10 Times Your Favourite Directors Totally Let You Down

You're not who we thought you were.

Lost World Spielberg If the final line of Some Like It Hot is anything to go by, "Nobody's perfect." And that doesn't just go for the average schmuck off the streets, either: it goes for some of the world's most acclaimed directors, who - just like you - are capable of turning in what might as well be branded "a load of old crap." Okay, so perhaps that's a little harsh, but there's certainly some truth to such an observation: even the filmmakers who we hold in the highest esteem - and have created some of the best motion pictures of all-time - have turned in some inferior products. When this happens, of course, it can not only be disappointing, but surprisingly disheartening, too, resulting in strange feelings of being "let down" - a kind of embarrassment, even. Join us now, then, as we delve into the filmographies of 10 highly respected, world class filmmakers, and take a look at those movies inherent to their canons that caused us to turn away and bite our lips in a state of awkward confusion. True, some of these filmmakers have let us down on more than on occassion, and in those cases we've picked the worst offenders...

10. Gangs Of New York - Martin Scorsese

Gangs Of New York Leonardo DicaprioParamount PicturesGangs Of New York is nothing close to the worst ever Martin Scorsese movie; there are others, such as Boxcar Bertha, New York, New York, and Kundun, all noticeably lesser in quality that this flick, which features the likes of Daniel Day-Lewis, Cameron Diaz and Leonardo DiCaprio. And yet, in terms of feeling "let down" by a picture, this is arguably the one that takes the prize, given the sheer potential - and talent - that is on show throughout. Here's Scorsese at his least prepared, at the helm of a picture that feels like it's being made up on the spot. Where to start on the problems with this movie, then? How about with Leonardo DiCaprio, who is wholly unconvincing in the leading role? Or with the sappy love story, which feels at odds with the tone of the movie and makes ill use of Cameron Diaz? Gangs of New York was also reportedly recut and edited into something resembling incomprehension before being shaped as it appears now, but there's no denying that the movie feels messy and unfocused - despite an excellent, Oscar-worthy performance from the legend that is Mr Day. Lewis.

9. The Lovely Bones - Peter Jackson

Paramount PicturesParamount PicturesOff the back of his immensely successful adaptations of The Lord of the Rings, Peter Jackson had Hollywood in the palm of his hand. Indeed, he was gifted with the chance to do pretty much whatever he wanted, and chose to render his dream project - a remake of King Kong - for a new generation. The resulting film was something of a triumph - adventurous, romantic, visually stunning; a worthy successor to the legacy of Rings, no doubt. For his next film, though, he set Alice Sebold's acclaimed novel, The Lovely Bones, in his sights. Big mistake, Jackson. Given how brilliant pretty much everything Peter Jackson had jumped upon up had turned out until The Lovely Bones, nobody was doubting the fact that his adaptation of this novel - about a young girl who is raped and murdered and watches on from Heaven - would be a magnificent one. Unfortunately, though, the director completely misjudges the material, making for one of the most tone confused movies in recent memory. There are good visuals, but there is no poetry, no heart, no consistency. It was just one big fumble on Jackson's part.

8. The Lost World: Jurassic Park - Steven Spielberg

Jurassic Park Sarah Harding The Lost World Julianne MooreUniversal PicturesGoing by the magic that he worked on the Indiana Jones sequels, fans of the world's most famous movie director - and there are millions of them - had high hopes for the follow-up to Jurassic Park, which was by all accounts one of the biggest movie events of all-time and remains a staple classic to this day. But whereas Jurassic Park felt fresh and innovative in all the ways that it still does now, The Lost World - which brought Jeff Goldblum's Dr. Ian Malcolm in as the main career - felt like Steven Spielberg on autopilot; a man going through the motions. So it's safe to say that, essentially, that the spark is entirely missing. Whereas every scene in Jurassic Park clung to an excited energy, Spielberg's sequel doesn't even feel like he's behind the camera. The pacing is off, the action scenes - aside from one mesmerising sequence involving a cliff and a trailer - are lackluster, and the characters are largely bland and unsympathetic. For what could have been one of the greatest sequels ever made, The Lost World is a notable letdown - presumably a result of Spielberg's lack of overall enthusiasm.

7. The Ladykillers - The Coen Brothers

Touchstone PicturesTouchstone PicturesStrange. Whereas almost all of the films in the Coen Brothers' canon feel like "them," so to speak, The Ladykillers feels like it's been imported from a parallel universe where one of the siblings is actually Tim Burton. Without a doubt, anyone expecting the consistent brilliance of regular Coen fare with this movie was bound to be disappointed upon first sitting down to this frenzied mess of a remake; and did we really need it in the first place, given that the original movie is something of a comedy classic in its own right? The answer: no thanks, guys. Tom Hanks found himself at the centre of this thing, and it's probably safe to say that he probably doesn't regret signing up to this movie in retrospect, given that his performance is downright demented (in a good way), and is a far cry from anything else he's ever done. But the rest of the movie falls entirely flat in all the ways you expect a Coen movie not to. The sense of desperation clinging to every scene is largely off-putting, as joke after joke falls flat. The weirdest thing here is that this is clearly a passion project, and yet it feels so very half-assed.

