10 Things You Learn Rewatching Halloween: Resurrection (2002)

Trick Or Treat, Motherf***er!?

Hallowen Resurrection
Dimension Films

The Halloween franchise has certainly had its ups and downs, with certain installments being more divisive than others but the franchise had never experienced hatred quite in the way it did when Halloween: Resurrection was released in 2002.

Fans hated this thing with a fiery passion. Unlike prior movies, Halloween: Resurrection had to endure the full force of an internet backlash, as people proclaimed this installment 'ruined the franchise' forever. To this day, it is the most detested Halloween sequel and the one frequently cited as the franchise's lowest point.

So is it really that bad? Could this film really be worse than Halloween 6, the one that had Michael become an incestuous father and leading an underground cult?

Let's find out...

10. The Music Is.... Good?

Michael Myers In Halloween Resurrection
Dimension Films

Let's start on a surprisingly positive note.

Halloween: Resurrection has what is easily the best score of the last four films. Composer Danny Lux may have risen to fame composing music for decidedly lighter fare such as Dawson's Creek and Melrose Place, but his sonic sensibilities fit well within the Halloween franchise.

Crucially, Lux seems to understand that Carpenter's original score's power is in its simplicity and opts to preserve that rather than giving it another big make-over.

Sure, there are a few new additions that are Lux's own, such as the more-refined percussive elements and the inclusion of some more ethereal choral synths. But these are all done in service of the classic theme rather than hampering it as previous incarnations like Halloween 6's electric guitar score and H20's orchestral score did.

Even the rest of Lux's score is fairly solid, with him crafting some moody and effective pieces. But sadly, the film has absolutely no idea how to utilize any of it (including the main theme) properly. Instead, all of Lux's original work is pretty much just cut down to 'false startles' and eerie tones, sounding like every other horror movie of the era.


9. THAT Awful Retcon

Halloween h20 ending
Dimension Films

In the interest of keeping Michael Myers alive in the narrative, the creative team behind Halloween: Resurrection faced the difficult task of explaining how Michae could still be alive after being decapitated in H20. And somehow, they settled on the absolute worst solution imaginable.

According to Resurrection, Michael switched outfits with a paramedic before H20's finale, letting Michael escape and leaving Laurie to decapitate the wrong man. In theory, this is dumb but nothing too far removed from some of the lower points of previous films. Heck, it's practically a rip-off of the ending of the Halloween 6 Producer's Cut.

But in execution, this is horrendous. All of this is communicated to the audience through one big exposition dump by some nurse characters the audience never sees again right at the start of the film. To accompany it, we get flashbacks that hilariously have Michael still carrying his knife around even after he's supposedly 'in disguise'.

It's an absolutely laughable sequence that gets the film off to a wonky start. Not only does it undermine everything that made H20's ending so thrilling, but it's also just written and shot in about the worst way imaginable. It's the worst kind of retcon in that it raises way more questions than it answers and seems to have been tossed in without so much as a second thought.

It's as if one of the writers' lost a bet and had to write the most ridiculous reason they could think of for Michael to be back, and it somehow made it into the finished film.


8. Laurie's Swan Song

Halloween Resurrection
Dimension Films

Poor Jamie Lee Curtis.

If nothing else, rewatching this film makes one exceedingly grateful to David Gordon Green, Danny McBride, and everyone at Blumhouse for giving Jamie Lee another go at Laurie Strode because she deserves so much more than this.

Appearing in the first few minutes of the film, Laurie Strode has been institutionalized after the events of H20. When Michael inevitably shows up, she has a face-off with him on the roof and attempts to kill him. This doesn't go as planned and Michael unceremoniously stabs her and throws her off the roof.

Curtis has been exceedingly vocal in the years since Resurrection's release about not being at-all-pleased with the film or her role in it, openly stating that she was practically forced into taking part in the sequence due to contractual obligations buried in the fine print of her H20 contract. And it's pretty obvious to see why. Curtis plays it like a pro, delivering a performance that is light-years ahead of any other performance in this film, but it is painful to watch her reduced to this.

To top it all off, her death has literally no impact on the story. She dies in the opening minutes and the entire sequence has no bearing on the rest of the film, whatsoever. Her death and the way Miramax featured Jamie Lee Curtis's appearance prominently in all of the marketing was nothing more than a cheap ploy to get butts in seats.


