10 Terrible Movies That Should Have Stayed In Development Hell

Some movies would have definitely been better off if they were never made at all.

Will Smith Gemini Man
Paramount Pictures

Development hell is a cold, barren wasteland littered with countless ideas that have failed in their attempts to escape and reach the promised land of the big screen. Making movies is an incredibly difficult process, and the vast majority of pitches never even make it past the first hurdle.

An idea has to become a script, which needs to be approved and green-lit by a studio, then the producers get involved, more writers are drafted in for polishes, budgets need to be worked out, and a cast and crew needs to be hired before the thought of even shooting a single frame can be considered.

The longer a project remains stuck in development hell, the less likely it becomes to ever see the light of day, and some of the biggest names in the business have found themselves unable to escape its clutches. However, some movies have battled for years and even decades and finally managed to get themselves into production, only for the end result to be so terrible that it would have worked out much better for everyone if they'd just remained in purgatory instead.

10. Watchmen

Watchmen Opening
Warner Bros.

Watchmen had been in the works for over 20 years by the time Zack Snyder finally managed to bring it to the big screen, and after decades stuck in development hell the end result turned out to be one of the most polarizing comic book adaptations ever made.

The reaction was split right down the middle, with fans praising such a faithful live-action take on the source material, while much of the criticism was based on the exact same reasons. For the uninitiated, Watchmen was a frustratingly complex and almost impenetrable anti-superhero movie, while those in the know celebrated the fact that the supposedly unfilmable graphic novel had turned out so well.

After sinking $185m into the project, not to mention the countless millions that were spent developing it when Terry Gilliam, Darren Aronofsky and Paul Greengrass were all attached at various points over the years, Warner Bros. ended up taking a huge loss on Watchmen when it failed to even recoup the budget at the box office.

Having been in the works since 1986 and passed through the hands of Fox, Universal, Paramount and Revolution Studios before WB managed to get it made, all of that effort hardly seemed to be worth it once the reviews came in and Watchmen ended up firmly in the red.


9. Fantastic Four

The Invasion Nicole Kidman
Warner Bros.

Tim Story's two Fantastic Four movies weren't exactly critical darlings, but they looked like Batman Begins and The Dark Knight by comparison when Josh Trank's disaster was unleashed on the world.

With the comic book boom still in full swing, and the previous adventures for the team having earned over $600m at the box office, Fox were keen to reboot as soon as possible and had a new version of Fantastic Four in the works as early as 2009, but even after six years this was apparently the best that they could come up with.

Trank was the wrong man for the job, with the director having no interest in the comic book genre as a whole, and ignoring any and all advice in order to forge ahead with his own take on the material. After well-publicized behind-the-scenes turmoil, heavy studio interference and no shortage of terrible reshoot wigs, Fantastic Four turned out to be one of the worst superhero movies ever made, and sent the man who was once called cinema's next big thing straight to Director's Jail.


8. The Dark Tower

The Dark Tower
Warner Bros.

The Dark Tower is regarded by many as Stephen King's magnum opus, an intricately-detailed series of novels with a rich and complex mythology. So it seemed obvious that after finally escaping the clutches of development hell, the movie would end up being a kid-centric adventure that ran for a brisk 95 minutes, right?

At this point, the project had been in development for ten years, initially with JJ Abrams at the helm, before the Bad Robot head honcho dropped out and The Dark Tower moved over to Universal. Ron Howard then spent a long time trying to get it made as either a feature film or a TV series, before he too decided that it really wasn't worth the increasing hassle.

From out of nowhere, the fantasy epic was suddenly fast-tracked into production and was in theaters before we knew it. The $66m budget seemed nowhere near high enough to be able to do any sort of justice to the source material, and it didn't. The Dark Tower seemed like a rush-job designed to capitalize on the recent Stephen King resurgence rather than the result of ten years of blood, sweat and tears.