6. Psycho - Gus Van Sant

Universal PicturesUniversal PicturesGus Van Sant is certainly one of Hollywood's most experimental filmmakers, so his work tends to divide audiences on a frequent basis. Still, whatever you think of his movies, there's no denying his place as one of cinema's most interesting and critically-acclaimed directors. There's also no denying the fact that his decision to make Psycho was something akin to a travesty - even if it was done as a full-blown experiment, as Van Sant has continually insisted. Starring Vince Vaughn and Julianne Moore, this shot for shot remake is downright awful. Why, then? How did it go so wrong? Well, essentially, in Van Sant's decision to literally remake Alfred Hitchcock's seminal movie in a shot-for-shot fashion, he comprised his integrity as a filmmaker. It doesn't matter that Van Sant's intention was to explore whether or not reproducing a famous and popular film in its exact quantities would result in the same levels of adoration - the fact that he touched a classic of this kind was not only a let down for his fans, but a let down for the cinematic community in general. The truly appropriate word, really, is "sacrilege."

5. Death Proof - Quentin Tarantino

Death Proof Kurt RussellMiramax PicturesChances are that, considering the immense and highly idiosyncratic nature of Quentin Tarantino's movies, the man would eventually produce something that rubbed people the wrong way - especially since, as time has gone on, his pictures have become more and more obvious in their standings as homage-clad pastiches. Which is to say, the heavy pop cultural referencing in films like Pulp Fiction and Jackie Brown was nowhere near as obvious as it was in, say, Kill Bill or Django Unchained; one could even argue that Tarantino is regressing somewhat. So it was with Death Proof, however, that Quentin Tarantino finally took a tumble and succeeded in adding a blemish on his otherwise consistent filmography. The problem with Death Proof, then, was the level of indulgence on display; Tarantino clearly fell too far in love with his own voice whilst writing the movie, and as a result all the characters come off sounding exactly like him - not to mention that their conversations are surprisingly boring. There were movies of genius, of course, like the final car chase, but ultimately the film was a major let down.

4. A Good Year - Ridley Scott

A Good Year20th Century FoxThere is only one appropriate response to the likes of A Good Year: "What the f*ck is this?" And so for some reason that is yet to be explained, Ridley Scott (of Gladiator fame) and Russell Crowe (of Gladiator fame) decided to jet to France and make the "most generic romantic comedy movie ever," presumably as a way of implementing a vacation in their work schedules. The resulting film is so bland and so passive that it's a wonder that anybody ever bothered using the script for anything other than as something to put a coffee mug on. So why do we feel let down by this? Mostly, because A Good Year doesn't feel at all like a Ridley Scott vehicle nor a Russell Crowe film. There is the truest sense of apathy lingering around this project, as Crowe attempts to seduce Marion Cotillard against a variety of backdrops straight out of a holiday brochure. The dialogue, the setting and the storyline are so vanilla that there's no way in hell that Scott felt personally attached to the project, and just wanted to relax in the sun and get paid. For a director of "auteur" status, that's rather disappointing.

3. Elizabethtown - Cameron Crowe

ElizabethtownParamount PicturesThe decline of Cameron Crowe has been an odd one. Lauded by critics for his sweet yet undeniably cool romantic comedies like Say Anything... and Jerry Maguire, Crowe confused a lot of people with the bizarre but interesting Vanilla Sky, and then pushed his luck a bit too far with the resoundingly awful Elizabethtown, which pegs Kirsten Dunst as something of a Manic Pixie Dream Girl, and Orlando Bloom as the yawn-machine tasked with winning her over. What should have been rather inspired came across as merely pretentious and one-note. The biggest issues with Elizabethtown come firstly with its script (cliched and unbelievable and existing of nothing but people just wandering around making polite conversation), and then with the supposed chemistry between Miss Dunst and Mr. Bloom, in as much as there isn't any. At all. The fact that this is a romantic comedy of sorts aside, that's something that Crowe should have really insisted on getting right, given that it's the entire point of the picture. Why did Crowe think this was a good idea? What made him sit down and write it? Wasted effort.

2. The Adventures Of Sharkboy & Lavagirl In 3D - Robert Rodriguez

Sharkboy LavagirlDimension FilmsRobert Rodriguez presumably alienated his entire fanbase when he decided to create an entire Hollywood movie out of a couple of characters that his six-year-old child scrawled on a piece of paper one day - and no, that's not a joke; it really happened. Hearing that a motion picture called "The Adventures of Sharkboy & Lavagirl In 3D" is in production is a terrifying concept in its own right, but learning that Robert Rodriguez - the man behind Sin City, From Dusk Till Dawn and Desperado - was at the helm is another thing entirely. WHAT WAS HE THINKING? The results, then, as you can imagine, were downright terrible - the sort of movie watching experience that is only improved by ingesting a bowl of hallucinogens beforehand, and then dying before the movie actually starts. So should we really feel let down by the fact that Rodriguez made a movie for his kids, then? Probably not, and yet... there's something about the idea that this is stuck to his filmography forever that is increasingly annoying, because at least those Spy Kids movies had a sense of self-awareness. We doubt that his kids even liked this.

1. Jack - Francis Ford Coppola

Jack Robin WilliamsBuena Vista PicturesThe fact that Jack exists is, quite frankly, insane. The fact that it was directed by the man who also helmed the likes of The Godfather and Apocalypse Now - two of the greatest motion pictures in the history of cinematic endeavour - is even insaner. So although Francis Ford Coppola has made a number of questionable pictures over the course of his long and inevitably spotty career, it is Jack that stands out as the most curious of all the blemishers inherent to his filmography, because it's seriously bewildering to think that he actually made it. Likelihood is that Jack was a result of a mental breakdown on Coppola's part; years after the production of Apocalypse Now sent him to the edges of sanity, his brain decided that this was something he should jump upon - an insensitive and mawkish film about Robin Williams playing a small boy trapped in a man's (very hairy) body. The picture plays out like Big (wit Tom Hanks), but with none of its winking self-awareness, nor any of the gags. Quite simply, it's a terrible, embarrassing picture, made even more so because Mr. The Godfather directed it. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.