7. The Concept Is Outrageously Stupid

Halloween Resurrection
Dimension Films

In last week's list, I called Halloween H20 'painfully of its era'. Well if H20's carbon-dating was painful, then Resurrection's is excruciating.

The entire plot of the film feels more like parody than reality. A reality show called Dangertainment, run by Busta Rhymes and Tyra Banks, sets their Halloween-night episode inside of the actual Myers house and sends a cast of college students in for the night. And somehow, it is even dumber than it sounds.

Pretty obviously, the film is aiming for the teen audiences of 2002 with this gimmick. But instead, it's just the arduous final breath of a dying franchise, trying desperately to cling to some sense of relevancy in the most mind-numbing way possible.

Of all of the Halloween films, Resurrection has aged the worst. No other entry in the franchise has been so brazenly stupid as to make what is essentially just a pop-culture reference a key part of their actual narrative. This film already felt outdated to audiences in 2002 and now, more than a decade removed, it's nothing more than a cringe-inducing time capsule of early 2000s pop culture.


6. The Entire New Cast Is Atrocious

Halloween Resurrection 2002
Dimension Films

Following the Laurie Strode-centric opening sequence, Resurrection goes on a mad-dash of exposition, introducing about a dozen characters to the audience in the span of about five minutes.

And while these kinds of exposition dumps are rarely a good thing, it would at-the-very-least be much easier to stomach if every single one of the characters its introducing weren't awful. Busta Rhymes, Sean Patrick Thomas, Katee Sackhoff, Tyra Banks, Thomas Ian Nicholas, all of these performances feel as wooden and stilted as performances on actual reality shows.

Even Bianca Kajlich, who would go on to demonstrate acting talent in the years since in things like Curb Your Enthusiasm, gives an incredibly dull performance here and cements herself as far-and-away the worst 'final girl' of the franchise.

The actors themselves certainly do deserve some of the blame, a large portion of it must also be levied at the writing for the characters themselves. Screenwriters Larry Brand and Sean Hood fail to give any of these characters any defining traits beyond one-word adjectives like 'hot' or 'pervy'. They are all one-dimensional cardboard cut-outs that exist solely as people for Michael to slash through.

Seeing as Resurrection remains the only Michael Myers Halloween film to date to not feature either Laurie Strode or Dr. Loomis as central characters, it was in dire need of a strong central character or two. Sadly, no one involved with this production is anywhere near up-to-the-task.


5. Zero Logic

Halloween Resurrection
Dimension Films

The film doesn't just have logic gaps, it is one big logic gap.

From the first moment the Dangertainment crew sets foot in the Myers house, it is established; the real Michael Myers is already there. But because this thing needed to stretch to feature-length, the film stops dead in its tracks and just has the character roam around the house freely for the next thirty minutes of the movie without Michael doing much of anything.

And then when Michael does finally start doing things, it raises even more questions. If all of the characters are stuck inside of the relatively small Myers house, how do none of them hear what the others are doing? Bill is the first member of the main cast to die, getting stabbed through the head as he screams bloody murder, yet no one else in the house hears any of this.

This isn't an exception for this film, its the norm. It pays so little attention to its own established rules that it is mind-numbing. Early on, it's established that each of the characters has a camera attached to them and that there are additional cameras stationed all around the house, and that online viewers can choose to watch any camera they want at any time.

So then how do none of the viewers see the initial murders? And how can Busta Rhymes, dressed up as Michael Myers, have a secretive conversation with the real Michael about he's going to blow his cover if everyone's watching them?

Zero logic or thought was put into any of this.


4. The Editing

Halloween Resurrection 2002 7
Dimension Films

Halloween: Resurrection isn't just a bad movie, it's an eye-sore. It's actually painful to watch at times, and not just because of the incredibly fuzzy quality of those Dangertainment cams.

Instead, a large part of the film's ugliness comes from flat-out awful editing. Even simple sequences like Laurie's death are butchered to the point of incoherency. But things only get worse as the film progresses and introduces the element of the Dangertainment cams.

