10 Terrible Film Sequels That Somehow Made It To Cinemas

Potc The film culture of the early-21st century has been dominated by sequels, prequels, reboots and franchises. The growing insecurity of Hollywood in the face of piracy, the rise of online media and a resurgence in TV drama, has all led to a multitude of sequels designed to perpetuate the money-making ability of an idea for as long as humanly possible. In the process we've ended up with a lot of bad sequels, and today we're marking the 10 follow-up films that we really could have done without. For the purposes of this list I am discounting sequels that were straight-to-video, straight-to-DVD or even straight-to-TV like Highlander: The Source. This is because these were generally seen by far too few people to have done any real damage to a franchise: even if you hate American Psycho II or the straight-to-video Disney sequels, they've not resulted in their respective originals being deflowered by future cinema releases. What we're talking about today are cinematic sequels so bad that they damaged the reputation of the originals and tarnished all the good memories we have of them. So without further ado, let's dig to our Top 10 of Terrible Sequels - and we begin with one that might surprise you...

10. Jaws 2 (1978)

Jaws 2Sequel To: Steven Spielberg's career-making blockbuster Jaws. Who Made It?: Jeannot Szwarc, who later made Supergirl and Santa Clause: The Movie. His TV credits include Fringe, Boston Legal and the 200th episode of Smallville. Why Was It Made?: Spielberg's film changed the face of summer releases, setting off a chain of events which eventually resulted in the summer blockbuster that we know and love (or hate). Together with Star Wars, it proved that studios could make money during the summer, and that B-movie material (a killer shark) could achieve widespread appeal with the help of an A-movie budget. Why Is It So Bad?: While it's widely held that the third and fourth Jaws films are genuinely terrible, Jaws 2 deserves its fair share of derision because it is the exact opposite of the original in so many ways. The original worked because it kept things simple and withheld the monster for as long as possible; we only got glimpses of 'Bruce' during the first few attacks, which built up tension before the big reveal. In Jaws 2, there is more emphasis on action and soap opera dialogue, showing the monster far too soon and then getting bogged down while retreading old ground. Put simply, the film takes something that terrified audiences and fails to make it scary. What Happened Next?: The series limped on with Jaws 3D and finally Jaws: The Revenge, starring Michael Caine. Caine won his first Oscar, for Hannah and Her Sisters, while filming on location in the Bahamas.

9. Superman III (1983)

Superman 3Sequel To: Superman II, and to some extent Superman: The Movie, since they were originally conceived as two parts of the same story. Who Made It?: Richard Lester, who took over Superman II after Richard Donner was fired by producers Alexander and Ilya Salkind. Lester had previously helmed The Three and The Four Musketeers for the Salkinds, along with Help!, A Hard Day's Night and the cult classic The Bed-Sitting Room. Why Was It Made?: Superman II was a big hit in spite of its production problems. It had a record-breaking opening weekend (beating The Empire Strikes Back), and after a delayed release in Europe it became one of the highest grossing films of 1981. Lester got on well with the Salkinds and so a third film was pretty much inevitable. Why Is It So Bad?: It undoes all the good work of I & II in attempting to portray Superman in a serious light. All the good intentions and the Christian allegory present in Mario Puzo's screenplays for the first two films are replaced by camp silliness and a desire to play things more for laughs. Richard Pryor is shockingly unfunny in his supporting role, the fight scenes have no tension, the story is far more episodic and Robert Vaughn's villain is quite boring. The only good scene is the junk yard fight, in which our hero splits into Clark Kent and an evil Superman after being exposed to red kryptonite. Christopher Reeve felt this was the only scene which did Superman justice, and fought hard to keep it in the film. What Happened Next: Following the unsuccessful spin-off Supergirl, the series ended with Superman IV: The Quest for Peace. Bryan Singer attempted a reboot in 2006 with Superman Returns, which picks up after the ending of Superman II and ignores the continuity of III and IV. The franchise was subsequently rebooted by Zack Snyder in Man of Steel.

8. Highlander 2: The Quickening (1991)

Highlander 2Sequel To: Highlander, the 1986 cult classic which gave us the phrase: "there can be only one". Who Made It?: Russell Mulcahy, who also helmed the original. He also made directed many of the most famous music videos of the 1980s, including Buggles' 'Video Killed The Radio Star', Bonnie Tyler's 'Total Eclipse Of The Heart', and the majority of Duran Duran's biggest hits. Why Was It Made?: Unlike many of the films on this list, Highlander was not a big hit at the box office. Instead it found a very loyal audience on home video both in Europe and in America. Word slowly spread and eventually Mulcahy gave in to fans' demands. Why Is It So Bad?: Highlander 2: The Quickening is one of the most infamous examples of retconning in cinema history. In other words, it undoes pretty much all the key elements that made Highlander so enjoyable by re-writing the history of the immortals; for instance, making them aliens from the planet Zeist that came to Earth many years ago. This created enormous plot inconsistencies and reduced much of the film down to exposition and pointless action scenes. Even in the subsequent Renegade Cut, which removes all references to aliens and Zeist, the film makes very little sense and is incredibly boring. What Happened Next:Highlander 3: The Final Dimension, made without Mulcahy, disregarded Highlander 2's continuity but met with poor reviews and flopped at the box office. The series subsequently shifted into several TV series, more films, anime and TV cartoons, before finally dying a much-needed death with the horrendous made-for-Syfy movie Highlander: The Source.

