10 Times Alfred Pennyworth Utterly DESTROYED Batman

The only weapons Alfred needs to destroy the Dark Knight are quick fit and dry humour.

Alfred Pennyworth Portion of Nothing
DC Comics

It's almost impossible to think about Batman without immediately following that thought up with Alfred Pennyworth, Bruce's loyal butler, armorer, mission specialist, medic, conscience and surrogate father.

Loyal to a fault, Alfred has literally given his life to protect Bruce and other members of the Bat-Family. He has proved adept as a fighter - after all, most versions of Alfred spent time either in the military or as an intelligence agent - and he is the only member of the Bat-Family who Bruce doesn't frown upon for using a firearm, with Pennyworth partial to a shotgun or antique blunderbuss.

Alfred's greatest weapon, though, is his ability to completely put Bruce in his place, generally through the driest of dry British wit, biting sarcasm, and the confidence that he is virtually the only Family member who can escape Bruce's wrath for speaking his mind.

Despite beatings from the many members of the Caped Crusader's rogues gallery, despite the broken back and fractured skull and bullet wounds, despite being driven to the point of madness by multiple villains, the only person in Bruce's life who can bring him to a halt virtually any time he wants, and all with a handful of words, is Alfred Pennyworth.

Let's look at ten times that Alfred schooled Bruce in knocking someone down a notch or two.

10. Justice League: Doom - Alfred Treats Bruce Like A Kid By Making Him Eat His Dinner And Take A Nap

We have been told many times that, as Batman, Bruce Wayne pushes his body and mind to superhuman limits. Alfred once referred to him as 'possibly the best-conditioned man on the planet.'

Because of Bruce's indomitable will, he often makes a point of trying to push himself past the point where he should be taking a step back to recharge and relax.

Enter: Alfred.

In Justice League: Doom, Alfred recognizes that Bruce is far, far overdue for food, sleep, and healing. He tries reasoning with Bruce, and when that doesn't work literally steps into his 'dad' role by blocking Bruce from the Batcave and telling him that he is not going back to work without Alfred stitching up his wounds, eight hours of rest, and a meal of Alfred's famous chicken soup (said chicken soup would also make a pivotal appearance in the classic Batman: The Animated Series 'Heart of Ice' as a weapon to stop Mr. Freeze).

Begrudgingly, Bruce agrees and lets Alfred escort him to the kitchen, where, in Alfred's words, Bruce can "brood while you eat and I'll stitch up your wounds".

The scene is a great mix of the love, exasperation, and humour with which Alfred views Master Bruce.


9. Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm - Alfred Points Out How Ridiculous Bruce's Alter Ego Life Really Is

Alfred Batman: The Animated Series
Warner Bros. Animation

Mask of the Phantasm is perhaps the finest Batman movie, animated or otherwise. Aside from creating a fantastic character in Andrea Beaumont/Phantasm, it gives a very nuanced look at Bruce's final transformation into Batman.

At this point in Bruce's life, Alfred is still making attempts to bring some normalcy to his surrogate son's existence - suggesting he pursue relationships, reminding him of the good things in the world, and trying to steer him away from the darkness that Batman continuously walks so close to.

As he often does, Alfred relies on wit and sarcasm to do this, and he of course does it extremely well.

During a news broadcast, a corrupt Gotham politician (is there any other kind?) named Arthur Reeves critiques Batman's work as being that of a "potential madman".

Bruce, who is clearly annoyed, turns off the TV, whereupon Alfred steps in to 'reassure' Bruce with, "Why, you're the very model of sanity. Oh, by the way, I pressed your tights and put away your exploding gas balls" - to which Bruce simply replies, "Thank you, Alfred."

While still proving he is ever the capable servant, Alfred takes this opportunity to point out just how bizarre Bruce's existence as a billionaire playboy who can have literally anything but who spends his days in an underground cave and his nights zipping around Gotham with 'exploding gas balls' really is.


8. Batman Begins - Alfred Picks A Questionable Time To Critique Bruce's Fitness Regimen

Batman Begins tells the tale of, well, Batman beginning. The 2005 Christopher Nolan movie introduces us to Christian Bale's raspy-voiced Dark Knight and his origin.

During the movie, Bruce becomes entangled with the League of Shadows, an ancient group who believes that the only way to save humanity is to occasionally destroy places that have become so dark and corrupt that they are beyond saving.

Like, say, Gotham City.

During a lavish party at Wayne Manor, the League infiltrates the house and League leader Ra's al Ghul confronts Bruce. After throwing a pretend drunken tantrum to get rid of his guests, Bruce and the League get down to business. As part of the ensuing chaos, a fire breaks out and Bruce becomes trapped under a fallen beam.

Master Wayne and Alfred lift, but can't budge the beam. Knowing what needs to be done, Alfred pricks at Bruce's ego with the classic line, "What is the point of all those push-ups if you can't even lift a bloody log?" Incredulous at Alfred's attitude and wit, even as death surrounds them, Bruce puts those many push ups to work and moves the beam.

