10 Most Underrated 90s Teen Films

We bet you shamefully haven't even seen many of these!

The 1990s were an interesting time for teen films. Not as commercial and all-American as the ones came out in the 80s, you start to notice a pattern that separates these films from their predecessors far more than you would expect for a period of only ten years or so. A lot of 90s teen films were more edgy and cynical, focused less on the drama of the high school social structure and more on the societal outliers. There's a lot more absurdism and black comedy to be found, fewer traditional romantic dramas. In this way, teen films from the 90s were surprisingly interesting, with fantastic characters that went so much further than trite stereotypes.

But for some reason, a lot of the best films of the decade are ignored in favor of movies like Clueless and American Pie. Nothing against those films -- they're good in their own right. But there are a lot of classic 90s teen films that better represent the decade as a whole, that have been sadly neglected over the years. These are some of my personal favorite films aimed broadly at the teenage demographic, that I'd like to see get the attention they deserve.

10. Cry-Baby

In which John Waters takes a gleeful swipe at 1950s popular culture, with Johnny Depp at his helm as the misunderstood greaser who is tough as nails except for his one lone teardrop. The absolute best thing about Cry-Baby is that it refuses to take itself even a little bit seriously. It has delightfully absurd elements around every corner that make this one of those films that you really need to see a few times to get all the jokes. The basic storyline is about a young "drape" who falls in love with a WASP-y square. A pretty cliché story, to be sure, but the supporting cast completely succeed in elevating the material into some kind of campy masterpiece.This is a film that features Iggy Pop taking a bath in a metal pot on the front lawn, parents attempting to send their tramp of a daughter (played by Traci Lords) to Scandinavia in exchange for a nice, well-behaved girl, and a teenage Ricki Lake giving birth to her third child in the middle of a high-stakes game of chicken. It's worth watching just for the Alphabet Bomber scene, where Johnny Depp loses his shit over a bit of lightning and explains to his new girlfriend, "Electricity killed my parents!" It really has to be seen to be believed.

9. Hackers

Back in the 90s, computers were this cool, edgy piece of equipment that you really had to know your shit to be able to do much with. So it's understandable that the concept of a hacker culture was at an all time high, where rebellious teens could sneak onto the websites of really important companies (or even the government) and mess with things just for the fun of it. There may not have been that many people actually doing it, but the idea was certainly big enough to warrant a feature film. And that's where Jonny Lee Miller and Angelina Jolie came in. Dating at the time, these two up-and-coming stars played a pair of rival hackers and eventual love interests. It's a fun ride, even if most of the actual computer stuff is laughably flawed. I get a kick out of seeing Jesse Bradford and Matthew Lillard as part of their merry band of hackers, and the entire cast does a good job of selling the concept. But to be totally fair, this movie is worth watching just to see how dated it is. They're losing their minds over a computer with a 28.8 bps modem, and a large part of the suspense involves them plugging into a telephone booth so that their online activities can't be traced. Come on, that's just adorable.

8. Can't Hardly Wait

Can't Hardly Wait is one of those films that was on the cusp of being one of the most well known films of the 90s, and to be fair, this one isn't nearly as overlooked as a lot of the others on this list. But in my opinion, it should be up there with the best the decade had to offer. As is often the case in these kinds of films, the main couple isn't really much to write home about. Ethan Embry and Jennifer Love Hewitt are sweet, but it's the large ensemble cast that really makes this film stand out. Sometimes it seems like half of Hollywood was in this film when they were just starting out. I cherish every moment of Seth Green desperately trying to sound gangsta in the hopes that it will make him cool and accepted. I love the scene where Hewitt explodes at Peter Facinelli's a**hole jock, turning the crowd against him until he's practically in tears, yelling that he's going to kick everyone's ass in this room! And I will never forget uber-geek William's elaborate revenge plot which goes tragically wrong. On the surface it might seem like just another teen movie, but there's so many brilliant little nuggets in it that have always made this one of my favorites, and are the reason why I can still watch it today, even though I'm long out of high school.

7. Don't Tell Mom the Babysitter's Dead

Alright, so this one might not be the most believable teen movie of all time, but it makes up for it with a ton of charm. A mother goes away on an extended vacation, leaving her children with an elderly babysitter, who promptly dies on pretty much the first night she's there. Rather than trying to get a hold of their mom, they decide that they can manage on their own for a few months. So they do what any normal kids would do: put the babysitter in a trunk and drop her off at the nearest hospital. But their budgeting skills aren't very good, and they run out of money pretty early on in this whole adventure, leaving eldest sibling Christina Applegate to get a job to support the family. The enterprising teenager manages to find a job as an assistant at a fashion company. Yes, you read that right. The girl with no college degree or experience snags a cool, glamorous job with plenty of room for growth. It must have been cool heading into the workforce while the country wasn't in a recession. Anyway, the film takes the teen fantasy of ultimate independence and takes it to a logical, if somewhat unbelievable, conclusion. Plus, you've got a young Josh Charles (from The Good Wife) starring as Christina Applegate's ice-cream truck-driving boyfriend, which is kind of reason enough to give it a watch.

