10 Unexpected And Surprising Horror Movie Sequels

When certain movie follow-ups came out of nowhere, and were either terribly good or terribly bad.

Halloween 3 Season of the Witch
Universal Pictures

Horror is undoubtedly the one genre where a hit movie can quickly become a franchise, as studios look to capitalise on the success of a popular film and milk it for all its worth.

Over the years, while it’s fair to say viewers have been subjected to some fine examples of sequels, where certain films have been enhanced by being revisited and deeper elements of the story are explored, it’s also fair to say that moviegoers have been served some real forgettable duds at the same time.

Many of the successful horror franchises we have to come to know and love have often gone on to churn out repetitive and unimaginative follow-on films as the years have gone by. However, every now and then a film also comes along which rips up the rulebook and takes a left-field turn that surprises and amazes an audience, while others arrive at a time that a sequel to a certain movie seemed unimaginable.

With that in mind, here are ten films which rightly or wrongly made cinemagoers sit up and take notice.

10. Lost Boys: The Tribe

Lost Boys The Tribe
Warner Premiere

The Lost Boys (1987) is one of the most beloved vampire movies of all time, featuring a near perfect cast executing a near perfect script. Then some 21 years later came a sequel that absolutely nobody asked for. The story this time focuses on a gang of surfing vampires, and gone is the subtle slow build of the first movie, as in the opening scene they kill another vampire, using god awful dialogue as they decapitate him before playing football with his head.

In Lost Boys: The Tribe, Chris (Tad Hilgenbrink) and his sister Nicole (Autumn Reeser) move to the coast so that he can follow his dream of making it as a pro surfer, setting up a typical fish out of water story that somewhat mirrors the first movie. Chris meets vampire surfer Shane (Angus Sutherland) and he and his sister are invited to a house party where Shane infects Nicole, damning her to a life as an immortal bloodsucker.

The plot then basically revolves around a race against time by Chris and returning vampire hunter Edgar Frog (Corey Feldman), to save her soul by killing the head vampire before she feeds for the first time. The script is poor throughout, and gone are the superb practical effects of the original, replaced with below par scenes of CGI. There are Easter egg nods to the original littered throughout, but these moments are all too little in justifying the film as a worthwhile extension of The Lost Boys saga.


9. Friday The 13th: Part 2

Friday The 13th Part 2 Jason
Paramount Pictures

Friday the 13th (1980) was a schlocky B-movie looking to capitalise on the success of John Carpenter’s Halloween (1978), which had rejuvenated the slasher genre and sparked a craze that would continue through the next decade. Friday the 13th would go on to spawn a franchise of its own and create one of the legendary horror icons in Jason Voorhees. But the killer in the original film wasn't Jason, it was his mother Pamela Voorhees.

Pamela believed Jason was drowned in a tragic accident at the Crystal Lake holiday camp, which she blamed on the summer workers of the camp, taking her revenge. It could have sat as a decent enough standalone film, but Part 2 (1981) arrived, this time introducing Jason as the killer. He hadn’t in fact drowned, and had been living in isolation in the woods… waiting to take revenge of his own. In the opening scene, he avenges the death of his mother who was beheaded at the end of the first film, brutally murdering her killer Alice.

This sequel is careful not to show Jason's face during the proceeding kill sequences, and in many ways this film can be considered the key player in the franchise; introducing the legendary antagonist, while also remaining unique in the sense that he is not yet wearing his trademark hockey mask, which was first introduced in Part 3 (1982).

For this reason, Friday the 13th: Part 2 can be quite a forgotten gem, when the series is looked back on in retrospect.


8. Hellraiser IV: Bloodline

Hellraiser 4 Bloodline Billboard 600x300
Dimension

Hellraiser (1987) was horror novelist Clive Barker’s directorial debut, and its blend of gore, violence and the fantastical made it a surprising hit, followed by its sequel Hellbound (1988). Hellraiser tells the story of a mysterious puzzle box which opens a gateway to Hell for anyone who is able to complete it, unleashing demons known as Cenobites into our world, who come to claim the soul of that person.

The sequel was a continuation of the story, expanding on the lore and entwining characters from the first movie. Then came Hell On Earth (1993), the third in the series and a departure from the initial film with a new standalone story and fresh characters. But the quality was noticeably starting to dip, and when the fourth film Bloodline (1996) arrived, it was a movie that was literally all over the place, with three stories set across different timezones, brought together with a runtime of barely 80 minutes.

Bloodline feels like three different films hastily chopped up and stuck together, with one saving grace being the first part set in 1800s Paris, and showing the creation of the Puzzle Box. This is an intriguing tale providing a backstory to the already established events, but the film then prematurely jumps through to the then-present day of the '90s, before bizarrely leaping again into the future, where we get to see a ludicrous battle with the Hell Demon Pinhead (Doug Bradley) in space... and this just fails on many levels.