7. Tim Burton's Planet Of The Apes

Planet Of The Apes
20th Century Fox

Tim Burton's Planet of the Apes remake has taken a battering over the years since it was first released in 2001, but sometimes it's easy to forget that it was actually a big hit at the box office, earning over $362m. Obviously, it has now become a byword for shoddy re-imaginings and been blown out of the water by the recent reboot trilogy, but Fox must have wondered why they spent so long trying to get it made in the first place after facing such huge backlash.

A reboot of the franchise had been in the works since 1988, with Peter Jackson at one point pitching an idea to the studio. Oliver Stone was attached to executive produce and co-write the script in the early 90s, while Arnold Schwarzenegger was set to star for director Phillip Noyce in 1995.

Schwarzenegger remained on board as first Chris Columbus and then James Cameron flirted with the idea of Planet of the Apes, before the big Austrian also jumped ship, although the reboot still lingered in development hell as Michael Bay turned it down and Peter Jackson ironically knocked it back twice.

Burton finally got it in front of cameras armed with a $100m budget, but as the decidedly mixed reviews flooded in it seemed as though the reinvention of the classic sci-fi franchise had more than lived up to its title as a cursed endeavor.


6. Freddy vs. Jason

Freddy Vs Jason
New Line Cinema

Fans had wanted to see two of slasher cinema's biggest icons go head-to-head for years on the big screen, and the brains behind both the Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13th took this on board, with attempts to film a crossover beginning as early as 1987.

The final shot of 1993's Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday saw Freddy's gloved hand bursting out of the dirt, leading many to speculate that we'd see the showdown between the mass murderers sooner rather than later, but it would be another ten years before Freddy vs. Jason finally reached our screens.

It may have done solid business at the box office and included plenty of fan service that appealed to longtime aficionados of both franchises, but Freddy vs. Jason is not a good movie. It bears all the tropes of early 2000s horror including awful CGI, a cast of characters that exist as little other than cannon fodder, and the all-important nu-metal soundtrack, and served as an example of why sometimes caving into other people's demands isn't the greatest idea.


5. Catwoman

Halle Berry Catwoman
Warner Bros.

Catwoman's solo movie had spent so long in development hell that it was first pitched with Michelle Pfeiffer reprising her iconic role from Batman Returns, but the project not-so-coincidentally fell apart after the script was handed over to the studio the very same day Joel Schumacher's Batman Forever was released.

Ashley Judd was set to star in 2001 before things fell apart once again, while Nicole Kidman also turned down the role before Halle Berry signed on in 2003, with Warner Bros. reportedly desperate to get a comic book movie into production after their latest attempts to reboot both Batman and Superman fell by the wayside.

Of course, we all know how this one turned out, with Catwoman tanking at the box office and quickly gaining a well-deserved reputation as one of the worst movies ever made, not just in the comic book genre. Berry was gracious enough to accept her Razzie Award for Worst Actress in person, where she called it a 'piece of sh*t'. To be fair, she wasn't wrong.


4. Green Lantern

Green Lantern
Warner Bros

Ryan Reynolds has apologized for Green Lantern on numerous occasions over the years, but even he isn't as sorry as the executives at Warner Bros., who spent almost fifteen years trying to get the movie made before it ultimately landed with an almighty thud at the box office, and was savaged by critics for good measure.

Kevin Smith had turned down the opportunity to write the script as early as 1997, while Quentin Tarantino of all people was also offered the chance to write and direct. The closest Green Lantern actually came to moving forward was when Jack Black was set to star in a comedic version, but huge backlash from the fans quickly saw that idea swept under the rug.

David S. Goyer also rejected the chance to tackle Hal Jordan's big screen debut, before Martin Campbell was eventually recruited and an exhaustive casting search saw Reynolds beat out Bradley Cooper and Justin Timberlake to land the highly-coveted lead role.