Editor Robert A. Ferretti, known for editing other timeless classics such as Rocky V, seems to be picking shots at random and just inserting them into the edit for most of the runtime. In the midst of sequences of suspense, the film frequently cuts to various other POVs on the Dangertainment cams, deflating any chance of generating tension.

"What just happened?" indeed, Tyra.

The end result is a confusing and muddled final edit that can't even land the most basic of beats with any kind of assuredness or clarity.


3. It's Pretentiously Full Of Itself

Halloween Resurrection
Dimension Films

One of the most infuriating things about Halloween: Resurrection is just how much it loves itself.

Remember how in 2017's The Mummy, when Russell Crowe quoted dialogue from James Whale's original Bride of Frankenstein, and the entire audience collectively sighed because it was a sh*t film disgracing a great one by even attempting to reference it? That's how all of Halloween: Resurrection feels.

Director Rick Rosenthal returns to the franchise here for the first time since Halloween II, and while he's apparently forgotten how to craft an even-half-decent sequence of suspense, his ability to reference better films has never been stronger. There are all kinds of nods to the original Halloween, from having Sara introduced listening to a lecture of good-and-evil in a classroom to the unintentionally hysterical moment where Rudy punches through a closet door just like Michael.

But it doesn't stop there. The film also drops surface-level references to things like the work of Carl Jung, the careers of infamous serial killers like John Wayne Gacy, and most painfully of all Michael Powell's Peeping Tom.

Powell's film is an absolute classic about a man who films women and kills them with his camera's tripod, so when Michael follows suit early on in this film, it feels less like an homage and more like an insult. This film never comes close to earning any of these references, no matter how highly it thinks of itself.


2. The Worst Finale In Horror Movie History

Halloween Resurrection
Miramax Films

This film is the proud owner of the worst third act in all of horror movie history.

After Michael has whittled the cast down to just Sara and Busta Rhymes' Freddie, he chases them into the garage. It is here that Busta Rhymes decides to take his final stand, making a grand entrance and delivering the iconic line;

"Trick or treat, motherfucker!?"

Busta proceeds to use his kung-fu fighting skills (yes, actually) to fight Michael. And then just when it looks as though Busta's time in the film has finally come to a merciful end and Michael might actually kill him, Busta picks up an electrical cord and proceeds to electrocute Michael Myers in the balls.

This is it, folks. The absolute low point of the franchise. The new film could have a ten-minute sequence of Michael Myers delivering a Shakespearian monologue and it would still not be the worst thing to ever happen to the character, because that right will always belong to this film.

Allegedly, this all had to do with Busta Rhymes insisting on fighting Michael in hand-to-hand combat and initial test audiences saying they wanted to see more of his character in the ending. Which just goes to show, test audiences are the worst.


1. In Summary

Halloween Resurrection Jamie Lee Curtis
Dimension Films

Halloween: Resurrection isn't just the worst film in this franchise, it's the worst film in this franchise by a quarter mile. Fans may hate the film for killing off Laurie and for letting Busta Rhymes beat Michael, but the film deserves to be hated for so much more. It is a truly terrible film in every sense, from the writing, to the direction, to the acting, to the editing. Everything about this film is a mess.

A rewatch of this film is a torture I would not inflict upon my worst enemy, and that's coming from a writer who has genuinely enjoyed watching every one of these films previously, no matter how bad they got. Resurrection is a whole new kind of low.

Haddonfield High Superlatives:

Best Kill: Jen's decapitation is laughably awesome.

Funniest Scene: Any scene with Busta's kung-fu.

Biggest Dick of a Character: The people who made this atrocity.

How Awful of a Town is Haddonfield?: 7 out of 10 (allows a cleary deranged reality television program to exploit its greatest tragedy)

Scream Queen Award: NO ONE. (Curse you Rosenthal for wasting Jamie Lee Curtis...AGAIN!)

Ranking of the Films Revisited Thus Far From Best to Worst: Halloween (1978), Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982), Halloween II (1981), Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989), Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998), Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995), Halloween: Resurrection (2002)

Check out our previous Halloween Retrospectives below:

Halloween

Halloween II

Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers

Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers

Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers

Halloween H20: 20 Years Later


Contributor
Contributor

A film enthusiast and writer, who'll explain to you why Jingle All The Way is a classic any day of the week.