10 Times Two Actors Perfectly Executed The Same Character

When iconic roles have been exquisitely performed... in uniquely different ways.

Joker Jack Nicholson Heath Ledger
Warner Bros.

At the heart of every good movie sits an engaging character that audiences will either love or hate. And the development of that person and their relationship with other characters will always be a key factor in telling a good story. We live in an age where popular films from the past are often revisited, and we are seeing more and more examples of different actors playing the same roles.

Stepping into the enormous shoes of an established and iconic character can often be seen as a daunting task, where inevitably the actor is either going to do the role justice in their own way, or potentially fall flat on their face. In addition to remaking classic movies from yesteryear, we are also seeing modern films - specifically from the superhero/comic book genre - being rebooted, often within the space of just a few years.

Since the beginning of the millennium, we’ve already seen three different versions of Spider-Man, with Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland all stepping into the role, and all doing a decent enough job. However, there are also a number of other shared performances that absolutely stand out from the crowd.

10. Freddy Krueger - Robert Englund & Jackie Earle Haley

A Nightmare on Elm Street Freddy Krueger Robert Englund Jackie Earle Haley
New Line Cinema/Warner Bros.

Writer and director Wes Craven changed the face of the horror genre when he created A Nightmare On Elm Street in 1984 and unleashed the terrifying antagonist Freddy Krueger onto an unsuspecting audience. The movie broke new ground with the character, a razor-fingered demon who stalks his teenage victims in a place they have no escape from… their dreams. The concept devised by Craven allowed for endless creative possibilities for what the killer was capable of doing. And in Robert Englund, he found the perfect actor to take on the despicable role.

Englund would play Freddy in seven sequel movies and truly made the role his own, although it is fair to say that over time the quality of the films drastically diminished. The character of Freddy would eventually become a parody of himself, leaning heavily on humour over horror. Then, the unimaginable happened when the series was rebooted by director Samuel Bayer, with a new version of A Nightmare On Elm Street in 2010 and with Jackie Earle Haley stepping up to play Krueger.

The movie was almost completely discounted by the franchise's fickle fanbase. However, despite this Haley would actually go on to create an entirely acceptable version of Freddy; moving the character back into darker waters, foregoing the humour and providing a version that was about as good as you could hope for, without Robert Englund himself donning the dirty striped jumper and knife-fingered glove.


9. Count Dracula - Christopher Lee & Gary Oldman

Dracula Christopher Lee Gary Oldman
Hammer Horror/Columbia Pictures

Count Dracula is the most infamous of all screen Vampires, with his legend dating back to Bram Stoker’s classic gothic horror novel published in 1897. Universal Studios first brought the legend to the screen in 1931, starring vintage actor Bela Lugosi. But it would be 27 years later when Hammer Horror revisited the tale in 1958, with Christopher Lee stepping into the iconic role. The legendary British actor would provide the definitive version of the character, and the version that most film fans think of first when thinking of Drac.

Lee played Dracula with an eerie seductive quality that turned absolutely vicious when needed, and he would reprise the role numerous times for the famed horror studio. It would be some years later that the legacy would be revisited by director Francis Ford Coppola (The Godfather), with an adaptation which stayed faithful to the original text like no other film had before, in Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992).

The movie, which won numerous Academy Awards, featured an ensemble cast including Keanu Reeves, Winona Ryder and Anthony Hopkins, but will always be best remembered for Gary Oldman’s unique and sinister take on the Count himself. Oldman played a very human, younger version of the character when visiting Victorian London, as well as an ancient and iconic decaying version of the vampire in his true form at his Transylvanian castle, in what is undoubtedly the performance of Oldman's career.


8. Superman/Clark Kent - Christopher Reeve & Henry Cavill

Man of Steel Superman Christopher Reeve Henry Cavill
Warner Bros.

Superman first appeared in Action Comics #1 (1938) and has remained one of the best loved and most popular superheroes ever since. His debut appearance on screen was in the TV series Adventures of Superman (1952-1958) before The New Adventures of Superman animated show aired from 1966-1970. It was then only a matter of time before Hollywood produced the first live-action movie, with the Richard Donner-directed Superman (1978).

That film featured Christopher Reeve in the role of the heroic alien and his alter-ego Clarke Kent, and he immediately optimised the role, playing the character again in Superman II (1980) and a further two times, ending with Superman IV: The Quest For Peace (1987). At this point the quality of the movies noticeably dipped, and Warner Bros. would turn their attention to DC’s other significant comic book character, Batman. It wouldn’t be until Superman Returns (2006) that the character returned to the silver screen, in a largely forgettable movie.

Then, Man Of Steel (2013) arrived as DC looked to put together a series of films to rival the success of Marvel Studios, producing a fresh origin story grounded in a gritty realism to match the tone of Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy. Henry Cavill stepped into the iconic suit and produced an engaging performance and a darker version of the character, to finally rival that of Christopher Reeve.