An amazing physique, one that allows him to compete with literal gods, has always been one of Batman's best tools. Leave it to Alfred to bring it to bear when the moment called for it.


7. The Dark Knight Returns - Alfred Reminds Bruce How Insane Coming Out Of Retirement Is

Alfred Bruce Dark Knight Returns
WB Animation

The Dark Knight Returns is Frank Miller's seminal take on a Bruce Wayne ten years into retirement; a faded urban legend in a world where the only hero left is a government puppet Superman. A combination of factors culminate one stormy night in Bruce putting the suit back on and returning to the streets.

Alfred, naturally, feels it's his role to attempt to talk Bruce out of what he views as a needless effort - in his mind, Bruce did his part and now deserves a quiet life. The story is full of jabs from Alfred trying to remind Bruce of this.

The morning after Bruce's first night back, Alfred is healing the many aches Bruce is suffering from and advises him, "If it's suicide you're after, Master Bruce, I have the recipe for an old family potion. It's slow in working and quite painful. You'd like it".

A few minutes later he reminds him, "You know, sir, that there is precedent for wheelchair detectives". To which Bruce can only reply, "Shut up, Alfred."

While running through Bruce's daily schedule, another opportunity arises:

Alfred: "Your accountants wait in the West Wing, sir."

Bruce: "Tell them I'm sick."

Alfred: "I shan't have to lie."

Alfred even suggests that Bruce is now a member of the 'Committee for the Prevention of Obsessive Behaviour in Middle-Aged Men.'

Despite Pennyworth's best efforts, Bruce simply won't be deterred.


6. Harley Quinn: Batman's Back, Man - Alfred Spends Most Of The Episode Treating Bruce Like A Child

The animated Harley Quinn series is a wonder - funny, touching, thoughtful, and very, very adult.

The beginning of the Season Two storyline included the tale of Bruce Wayne being recovered from the rubble of a building blown up by the Joker. After weeks in a coma, Bruce wakes up in Wayne Manor, with Alfred cheerfully keeping up the illusion that all is well, only for Bruce to find out that Gotham is now a hellscape ruled by different members of his rogues gallery.

Bruce immediately wants to resume protecting Gotham, which Alfred shuts down by reminding Bruce that at this point he can't even put his "sockie poos" on his "feetsies". Undeterred, Bruce has Lucius Fox design him an Iron Man-like suit with an AI named Veronica. On its first use, Bruce gets pummelled by Bane, who breaks both his legs and destroys the armour.

Throughout the episode, Alfred attempts to show a whiny Bruce over and over that he is simply not capable of fighting, armour or not, and at one point tells him ", Your ego is writing checks your broken body cannot cash". Bruce, who wants none of this, ignores Alfred's advice, ends up even more injured, and has to be rescued by Alfred and Batgirl.

The shame of it all...


5. Batman V Superman - Alfred Laments The Lack Of Baby Waynes

Alfred has often lamented Bruce's lack of relationships beyond the Bat-Family and his Justice League allies. In both comics and movies, Alfred has repeatedly reminded Bruce that there are bigger things in the world than justice, vengeance and the costume.

Bruce, for his part, seems unable to ever really grasp what a relationship means. Despite flings with dozens of women, including other heroes, the closest he ever got to true happiness was ALMOST marrying Selena Kyle. He does have Damian, his son, but that offspring was the result of a sexual encounter that only happened because Bruce was drugged by Talia al Ghul.

Moving on...

Jeremy Irons plays an excellent Alfred in the DCEU; one who willingly helps Bruce in his war on crime but never fails to remind Bruce that there's more to life than Batman.

In Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice - although the dialogue is originally from The Dark Knight Returns - Alfred picks up an empty wine bottle and tells Bruce that he hopes the "next generation" of Waynes won't inherit an empty wine cellar, before deliberately muttering "not that there's likely to be a next generation".

In one line, he not only makes it clear that he feels Bruce is wallowing in selfpity and alcohol, he also reminds him that he is not getting any younger and that everything he has built may end up going to no one.

Ouch.


4. The Batman's Grave - Alfred Rebuts Bruce's Questionable Logic In A Murder Investigation

Alfred Porcelain
DC Comics

The Batman's Grave is a fantastic mini-series that involves Bruce attempting to solve a string of murders, imagining the last moments of the victims' lives as he does so.

The Alfred of this story is growing increasingly worried that Bruce's path will very shortly put him into the empty gravesite next to those of his parents, which Alfred tends to once per week.

As a result, Alfred is more prickly than usual, which manifests itself in one exchange that critiques not only Bruce's image of himself as Gotham's sole saviour but also the Gotham City PD.

