10 Underrated Comedy Performances In Film
"I'm funny how? I mean I'm funny like a clown? Like I amuse you?"
“Tragedy is far easier to act than comedy,” claimed Vivien Leigh in a 1960 interview. “It’s much easier to make people cry than to make them laugh.”
So while it’s no trade secret that raising an audience’s smile is much tougher than quivering their bottom lips, it’s baffling as to why so many comedic performances seem to go seemingly unnoticed by audiences. Comedy films rarely trouble voters at The Academy, and even fewer comedic performances are held up for your consideration.
There are exceptions, of course. Kevin Kline bagged a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his masterful turn as the obnoxious and perma-horny criminal Otto in A Fish Called Wanda. Diane Keaton’s magnificently nuanced depiction of Annie Hall justifiably won her all the plaudits, and Olivia Colman’s vast experience of TV comedy almost certainly stood her in good stead for her Oscar-winning portrayal of Queen Anne in 2018’s The Favourite.
But for reasons known only to The Gods of the Movies (let’s call them Dustin and Meryl, shall we?) comedy just doesn’t rock our world in the same way tragedy does.
With this in mind, let’s take a few moments to revisit ten brilliant comedic performances that, while not necessarily Oscar-worthy, certainly deserve a double take…
10. Eugene Levy - American Pie (1999)
What could have a been Just Another Teen Gross Out Movie was given a much-needed touch of warmth by Eugene Levy’s scene stealing turn as Jim’s Dad.
In a film packed to the rafters with flutes in pussies and cocks in pies, Levy brought an irresistible affability to a character who made every teen in the cinema want him to be their dad, despite his excruciating birds-and-bees conversations with his son Jim.
“I made him a little more a square and on the goofy side because, let’s face it, that’s what I do,” said Levy of the character in 2015. Jim’s Dad was originally written as a much more confident and – ahem – experienced chap, but Levy convinced the writers to render him as a gentle, naïve and deeply kind man and in doing so became a perfect foil for Jason Biggs’ awkward and bad luck prone Jim.
That Levy improvised much of the character and dialogue is a testament to his comic ability and justifies his position as an icon of modern American comedy.
Stand-Out Moment: That chat with Jim. “Do you know what a cli-tor-is is?”
9. Catherine O'Hara - Beetlejuice (1988)
Long before she would go on to win critical praise starring alongside former SCTV co-star Eugene Levy in mockumentaries Best in Show, A Mighty Wind and For Your Consideration, Catherine O’Hara was a staple of the 1980’s TV comedy scene. A few small film roles here and there went largely unnoticed until Tim Burton came a-knocking. (Or maybe she said his name out loud three times. Who knows?)
O’Hara’s turn as the melodramatic and hypercritical Delia Deetz manages to shine through in a film replete with big performances and even bigger production design. Just revisit the incredulousness on her face as she is forced to – quite expertly – dance and lipsync to Harry Belafonte’s Day-O in the film’s most iconic scene.
Making what could have been a go-to archetype so much more human, whilst balancing the requisite Burtonesque heightening of character, O’Hara’s delivery of histrionics, neuroses, and an overwhelming sense of self-importance dominate each scene she is in, without ever upstaging her (equally brilliant) co-stars.
Stand-Out Moment: A collaborative chat with husband Charles: “If you don’t let me gut out this house and make it my own I will go insane AND I WILL TAKE YOU WITH ME!”
8. Bill Paxton - True Lies (1994)
When you talk about underrated performers, look no further than the late, great Bill Paxton. He was the master of turning up in a couple of scenes but remaining the most memorable character in the film.
With his floppy side parting and Errol Flynn ‘tache, Paxton’s Simon is the perfect cinema sleazeball. Initially arriving as an earnest and paranoid secret agent, forced to blow his cover to Jamie Lee Curtis’s Helen, he is later revealed to be a used car salesman who pretends to be a spy to get women to sleep with him. “These women…need some release. A sense of danger. I provide that for them.”
Not just a comic subplot, Simon’s function in the film is to drive a wedge between Helen and her husband Harry, only to inadvertently strengthen their relationship as the stakes get higher. Paxton delivers this with aplomb whilst clearly relishing every slimy boast, and when the character finally tastes justice at the hands of Harry’s Omega Sector pals, it’s hard not to feel some compassion for him.
Stand-Out Moment: The car ride with Arnie’s Harry Tasker, husband of the woman Simon has his eyes on. “Let’s face it, if the husbands took care of business, I’d be out of business!”