7. Professor Charles Xavier - Patrick Stewart & James McAvoy

Charles Xavier Professor X Patrick Stewart James McAvoy X-Men
20th Century Fox

When Bryan Singer’s X-Men (2000) landed at the turn of the century, it heralded a new era for both Marvel Comics and comic book movies in general, sparking the beginning of a successful franchise that would lay the groundwork for what would come later with the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The leader of the X-Men, Charles Xavier, aka Professor X, was played by Patrick Stewart, a Shakespearean-trained actor with his roots in theatre, before becoming an iconic sci-fi figure as Captain Jean-Luc Pickard in Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Stewart's turn as the sophisticated and powerful superhero would continue through the original X-Men trilogy, before the franchise took a fresh turn with X-Men: First Class (2011), taking the story back in time to the sixties when Charles was a young man and telling the origin story of the X-Men with James McAvoy assuming that role. The next movie, and one of the strongest in the series, X-Men: Days Of Future Past (2014) brought the two actors into the same film, telling an engaging story based around time travel and linking the two generations of the X-Men together to great effect.

The series has been able to nicely utilise the two different timelines, focusing on McAvoy’s version progressing through to becoming the present-day Professor X. Elsewhere, Patrick Stewart’s version has appeared at the end of his days in the Wolverine spin-off Logan (2017), and most recently in the mind-bending Doctor Strange In The Multiverse Of Madness (2022).


6. Obi-Wan Kenobi - Alec Guiness & Ewan McGregor

Star Wars Obi-Wan Kenobi Alec Guinness Ewan McGregor
Lucasfilm

George Lucas created a phenomenon when he unleashed Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope in 1977, the ultimate sci-fi space adventure story which really needs no introduction. Over a trilogy of films, Lucas introduced us to the story of Luke Skywalker and a rebellion against the evil galactic empire controlled by Emperor Palpatine and his warlord Darth Vader.

In the opening episode, Luke is merely a farm boy who can only dream of the adventure he is about to embark on. This starts when he meets his mentor, the aging Jedi Knight, Obi-Wan Kenobi, who steps in to help Skywalker when he is most needed and teaches him the ways of the magical Force. The heroic Jedi was played by traditional English actor Alec Guinness, who famously distanced his involvement in the film, which he classed a B-movie space soap opera. However, his role as Kenobi would go on to define his career for a new generation.

Lucas of course would eventually revisit to tell the origin story of his epic tale in a new trilogy starting with The Phantom Menace (1999); telling the story of Luke’s father Anakin Skywalker and his descent into becoming Darth Vader, as well as the rise of the Emperor and the fall of the Jedi Order. Obi-Wan Kenobi plays a key role, with Ewan McGregor superbly taking on the character across all three movies, before he once again revisited the role in Disney’s recent Obi-Wan Kenobi (2022) TV series.


5. Batman/Bruce Wayne - Christian Bale & Robert Pattinson

Batman Christian Bale Robert Pattinson
Warner Bros.

Batman is the jewel in DC’s crown and was the next significant comic book character to be given a big budget screen makeover with Tim Burton’s Batman (1989), following on from the earlier Richard Donner-directed Superman (1978) and its sequels. Michael Keaton played billionaire Bruce Wayne and his crimefighting alter-ego, and then revisited the role in Burton’s Batman Returns (1992), before the legacy of the character was passed to Joel Schumacher who, with Batman Forever (1995) and Batman & Robin (1997), pulled that legacy into the artistic gutter.

Eight years passed before we were delivered Batman Begins in 2005, the first movie in a new trilogy by director Christopher Nolan, which showed a more realistic origin story of the character which Christian Bale absolutely owned with a near perfect performance in a near perfect film. Bale's tenure came to an end with The Dark Knight Rises in 2012, and although we’ve seen Ben Affleck take on that role in the DC Universe of films, fans had been crying out for a new standalone movie.

This was finally delivered in style with director Matt Reeves' The Batman (2022), with Robert Pattinson playing a new, unique version of the character. Providing a younger and deeply flawed version of Bruce Wayne, Pattison also provided a sultry performance of the superhero himself, in a dark neo-noir detective movie that has offered a wholly fresh perspective of the character.


4. James Bond - Sean Connery & Daniel Craig

James Bond Sean Connery Daniel Craig
MGM

Ian Fleming created the world’s most famous British spy James Bond when he wrote Casino Royale in 1953. He continued to write many more novels with Agent 007 at the heart of his espionage stories, and in 1962 Dr. No was brought to the screen with Sean Connery in the heroic role. Connery was suave and sophisticated, and was the perfect casting for the role at the time. That said, it’s fair to say that the portrayal and overall misogynistic characterisation that fit in the sixties certainly raises eyebrows in today’s society.

There have of course been numerous actors stepping into the role since Connery, including Roger Moore, who provided a slightly more tongue in cheek take during his seven-film run, as well as George Lazenby, Timothy Dalton and Pierce Brosnan. But the films started to feel a little formulaic and stale by the time Brosnan finished his turn with Die Another Day in 2002. With the launch of a new bond in Daniel Craig, the series was taken back to Fleming’s Casino Royale in 2006 with a grittier origin story.