After the $200m blockbuster bombed hard, with Warner Bros. losing $100m in the process, any plans for a sequel were swiftly scrapped. Now we find ourselves experiencing deja vu, with the DCEU's reboot that was first announced in October 2014 following its predecessor's lead and lingering in development hell.


3. Alien vs. Predator

Alien Vs Predator
20th Century Fox

From the moment a Xenomorph skull was glimpsed in the background of Predator 2's climax, fans waited patiently for the inevitable crossover, with the Aliens and Predators facing in various other media during the interim.

Alien vs. Predator was first approved by the studio in 1991, but it would be over a decade until they iconic extraterrestrials were brought to the big screen as part of the same movie. Not exactly one for holding back his opinions, James Cameron thought that the crossover would kill the validity of both franchises and even used the phrase 'milking it', which turned out to be pretty spot on.

Director and king of the mediocre genre movie Paul W.S. Anderson had been working on the story for eight years, but you definitely didn't get that impression watching what was at that point the worst movie that either species had been appeared in.

That unwanted honor ultimately fell to sequel Requiem, which was so awful that it made Anderson's movie look like it belonged in the pantheon of what Ridley Scott, John McTiernan and Cameron himself had brought to Alien and Predator by comparison.


2. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull

Harrison Ford and Cate Blanchett in Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
Paramount Pictures

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull suffers from many of the same problems that blighted John McClane's return to our screens in Live Free or Die Hard the previous year. When viewed outside of the bubble of their respective franchise, they aren't flat-out awful movies, but they pale massively in comparison to their much more illustrious predecessors.

It took 19 years for cinema's most high-profile bearded best friends to come up with CGI gophers, fridge-nuking, Shia LaBeouf doing his best Tarzan impression and poorly-rendered extraterrestrials, which makes you wonder what sort of terrible ideas they'd come up with that had been deemed as not enough over the intervening decades.

Jeb Stuart, Jeffrey Boam, M. Night Shyamalan, Stephen Gaghan, Tom Stoppard, Frank Darabont and Jeff Nathanson all had a shot at trying to crack the story, before Steven Spielberg and George Lucas settled on David Koepp's script, with some input from Lawrence Kasdan.

The fourth Indiana Jones movie went through so many drafts that featured so many combinations of concepts, villains and MacGuffins, yet they ultimately ended up going with the very same idea that Lucas had conceived in the early 90s, making everything that happened in the interim a waste of time.

Reception to Kingdom of the Crystal Skull hasn't softened over time, and the general consensus remains that Indiana Jones should have been allowed to ride off into the sunset as he quite literally did at the end of The Last Crusade.


1. Gemini Man

Gemini Man
Paramount

Gemini Man was one of the most famous movies that had never been made for a long time, but after the collaboration between director Ang Lee and star Will Smith finally got the project over the finishing line, most people were in agreement that it would have been better off remaining in development hell.

The concept was originally sold in 1997, with a revolving door of directors and stars circling the project in the meantime. Gemini Man was stuck in development hell for so long that Clint Eastwood was one of the first names linked to pull double duty in a big budget action movie, and he turns 90 at the end of this month.

Expectations were high with proven talents like Lee and Smith tackling the highest of high concepts, but the Academy Award-winning director seemed more pre-occupied playing with his shiny new filmmaking toys rather than focusing on telling a decent story, with the entirely digital youthful recreation of the former Fresh Prince actually being pretty convincing. At least until it had to move, or talk, or do anything that wasn't remaining completely still.

Gemini Man turned out to be one of the biggest box office bombs of last year, losing $100m for Paramount and wasting a killer concept that had almost unlimited potential as the focus of a game-changing action movie.


Contributor

I don't do social media, so like or follow me in person but please maintain a safe distance or the authorities will be notified. Don't snap me though, I'll probably break. I was once labelled a misogynist on this very site in a twenty paragraph-long rant for daring to speak ill of the Twilight franchise. I stand by what I said, it's crap.