10 Subtle Details That Make Joaquin Phoenix's Joker Incredible
The anatomy of an Oscar winner to be?
While it's obviously a comic book movie in a certain sense - in that it adapts one of the most famous comics characters of all time - Todd Phillips' Joker is more of a character piece. It's about one man's reaction to being downtrodden, abused, left to rot by a society over-run by self-interest and dehumanising greed. And that one man is played quite stunningly by Joaquin Phoenix.
If there's any justice in the world, Phoenix's performance will be considered right up there with Heath Ledger's in terms of quality. It is just as worthy of Oscar attention and it is arguably even more layered and more complex. Where Ledger had charitable mystery to hide behind, Phoenix had detail he had to fit into the characterisation.
What he has created is as subtle and nuanced as it is brutal and provocative and analysis of what he's done could and should run on for a long time. How he managed to do what he did is all about the intricacies of his observations and the little details you might not pick up first time.
SPOILERS will follow for Joker...
10. The FOUR Laughs
A lot was said about Joaquin Phoenix's approach to capturing the right laugh and how key he thought it was to even accepting the role. The most instantly infamous aspect of the laugh is also a huge part of the inspiration for the movie generally speaking - Todd Phillips showed him videos of people suffering with uncontrollable pathological laughter.
We see this particular laugh repeatedly - usually when Arthur is faced with adversity or social embarrassment or a perceived threat - and it causes him obvious physical pain. He doesn't just grimace, he claws at his neck, his throat convulses, his sinews twist as if this laughter is a psychosomatic punishment. When we learn the truth of his past, it fits even more that he would create such a response.
But it's not the only laugh we see: there are crucially three others that lend to the picture of Arthur as a performer of increasing layers. The final to be revealed is a variation on the pathological laughter, seen right at the end as Arthur considers the tragedy of the Waynes. He grimaces once more, but the pain is gone and he seems almost wistful, no longer fighting the impulse and genuinely enjoying "the joke" as he calls it.
Earlier, he tells his mother that his pathological laughter is when he is most himself and it would seem that this little flash of an evolved impulsive, pained laugh is his true Joker laugh.
The other two laughs sit at opposite ends of the performative spectrum, the first is his natural laugh, as anyone would have - his rare expression of joy that we see when he sees himself on Murray Franklin's show - and it's telling that this laugh matters the least. Arthur says he's never had a moment of happiness in his whole life, which is obviously untrue because we see it, but to him, happiness is a performance and he genuinely doesn't know what true happiness is even as he experiences it.
And finally we have what most people thought would be the Joker laugh, the shrill, jester laugh from the trailer that is Arthur's fake, performance laugh. He uses it when he believes it's right to, but he doesn't understand it as the first Pogos sequence confirms - his disconnection there manifests as him laughing away from the punchlines. He's performing to try and fit in.
9. His Childish Tell
Eventually, we learn that Arthur's psychological trauma traces back to his childhood and abuse he suffered at the hands of his adoptive mother's boyfriends. He had his childhood robbed from him, in other words and then he became Penny's carer on top of that, feeding her even as he chose not to eat himself as they struggled financially. He's more like the parent than her.
The hint of his abuse actually comes a lot earlier than when he visits Arkham. The first time we see him watch Murray Franklin's show, he fantasises about being in the audience. But it's not just the "normal" Arthur who sits in the audience and ends up talking to Murray - it's Arthur as a child.
He talks about how it's his life-long dream to speak with him and to reinforce both that and the idea of Arthur never having developed fully beyond childishness, his demeanour is very much like that of a child. He softens and infantilises his voice, puts his hands behind his back nervously and swings his body slightly. In his dream world, he might look like an adult, but he's a child.
8. The Affected Limp & Bowed Head
Not long after we first meet Arthur, he's beaten in the streets by kids who steal his sign and jump him. They have no motivation other than malice and are a reflection of Gotham's poisoned heart and bleak future. Naturally, the savage beating leaves him battered and bruised and he walks with a noticeable limp.
It turns out that the limp came before the beating, as he continues to walk like that even after his wounds heal. His natural walk sees him tuck his head into his chest slightly like a bow while he drags his leg a little. And we know that it's put on because he casts it off both when he's dressed as a clown (he calls himself Carousel at first) and when he begins to feel a little more alive and less disassociated.