Craig’s performance was the finest of the character that we’d seen since the early Connery days, and he brought James Bond firmly into the modern action movie age with a further four films, including Skyfall (2012) and his final outing No Time To Die (2021), which would bring a definitive closure to his version of the character’s arc.


3. Pennywise The Clown - Tim Curry & Bill Skarsgard

IT Pennywise Tim Curry Bill Skarsgard
Warner Bros.

When horror master Stephen King’s substantial novel IT was turned into a two-part TV mini-series by director Tommy Lee Wallace (Halloween III: Season Of The Witch) in 1990, Tim Curry superbly portrayed Pennywise, scaring the hell out of audiences while inciting a deep rooted fear of clowns for many. Pennywise is a supernatural demon who feeds on the fear of children, lulling them in to a false sense of security before turning on his victims and exposing himself as the murderous being he is.

Curry exquisitely performed the two sides of the character, excelling at the menacing side of the clown and making the role one of the most iconic in horror from that era. However, the relatively low budget effort was always ripe for a glossier remake, and that arrived with Chapter One of the story in 2017 and Chapter Two in 2019, both directed by Andy Muschietti and placing Bill Skarsgard into the role of Pennywise.

Tim Curry had enormous shoes to fill but Skarsgard stepped up to the plate, taking the character into an even more sinister direction, albeit this time aided by the significant use of CGI. He delivers a wonderfully creepy version of Pennywise with an even bigger gulf between the two sides of the character, as highlighted in the iconic kill scene where he lures a young boy to his death from a sidewalk drain, in what is the most famous scene from the movie.


2. Hannibal Lecter - Anthony Hopkins & Mads Mikkelsen

Hannibal Lecter Anthony Hopkins Mads Mikkelsen
Orion Pictures/NBC

When director Jonathan Demme filmed Thomas Harris’s novel The Silence of The Lambs in 1991, he created one of the greatest ever thriller serial killer movies. Winning five Academy Awards, including Best Actor for the portrayal of the psychopathic Dr Hannibal ‘The Cannibal’ Lecter by Anthony Hopkins. His creepy performance of the character made the movie while likewise defining Hopkins as an actor. The Brit would go on to revisit playing Lecter in Hannibal (2001), allowing audiences to see the killer living a secret life out in the open following his escape from incarceration at the end of The Silence Of The Lambs.

Hopkins returned again in Red Dragon (2002), which was a remake of Michael Mann’s Manhunter (1986), which featured the first screen version of the character and a comparatively forgettable performance by Brian Cox. Hopkins played Lecter so perfectly that it was almost inconceivable to imagine anyone else stepping into his shoes. However, in 2013 NBC served up the TV series Hannibal, starring Danish actor Mads Mikkelsen (Casino Royale) in the central role.

Mikkelsen makes the younger version of the character his own, playing a subtler version of the cannibal as a hidden snake in the grass as he works with the FBI’s behavioural science unit. Here, Hannibal provides psychological input to help with the FBI's investigations, whilst also acting as a psychiatrist for investigator Will Graham (Hugh Dancy) as the series slow burn teases the unveiling of Lecter's true sadistic nature.


1. Joker - Jack Nicholson & Heath Ledger

Joker Jack Nicholson Heath Ledger
Warner Bros.

The Joker is unquestionably the standout villain of Batman's rogues' gallery and one of the most iconic in comic book history. He was first portrayed on screen by Cesar Romero in the camp sixties TV show, and for many years his interpretation remained the only version that fans got to see. That all changed in 1989 when Tim Burton brought the first major big budget Batman movie to the cinema. Jack Nicholson applied the make-up and played an unforgettable street-hoodlum version of the villain, putting his own uniquely vivacious stamp on the character.

The Batman movies would eventually descend into farce as director Joel Schumacher took over from Burton, and after the disastrous Batman & Robin (1997) the series seemed dead in the water. Then came the Christopher Nolan-directed trilogy, which provided a gritty and grounded take starting with Batman Begins (2005), teasing the return of Joker in the very final scene of that movie. Then, The Dark Knight (2008) followed, starring Heath Ledger as the Clown Prince of Crime and widely considered to be the finest comic book movie ever created.

Matching the gritty realism of the film, Ledger’s take was sinister and unlike any Joker we had seen on screen before, taking influence from the very darkest of the Batman graphic novels. Ledger’s performance was truly remarkable and has forever been immortalised by his tragic death, which came a short time after he had finished filming and prior to the movie's release, gaining him a posthumous Oscar for Best Supporting Actor.


In this post: 
joker
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Connoisseur of Alternative Music & Cult Movies. Freelance writer covering the Rock & Metal music scenes, and the Horror, Sci-Fi and Fantasy Film & Tv genres.