7. Prey

Prey Amber Midthunder
Hulu

Predator (1987) was one of the finest movies of the '80s. Part sci-fi, part action and part slasher horror, the film is not only one of the strongest in the repertoire of a certain Arnold Schwarzenegger, but it also launched an iconic deadly alien character. However, the franchise over the proceeding years has been far less hit than miss. Predator 2 (1990) was a solid enough follow-up in bringing the story from the jungle to the suburbs, but it just didn't quite live up to what had come before.

The series then saw the mediocre Alien vs. Predator movies, and finally a further two more recent sequels, with the patchy Predators (2010) set on a distant planet but returning to the jungle setting of the original movie, and the incoherent follow-up that was The Predator (2018). Then out of nowhere came Prey (2022), a film which takes the idea back to the fundamental basics of the original classic, set in an intriguing Native American period as a more primitive Predator faces off with a Comanche warrior girl.

Prey is a beautifully shot period piece, reminiscent of Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto (2006) in places, stripping the threat back and setting up a thrilling single combat finale. This is a subtle and carefully crafted film compared to the other sequels, and in a nutshell is a complete breath of fresh air for what increasingly seemed like a tired franchise, that had been fresh out of good ideas up to this point.


6. Psycho II

Psycho 2 Norman Bates
Universal Pictures

Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960) is a film that is as influential to the horror/thriller genre as you can get, laying the blueprint for what would become the slasher genre as we know it in the decades to come. It is an absolute classic, created by a master auteur, which remained as a standalone movie for 23 years, before the story and character of antagonist Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins) was revisited.

The original film was shocking for audiences at the time. Not only did Hitchcock throw in the ultimate twist by killing off his lead character a third of the way through in that shower scene - one of the most famous kill sequences in cinema history - but he also explored a darkness of horror that was highly original for the genre in 1960. Psycho II (1983) unexpectedly dared to return to the story while putting a fresh perspective on the character of Norman Bates, who we now meet being released back into society, supposedly a cured man.

Surprisingly, the film, and Perkins portrayal in particular, works well, with the story playing nicely on whether Norman really is actually cured or just the same monster who is going to return to his murdering ways. We also meet members of the wider community living around the Bates Motel, some trusting and some not so of the recently released killer.

Psycho II ultimately pays respect and homage to Hitchcock’s original film, and acts as a fine follow-up companion piece.


5. Alien 3

Alien 3 Rip
20th Century Fox

Alien (1979) was a masterclass in filmmaking from Ridley Scott (Blade Runner), with groundbreaking special effects and a perfectly executed story. Its action was subtly introduced, as the alien Xenomorph takes out the crew of the Nostromo before being destroyed by Lieutenant Ripley (Sigourney Weaver). It was seven years before we would see a sequel, but Aliens (1986) did not disappoint.

This follow-up was another superb film which came at the height of popularity for over-the-top action flicks, in which director James Cameron (The Terminator) did a fine job. At the end of the movie, there is a satisfying pay-off as Ripley yet again survives the alien onslaught thrown at her, this time also rescuing Newt, the orphaned young girl she has mothered throughout the picture. They, along with Corporal Hicks and android Bishop, float off into space together in a deep hyper-sleep, seemingly headed for Earth.

But, before the opening credits are finished on Alien 3 (1993), Newt and Hicks are killed when their vessel crashes into the Fiorina "Fury" 161, negating so much of what Ripley had fought for at the end of Aliens.

Further to this, the third movie is a darkly dismal follow-up which has since all but been disowned by director David Fincher (Se7en). Gone was the subtle slow build of the original, and the exhilarating action of the second. Alien 3 also replaced the engaging practical special effects of the first two with poor CGI that, like the script, could not hold a candle to its predecessors, and signified the start in a dip of quality for the series.


4. Army Of Darkness

Bruce Campbell Ash Army Of Darkness
Universal

At the end of Sam Raimi’s Evil Dead II (1987), protagonist Ash (Bruce Campbell) tumbles through an interdimensional portal where he hits the ground with a thump and is surrounded by men on horse-back in what appears to be medieval Europe. Not the ending viewers may have expected following the events of the Evil Dead films up to this point. And if this was surprising then what followed later in Army of Darkness (1992), took the change in tone to a whole new level.

Ash begins the third movie as a slave and is thrown into a dungeon pit and forced to fight a demon for the entertainment of his captors. He wins which then sees him then treated like a lord, but his primary concern is getting back home to the present day. Army Of Darkness is a full-on medieval fantasy/horror/comedy, unique for the time and the best in The Evil Dead series, showcasing Sam Raimi as a highly forward thinking and creative film-maker.