7. Letitia Wright - Black Panther (2018)
Charm is the name of the game when it comes to the MCU. Even the most ostensibly serious characters get to crack wise every now and then, but no one does it with as much joy and twinkle as Letitia Wright’s Shuri.
In a role that is sure to make the Londoner a soon-to-be household name, Wright provided the perfect dose of annoying little sister energy to her brother King T’Challa. Only this little sister is an inventor and a tech genius unrivalled by anyone, not even Bruce Banner. “I’m sure you did your best,” she says to him when he admits to making a programming error. Withering.
Shuri truly is a timely character in a genre traditionally dominated by men and masculinity. She’s sparky, witty, fiercely intelligent, and in no mood to be anything like the Disney Princesses that preceded her: “this corset is really uncomfortable so can we all just wrap it up and go home?”
Stand-Out Moment: Upon seeing her older brother wearing sandals. “The real question is what are thoooose?!”
6. Paul Higgins - In The Loop (2009)
“SHUT IT, LOVE ACTUALLY,” screams Jamie McDonald to a soft-spoken advisor. “YOU WANT ME TO HOLE PUNCH YOUR FACE?!”
Armando Iannucci’s movie spin-off to his immensely popular TV satire The Thick of It introduced us to a host of characters, every one an expert in the art of subtle intimidation and unsubtle insult, but none more so than Paul Higgins’ criminally unsung press officer Jamie McDonald. Often overlooked in favour of Peter Capaldi’s Malcolm Tucker, Jamie is arguably even brasher, even fiercer, even angrier. He is every bit “the crossest man in Scotland,” as an under-fire MP dubs him.
Better known for playing high ranking police officers and corrupt officials Higgins, with his diminutive, lean frame and thick Lanarkshire accent, is the perfect vessel for this snarling, rancorous taskmaster. After one character calls him a “cro-magnon Scottish dwarf,” Jamie’s anger flares, subsides just as quickly as he takes a phone call with impeccable politeness, then instantly returns to ire and fury. It’s masterful stuff.
Stand-Out Moment: Being distracted by opera music during a pivotal discovery. “It’s just vowels! Subsidised f*cking foreign vowels!”
5. Tim Curry - Clue (1986)
Having spent the majority of his career carving a niche for scenery-chewing turns as sneering villains and mischievous otherworldly beings, a revisit to the Johnathan Lynn helmed Clue boasts Curry at his most refreshing: playing the straight man.
Acting as a comic foil to a host of highly-strung suspects, Curry’s Wadsworth facilitates proceedings with composure, ease and deference. Even in the face of some outwardly hilarious theatricality, (Madeleine Kahn’s iconic “flames on the side of my face” moment deserves a list of its own) Curry manages to undercut the absurd with a gentleness we don’t often see from him. His tearful admission that he and his wife “had friends who were…socialists” would be moving if it weren’t so amusingly bizarre.
The film isn’t perfect. In fact, upon its release it was given a lukewarm reception to say the least. But a retrospective viewing proves it to be an entirely enjoyable, rather strange romp performed by an exceptional ensemble cast, of which Curry shines in one of his defining roles.
Stand-Out Moment: The film’s denouement.
All three of them. In which Wadsworth gets a sweat on, dashing in and out of rooms whilst unveiling the murderer and how they did it. “And monkey’s brains, so popular in Cantonese cuisine, are not often to be found in Washington DEE SEE…” You can get tired just watching it.
4. Ellie Kemper - 21 Jump Street (2012)
And the award for least amount of screen time for a performer on this list goes to…Ellie Kemper, for her portrayal of Ms. Griggs, a girl-next-door high school teacher who falls madly in lust with an undercover cop posing as one of her students.
With a little under two minutes of total screen time, Kemper manages to mesmerise us with her every moment on screen.
Looking like she’s been punched in the face when she first lays eyes on Channing Tatum’s Jenko, you can literally see the thoughts galloping through her brain as she wrestles with her own sense of right and wrong, all whilst wearing a warm, playful smile on her face. It’s such an insanely skilled and nuanced performance that it’s almost a travesty the character wasn’t given more screen time. But then, you should always leave them wanting more…
Stand-Out Moment: Confronting Jenko at the prom, despite them never having had any sort of prior relationship. "Get out of me, I'm gonna throw up. You're so hot.”