7. Evil Dead 3: Army Of Darkness (1993)

Bruce Campbell Ash Army of DarknessSequel To: Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn, which was both a sequel to and a remake of The Evil Dead. Both are classic horror-comedies and have cult status in their own right. Who Made It?: Sam Raimi, who helmed both the first two films. Why Was It Made?: Raimi had always envisioned doing an Evil Dead sequel set in medieval times. He had wanted to start production after Crimewave, but the box office failure of that film led him to postpone and make Evil Dead 2 instead. He spent the next five years working in the script, in-between shooting the cult classic Darkman. Why Is It So Bad?: Sam Raimi once described The Evil Dead as "a Three Stooges movie, with blood and guts standing in for custard pies". In the first two films there was a near-perfect balance of horror and comedy, with the goofy tone making the horror seem all the more demented. In Evil Dead 3, however, there is a shift towards goofy comedy that quickly falls flat. In a bid to expand the world of Ash and the Deadites, the plot becomes sprawling and is ultimately just a series of set-pieces interspersed with special effects. It has its moments but never builds to anything, resulting in an incoherent mess. What Happened Next: The film was a commercial flop and the series ended. Raimi continued to court mainstream success with The Quick and the Dead before directing the Spider-Man movies. A remake of The Evil Dead was released earlier this year.

6. Alien Resurrection (1997)

alien resurrectionSequel To: Alien 3, the debut effort by David Fincher, who went on to make Se7en, Fight Club, Zodiac and The Social Network. Who Made It?: Jean-Pierre Jeunet, famous for such quirky, whimsical works as Delicatessen and The City of Lost Children. Why Was It Made?: Despite its mixed critical reception and production problems, Alien 3 made money at the box office. With each instalment having a different director and Fincher keen to disown the film, it was only natural to go with a new man at the helm. Why Is It So Bad?: There's no doubt that Jeunet was the wrong man for the job: big romping sci-fi action is just not his style, and the film lacks the personal stamp of his oeuvre either side of it. But aside from that, the series had nowhere to go after killing off Ripley. Even with a treatment by Joss Whedon, the film feels bloated and shallow with a video game plot and a host of underdeveloped or uninteresting characters. While sections of Alien 3 were messy, they did at least follow through on a number of interesting ideas which stemmed from Vincent Ward's original vision. Alien Resurrection ignores all such opportunities, settling for tedious shock deaths, nonsensical plot twists and needlessly retreading old ground. What Happened Next: The Alien vs. Predator films and eventually Prometheus. Jeunet went on to repair his reputation with Amelie four years later.

5. Batman And Robin (1997)

Batman and RobinSequel To: Batman Forever, Joel Schumacher's first Batman effort after Tim Burton left the series. Schumacher previously had success with Flatiners and the cult classic The Lost Boys. Who Made It?: Schumacher, who made A Time to Kill in the meantime. Why Was It Made?: While Batman Returns underperformed compared to Warner Brothers' expectations, Forever was a genuinely big hit. The studio wanted to capitalise upon the film's success and ordered Schumacher to make a sequel quickly. Why Is It So Bad?: So much has been written about Batman and Robin being one of the worst films of all time that I almost don't need to flesh out why. The script is terrible, seeming to consist almost entirely of cheesy one-liners. The plot itself is almost totally superfluous, since the film is far more interested in silly action, special effects and the increasingly homoerotic nature of the characters' costumes (not that there's anything wrong with that). On top of all that, the film also betrays so much of what made the Burton films work so well. Instead of Batman hiding in the shadows and going to great lengths to work undercover, in Batman and Robin he's making big public appearances and purchases with the now-infamous Bat Credit Card... What Happened Next: A sequel was planned called Batman Triumphant, which would have involved Jack Nicholson reprising the Joker in a dream sequence. But after the disappointing box office of this film, that was abandoned, and the Batman series went into hibernation until Batman Begins rebooted it in 2005. Schumacher went on to make such film as Phone Booth and The Phantom of the Opera.

4. Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me (1999)

Austin Powers 2Sequel To: Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery, a spoof of the James Bond series which cemented Mike Myers' pop culture status after the success of Wayne's World 1 & 2. Who Made It?: Jay Roach, who also helmed the first film. No excuses then. Why Was It Made?: Austin Powers was a big hit on both sides of the Atlantic, coinciding with the Cool Britannia trends in Britain and the recent re-launch of the Bond series with Goldeneye. Having taken nearly $68m on a budget of $16.5m, the sums clearly added up. Why Is It So Bad?: While many sequels feel like cheap cash-ins, The Spy Who Shagged Me is certainly one of the most cynical. While the first film was adolescent in places, it did intelligently explore and send up the clichés of the spy thriller in amongst all the gross-out humour. In the sequel all that has been replaced by lazier, more repetitive jokes, cheap references to Star Wars (cashing in on the Special Editions) and a plot which fulfils on none of the potential of the film's central conceit (Austin Powers losing his mojo). It's also really mean-spirited, believing that both fat people and little people are inherently funny, especially when they are being humiliated. What Happened Next: A second sequel, Austin Powers in Goldmember, arrived three years later to mixed reviews. A fourth film has been mooted for many years. Myers went on to find success in the Shrek series, while Roach later made Meet the Parents.

3. The Matrix Reloaded/ Revolutions (2003)

The Matrix Reloaded

Sequels To: The Matrix €“ or as advertisers would have us call it, last generation's Looper. And yes, I'm counting them together because they were shot back-to-back. Who Made It?: Andy and Larry (now Lana) Wachowski, who directed the original Matrix and the cult lesbian noir Bound. Why Was It Made?: The Matrix was a huge critical and commercial hit, scoring $463m on a budget of $63m. It put the Wachowskis on the map, won four Oscars and popularised the 'bullet time' style of action scenes, involving slow-motion and multiple camera angles. Why Are They So Bad?: The Matrix sequels aren't exactly awful, but they are a crushing disappointment compared to the original. While both have moments of either spectacular action or mind-bending philosophy, neither of them strike the perfect balance between the two that The Matrix managed, nor do they have the discipline that separates a full-throttle ride from a meandering cruise. The philosophical moments are more impenetrable, thanks to heavy-handed dialogue and wooden acting, while the action sequences are visually impressive but go on far too long. Eventually the rules are broken so many times that it becomes boring, and the ending is a massive anticlimax. What Happened Next: The Wachowskis went on to write V for Vendetta and Ninja Assassins (both directed by James McTeigue), and contributed rewrites to Oliver Hirschbiegel's The Invasion. They later directed Speed Racer and Cloud Atlas (with Tom Tykwer).

2. Pirates Of The Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest/ At World's End (2006/ 2007)

PotcSequels To: Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, which turned Johnny Depp from an indie darling into a mainstream icon. See the previous entry for why I am including these together. Who Made Them? Gore Verbinski, who directed the original Pirates as well as the innocuous farce Mousehunt and the terrible remake of Ringu (The Ring). Why Was It Made?: Pirate films had been a no-go area since the box office failure of Cutthroat Island, but Pirates of the Caribbean was an unexpected smash, taking over $600m on a $140m budget. It also received critical acclaim, resulting in an Oscar nomination for Depp - the repercussions of which are still being felt on his recent performances. Why Is It So Bad?: While the first Pirates film was vaguely entertaining and had a fairly decent plot, both Dead Man's Chest and At World's End are closer to the series' origins as a theme park ride. The plot in both cases is nothing more than a random collection of set-pieces inter-cut with meaningless exposition about quests and artefacts, an unbelievable love triangle and a trio of unconvincing performances from Messrs. Depp, Bloom and Knightley. To cap it all, Verbinski is a complete hack, handling the special effects just fine but having very little sense of comic timing or dramatic tension. Both sequels are bloated, sluggish, insulting to one's intelligence and completely unmemorable. What Happened Next: Rob Marshall took over the franchise for Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides, while Verbinski went off to make Rango. A fifth film is slated for 2015.

1. Quantum Of Solace (2008)

Quantum Of SolaceSequel To:Casino Royale, the film which brought James Bond back from the brink after Die Another Day. The film was directed by Martin Campbell, who previously directed Goldeneye, and can therefore claim to be the only man who rescued Bond twice. Who Made It?: Marc Forster, who directed the Oscar-winning Monster's Ball, Finding Neverland and The Kite Runner. Why Was It Made?: Casino Royale was a big hit, and James Bond will always return. Why Is It So Bad?: Put simply, it undoes all the good work of Casino Royale. While Campbell's film went to great pains to emphasise the pain of the characters and create at least the appearance of emotional depth, Quantum of Solace feels, in the words of Mark Kermode, like it has been shot by the second unit. We still get a load of Bourne-inflected set-pieces, but they have no tension and no real credibility. The villain is unconvincing, the plot is immensely convoluted, the product placement is even more bothersome and the supporting cast are very annoying, particularly Gemma Arterton as Agent Fields. And to cap it all, it has the worst Bond theme song of all time - yes, worse than 'Die Another Day'. What Happened Next: After many delays caused by the collapse of MGM, Skyfall was released in 2012 to rave reviews. Sam Mendes is currently working on Bond 24. ---- Which sequels get your blood boiling? Drop us a comment below or visit Mumby at the Moviesfor more reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.