It seems that Arthur's walk and stance are performances too: his past abuses taught him to bow his head meekly and he limps because he carries old wounds. It's telling that his way out of that affected behaviour is clowning, during which time he riffs on Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton performances to find more of a natural way of moving.
It's notable that Arthur's demeanour changes when he feels he doesn't need to perform - he's more direct with his mother for instance and feels able to hold his gaze. The same goes for when he interacts with Sophie. And it's also the case when he's angry - he stares almost manically, rather than letting his eyes drop as he does more naturally throughout the film. The fact that all three are inherently linked to his transition to Joker says a lot.
7. He Doesn't Breathe
Obviously, Arthur DOES breathe throughout the movie, because he needs to - plus he visibly smokes and you need to inhale to do that - but there are moments where Joaquin Phoenix chose to heighten the intensity of a scene by not breathing.
The first most noticeable is when his social worker tells him that the service is being shut down and he won't be getting any kind of support or medication. He breaks into a pained smile, remembering what his mother told him about "putting on a happy face," but he is very visibly not breathing. It's disconcerting because he's clearly having an anxious episode - it might as well be a panic attack in fact - and that's usually coupled with hyperventilation. Arthur's training to suppress and look happy even as he's going through trauma though, means he even stops that.
The other time we see it most is when his mother's instruction to put on happy face comes full circle and he confronts her with the revelations of his past before killing her. As he takes the pillow and suffocates her, he holds his breath too, again almost as a means to not show his real feelings.
6. The Unreliable Narrator Hints
As Arthur reveals after he's killed the three Wayne employees who assault him on the train, his "fighting back" is a sudden revelation to him that he is real. He tells his therapist Debra that for most of his life he didn't know whether he was real, foreshadowing something the film plays with throughout - the idea of an unreliable narrator and of fantasy versus reality.
That statement is Arthur telling us that sometimes he really isn't real and there are little tics throughout his performance that go to the same idea. First off, the first triple murder scene. Arthur uses a Colt Detective Special .38 revolver, which holds six bullets. However, when he shoots his targets, he fires at least 7 bullets before the gun runs out of ammo. You could say it's a mistake on the film-makers' part but it fits with Arthur's faint grasp on reality. Or at least with the intention to make you question it.
On top of that, at the end, we see Joker remembering the sight of Bruce Wayne standing over his dead parents as he gleefully drinks in the moment. Only, this is an impossible scene - Arthur didn't witness it but we're shown it as if he did. It's no more than a fantasy and who even knows whether it really happened.
And finally, there's another subtle way the film messes with Arthur as a reliable narrator - his make-up. In films like this, you'd expect a continuity team to have Arthur's face appear entirely consistent between scenes, but there are so many small changes to his clown make-up in single scenes that it's almost as if they chose to allow them in order to mess with the audience.
5. He's A Mimic
In the interviews that Phoenix has given when he talked about pathological laughter and how it informed his performance as Arthur, he also, intriguingly mentioned mimicry. It's something tied to pathological emotional responses and it's important here because Arthur is the very definition of a mimic.
Whenever he interacts with another character, he tends to adopt their mannerisms. When the other clowns mock Gary for his dwarfism, Arthur bursts out into his fake laugh because everyone else is. When Sophie comes to his door and leans on it, he copies, when Brian Tyree Henry's admin clerk calls him "man", Arthur reflects it back to him. He learns how to be a stand-up by watching them and writing explicit notes, he prepares for Murray's show by copying other guests.
And there's a far more subtle one too: in the chilling climactic scene that sees Arthur kill Murray Franklin live on TV, he repeatedly over-pronounces words, extending vowels in what appears to be a mocking tone. The reality is that this a side of his performance and it is, again, a mimicked action.
When we first see Arthur putting on his Carousel clown makeup, there's a sign above his mirror that reads "you look mah-velous", written to spell out the same verbal tic. It's there as a comfort blanket to Arthur and in the end, he adopts the mantra for his big performance. It could be mimicked from 1950s eccentric actor Fernando Lamas (who Billy Crystal sent up on Saturday Night Live with that very phrase - "you look mahvelous" - in the mid-1980s), but whatever the case, it's Arthur borrowing from elsewhere to perform at being real.
