10 Underrated Movies Based On Stephen King Stories
There's much more to Stephen King than The Green Mile and The Shawshank Redemption.
Stephen King is one of the most prolific horror writers the world has ever known. With over fifty published novels and hundreds of short stories to his name, it's no surprise that King's work has been adapted for film and TV on countless occasions.
These adaptations have varied vastly in quality, from Academy Award winning movies like The Green Mile and The Shawshank Redemption all the way down to laughable flops and box office bombs like Cell and Graveyard Shift.
But how about the middle ground? What about those movies that didn't exactly set the world on fire but are still worth a watch? Misery, The Shining, IT and Carrie are often cited among the greatest King movies, but there are plenty of other awesome King adaptations that are too often overlooked.
10. Gerald's Game
Released last year, Gerald's Game is based on a King story written in 1992. The movie was greeted with good reviews upon release but seemed to fade away quickly without getting the plaudits it deserved. The story follows married couple Jessie and Gerald as they attempt to spice up their love life, but things take a dark turn when Gerald collapses and Jessie is left handcuffed to the bed with no way out.
Almost the entirety of the film takes place in one room, relying on the very small cast to provide sufficient tension and drama to keep us glued to our screens. Fortunately, Carla Gugino provides an award-worthy performance as the stranded Jessie, who rides a rollercoaster of emotions in her bid to escape the bedroom.
Gugino's acting is top notch and Bruce Greenwood turns in an excellent performance too in the part of Gerald, while special praise is also reserved for Carel Struycken in his role as the mysterious 'Moonlight Man' who haunts Jessie when the sun goes down. Director Mike Flanagan keeps the tension high from the opening moments to the closing credits and the film features some truly nightmare-inducing scenes in its latter stages.
9. Apt Pupil
Apt Pupil was released in 1998 and directed by Bryan Singer. Starring Ian McKellen and Brad Renfro, the film follows teen Todd Bowden who learns that a former Nazi is living in his town under a fake name. Rather than turning him in, Bowden implores the ex-SS officer to regale him with horrific stories of his time in the war.
A complex film, Apt Pupil explores dozens of themes and is worthy of multiple viewings to truly appreciate the depth of its writing and dialogue. McKellen is always excellent but shows a new side to his acting skills with this spine-tingling performance and Renfro does an admirable job of portraying a highly disturbed and suggestible kid who gets in way over his head.
As with many other of the best King adaptations, tension and suspense builds up over the course of the film to a final dramatic crescendo. Apt Pupil received middling reviews and failed to recoup its budget at the box office, but it's still more than worthy of a watch for King fans.
8. The Dark Half
Directed by none other than George Romero and released in 1993, The Dark Half tells a twisted tale of a horror writer named Thad Beaumont whose alter ego, George Stark, seemingly comes to life to launch a murderous rampage on Beaumont's friends and family.
An intense Jekyll and Hyde story begins to play out, with Thad's life spiralling dramatically out of control as he desperately attempts to prove his innocence and put an end to the killings. Michael Rooker, of The Walking Dead fame, appears in the movie as the local sheriff, but the star of the show is undoubtedly Timothy Hutton as Beaumont.
Romero's fast-paced direction and horror mastery is on display throughout the film, which faithfully recreates one of King's more obscure and inventive stories. Like many other movies on this list, the film released to mediocre ratings and modest box office performance, but is still a solid King adaptation with a lot going for it.
7. 1408
1408 was released back in 2007 and starred John Cusack and Samuel L. Jackson, who would later team up again in the vastly inferior King adaptation: Cell. The movie follows horror writer and paranormal sceptic Mike Enslin, played by Cusack, as he spends the night in a haunted hotel room. The film did well at the box office and earned positive reviews but is often overlooked when discussing the greatest King adaptations.
Cusack's performance is an undoubted highlight of 1408, as he successfully captures and conveys the frosty wit and snarky attitude of many of King's protagonists. The opening half of the film is especially effective as increasingly spooky and menacing events begin to occur in the room and Enslin's staunch disbelief in the supernatural begins to crumble.
The film takes some unexpected twists and turns as it continues, leading us down a deep, dark rabbit hole without ever fully showing its hand. A constant sense of mystery and dread builds up from scene to scene, resulting in a satisfying conclusion that remains open to interpretation.
6. Creepshow
Directed by George Romero and released in 1982, Creepshow presents a compilation of five skin-crawling tales. King himself wrote the screenplay for the movie and even made a cameo appearance in one of the stories. The film had mixed reviews upon release but has developed a cult following over the years, even spawning a couple of sequels.
Combining the darkest of comedy with the grisliest of horror, Creepshow is a masterpiece in its own right and a veritable love letter to retro horror comics like Tales from the Crypt. Many modern horror anthologies have taken more than a few cues from Creepshow, which has become a cult classic for its wicked sense of humour and fantastic practical effects.