6. Freaked

In case you were wondering what Alex Winter did as a follow-up to the Bill and Ted movies, this is it. Freaked is a truly surreal film about an arrogant actor (played by Winters) who ends up getting physically deformed when he pisses off the wrong guy. He accepts a ton of money to promote "Zygrot 24", a fertilizer that turns out to be pretty bad news. But when he gets to South America, he runs into a shady freak show owner, played by (unsurprisingly) Randy Quaid. He and his friends end up getting put in his Tasty Freekz Machine, which uses Zygrot 24 to turn average people into members of his freak show. Once turned into a half-man, half-monster, he meets the rest of the gang. Highlights include Sockhead, which is pretty much just Bobcat Goldthwait as a man with a sock puppet for a head, and The Hideous Frogman, which boils down to a Frenchman in a scuba suit. So right about now, you might be thinking it makes sense that after test screenings the studio decided that this film was just too weird, and it was only released at a handful of theaters nationwide. But if you like absurd humor, this might just be the best movie you've never seen.

5. PCU

I wish I was exaggerating when I tell you that PCU was my college experience. I went to a small liberal arts university in New England, and it sometimes seemed like half of the kids I went to school with were majoring in being social justice warriors. (I chose film, and clearly made the wrong decision, because they're all off working for the UN right now.) But it was cool, because I watched PCU when I was in high school, so I was totally prepared for it. PCU is the story of a high school senior who goes on an overnight college visit to Port Chester University, and basically manages to piss off every special interest group on campus. The poor lad finds refuge at a place called The Pit, where a group of outsiders live. Jeremy Piven plays a seventh year senior who enjoys messing with the politically correct, David Spade plays his racist Reagan-loving arch-rival/freshman roommate, about 100 pounds of meat are poured on a vegan protest, and good times are had by all (except for the vegans). There's an endless barrage of classic lines, and the film provides a look at the modern college atmosphere. I've heard it called the Animal House of the 90s, and while Piven is no Belushi, it definitely deserves more praise than it gets.

4. That Thing You Do!

If you can make your way through this film without the title track permanently seared into your brain, you probably deserve a medal. That Thing You Do is a film about a fictional band (called The Oneders/The Wonders) in the 1960s who makes it big...it's also the name of their number 1 hit, and yes, they play it about once every five minutes. This is Tom Hanks' baby, and he was responsible for writing both the script and a number of the songs featured in the film, as well as directing and starring in it. Hats off to you, Mr. Hanks, because you have created a well-crafted picture that I could watch pretty much once a week and not get tired of. The main characters are all intensely likeable (except for Jimmy, but that's kind of the point), with special kudos to Guy Patterson for proving once again that the lead singers may get all the attention, but the drummers are the chillest members of the band. Humor is top notch in here (Steve Zahn is a particular highlight), and I really enjoy the period feel they were able to maintain throughout the film. Can't say enough good things about this movie, and I really wish more people knew about it.

3. But I'm A Cheerleader!

This movie is probably one of the most important LGBT films to come out of the 90s, and it works in a way that appeals to wider audiences as well as the gay community. For that reason, I think it belongs on this list. It stars Natasha Lyonne as an incredibly naive teenager whose parents send her away to straight camp. But she's absolutely convinced that she's not a lesbian...until she gets there. Ironically, the camp that was supposed to turn her straight allows her to come to terms with her sexual identity. It's a satirical black comedy that shines a light on the absurdism of conversion therapy. In a lot of ways, the film challenges traditional gay and lesbian stereotypes in a time when most people were just coming to terms with gays portrayed in the media at all. It also deals with issues of gender and stereotypical gender roles, as shown through the 5-step process instituted by the camp. Hot off her success from American Pie, Natasha Lyonne turns in a fantastic performance as the sweet and innocent Megan, while the film also features standout performances from Clea Duvall and the villainous Cathy Moriarty.

2. Empire Records

Watching this movie when I was younger made me desperately want to work at a record store. I knew distantly in the back of my mind that Napster had killed the record store, and the only ones to survive would be so hopelessly corporate that it would be a soul-sucking work environment, but I didn't care. Damn the man. Save the Empire! Empire Records is the story of a ragtag group of kids in their late teens and early twenties who work at a privately owned record store on the verge of being sold to a large, impersonal chain.This will destroy the unique way they have of running the shop, and take away all the fun of working at a place where you get paid to hang out and listen to music all day. The cast of characters is top notch, each well-rounded and interesting in their own way, and the film features performances from a young Liv Tyler and Renee Zellweger. It's a gorgeous microcosm of mid-90s culture, and is full of hilarious dialogue that should have made it a major hit. Alas, this wonderful film is relegated to cult classic status.

1. My Boyfriend's Back

You might think that the idea of a zombie love story is unique to the recent film Warm Bodies, but there was actually a movie that came out back in the early 90s that pulled off a similar concept with a better sense of humor and a lot more heart. It was called My Boyfriend's Back, and it was glorious. There's a teenage guy who has been hopelessly in love with the same girl since he was six years old, and he finally works up the courage to tell her how he feels about her. And then he is promptly shot trying to protect her in a gas station robbery, fatally wounding him. So imagine his surprise when he wakes up in the cemetery, seemingly fine €“ just a little paler and with a taste for brains. Without a doubt, the best part of the film is how they treat his zombification. He heads back to his parents and starts going to school again, where it's pretty much business as usual. Sure, there's some casual anti-zombie behavior, but things go back to normal alarmingly quickly. I mean, when he shows up for class late (on account of being dead), his teacher tells him, "just because you're dead does not mean you can come waltzing in here whenever you like." It's a sweet, clever story that manages to combine black comedy with romance seamlessly, and it doesn't get nearly the attention it deserves.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.