4. His Colour Choices
On the surface, Arthur's Joker "costume" is merely a slight variation on the Joker's usual outfit from the comics, with bold contrasting colours to set against the white palour of his made-up skin. The colour scheme is vaguely drawn from the comics, admittedly as his first appearance had a purple suit and a deep green shirt, the orange comes from later shirts and Joker's Daughter wore an orange waistcoat when she debuted fighting Batgirl and Robin in July of 1976.
It's supposed to look recognisable, that's obvious, but it doesn't explain why Arthur would chose those colours specifically for his Joker look. He couldn't draw from the comics, after all, and yet the decision to dress a clown in a disco suit when he usually dresses up in your normal clown attire.
The answer, rather brilliantly, comes when Arthur goes to Arkham, a place he told his social worker he felt most comfortable. After stealing his mother's records, he flees into a back stairwell and low and behold, the walls are painted in the same orange as his waistcoat and the floor and pipework is the same maroon as his suit. A strange choice for such a place and the real hint at where his inspiration came from. He isn't wearing the costume of a clown, he's wearing the costume of his true home.
3. His Straitjacket Stance
For almost the entire film, Arthur is a sinewy, twisted knot of a man, painfully thin to the extent that you worry that Joaquin Phoenix would have lasting damage done (and he did say it destabilised his mental condition to get to that point). He's also hunched, with his shoulders curled inwards and his spine curved. It's a posture clearly designed for visceral reactions, but it isn't without context too.
At one point, Arthur write a joke about a straitjacket that is too tight in his joke diary, he also seeks comfort at another point by emptying his fridge and climbing into it (at which point we find out the door looks the same as his former Arkham cell door did) and expresses his happiness at Arkham. He even tells the admin clerk about his crimes as a means to get locked up. It doesn't work but he tries because he wants to be there.
The reason for his posture is linked to the same thing: Arthur feels comforted by constricting his body as if he's wearing a straitjacket, pulling his shoulders across him and bending his back as if too tight. Even when he's not in Arkham, he's still wearing that jacket.
2. He Makes Himself Big
And on a related point, we see at several points that Arthur likes to dance as a sort of therapy of freedom. It's when he feels some sense of happiness (even as he claims he never feels it) and it's part of his ritual of appearing sexually appealing and fitting in with what he thinks real men are like. He also uses it as part of his ritual to calm and prepare himself, sort of like he's doing karate, which we see a condensed version of later as he prepares to go on stage on Murray's show.
But it isn't just normal dancing - the movements are pronounced and balletic and for the most part, involve Arthur making himself appear bigger than he is - lifting his arms into the air to appear more menacing as an animal would. It's a display that's part of him trying to be seen. When he's on Murray's show he bemoans how people don't notice him, how they'd step over him and people like him - his dance ritual is an answer to that.
And really tellingly, after it's revealed that his relationship with Sophie is a figment of fantasy and he "snaps" finally, the camera shoots him from below as he stalks along the corridor. At this point, he no longer needs to pretend to be big.
1. The Cigarette Stains
Arthur Fleck smokes a lot. He smokes so much, actually, that right at the end of the movie, we see a close up of his hands and his fingers are stained orange with nicotine. That suggests more than a recreational habit.
The tiny detail gives us an insight into the scale of his smoking, but the rest of his behaviour around smoking suggests why he does it. Throughout the film there are several fantasy sequences and they're the only times Arthur seems not to have a cigarette in his mouth. It's something he mostly does while he's alone (apart from his Murray Franklin Show sequence, where he adopts it as part of his act) and it's something that seems tied to his most stressful moments.
It feels like smoking is Arthur's totem - his anchor to the real world that lets him know that what he's experiencing is indeed real. He says he can't really recognise what's real and what isn't at one point and it would absolutely fit that he'd choose something self-destructive as an indicator.
Arthur actually has three different "totem" behaviours. The most blatant of the others is seem after Murray Franklin's show producer calls him and asks if he can appear on the show. He pats himself down, checking his face as you would if you were dreaming. He's checking he's awake and that what he's experiencing is reality.
And he can also be seen bouncing his legs in apparent frustration - it's a little hint for him that he's rooted in the real world. There's obviously some interpretation there, but it definitely seems like Arthur's grip on reality is linked to these behaviours.
What did you think of Joker? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.