10 Things You Need To Know About J.J. Abrams' Superman: Flyby

Sadly, you're not being Punk'd...

If you think the current slate of superhero movies that are due to come out across the next decade is overwhelming, just remember that it could've been a lot worse. For all the comic book adaptations that Hollywood has in the works, there's been something like a dozen more that never actually made it into production. And for the most part, that's a good thing. Warner Bros. have wrestled with the right way to bring Superman back to the big screen for decades. After totally tanking the original, acclaimed Christopher Reeve-starring series there were projects involving Tim Burton and Kevin Smith, Bryan Singer's love letter to the Reeve films in Superman Returns, before settling on Man Of Steel. Somewhere in the hinterlands between all those unmade and underwhelming films, there is a Superman film so strange, so insane, so non-traditional and so poorly written that you will scarcely believe it was in pre-production for the better part of a decade. Krypton all in one piece? Obviously. Jude Law as Clark Kent? Makes sense. Lex Luthor as an alien? Yeah, that seems like a good idea. Here are ten things you need to know about J.J. Abrams' Superman: Flyby. And it's not pretty.

10. Krypton Is Important

Abrams commented, in the run up to recent grimdark Superman reboot Man Of Steel, on the similarities between his script and Zack Snyder's film. There actually is a lot that Flyby and Man Of Steel have in common, not least of all the importance of Krypton in the film. Obviously Krypton's fairly important in every Superman story - it is where he comes from and all. Man Of Steel spent its first twenty minutes on the planet, with the hero's father Jor-El getting up to all sorts of action-packed shenanigans before jetting his son off to Earth. Flyby also involved Superman's dad, only this time he was immersed in a civil war, pitted against his corrupt brother, Kata-Zor. A trio of Kryptonian villains figure as heavily in Flyby as they do in Man Of Steel, lead by main antagonist Ty-Zor: Kata-Zor's son and so, Superman's cousin.

9. The Origin Story Was Tweaked

Whilst most versions of Superman fighting fellows Kryptonians involves the presence of General Zod, who avoided the destruction of Krypton - you know, the whole reason the Man Of Steel gets sent to Earth in the first place - there's no Phantom Zone prison or any of that nonsense in the Flyby script. Nope, because Krypton hasn't actually been destroyed. Eh what? Yep, J.J. Abrams totally threw out one of the central incidences of the Superman origin story, having Jor-El rocketing his sprog away from Krypton not because it's about to blow up, but so his brother doesn't kill him. Also there's some mumbo jumbo about Superman being €œdestined€ to live on Earth, or something. There's also a weird thing about how Martha and Jonathan Kent are worried their super-powered adopted kid - whose arrival they were warned about ahead of time - might kill them.

8. Henry Cavill And Brandon Routh Both Auditioned

Some interesting news came out regarding Superman: Flyby this week. It turns out that the costume that was being developed for the film had a similar bent to the one eventually worn by Henry Cavill in Man Of Steel, with a €œKryptonian armour€ design and a worrying lack of red trunks. Oh also, Henry Cavill totally wore that prototype costume. Because both he and Brandon Routh, who wound up playing Clark Kent in Bryan Singer's underwhelming Superman Returns, auditioned for the leading part in Flyby. In fact there seems to be very few men in Hollywood with dark hair and chiselled chins that weren't considered for the project, but it seems especially odd that the two men who have since played the character were considered. Especially because they hadn't done as much back then.

7. And A Bunch Of Other People Were Considered

The two were turned down in favour of every man in Hollywood with dark hair and chiselled chins. Whilst Tim Burton's unmade Superman movie had settled on the frankly bonkers casting of Nicolas Cage, Flyby never quite settled on a leading man. Not that it was from lack of trying on the part of the producers. Former star Christopher Reeve was brought on as a creative consultant early on, and his first choice was Tom Welling, who (at the time) starred as the young Clark Kent in superhero soap opera Smallville. The small screen also lead the casting director to That '70s Show-era Ashton Kutcher - put off by the Superman curse - and Angel's David Boreanaz. There were some bonafide film stars in the frame as well. Josh Hartnett, Jude Law, Paul Walker and Brendan Fraser were all considered, but no big name wanted to be tied down to endless sequels.

6. The Rest Of The Cast Was Bonkers

Considering how weird a choice Nicolas Cage was for the part, the producers of Superman: Flyby managed to group together an equally bizarre and disparate cadre of actors to audition for the Man Of Steel. Which they matched with the rest of the casting as well. Amy Adams auditioned for Lois Lane, the role she eventually played in Man Of Steel, but Scarlett Johansson and Felicity's Keri Rusell were also in line; Christopher Walken was in negotiations to play Daily Planet editor Perry White, with Shia LaBeouf (whilst he was still famous) the main pick for Jimmy Olsen; and Anthony Hopkins would've been Jor-El. Lex Luthor was, of course, going to be involved, even if the main villain was going to be those Kryptonian criminals. Apparently Robert Downey, Jr. was the final casting, but before that Johnny Depp and Ralph Fiennes were also given a shot.