3. Ralph Fiennes - In Bruges (2009)
Fiennes’ mid-career defining role as M. Gustave in Wes Anderson’s Grand Budapest Hotel will forever be one of cinema’s finest comic performances. But it was as crime boss Harry in Martin McDonagh’s In Bruges five years previously that showed audiences an as yet unseen side to one of Hollywood’s most captivating leading men.
In a film that garnered much well deserved acclaim for the odd couple pairing of Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, Fiennes’ deadpan, borderline psychotic cockney mobster is a perfectly deployed character in the Don Logan vein who lights up the screen every time he appears.
“You’ve got to stick to your principles,” says Harry. And stick to them he does. Harry lives by a twisted moral code whereby he’s perfectly happy to maim, murder and extort, but as soon as you insult his kids you’ve taken it a step too far. The climactic gunfight between Harry and Farrell’s Ray is a masterclass in balancing high stakes violence with dark, dark humour; Harry desperately wants to kill Ray, but has enough honour to allow Ray to jump into a canal and try to escape before he continues to shoot at him. It’s absurd, ridiculous, and utterly hilarious.
Stand-Out Moment: Harry’s showdown with Gleeson’s Ken in a cafe the main square. “Let me get this straight. Not only have you refused to kill the boy, you’ve stopped the boy from killing himself. Which would have solved my problem. Sounds like it would have solved the boy’s problem.”
2. John Goodman - The Big Lebsowski (1998)
In what should surely have been his Kevin Kline moment, Goodman received only one Satellite Award nomination for his peerless turn as the jaded and eternally livid Vietnam vet Walter Sobchak.
Often acting as a devil-on-the-shoulder of stoner protagonist The Dude (Jeff Bridges), Walter is a joy to behold in every scene he appears. Belligerent, proud, haughty, and more than a little bigoted, he bullies and cajoles his way into The Dude’s predicament, managing only to make the situation even stickier. “Let’s go bowling,” is his solution to most problems, despite him being the architect of said problems.
Despite his unbalanced nature Walter’s relationship with The Dude borders on, but never transitions to, touching. He is fiercely protective of his bowling buddy. The same can’t be said, though, for the third in their triumvirate, Steve Buscemi’s Donny. Just how many different deliveries of the line “shut the f**k up, Donny” do you think you’d be able to achieve? Because Goodman can do loads. And each one is as priceless as the eulogy he delivers at Donny’s funeral, scattering his ashes into his buddy’s face.
Goodman is a solid presence in every film he makes, but none make you laugh out loud anywhere near as much as Walter. Let’s go bowling.
Stand-Out Moment: The handoff scene, in which Walter rolls out of the moving vehicle and takes matters into his own hands. “Ok Dude, you’re wheel. Fifteen MPH. I roll out of here, double back and beat it out of them…TAKE THAT HILL!”
1. Hugh Grant - Paddington 2 (2017)
Okay, okay, I know, I know. He was nominated for a BAFTA and won a Critic’s Circle Award and was selected for all sorts of other gongs but let’s be honest with ourselves for a second; Paddington 2 is a perfectly formed, infectious family adventure, and Hugh Grant steals every scene he is in. And even some he isn’t in. It’s a performance that, were comedy treated with the same grovelling deference as drama, would have won Grant every award going.
Always adept at comedic performances, before 2017 Grant had never truly elevated much above either of his niches; the stammering, floppy-haired rom-com heroes of Four Weddings or Love Actually, and the self-absorbed man-children of Bridget Jones Diary and About a Boy. But here he gives a career-high turn, and it’s magnificent.
Portraying a faded West End star, Grant takes on the role as the film’s intensely arrogant villain Phoenix Buchanan. Seemingly given free rein to be as camp as humanly possible, Grant relishes every moment he has on camera, and in doing so gives us one of the most delicious bad guys in recent memory.
Disguising himself variously as a medieval knight, a bearded cockney, a bald-capped train conductor and, wonderfully, a nun, Phoenix frames our furry hero for theft and terrorises his adopted family, all to gain possession of a book that leads to a treasure trove. Which he can then use to fund his one-man-show. Yes. That’s the motive.
See? Gloriously camp, isn’t it.
Stand-Out Moment: At his sentencing, the judge tells Buchanan he is “a disgrace to the noble profession of acting.” Phoenix’s reaction – wailing into a hanky as if it’s the worst thing he could possibly hear – I would happily watch on loop for an hour.