The tagline for the film was "The most fun you'll ever have being scared!" and that's a statement that rings true from the first minute to the last. Each of the stories offers something new and exciting, while constant themes of dark humour and hideous gore permeate the entire film. Everyone has their own favourite story from Creepshow, but They're Creeping Up On You and The Crate are undoubtedly two of the best.
5. Secret Window
Based on one of King's short stories, Secret Window came out in 2004 and stars Johnny Depp as best-selling crime author Mort Rainey who retreats to a lonely lake cabin to overcome writer's block. There, he is confronted by a menacing man named Shooter who claims that Rainey stole one of his story ideas. Thus begins a harrowing 90 minutes in which Depp is physically and psychologically stalked by his new neighbour and his own personal problems.
Hitchcockian in style and tone, Secret Window is a highly tense and riveting suspense movie with a well-paced plot that becomes more twisted and terrifying as it continues, typing up with a shocking ending that's sure to leave viewers' jaws on the floor.
The movie is regarded as one of Depp's deepest and greatest performances, and he carries the plot along with aplomb. The original book is one of King's smartest stories and director David Koepp did a sterling job of bringing that tale to life on the silver screen.
4. The (Other) Shining
Technically a miniseries, the 6-hour long 1997 version of King's magnum opus is often compared infavourably to the well-known Stanley Kubrick adaptation, but King himself actually prefers the TV movie and it's not too hard to see why.
For starters, the 1997 version of The Shining is far more faithful to the original source material. Where Kubrick took liberties with the plot in more ways than one to craft his own vision of the story, the 1997 iteration was fully written by King himself and is much more in line with the novel, featuring plenty of classic moments that were cut from the film like the famous hedge monsters and an arguably superior ending.
King was famously critical of Kubrick's movie, but he managed to bring his original story to life very well in this version. Jack is more relatable, Wendy is far less meek, and the fascinating character of Dick Hallorann gets much more screen time. In short, if you enjoyed the novel and want to see that story played out on screen, this is the version to watch.
3. Dreamcatcher
With a big budget and an all-star cast including Damien Lewis, Morgan Freeman, Tom Sizemore, Thomas Jane and Timothy Olyphant, Dreamcatcher had all it needed to be a box office smash but failed miserably, releasing in 2003 to mostly negative reviews and failing to earn back even half of its initial budget.
The story focuses on a group of friends with mysterious telepathic powers who are caught in the middle of an alien invasion. It starts off at a ponderous pace with an air of mystery and some interesting backstory for the main characters, but swiftly develops into a full-on monster movie. The sudden tonal shift was heavily criticised by reviewers, but if you take Dreamcatcher as a fun alien horror flick, it actually works really well, with an almost B-movie vibe present in certain scenes.
The highly talented actors making up the cast help to keep the action engaging, and if there's one argument we can make in favour of Dreamcatcher, it's that this movie is compelling. Whether you like it or not, it's hard to stop watching, and that's what makes this film one of King's more underrated adaptations.
2. The Running Man
Released in 1987 and starring Arnold Schwarzenegger himself, The Running Man is vastly different to King's original story, which he wrote and released under his alter ego, Richard Bachman. The film takes place in the far flung future of 2019. The biggest show on TV is The Running Man, in which death row inmates are thrown into a huge arena in a life-or-death battle with 'stalkers': heavily armed guards with amusing names and flashy costumes, not unlike boss characters in video games
The whole movie really does play out like an arcade game as Schwarzenegger and other 'runners' battle their way through the arena, taking on one increasingly ludicrous stalker after the next. Outside the game zone, real-life game show host Richard Dawson puts in a truly brilliant performance as the chillingly charismatic Damon Killian.
It's a pure popcorn action movie with a ton of '80s charm and wonderfully cheesy dialogue, and despite deviating massively from the source material, it remains one of the better mid-level King adaptations, as well as being highly rewatchable.
1. Thinner
Thinner was released in 1996 and based on the story of the same name, which King published under his pseudonym, Richard Bachman. The film tells the tale of Billy Halleck, an arrogant, overweight lawyer who falls victim to a 'gypsy curse' and gradually begins to get thinner and thinner as the dark magic eats him alive. The movie barely broke even at the box office and got plenty of negative reviews, but it does have more than a few redeeming features.
Tom Holland's direction is one of the film's saving graces. Writer and director of the first Child's Play movie, as well as Fright Night and a few other horror classics, Holland has a lot of experience in the genre and his influence helped to produce some memorable body horror scenes and really decent practical effects throughout Thinner. This film is worth watching for the makeup alone.
Joe Mantegna's turn as mob boss Richie Ginelli is another highlight. The film was criticised for featuring a cast filled with eminently detestable characters, including the protagonist, but King's original story suffered the same problem, proving that the film is actually a pretty faithful adaptation.