5. Lex Luthor Was A UFOlogist (Amongst Other Things)

Abrams was pretty committed to basically ignoring everything that had ever happened in any Superman story before. At least, it seems that way based on his characterisation of Lex Luthor, who went from being an evil scientist entrepreneur guy to a government agent obsessed with UFOs. Like, really obsessed. To the point where he barely seems involved with the actual plot of Superman: Flyby (such as it was), and instead spent most of his time examining a crashed Kryptonian ship. Because he was so crazy for aliens. He probably teamed up with the bad guys at some point but the ultimate twist at the end of the film? That Kryptonian ship was his! Lex Luthor is a Kryptonian now. Which, erm, robs him of his entire motivation for hating the alien Superman. Great job J.J.

4. It Would've Been Directed By McG Or Brett Ratner

Not that J.J. Abrams can be blamed for all of Flyby's issues. At the time he wrote the script he was still toiling away as TV writer, yet to breakthrough with Lost, and instead showrunning the likes of Felicity and Alias. He was untested as a director, and so Warner Bros didn't want to trust him with this huge blockbuster franchise. So instead they went with some more proven successes. Which is a very different thing from actually talented directors you'd want to see direct a Superman film. Zack Snyder's Man Of Steel may not be perfect, buy you can bet it's better than Flyby by McG - the man who brought you the Charlie's Angels films - would've been. McG kept jumping on and off the project, and who was his replacement whenever he got cold feet? Why, none other than Brett Ratner, the total hack whose biggest hit is the Rush Hour films and also subbed for Bryan Singer on X-Men: The Last Stand, which temporarily killed that franchise.

3. Superman Is Killed

Speaking of which - and in a strange move for a film that was supposed to spark off a new series, presumably - Superman was also going to be killed off during the events of Flyby. It made sense (kind of) when Tim Burton was working on a Man Of Steel flick, since The Death (And Return) Of Superman comic was fairly contemporary. J.J. Abrams was writing his script in the early noughties, however, so presumably the reason he was going to bump off his star was to highlight those Christ parallels that Snyder's film handled oh-so-subtley. Although, from the looks of it, it could've been much worse. In Flyby, Superman defeated the evil Kryptonians (piloting a giant mech), but died from being stabbed with a shard of Kryptonite. Simultaneously, Jor-El has committed ritual suicide in a Kryptonian jail. They meet in Kryptonian Heaven and then Superman comes back somehow. This is the man making the new Star Wars, FYI.

2. Kryptonian Kung-Fu Was Involved

The filmmaking world of the early noughties was a different one to now in many ways. Brett Ratner and McG were being considered for big properties. J.J. Abrams was, conversely, not a viable director. And everybody was still in thrall to the mega-successful Matrix, because the crummy sequels hadn't soured everyone. Which doesn't mean that Superman: Flyby was going to be in an way a deep, philosphical study of Clark Kent - perhaps about the nature of what it means to be an alien, the dynamics of power and the like - but that it would've ripped off all of the zero-gravity bullet-time fights. To wit: the bad guys that Superman was set to fight in the film (before they clambered in their surely unnecessary mech suits) came at him with something called €œKryptonian Kung-Fu€, which would've probably looked something like this. Only way more stupid. Better or worse than the last act of Man Of Steel?

1. It Would've Been Terrible

In general, Superman: Flyby would undoubtedly have been worse than Man Of Steel, for all that film's problems. It wouldn't even have matched up to Bryan Singer' Superman Returns, and nobody likes that tedious little film. Honestly, it would've been right around the Superman IV: The Quest For Peace level, and that's one of the worst Hollywood movies ever made. Comic book fans should count their lucky stars that Flyby went through such a torturous production process that there was never a chance of it getting made. Which means that the world was never burdened with having to see Jude Law, or Ashton Kutcher, or TV's Chuck play the Man Of Steel. They also missed out on Kryptonian Kung-Fu, more films by Brett Ratner, a more confusing origin story, and a promise that the next film would involve Superman flying off in a rocket to his home planet. The world where Superman: Flyby got made is like some sort of dystopian alternate reality, where superhero films never underwent their current renaissance, the MCU never occurred, and Abrams probably wouldn't have gotten a chance to resurrect Star Wars properly. Would you have liked to have seen Superman: Flyby? Discuss J.J.'s attempt down in the commments.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/