aspect of not only Nolan's Batman films, but his career as a whole, is his decision to have Batman use an exaggerated growl to hide his normal Bruce Wayne voice. While it does make sense within the context of the story, frankly it just sounds silly, and it's hard to take anything he says seriously. Case in point, when Batman has captured the Joker and says "This city...just showed you...that it's full of people...ready to believe in good", it just sounds so awkward, like Bats has to take about 8 breaths just to get through the scene. This gets taken to ridiculous, if hilarious, lengths in The Dark Knight Rises when Catwoman sneaks off mid-dialogue and in full Batman voice, Bats says, "So that's what that feels like". Hilarious, but silly. And then at the end of the film when Batman reveals his identity to Gordon, he still speaks in the Batman voice despite everyone in that area now knowing his real identity. Plus, wouldn't it have been more affecting if Bruce broke character and just talked in his normal voice? Are there any moments we missed? Were Memento, Insomnia and Following dumber than I've given them credit for? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.