Ash must complete a quest to find the Necronomicon (The Book of the Dead), which he is told has magic passages that once read can send him home. But the land is over run with demons trying to thwart his mission at every turn. The movie is a ludicrous take on popular fantasy films from the eighties such as Conan the Barbarian (1982), and provides an amusing back story on the origins of the Book of the Dead, and the ‘Deadite’ demons who possess it.


3. Wes Craven's New Nightmare

Wes Craven's New Nightmare
New Line Cinema

After writing and directing the original horror classic that was A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984), the franchise was taken out of the hands of Wes Craven. The studio were able to continue the high standards set with the first two sequels, Freddy’s Revenge (1985) and Dream Warriors (1987), before swiftly dropping the quality with each subsequent film through to Freddy’s Dead: The Final Nightmare (1991), ultimately making a parody out of one of the genuinely scariest horror icons of all time.

However, Craven would unexpectedly return for one final throw of the dice at the story which made his name, with his New Nightmare (1994) laying the blueprint for the self-aware meta style of filmmaking that he would go on to develop further with his next movie, the hugely successful Scream (1996). Setting his film in the ‘real’ world with the actors from his original movie playing themselves, and even Wes himself involved in the story, an essence of evil called the Entity takes the form of Freddy Krueger and becomes a real threat to the characters.

The lines of reality become blurred, especially for Heather Langenkamp, who played final girl Nancy Thompson in Craven’s first film. She is haunted by Freddy and her reality starts to mirror that of the fictional world she once helped to portray. The film was a uniquely fresh take on A Nightmare on Elm Street, with Wes Craven producing a real unexpected return to form for the series.


2. Doctor Sleep

Doctor Sleep Ewan McGregor
Warner Bros.

The Shining (1980) is one of the most critically acclaimed psychological horrors of all time. Based on Stephen King’s novel of the same name, visionary director Stanley Kubrick (A Clockwork Orange) superbly brought this story to the screen, where it stood the test of time as a unique standalone movie. However, King would unexpectedly return to his idea over three decades later with follow-up novel Doctor Sleep (2013), picking up the story with a now adult Danny Torrance, the central child with the gift of ‘The Shining’ in the original.

Director Mike Flanagan (Gerald’s Game) adapted Doctor Sleep, creating this wonderful 2019 follow-up movie starring Ewan McGregor (Trainspotting). The film follows the journey of Danny following the events of the first notorious tale, through to him living as a troubled adult, finding his way in the world as a struggling alcoholic, whilst trying to control the anger inherited from his father. He lives with his psychic ability which he also tries to suppress, as he is literally haunted by the ghosts of his past.

McGregor's character has to contend with a cult of vampire-esque beings who murder and feed on the ‘Shine’ of gifted children, whilst mentoring young Abra Stone (Kyliegh Curran), who shares his supernatural affliction. The movie beautifully looks back to Kubrick’s classic with great homage, whilst also staying faithful to Stephen King’s text, with the novelist famously distancing himself from the creation of Stanley Kubrick, despite its success and obvious strong artistic style.


1. Halloween III: Season Of The Witch

Halloween 3 Season of the Witch
Universal Pictures

‘The night no-one came home’ turned out to be a controversial tagline for Season of the Witch (1982), the third installment of the Halloween franchise. Following the success of John Carpenter’s original slasher flick (1978), the producers had shoehorned in Halloween II (1980) to capitalise on the intrigue in the infamous killer, Michael Myers. The movie was co-written by Carpenter, despite his reservations in continuing the story, and carried on from the very last scene of the original picture.

It was then felt by all involved that the story of Myers and final girl Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) had been completed, with the producers having the idea to turn the franchise into an anthology series, releasing unrelated standalone Halloween-themed movies. However, the reappearance of Michael Myers was alluded to in Season of the Witch's marketing. In a pre-internet age without spoilers, viewers went flocking to the cinemas expecting to see the horror icon.

The fanbase were surprised when what they got instead, was this bizarre, sci-fi-influenced horror movie about a megalomaniac planning on brainwashing the children of America with hypnotic Halloween masks... and with Myers nowhere to be seen.

The backlash to this threequel was severe enough to change the plans of the creators, who backtracked and eventually followed up with Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), placating fans and providing a springboard which created one of the longest running horror series - with Halloween Ends (2022) providing the latest depiction of the infamous Shape.


Contributor
Contributor

Connoisseur of Alternative Music & Cult Movies. Freelance writer covering the Rock & Metal music scenes, and the Horror, Sci-Fi and Fantasy Film & Tv genres.