Bruce is defending his carriage of this murder case, which, realistically, should be a police investigation, by explaining to Alfred that Commissioner Jim Gordon is working with an overstretched police force, many of whom are either criminals themselves or in league with criminals, and that Gordon doesn't need another complicated matter on his plate.

Alfred rebuts this by sarcastically complimenting Bruce on allowing Gordon to get 15 minutes of privacy in the bathroom, and further adds that if Bruce took over the amount of illegal beatings the Gotham PD lays out during they day he could probably allow Gordon to take a vacation.

It's at once a reminder of Bruce's place in the underbelly of Gotham and the fact that underbelly sometimes doesn't deserve protecting.


3. Detective Comics - Alfred Mocks Batman's Whole Shtick

Batman Alfred
DC Comics

The current version of the Dark Knight is, well... dark. Brooding. Serious. Almost self-loathing in some aspects.

Luckily, we have Alfred to remind Bruce not to be, to paraphrase Heath Ledger's Joker, "so serious".

As mentioned, Alfred often ends up playing doctor for Bruce, stitching up wounds, setting broken bones, even performing more serious tasks like X-rays, digging out bullets, decontaminating toxins, and performing minor surgeries.

It was during one such repair session that Alfred managed two separate shots at Bruce - hitting both his public image and his self-image.

For starters, while stitching up a nasty cut on Bruce's shoulder, Bruce quietly says "Oww", a minor thing that the annoyed Alfred immediately jumps on by sarcastically suggesting that he should alert the media that the fearsome, stoic Batman admitted that something hurt.

He follows this up by asking what would have happened on the night that Bruce was inspired to become Batman if nothing had came through the window that Bruce was staring through.

Of course, what came crashing through that window on that fateful night was a screeching bat, which Bruce felt would scare criminals.

Alfred suggests that if Bruce hadn't been so inspired, his motif may have become that of 'The Curtain', a theatre-themed vigilante stalking the streets of Gotham.

Nothing like kicking a man when he's already nursing wounds.


2. Batman: Earth 1 - Alfred Proves Bruce Isn't Ready To Don The Cowl

Alfred Pennyworth Bruce Wayne Earth 1
DC Comics

DC loves the multiverse. One alternative realm, Earth 1, illustrates a more realistic story of Bruce training to become Batman - and Alfred's role in it.

It depicts a very different relationship between Alfred and Bruce. In this reality, Alfred was a Royal Marine who saved Thomas Wayne during a battle in the Middle East. During the rescue, Alfred lost a leg, which Thomas replaced with a high-tech Wayne Enterprises prosthetic.

Jump ahead 30 years, when Bruce is ready to become Batman. In the intervening time, Alfred became Bruce's legal guardian when Thomas and Martha were killed and has been more of a bodyguard than a butler.

As he prepares to don the cowl, Bruce has become pretentious, arrogant, and moody. Alfred, who has tried to prepare Master Wayne for his crimefighting career finally snaps at his ward's attitude, slapping him across the face and challenging Bruce to take him down.

What follows is a no-holds barred battle between the two, with Alfred putting every aspect of his Marine training to use, all the while critiquing Bruce's idea's for his mission - not using guns, not conducting recon, and not considering any combat tactics.

Despite Alfred's age, Bruce only beats him by finally disabling his prosthetic leg, before admitting that Alfred is right: he's not yet ready to declare war on crime.


1. Batman Adventures / Legends Of The Dark Knight, Vol 1 - Alfred Is Not Afraid To Exploit Bruce's Origin

Alfred Bruce
DC Comics

The death of Bruce Wayne's parents is considered to be one of the most tragic events in comics. Two good people, pillars of Gotham City society, gunned down in front of their son. It was also the catalyst to send the now orphaned and very wealthy Bruce down his dark path of vengeance.

Alfred, however, who was as close to Martha and Thomas Wayne as anyone, has no problem seeing a lighter side in their deaths.

In an issue of The Batman Adventures, Alfred responds to Bruce's criticism of his sandwich-making skills with a surprisingly dark joke:

"Do you know what I did to the last person that said that to me, Sir?"

"What?"

"Hired a junkie to shoot her and her husband in an alley."

Anyone else daring to make fun of their death would no doubt end up in traction for several weeks, yet Alfred threw the line out there like he was making a knock-knock joke.

In another instance of downplaying their death, Alfred bets a 'very early in his career' Batman that he is too overconfident in himself and his abilities. With the bet laid, Alfred sets out to hire a team to closely recreate the Wayne's death. Batman comes across Alfred's setup, becomes emotionally invested, and proceeds to take a beating as a result. At that point, Alfred arrives, removes a dollar from a pouch on Bruce's utility belt, and walks away.

Cold.


Contributor

Child of the Canadian '80s. Fan of Star Wars, Marvel (films), DC (animated films), WWE, classic cartoons. Enjoys debating with his two teenage sons about whether hand-drawn or computer animation is better but will watch it all anyways. Making ongoing efforts to catalogue and understand all WhatCulture football references.